10 Match Star Ratings For WWE Super ShowDown 2020
Ricochet is the hill to die on, lads. But don't bother.
You know, they told you this was going to happen.
They said in the build that Ricochet never stood a chance, he was too small, he'd need a miracle to win. Paul Heyman advised you of his spoiler warning. Goldberg outright said in the build that the Fiend's psychological tricks weren't gonna work on him. The Fiend was next, he said. He speared him out of his f*cking clown shoes last Friday. Goldberg famously doesn't work long matches that flatter his opponents. This was all foretold.
The winners of fairly turgid gauntlet matches aren't those announced ahead of and cleared for competition in the match itself. You know this. You should know this. Seth Rollins won a match he wasn't involved in not too long ago. This happened again at Super ShowDown, because of course it did. WWE ritually repeats the same finishes and the same mistakes and God bless you all, much like Kevin Owens, you just keep fighting. You have more stamina than Cain Velasquez, who, incidentally, will soon come back and squash WALTER or something.
And you didn't listen.
You never listen.
You're watching the wrong company.
You have been watching the wrong company for two decades.
You have Stockholm Syndrome.
And it is piss funny.
10. KICKOFF: The OC Vs. The Viking Raiders
This match existed.
Is there a match with less interest and purpose to it than the OC Vs. the Viking Raiders in February 2020?
The feud ended. The Viking Raiders won it, and we know that because they lost the RAW Tag Team Titles to Seth Rollins and Murphy subsequent to it. They must have. But it continued here, as every last f*cking thing rolls on, and it was decent, because the Viking Raiders are such a great team with a visceral style and chemistry. But it was ultimately forgettable fare you have seen several times already.
In much the same way as a classic pro wrestling match is a challenge to analyse - often, the only word is magic - there is an anti-magic quality to these Saudi Arabia matches. There's so little heat or excitement or story to them, and yes, an AEW match under these circumstances would have the same effect. In film circles, when an actor takes a job they don't give a toss about, they're doing it to buy a new pool. This is literally the case here, gauging by Karl Anderson's Twitter game.
Magic killer, indeed.
Can you remember who went over?
Star Rating: ★★½
9. Tuwaiq Mountain Trophy Gauntlet Match
In which the heat company can't even get heat right for the love of hilarious Christ.
R-Truth and Bobby Lashley worked a halfway decent TV match in which Lashley took a hurricanrana. They worked quite hard, R-Truth's John Cena tribute act remains sweet almost, but Lashley's heat spot is bland and old-fashioned. R-Truth stole one - well, he stole more than one, which was fitting for a night on which WWE completely over-saturated every bad thing it does to the point of parody. This however didn't see a wild-eyed Truth look like he'd just encountered a religious experience by winning a pro wrestling match; he banged heads with Andrade and dumb-f*cked his way into the next phase.
Cute on paper, the crowd didn't care, undermining the sought-for underdog spirit. Truth then defeated Rowan, who has been built for three months, in three minutes of ostensibly nothing. Rowan attacked Truth after the bell, weakening him ahead of his next duel, with AJ Styles, who just taunted Truth with exaggerated, broad comedy mannerisms.
His arch plan was foiled - the Undertaker emerged in Rey Mysterio's place - and won the Tuwaiq Mountain Trophy with just one Chokeslam, even though Styles hadn't endured a single blow.
Undertaker Vs. AJ Styles began with a comedy angle. The Chokeslam looked like sh*t. 'Taker didn't bother to remove his Stetson nor take home the trophy. This company is a complete joke and you should therefore laugh at and not whine over it.
Sensational.
Star Rating: ★¾
8. The New Day Vs. The Miz & John Morrison - SmackDown Tag Team Title Match
The sole, earnestly good thing on this entire sh*t-show, this match was fun, over, and almost stupidly committed.
Under the opulent and ugly bright lights - this show looked so stunning that they should replace the idiom "polish a turd" with "Super ShowDown" - Big E entertained the crowd by slapping John Morrison's ass, which unfortunately summoned Michael Cole to tell us that Big E does, in fact, like to have fun out there. Vince McMahon is essentially GOB Bluth telling everybody to dance now, expect he hasn't been funny since 2007.
Morrison in begging off showed as much personality as he did athleticism later in the match, in what was a very successful night for him. It was supporting evidence in his box of Schrödinger's star power that he got over in a land in which nobody gets over who isn't a grotesque, prehistoric, blood-money-hungry parody of their 1990s self.
Structurally and in terms of its pace, this wasn't remarkable, or anything, but Kofi Kingston in particular entered a very hard-working and super-professional performance to put over both the next Champions and the idea that he wasn't going to lose without first breaking his back.
Star Rating: ★★★
7. Angel Garza Vs. Humberto Carrillo
There's really not a lot to say.
Angel Garza and Humberto Carrillo worked a perfectly serviceable wrestling match with a real sense of working craft but nobody cared about it, they knew nobody was going to care about it, and consequently held back the banger in the chamber. There's an enervated quality to these Saudi Arabia matches that conspires to be even more dull than hour-two Monday Night RAW fare. This was a sequel to a far better, energetic and intense RAW match, from this very week, and didn't need to exist.
Still, Angel's Garza's face is just so wonderful to look at it. He turns all of us into Marlon Brando voicing Truckasaurus. They lunged at one another at the opening bell, holding nothing back in their strikes, trusting their sense of craft and chemistry to evade, and Garza being so excellent has this rare, ultra-valuable knack of projecting real animosity to whichever opponent he faces. It was just weird, as many of these matches are. You know it can be better - it was better four days ago - but there was a languid and meh quality to it.
There's really not a lot to say.
Star Rating: ★★¾
6. Seth Rollins & Murphy Vs. The Street Profits
A perversely entertaining show at critical points, elsewhere, Super ShowDown bled into itself by presenting too many matches with the same back-and-forth heat-driven structure, the same duration, the same level of interest, the same style.
There was no heft to the story. They did the customary opposing-partners-face-off thing on RAW, of course, but that barely counts. Montez Ford has something. That is a hot take. But where he shows it in the U.S. with his absorbing charisma, he had to tell it at Super ShowDown with overt crowd appeals, which while understandable was sad to see. His facial expressions were a bit too over-the-top to take seriously at points.
The camera work was sh*tty: the one time WWE finally rested on a single image is when they should have cut away, which was emblematic of a night on which they got nothing right. The timing wasn't great, either - Murphy telegraphed his cutoff - but, and here's the refrain, the fans weren't invested. They wouldn't have cared, had it looked perfect, like Angelo Dawkins had been wronged at the last, dying second.
They reacted to the stars of the '90s and didn't reacted to slow-downed versions of WWE's hardly banging in-house style.
Star Rating: ★★½
5. Mansoor Vs. Dolph Ziggler
This wasn't a bad match, by any means, and the pitch was inspired enough.
It was a continuation of Mansoor's regional character arc, in which he gets over in Saudi Arabia and Saudi Arabia alone through being paired with a seasoned workhorse. The issue is that WWE had already selected its best workhorse in Cesaro. This was a diminished return. The other issue is that this never leads anywhere, means nothing to anybody outside of Saudi Arabia, and is house show fare that needs an atmosphere you aren't a part of to get over.
Ziggler played the cocky veteran role convincingly enough, initially, and Mansoor possesses a star quality that gets over, but unfortunately manifests in dorky facial expressions. The (pretty good) comeback took an age to arrive, which didn't help. Ziggler's fast, big-bumping style of old is just that now, and as a result of his stop/start, overlong and overfamiliar midcard career lacks the gravitas to play this role in a match of any significant length. Mansoor crushed his ribs at the finish, revealing his inexperience.
"We're here to stay!" Mansoor said in his post-match victory speech, as if he even gets booked on NXT.
Star Rating: ★★¾
4. Brock Lesnar Vs. Ricochet - WWE Heavyweight Title Match
"No! No! No! I can't wait for Drew McIntyre to avenge Ricochet, and take down this big baddie once and for all!"
That's what WWE wanted you to feel, when laying out this match. You didn't, or you might have, but the prevailing feeling was "Welp, this company is knackered".
This is the hill to die on, because Ricochet is really, really talented. We were shown the most of cruel glimpses because his bumping and selling was awesome. The spectacular angles at which he landed on his neck were millimetre-precise to convey just how much of a monster Lesnar is, and he sold like he was dead in a way that stripped away any element of melodrama.
Can you imagine how effective this performance would have been, had this informed a babyface comeback and a desperate series of near-falls engineered through his jaw-dropping aerial assaults?
You can't, because this company strips away any feeling of hope for its full-time generation of incredible talent.
They turned Ricochet into the biggest f*cking geek in the world, and then they turned him into a squished fly. You will never take him seriously again. The Real-Life Superhero is, in fact, the Flaming Carrot.
Star Rating:
-★★
3. Roman Reigns Vs. King Corbin - Steel Cage Match
My God, what a waste of bastard time.
This feud is death. We know who was going to win this match because Roman Reigns already won the feud, and "Hey maybe they'll 50/50 this lol" isn't a source of interest, unless you're a nihilist.
Perhaps that was the entire purpose of this show. Perhaps WWE wants its audience to hate-watch the product.
This was a match you so desperately wanted Roman Reigns to win without actively caring at all, knowing full well that they could run back yet another rematch with no purpose nor shame.
Corbin, the tall, powerful heel who invariably grinds down his opponents with mind-numbing heat spots, and takes roughly 80% of every televised match, of course decided to climb the cage within seconds in the one match where, theoretically, he could have worn Reigns down with his chinlock and sprinted out of the door, under WWE's dumbass cage match rules, in less than the three seconds it would take to pin him.
This wasn't violent. It wasn't creative. It wasn't dynamic. It wasn't compelling.
It was slow. It was dull. It was pointless.
Star Rating: ★¾
2. Bayley Vs. Naomi - SmackDown Women's Title Match
It's so difficult to watch these Women's matches. Just the sight of an oversized t-shirt makes escapism impossible.
But, even if you're not a soyboy cuck, this match - once again - wasn't terribly exciting. They are almost immune to critique because this entire exercise is so artless and the talent, understandably, tends to only lace up one working boot, or in some cases two bare left-footed soles.
Bayley tried to wear Naomi down early with a side headlock and imagine liking this. Every single match was built on a grind-down heat spot and imagine WWE hiring several road agents to guide the talent through matches that never really deviate from a set in-house structure when a printed guide would do the trick for significantly less money. Naomi rocked Bayley with a corkscrew plancha, and it looked great, as the action heated up, but a crossbody looked like sh*t. The young girl in the crowd captured with awful, rotten cynicism seemed to enjoy it, though!
The heel outsmarted the babyface at the finish when the heel is stale, the babyface wasn't, and WWE can't book babyfaces.
Star Rating: ★★½
1. The Fiend Vs. Goldberg - Universal Title Match
Spear.
Spear.
Mandible.
Spear.
Mandible.
Spear.
Spear.
The sh*ttiest Jackhammer in all of creation.
But it wasn't the worst hammer in WWE history. That honour belongs to The Fiend Bray Wyatt's big stupid mallet, which made this absolutely awful squash match quite cathartic.
The Fiend wasn't over. Some people might have bought his merch, and he was r/SquaredCircle over, but he wasn't over over. His massive push coincided with tumbling fan-driven metrics. One of his matches received the most toxic reactions in the history of the company. The next generated mild "They're using weapons and that's always fun" pops. His TLC match with the Miz was met with almost complete silence. Daniel Bryan dragged a reaction from the crowd when those impossible triumphs peaked, but even he lost the crowd at points because there is no internal psychological logic to the Fiend's dumb horror movie matches. He's an unkillable monster who has to selectively sell for wrestling moves because this is wrestling.
One more time for the people in the back: not one Fiend match got over to an acceptable main event level.
On principle, this was awful, but how aren't you numb to this?
In execution, lol, this was sh*t. Goldberg is thrashed. There is no snap to his Spear anymore. Wyatt didn't so much get broken in half but fell down like a sack of potatoes. That big secret, teased by Ramblin' Rabbit, that was key to the Fiend's demise?
It was a suplex Tom Magee could have done a better job with lmao.
Star Rating:
-★★★★