10 Match Star Ratings For AEW All Out 2023

After Brawl Out and Brawl In, the vibe, at long last, is finally back. All Out 2023 was special.

Ricky Starks Star Ratings
AEW

When CM Punk was suspended indefinitely last year, following the events of Brawl Out, a vast, inescapable shadow loomed over AEW.

It just wasn't the same. AEW produced some excellent work in that period. Chris Jericho, Jon Moxley, MJF and Bryan Danielson were bound and determined to deliver quality action and storytelling, but virtually everything peaked at bittersweet, even some of the best TV matches of the year.

Plainly, the vibe was screwed.

Uncertainty prevailed. The idea that neither CM Punk nor the Elite may have returned was brutal. AEW was trapped, through its own making, in a dystopian alternate reality. The best part of Peak AEW Dynamite is those Excalibur run-downs, the idea that a surreal combination can appear on a match graphic out of nowhere and blow your head off into smithereens. In that awful moment, nothing AEW could Photoshop was as good or as thrilling as what was, after three dreamlike years, actually impossible.

Things immediately felt different now that CM Punk is gone for good, not that he isn't a wrestling genius. The Chicago crowd sprinted through every stage of grief, if they even grieved at all. Closure has been attained at long last, and this elusive acceptance stage finally allowed the promotion to become the best, unqualified version of itself.

Whether Tony Khan can maintain this week-to-week remains unclear. The power might not be back, but on the strength of All Out 2023, the vibe most certainly is.

10. Better Than You Bay-Bay Vs. Dark Order - ROH World Tag Team Title Match

MJF Adam Cole All Out
AEW

This was as fun as a lot of people weirdly didn't anticipate it to be - and a very astute old-fashioned PPV opener. Too often, a long, great match just happens to open the show and isn't an "opener" proper. This was a proper opener, and allowed the rest of the card to unfold without exhausting the crowd.

Once again, MJF is so gifted and so over that he can somehow navigate house show opener material and never not appear like the biggest deal in the company.

In and of itself, this bit is hugely entertaining, but it's even more compelling when you consider the bigger picture of his character arc. He's an expert manipulator, hence why he is able to get massive arenas rocking for his new, basic babyface move-set - but is that the point?

Is he doing an uncanny emulation of a babyface as part of a long con? Is this what the full babyface MJF will actually wrestle like, or will he play it more seriously when the unqualified turn actually happens?

As it turns out, the Dark Order pairing of John Silver and Alex Reynolds were ideal in this slot: while nobody bought a title switch, when MJF was carried to the back after a worked neck injury, Silver and Reynolds were so rapid and explosive with their double team handicap spots that the crowd didn't have time to think about their less-than-credible title credentials.

Star Rating: ★★★½


9. Samoa Joe Vs. Shane Taylor - ROH World TV Title Match

Samoa Joe Shane Taylor
AEW

When this match was announced, the vast majority of fans asked the same, befuddled question: What?

Why is this on the show?

The answer: to disguise an excellent angle.

When making his entrance as the opener had just barely concluded, recalling that scene of Joe bantering off MJF when he was a WWE extra, Joe barged into MJF. This led to a pull-apart confrontation which, coupled with MJF's worked neck injury, was a deliberate echo of Joe's beat-down of Roderick Strong. The intrigue now is in how Roddy reacts to Adam Cole's reaction.

Whose neck health does Cole truly care about?

This - a vintage bit of deft, dovetailing AEW plotting - should have significant repercussions on the Grand Slam tournament and the ongoing MJF/Cole story.

The match itself was pretext for more important business, but it was fine while it lasted. A nice, snug hoss fight - though one overshadowed by a superior genre offering just two matches later, which was less than ideal - the anticlimactic ending at least positioned Joe as a monster ahead of an important arc over the next month.

Star Rating: ★★¾


8. Luchasaurus Vs. Darby Allin - TNT Title Match

Luchasaurus Darby Allin
AEW

Darby Allin is at once one of the best and most underrated talents in the world.

As expected, he bumped his coccyx off for Luchasaurus in the only logical direction the match could take, but what was unexpected is how he worked (or battled) his way back into the match. For all the talk of his debilitating stunt work, there are few wrestlers better than Allin at earning his high spots. He makes it feel real, somehow, even when he's blasting a significantly bigger wrestler with an avalanche code red, as he did at All Out in a tremendous spot.

His dedication to getting mauled pays off deep into his matches. It isn't gratuitous stunt work. Nor does it feel like he's getting his s*** in. He sells and fires up so well that he can hit somebody the size of Luchasaurus with a crucifix bomb and make sense of it through emotional logic. He makes it feel like an accomplishment, like he needs the crowd's support, and he achieves this by, as an example, smashing into Luchasaurus with a lopé and bouncing right back off him. He puts everything behind everything. He wrestles with as much emotion as strategy.

He's simply really, really damn good, and so was this match.

Star Rating: ★★★★


7. Miro Vs. Powerhouse Hobbs

Miro Powerhouse Hobbs
AEW

Rendered unforgettable by a unique crowd response, Miro Vs. Powerhouse Hobbs could not have gone any better on the night.

Fans, overjoyed by the spectacle and bruising collision detection, used the word "meat" in various chants, inspired by that joyous Big E promo a few years back. Sometimes, this stuff is a bit cutesy and detached, but the "meat forever" chant was fun.

In truth, had the crowd not got into the match with the level of investment they did, this might have dragged at 15:30. The rest periods went a bit long, but that crowd was bang up for this, and they got their desire for meat most of the time.

The rhythm of the match was intoxicating; protecting their monster auras, it took forever - in a compelling, believable and suspenseful way - for either man to knock the other off their feet. It felt like a struggle and then an achievement. And, when the impact arrived, the beads of sweat flew. Gorgeously paced, the superhuman hoss fight picked and delivered its big moments. The Game Over finish looked a bit laboured, but that was more feature than big. They'd smashed one another into kingdom come. Of course the submission application wasn't going to look the cleanest.

Too often over the last year, AEW has booked cheap, carny finishes on TV. This was clean, and did much for Hobbs even in defeat.

Hopefully, a lesson will be learned.

Star Rating: ★★★¾


6. Kris Statlander Vs. Ruby Soho - TBS Title Match

Kris Statlander Ruby Soho
AEW

In a familiar and deflating story, the action was very good but the overall presentation was undermined by an apathetic crowd response. Since the AEW base has been conditioned not to care about women's wrestling, they barely cared about this women's wrestling match.

Cause.

Effect.

If Ruby Soho had been built as a credible challenger allocated with significant television time, the fans might have bit on the cracking sequence in which, with a poison 'rana, DDT and low hurricanrana comnination, she looked to have Kris Statlander's number. Instead, it was a great athletic flourish more than a spellbinding moment of drama.

Perhaps they overcompensated, and understandably so, but the match peaked when Statlander struck an avalanche Tour of the Islands of sorts. Nothing that followed was as exhilarating as that, and the finish wasn't great. Toni Storm emerged from under the ring to take away the spray paint can from Soho. As fantastic as her psychosis act has been, Toni's acting was a bit too hammy here, and Statlander hardly got over by capitalising on a distraction.

Star Rating: ★★★¼


5. Bryan Danielson Vs. Ricky Starks - Strap Match

Bryan Danielson Ricky Starks
AEW

There's an elusive moment in the best and most rare professional wrestling matches.

Consumed by bloodlust, disbelief suspended indefinitely, you stop thinking. You become early man, synapses firing by the spectacle of violence. You turn into this fellow right here:

Just Bleed Guy
UFC/Endeavor

When Bryan Danielson and Ricky Starks pelted one another full force in the side of the head with a leather strap, a state of wrestling nirvana was reached. They'd built the moment brilliantly.

After a snug, strategic match, in which Starks had levelled up to his genius of an opponent, Danielson with his expert body language seemed to send him a message. Come on. Can you hang?

And then the exchange happened, the wincing height of physicality and, somehow, since the match was hurriedly built the day before, bone-deep emotion. That instantly iconic moment felt like the culmination of a deeply personal grudge rivalry, and yet it didn't feel forced.

Even when they exchanged scintillating back-and-forth sequences - that spear counter to the Busaiku knee, yes! - it didn't feel too flashy for its own good. This was a harrowing experience and, if it isn't the making of Ricky Starks, promotional malpractice.

Starks was asked to sink or swim by CM Punk when Collision was launching, and it turns out Punk has in fact left something of a positive legacy in AEW.

Star Rating: ★★★★¾


4. Eddie Kingston & Katsuyori Shibata Vs. Claudio Castgnoli & Wheeler YUTA

Katsuyori Shibata Claudio Castagnoli
Katsuyori Shibata Claudio Castagnoli

After the unreal, special Strap match, it was difficult not to experience an adrenaline dump watching a tag team match that in and of itself as very, very good.

Bluntly, the average AEW pay-per-view is one match too long, and one match invariably suffers. All In - which one could argue was slightly inferior in the ring overall - was something of a rule-proving exception.

This was a victim of sequencing: the breather match before the home stretch caught ablaze. When it rocked, though, it rocked.

Katsuyori Shibata was on awesome form. He looked tentative in the early stages of an AEWROH run that remains bizarre in a way that is hard to place, whether through medical protocols or whatever else. Here, whether he is back-back or has mastered the dark arts of picking his spots, he felt like the old Shibata. Eating strikes when locking in an unbreakable submission hold, working a sequence of awesome intent with Claudio Castagnoli even when the big blows didn't land: the energy of Shibata returned, and who needs the headbutts?

Their dynamic was explored brilliantly in a match elevated by its attentive subplots and continuity.

The finish was anticlimactic - Claudio pinned Kingston with an uppercut - so much so that it almost felt botched. It should render Eddie's redemption all the sweeter, but on the night, it was a touch strange.

Star Rating: ★★★¾


3. Kenny Omega Vs. Konosuke Takeshita

Kenny Omega Konosuke Takeshita
AEW

Kenny Omega and Konosuke Takeshita worked what was an excellent wrestling match that didn't quite reach its ceiling.

That's not to say it wasn't outstanding, because it was - it just wasn't a fiver. It was heated, and fans clearly bought into Takeshita as a threat - otherwise those awesome, dramatic last five minutes don't happen - but since the build was so unfocused over the prior month, it didn't feel like the match that could write Kenny Omega off for good. They certainly tried to tell that story early, to scary effect.

With an insane bump, as directed by Callis, Take drilled Omega with a backdrop suplex right on his head before focusing his assault on the area from which Kenny underwent hernia surgery. The storytelling was strong, the action physical to an unfathomable degree, but a certain emotion was lacking. The action though, Jesus Christ. It was almost horrifying on an aural level.

Every V-Trigger and knee strike connected with a vile, concussive-sounding thud. Deeper into the match, after a drawn-out struggle on the top turnbuckle, Take destroyed Omega with an incredible avalanche blue thunder bomb. The execution of the move was unreal, as was the near-fall, but again, because Take spent too long in the background since Double Or Nothing, the all-important harrowing suspense just wasn't there. It did not feel like Take was going to badly injure him.

The last few minutes were driven by the power of the action: the work was so explosive and snug, and Omega's glazed-eyes selling was so expert, that the finishing stretch reached the ceiling.

The rematch could and should be even better, and really, only Omega is capable of working a ****1/2 match with the most pedantic twinge of slight disappointment.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


2. FTR & The Young Bucks Vs. Bullet Club Gold

FTR Young Bucks Bullet Club Gold
AEW

So ambitious that it was almost undone, this was still great.

It bordered on the astonishing at times, when, for example, Matt Jackson and not Cash Wheeler completed the Shatter Machine unbeknownst to Dax Harwood. It was a match that sought to achieve two outcomes: set up a rematch between FTR and the Gunns, and maintain the idea that the Bucks and FTR cannot be separated to almost have the fans demand a fourth match to find out once and for all who is better.

On that ambition, one unbelievable and very complex sequence fell apart at the last second. A breathless salvo of double, triple and quintuple team spots lost the thread when Nick Jackson missed his moonsault on Juice Robinson completely.

Watching FTR unleash superkicks was a strange delight. The idea that the two teams respect one another so much that they are willing to betray their own code is such a neat way of developing what can be a bland all-babyface dynamic.

Again, special praise must be reserved for Jay White. His positional skill and timing was the glue in this match. Few are better at directing traffic.

Messy, exhilarating, and compelling for reasons within and beyond the control of the performers - that Young Bucks reaction was something else, and they luxuriated in it - if this was a little bit more lean and tight, it could have been an all-timer of an AEW "party" match. As it happens, it was merely excellent.

Star Rating: ★★★★


1. Orange Cassidy Vs. Jon Moxley - International Title Match

Jon Moxley Orange Cassidy
AEW

The debate surrounding Orange Cassidy was settled in good faith years ago.

The question now is how good he is, and if they say the man makes the title, remember how the All-Atlantic belt was introduced and compare that to last night. His headlining an incredible All Out PPV in a worthy main event, in which he defended a title that was also "levelled up" via dire corporate synergy, is one of the biggest achievements in AEW history.

His match with Jon Moxley was excellent in a way that was distinct from his superb string of TV defences. The story was told that bit more patiently. He, in a great character choice, didn't play too many chess games because this wasn't a game. It was the match of his life, and he performed as such.

Great at virtually everything, he was also a great bleeder. He didn't just get a nice flow of claret going: he was wobbly, vulnerable, defiant. It was a consummate babyface performance. He registered everything brilliantly and sold fans on the despair of imminent defeat and the hope of beating the invincible Moxley character alike. The pacing was masterful, as was the "when" of the action. You see a piledriver every week. Here, the Gotch-style version was executed when Orange was at his most weakened for maximum effect.

Then, when Cassidy drew on the last reserve of stamina and fight to catch Mox out with a crucifix, he generated gasps and hope from an audience over which he held total control.

If you knew nothing of the Cassidy character, and just watched this match, with no discursive context, you'd think he was one of the best babyfaces of the 21st century.

Because he is.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!