10 Matches WWE Could HONESTLY Call ‘The Greatest Ever’

The Truth Is No Words

Johnny Gargano Andrade Almas TakeOver Philadelphia
WWE

Experienced veteran Al Snow once posited that "a good match is the one that drew the most money", but faced the reality of his words when forced to consider if that rendered his entire back catalogue moot.

On his day, Snow was capable of outworking many of his peers though only a minute portion of those in attendance would have confessed to buying a ticket for the primary reason of catching glimpse of The New Rockers or the fella with the mannequin head. Ironically, his fleeting moment as an inarguable top draw in ECW came at the expense of his in-ring skill - the styrofoam skulls brought the main event ambience his chain wrestling never could.

Al's logic stands up of course, but it isn't quite the be all end all he claims. There's a subjective middle ground between selling out stadiums and stealing shows, even if the idyllic situation contains lashings of both. WWE, by the nature of their presentation style, want to facilitate every contest as a contender. Outside of the darkest corners of the mid-1990s, arenas have always been dressed to impress and "packed to the rafters", aiding the aesthetic and providing the brightest possible spotlight for some of the industry's elite.

But they're subsequently guilty of rampant hyperbole, keen to posit moribund matches as a 'moments' before they even happen or blatantly lie about the supposed skills of a protected project. The truth of true greatness trumps any company-spun embellishment.

10. The Dudley Boyz Vs Edge & Christian Vs The Hardy Boyz (WrestleMania 17)

Jeff Hardy Edge
WWE Network

The true culmination of career-shortening clashes between the three teams over the prior two years, WrestleMania 17's Tables, Ladders and Chairs sequel benefited from the enormous crowd that got to share the pain and passion of six performers desperate to succeed.

The company's return to a stadium setting for the first time since Royal Rumble 1997 was in complete contrast to the intimate atmosphere and aggression of the Attitude Era, and perhaps one of the many reasons the show is considered the period's last hurrah. But it signified how far the organisation had come since San Antonio's cavernous Alamo Dome required extensive papering to fill a home town title win.

On a loaded card still considered by many to be the finest ever, Edge & Christian emerged victorious from a chaotic weapons war that stole the show. But rarely was Jim Ross' pre-show hyperbole about careers being made ever so accurate. Crafted smartly and logically in comparison to previous destruction derbies, a wacky stack of frightening spots built in imaginative style before all the pieces toppled with Edge's momentous spear on Jeff Hardy from a hanging title.

A 'WrestleMania moment' before the company became obsessed with manufacturing them, it fed into a match that etched all six into WWE lore and at least three (at current count) into the Hall Of Fame.


9. Sami Zayn Vs Shinsuke Nakamura (NXT TakeOver: Dallas)

Sami Zayn, Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Shinsuke Nakamura's maiden match under the WWE umbrella flew in the face of countless failures launching talent in personas not carefully constructed by the company's creative machine. Like success stories that had recently preceded it, it relied on the talent first and foremost with minimal (yet hugely impactful) sprinklings of NXT gold dust.

Promoted only with an iPhone video of his impending arrival, the minimalist nature of the build was in sublime contrast to the 'King Of Strong Style's entrance on the night. The violins and scintillating synths now synonymous with singalongs were instead a multi-sense assault matched only by Shinsuke's wink to the hard camera before kicking Sami Zayn's face off.

'The Underdog From The Underground' couldn't hide his own grin as the match commenced, knowing as he was of what the pair were about to assemble. It was to be his fond farewell to the developmental brand 48 hours before his own first - a slot on the card at the record-breaking WrestleMania 32.

With so much real-life endeavour laying dormant beneath the battle, the small matter of a wrestling match risked fading into the background. Zayn and Nakamura refused to allow their artistry to be overshadowed. An exhausting display of guts, determination and fire from the two babyfaces, Shinsuke's violent kicks were given evocative heft by Sami's limitless sympathy as his last goodbye loomed. Literally taking things on the chin, Zayn couldn't have looked less of a loser taking a loss, while a star was (re)born from his selflessness.


8. John Cena Vs CM Punk (Money In The Bank 2011)

CM Punk John Cena Money in the Bank 2011.jpg
WWE.com

John Cena and CM Punk had arguably superior in-ring efforts either side of an iconic Chicago clash, with arguments valid that the pair were each other's career opponents thanks to feuds the preceded and followed the magnificent events surrounding Money In The Bank 2011.

But as a complete Sports Entertainment spectacle from the spine-tingling seconds before and during Punk's music hitting through to his blown kiss to Vince McMahon, there's few contests more captivating.

A already-brilliant match elevated further by the fourth wall-smashing storyline, Cena and Punk's every move pulls on the positive tension of a white hot crowd. 'Big Match John's usual audience manipulation doesn't fall asunder, but nor is it required as the audience fall just short of employing physical interjection to carry their hero over the line.

Enhanced by interjections from bothersome busybodies Vince McMahon and John Laurinaitis in ways that don't compromise the integrity of Cena or Punk themselves, the chain of events feeding into Punk's iconic victory are among the most brilliantly manipulative minutes ever assembled by the company. High end soap opera on rewatch, the talent involved deserve enormous plaudits for timing their movements and reactions with believable perfection on the night - lesser performers may have dropped the ball having been handed the most delicate of potential touchdowns.


7. Razor Ramon Vs Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania 10)

Razor Ramon, Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

Chris Jericho and Shawn Michaels revived the lost art of telling a singles story in a Ladder Match with their climactic No Mercy 2008 battle, but they were victims of their own success for the sheer scale of repetition required for them to get there. 'HBK's WrestleMania 10 battle with Razor Ramon was only overplayed to the wrestlers themselves after weeks of practice on the house show circuit. To the audience inside Madison Square Garden and watching on pay-per-view, they'd made utter magic.

Phenomenal wrestlers without a gimmick, the pair were equally exceptional with a gimmick. The ladder was both the pathway to glory and the ultimate implement of their destruction, particularly for an increasingly vicious Michaels as he resorted to the weaponry as a replacement for his interfering bodyguard Diesel's early exit.

Driven to equal Shawn's ferocity but still keen most on claiming what he knew was his, Razor was atypically empathetic on the sell. Such sympathy was yet more uncharted territory for 'The Bad Guy', but it was impossible not to get behind the bruised Champion as he yelped and screamed in pain after wicked ladder shots to the back and head by the savage challenger. Ramon hadn't underestimated Michaels' ability, but had neglected to consider his violent desperation.

Upfront confidence betrays the relief in Razor's eyes as he stands atop the ladder with both his own and Michaels' imposter title belt following his heroic victory. He'd endured a war not with the chickensh*t that first assaulted him, but a man willing to prove his worth.


6. Andrade 'Cien' Almas Vs Johnny Gargano (NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia)

NXT TakeOver Philadelphia Johnny Gargano Andrade Cien Almas
WWE.com

Perhaps, perhaps, perhaps.

Too soon to consider a contest amongst the elite? Perhaps. But was it most heartbreaking chapter in NXT's best ever storyline? Perhaps. And was it best NXT match ever? Perhaps.

The developmental brand deserves praise for delivering so many contests over the years to put those hypotheticals in doubt. Andrade 'Cien' Almas' successful title defence against Johnny Gargano was without prejudice one of the greatest matches in the history of the organisation. Timeless as it was happening, Gargano's selling of a dreamlike moment slipping away against his struggle to cling on to it echoed the sentiment of every single fan glued to the action.

Almas - to his credit - was the perfect heel to feast on his desire. Few performers have risen so far beyond expectations in the last 12 months than the former 'La Sombra', but his surprising title victory in November was only shocking for all the right reasons. A deserved leader alongside vital missing piece Zelina Vega, 'Cien' has kept it one hundred as NXT Champion, with his maiden TakeOver defence untouchable against the already-high standards already set by Neville, Kevin Owens, Finn Bálor, Samoa Joe and others.

An only-slightly inferior variant of the Gargano/Almas template jerked the curtain at August's TakeOver: Brooklyn 3. For the two to somehow improve upon the original was a minor miracle, but the stature-enhancing effort has elevated them to additional to an elite group of sequel impresarios. Could they have one of the best ever trilogies? Perhaps.


5. The Undertaker Vs Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania 25)

Undertaker, Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

The Undertaker's robust professionalism in the face of his inherently silly gimmick in an inherently silly industry was a crucial reason why he lasted long enough to sully his legacy when it seemed for so long like he'd go out at the very top of his game.

A late bloomer as an in-ring performer after a decade of decadence dining on duds, The Undertaker elected to tighten his grip on superstardom by evolving into a supreme being with submission holds, rather than just super-powers. It was this Undertaker that thrilled audiences at the end of the 2007 Royal Rumble, start of the 2008 one, and in era-defining fashion at WrestleMania 25.

Of course, he wasn't alone in those endeavours, and had possibly the best partner to aid the displays. The unexpected Rumble dalliances with former rival Shawn Michaels had birthed new life into an old feud, and their epic WrestleMania 25 effort completely re-imagined an original masterpiece from a decade prior.

Once a frightened rabbit in the fearsome face of 'The Deadman', The 'Heartbreak Kid' was all man against him in their advancing years. Chasing a count-out win just for the win, Michaels exhibited some vintage desperation after Undertaker whiffed on a dive but other than that, it was Undertaker himself that almost lost all hope when Shawn somehow lifted a shoulder from the Tombstone. Ultimately, 'HBK's guts garnered no glory as a Undertaker caught him off a moonsault with another one to end the type of match an entire new generation of wrestling fans had yet to experience.


4. Bret Hart Vs Owen Hart (WrestleMania 10)

WrestleMania X Bret Hart Owen Hart
WWE.com

Vince McMahon's empire may have eventually ceased to exist by the end of the 1990s had it not been for years of unmatched effort by a prize horse he callously took out back and shot the second he no longer deemed it useful.

Considered short on drawing power due to his prominence coinciding with the industry's financial nadir, Bret Hart was a vital cornerstone when others shunned critical glare. Hulk Hogan b*ggered off in 1992 and 1993, Lex Luger profoundly failed as a replacement, Shawn Michaels' mind and body couldn't carry the load, and Hart himself was the only one outside of Kevin Nash's close circle of friends capable of making Diesel the type of WWE Champion McMahon desperately wanted.

Bret was hardworking, reliable and exactly as f*cking excellent as he claimed to be. They were traits instilled into him and brother Owen by their father Stu. Each one was left in the ring for their mesmerising technical classic.

Portraying the snot-nosed younger brother, Owen took shortcuts for fun followed up by finesse for function. Determined not to veer from his measured game-plan (and with a show-closing main event to consider later than night) Bret's attempt to over-egg his polished assault was his undoing.

Their worthy 20 minute battle had already pushed him beyond his planned pursuit when he straddled Owen's shoulders for a victory roll. Tired and masking the hurried approach, he execution was less than excellent as Owen stepped out of his brother's shadow and into a leg-trapping pinfall for an unlikely three-count.


3. Sasha Banks Vs Bayley (NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn)

sasha banks bayley
WWE.com

Speaking publicly on the loftiest of her ambitions, Sasha Banks hasn't hidden her aspirations to be the best women's wrestler ever. She'll potentially have to increase her hit-rate if she wishes to compete with the finest from the Far East, but in North American terms, her and Bayley's places amongst the elite are assured thanks to the greatest women's match in company history.

With a WWE Women's division now obsessed with making history just by the virtue of existing on the same plane as their male counterparts, it's easy to forget how 'The Boss' and 'The Hugger' managed it in 2015 by - shockingly - delivering a sensational match as a payoff to an emotion-driven storyline.

Banks was a sensational heel; the Champion, 'The Boss', the best. Babyface Bayley the challenger, the underdog, the great pretender to her opponent's throne. Purity oozed from her determined expression throughout, replacing a more literal representation negated by the PG-era blood ban.

Sasha initially soared, smashing her opponent's injured hand with cold vigour before flooring her foe with a plancha to shorten her recovery time. Relishing her work a little too much, she lost control as the match became a back-and-forth of submissions and finisher attempts.

Bayley's tenacity counted double in the frenzy of it all, particularly when she uncorked a terrifying reverse hurricanrana from the top rope to set up a match-winning Bayley-To-Belly. Her primal discarding of her wrist tape seconds before the move mirrored her long-awaited willingness to throw necessary caution to the wind.


2. The Undertaker Vs Shawn Michaels (Badd Blood: In Your House)

Badd Blood In Your House
www.wwe.com

Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker had multiple classics in their respective lockers, but miraculously saved their best efforts for epic clashes against each other.

October 1997's Hell In A Cell was and remains the company's best ever steel cage match in-part because of the return to the original psychology of the gimmick. 'HBK' was sh*t-scared of 'The Deadman', and not just because everybody was. The storyline had called for Michaels to turn his d*ckhead up to 11 in his assaults on the conscience of the company, the roofed mesh would facilitate his overdue comeuppance. And how.

Battered in a way few could emote, Shawn was beaten beyond reproach until he salvaged brief control and snatched at an escape. As a ringside cameraman required stretchering out of the structure, Michaels seized the opportunity but was quickly made to regret his decision when the relentless 'Phenom' gave chase.

Undertaker battered Shawn more for having the gaul to try and escape the inescapable reality of his grim situation, bloodying him up on one side of the structure for kicking him off the other. Kane's iconic debut was both a perfect payoff to the summer's long-form sibling mystery and the match itself. Undertaker was prepared to let Shawn die, as he'd done decades earlier with his younger brother - Paul Bearer's big red surprise was the real killer blow.


1. Bret Hart Vs Stone Cold Steve Austin (WrestleMania 13)

Stone Cold Steve Austin Bret Hart
WWE

The most important match in company history, Bret Hart and Stone Cold Steve Austin's WrestleMania 13 bloodbath was the dictionary definition of wrestling match excellence in both concept and execution. Hart's catchphrase had never been as potent, whilst the mechanics 'The Rattlesnake' had been hired for never fused more fluidly with the chaotic style that would come to form all WWE main events for the company's most prosperous period.

The words committed to the contest never really do it justice even now. An immaculately-told story since Hart returned in November, his slow-burning heel turn engulfed him on the go-home edition of Monday Night Raw when he pushed announcer Vince McMahon to the ground. His babyface persona was burnt to ashes by the end of this almighty war.

Hulk Hogan rose rapidly through the ranks upon his WWE return thanks to countless victories - Stone Cold Steve Austin had his breakthrough in defeat with his shattered face glued to the mat in blood. He had become the biggest babyface in the world before the world (and Vince McMahon) worked out what they wanted, but the incredible work from both men sealed the deal in a way nobody could miss. 'The Rattlesnake' was the hero McMahon needed, with his claret flowing rather than a cape.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.