10 Loudest Wrestling Pops You Didn't Know About

AEW returns to full crowds at Double Or Nothing - but can Sting rival one of his earliest mega-pops?

Dean Malenko Ciclope
WWE.com

At Double Or Nothing 2021, AEW welcomes a full capacity crowd back for the first time since March 11, 2020.

The euphoric relief of a world returned to normal isn't quite felt because we are still in the present tense. It was naive, in retrospect, to think there'd be a magic switch into we've-reached-herd-immunity-let's-f*cking-go: the tremendous success of the vaccine roll-out is tempered by jab hesitation and the lingering uncertainty of variants. The optimism is of a cautious strain.

Astutely, AEW has assembled a feel-good crowd-pleaser of a card: super-popular living meme Orange Cassidy working a main event banger; folk heroes Eddie Kingston and Jon Moxley exacting vengeance on obnoxious rich punks; Sting working a live match.

It's going to be wonderful, though when the camera rests on a front row populated by knackers wearing a mask as a chin-strap, if they're wearing one at all, a mild feeling of unease might undermine the feeling of what pro wrestling is meant to be.

Ahead of this scorcher of a day - with an ominous cloud threatening rain - there's no better time to relive that which was too depressing a few months back: spine-tingling mega-pops...

10. Kenta Kobashi Returns From Cancer

Kenta Kobashi
Pro Wrestling NOAH

Life-affirming is a grand word, but it's the only word that captures the feeling of King's Road legend Kenta Kobashi returning to the ring after his cancer diagnosis.

Kobashi's epic career trajectory allowed him to forge a unique bond with his people. He was the indefatigable babyface upstart booked to earn his spot inch by inch, and when he earned it - and earned is the word - he rewarded his fans with blow-away performances every night. The greatest ever purveyor of babyface fire grasped this incredible skill - really, it was a natural extension of his wonderfully human personality - and applied it to incredible matches. His firing up resonated all the more after enduring such harrowing (read: awesome) punishment.

The man who never took a night off took over a year and a half off between 2006 and 2007 before making the ultimate, defiant babyface comeback.

Life-affirming is the only word.

Hearing an entire Budokan Hall roar KO-BA-SHI in perfect sync - united in their adoration - is the sort of moment that genuinely makes one feel introspective. How bad can this world possibly be, when human endeavour is rewarded so resoundingly?

Layers of misanthropy are stripped away, replaced by goosebumps, as Kobashi stops and registers it all.


9. Hiroshi Tanahashi Graces New Orleans With His Presence

Wiki Tanahashi
ゾーヒョー, CC BY-SA 3.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

New Japan Pro Wrestling was held to such a monumental standard at its peak that the promotion, upon venturing west in the first stages of its expansion project, drew something of an underwhelming response.

The first shows were great - NJPW was incapable of anything less throughout its golden resurgence - but they were, understandably, Americanised. They were built around the introduction of the IWGP United States Title, and perhaps it was felt that a bridge was required to establish the promotion stateside. This wasn't the case. The west coast fans longed for the seminal undiluted experience.

The fans at the 2018 'Mania Weekend Wrestlecon Supershow received it without knowing: in front of the most hardcore of hardcores, Hiroshi Tanahashi made a surprise appearance to cameo in a six-man tag. The Ace embodied that desire: the rock star super-worker was one of the most charismatic pro wrestlers to ever also be a genius practitioner of the art. He spanned every ideal of what it is to be a professional wrestler, and he was greeted as an idol: the fans regressed to the headspace of children in his presence.

Tana reminded them what all of this should feel like, and they felt it with no abandon.


8. Magnum TA Walks

Magnum TA
WWE.com

Had he not been forced into early retirement, it is no exaggeration to state that the very complexion of today's industry might look unrecognisable. The flutter of a butterfly's wings made the halcyon days something less than that. That much is certain.

Mangum TA was the great lost talent: a barrel-chested, earthy hero so incredible at the babyface art that he convinced tens of thousands of North Carolinians that he was seconds away from getting his eyeball gouged out at Starrcade '85.

Just under a year later, having starred throughout what many consider to be the single greatest year in the history of the industry, Magnum totalled his car around a telephone poll and shattered his C-4 and C-4 vertebrae. The damage to his nervous system was so profound that it rendered the right side of his body paralysed. It was thought he would never walk again.

He walked out at the 1987 Crockett Cup in the Norfolk scope.

In the sort of scene that comes with a headphone warning, this is less a pop and more of a scream: the fans are so stunned in awed delight that they scream with an ear-splitting pitch between bouts of teary hysteria.


7. Shinya Hashimoto Brings It Back Home

Shinya Hashimoto
マ管, CC BY 2.1 JP , via Wikimedia Commons

New Japan Pro Wrestling was white hot in 1996.

Driven by the star power and futuristic workrate of its key acts across the heavyweight and junior divisions, the company was a Dome-sized sensation at its commercial peak: it was the promotion in which heroes generated as much loyalty as stunned disbelief. If Shinya Hashimoto wasn't embodying the legitimacy on which the promotion was built, the juniors were innovating new standards that remain in vogue, and spectacular, to this very day.

Much has been written about the NJPW Vs. UWF-i inter-promotional rivalry. It was and was not the way to do it, ultimately: New Japan may have drawn a few more of those sprawling, record-breaking vistas, with a less defensive attitude towards the development. But the reaction afforded to folk hero Hashimoto bringing the IWGP Heavyweight Title back home is undeniable. If the success of every booking decision is measured by the noise and the gate, the events of Battle Formation emphatically rebuke any criticism.

The fans went ballistic every time Hashimoto out-muscled the interloping Nobuhiko Takada on the mat, and when he took him down with a leg sweep just when he had cast doubt over his ability to withstand a standing strike exchange, they exploded.

This wasn't even the loudest pop in the match: Hashimoto's Brainbuster was received as the ultimate home team victory. It was as if he'd lifted a cup, not Takada's body, on his shoulders.


6. Nikita Koloff Atones To Atomic Pop

nikita koloff
WWE.com

Because pro wrestling is an inherently, unabashedly carny business, Magnum's tragedy was incorporated into storyline. The execution was so phenomenal - and the curve for questionable taste so stunningly low - that it never resonated as ghoulish.

Besides which, the fans wanted this to happen and something like it had to happen. The irreplaceable had to be replaced; there is no offseason in wrestling, and the car crash left Crockett Promotions without a top babyface act. Nikita Koloff, feared Russian baddie, turned in quite shocking fashion. He was there to draw heat through his nationality, reductively.

Executed with savvy timing - the tense Cold War years were thawing - Koloff revealed himself to be the partner of Dusty Rhodes to an eruption of a pop. Subverting the visual that accompanied the customary Dusty betrayal to stunning effect, this time, the steel cage acted as the backdrop for a new alliance.

The improbable moment was so powerful that both Dusty and Tony Schiavone cited it as the single loudest pop they had ever experienced, and this was literally Road Warriors territory: a squealing explosion, Koloff was so affected by Magnum's tragedy that it led him to respect his former rival.

Atonement as a storyline driver, that this was somehow earned speaks to its immense brilliance.


5. Tsuyoshi Kikuchi Enters The Babyface Performance Of A Lifetime

Kobashi Kikuchi
AJPW

They say Japanese wrestling fans are quiet.

Too quiet. So quiet that the very form - one that is confused for a singular form, when the scene is more expansive than in any other corner of the globe - isn't even watchable, much less good.

"They" are complete f*cking birdbrains who watched a few minutes of a slow-burn epic and thought that was it.

They never watched Tsuyoshi Kikuchi and Kenta Kobashi Vs. Dan Kroffat and Doug Furnas, because that pulsating classic of a match was not a slow-burn. It ignited immediately into what was a cauldron of a crescendo for its entire duration. Kikuchi generated waves upon waves of Road Warrior Austin Surprise Return From Serious Injury pops within the first minute purely by raining down fists upon Kroffat's head. It is an incendiary scene; Kikuchi is so ablaze with fire that he he nearly tumbles out of the ring, he is so intent on battering his opponent. Every fan in the building stands to their feet, roaring him on, pumping their fists in support. It's a bloodsport atmosphere within the first 60 seconds of a worked match.

Any younger fans raised on WWE who've made it this far: watch this match. An in-ring classic worked in defiance of the bullying foreign bastards, it intersects everything great about the mentality - and one electrifying form - of puroresu.


4. Dean Malenko Exposes Face, Bad Takes

dean malenko chris jericho
WWE.com

Many of Scott Hall's words have formed the story of modern professional wrestling.

He captured the heartbreaking truth of the old headliners versus cruiserweights divide of the 1990s: apocrypha has it that Hall congratulated two flashy talents after a particularly dazzling match, and said "Now I'm gonna go out there and get a bigger pop with a headlock".

Almost too cute to be a shoot, it was also wrong. The cruiserweights weren't just opening TV match guys who worked a style that engulfed a crowd by the finish; allocated enough resource with which to tell a story rich in emotional heft, two members of that legendary division - Chris Jericho and Dean Malenko - brought a different kind of noise. They engineered one of the loudest and most sustained pops of an era defined by them.

Malenko was known as a wrestler more than a worker, but he played the role of the latter in sensational fashion at Slamboree 1998; convincingly performing as Ciclope in plain sight, Malenko unmasked at the climax of a well-built storyline to avenge Jericho's terror campaign against his family.

When he lit Jericho up, the crowd was caught in the backlash: they went ballistic, popping dafter with every short round blast.


3. The Perfect Dynamic Clashes At Clash Of The Champions II

Sting Arn Anderson
WWE Network

The event, headlined by Sting and Dusty Rhodes Vs. Arn Anderson and Tully Blanchard, was titled Clash of the Champions II: Miami Mayhem.

Really, it was a clash between the past, present and future of Jim Crockett Promotions. If the promotion had peaked, and it had, this remained a deafening spectacle - a composite of its greatness and, through Sting's unreal babyface work, a cruel glimpse into a stunning future that institutional mismanagement married with Vince McMahon's money could not realise.

Sting was Cody's favourite wrestler, and this is Cody's favourite match, tied with Hulk Hogan Vs. The Rock. On this glorious, heated evidence, you get a sense of why Cody sought to bring back the old-school babyface archetype in 2018. It wasn't old-school; it was timeless.

Sting was thrown to the canvas and jumped straight back up. Arn Anderson reacted with fright, using that marvellously expressive face, before trying again. Nope. Sting leapt to his feet, jerked his head towards Arn in defiance, and Arn, thinking better of things, slithered out of the ring to regroup. The fans went wild, nuts., apesh*t for Sting before he executed a single move.

The tag team was short-lived, much to that crowd's despair. Kick-ass, witty, and hugely popular, they act as evidence for tiresome discourse.

Modern pro wrestling is missing something, and it's this.


2. Finn Bálor Returns Home

Finn Balor OTT
OTT Wrestling

A masterclass of pro wrestling production married to a wrestling moment as shocking as it was charged with emotion, Finn Bálor returned to Dublin ahead of Christmas in 2016.

WWE stars didn't just turn up to their local indie, no matter how hot that indie was. The production values that hyped his appearance were so exquisite that OTT barely felt like an indie at all: after a countdown, red lights flickered and the sound of a pulse reverberated from the PA. Shadowy images of a suited figure flashed on the big screen. The Tivoli Theatre was drenched in a bath of red light. With the anticipation ramped up, the remixed segue exploded into Bálor's WWE theme, and when the recuperating former Universal Champion made his entrance, the fans exploded. It was as if they were cheering a last-minute winner scored against the scum down the road.

As loud as the pop was, the crowd was library silent for his history lesson on the modern Republic of Ireland wrestling scene and plea to continue to support it. His manipulation of the crowd was expert. This was the antithesis of the "What?" chant.

Vince McMahon compared him to Super Mario three years later, on RAW, as part of his embarrassing main roster run.

Capital work.


1. Kyle O'Reilly Perfects The Lights Out Moment

Kyle O Reilly
WWE.com

The Lights Out trick popularised in the ECW Arena is almost too effective.

An expectation is set of something momentous, and if what follows is not momentous, you are f*cked. AEW discovered this - very early, mercifully - at its very first show. This was almost astonishingly dumb for the most astute wrestling company in the land. On a show that was bound to attract rumours of a CM Punk appearance, AEW pulled the trick that promised a cameo of CM Punk's star power. When they were turned back on, the Dark Order appeared. You can't f*ck up the Lights Out.

Kyle O'Reilly virtually perfected the Lights Out in PWG because his incredible rapid-fire offence was engineered to intensify the noise generated by the initial reveal.

Returning after a lengthy absence at All Star Weekend XI to exact vengeance on Mount Rushmore 2.0 - at the explosive apex of so much converged PWG mythology - the fans went absolutely f*cking nuts stamping their hands on the mat. O'Reilly was as stiff as he was propulsive on the beat-down, so unbridled in his energy that he only took two steps to fly from one end of the ring to the other.

A quintessential moment in the history of the company, Kyle O'Reilly captured its heart and electricity in one euphoric burst.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Dean Malenko
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!