10 Memorably Punishing WWE Matches
Wrestling is a tough business - never tougher than in these examples.
Wrestling is supposed to be safe, in that the wrestlers aren't meant to actually injure each other. No one said it wasn't allowed to hurt, though, and it does. Every wrestling match is a punishing experience, and the competitors rely on training, conditioning and the skills of their opponent to ensure none of it is permanent.
Some matches are more punishing than others. On some occasions a wrestler is injured and continues anyway, toughing it out until they can reach an ending, or a competitor is infected with the bloodlust of the crowd and goes way too far.
Other matches involve one wrestler deliberately battering the other. Wrestling's old-school (some would say petty and macho) culture involves a lot of hazing and 'paying one's dues', which means new wrestlers having the bejeesus smacked out of them at the hands of higher-status members of the roster.
WWE's in-ring style is on the safer end of things, because so many of their wrestlers work hundreds of nights a year. Even so, WWE's history is littered with notably painful matches when things went wrong, hazings were enacted, or old-fashioned punishment were meted out.
10. The Acolytes Vs. The Public Enemy (Sunday Night Heat, 7 March 1999)
Thanks to the booking prowess of Paul Heyman in ECW, tag team The Public Enemy were a huge deal when they became free agents in 1999. WWE acquired them, but the locker room were not immediately enamoured by two men who had previously chosen competitors over WWE and acted like a bigger deal than they arguably were.
In the face of such provocation, the vengeful roster of 1999 had only one recourse. Send in The Acolytes.
Farooq and Bradshaw got their crack at The Public Enemy on an episode of Sunday Night Heat and didn't let the chance go to waste. The unofficial executioners of the company's disgruntled wrestlers launched a full-out assault on the unsuspecting newcomers.
Bradshaw's murderous chair shots to their backs and shoulders and Farooq's criminal stomps to a downed opponent left no doubt as to the purpose of the match. A final unprotected chair to the head head added an exclamation point.
It was a punishment beating and because it was in front of a live audience, The Public Enemy were obliged to sit and take it.
9. Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels - Royal Rumble 1998
As legendarily titanic a jerk Shawn Michaels was in the mid-late 1990s, he delivered in the ring. For a man not renowned for his toughness he could nevertheless grit his teeth and tough it out when a match was at stake. When he faced The Undertaker in a casket match for the WWE Championship at the Royal Rumble main event in 1998, he had to.
In a backdrop onto the casket, Michaels glanced off the lid before spilling onto the ground. It looked like a typically fluid, safe Michaels bump, but the impact hurt way - way more than it should have.
With the main event of a major pay-per-view at stake, Michaels stuck to the plan of the match and fought a 20-minute match with only a slight pained stiffness to his gait suggesting he was hurting for real.
Shortly afterwards, the impact on the casket was shown to have herniated two discs and crushed another in his spine. The injury almost ended Michaels' career permanently. For Michaels, the match was too punishing to come back from.
8. Women's Elimination Tag Match - Survivor Series 1995
During the mid-1990s, partly in response to WCW's importing of talented luchadors, the WWE entered into a short-lived relationship with All Japan Pro Wrestling. One of the results was this Survivor Series women's elimination tag team match, which marked a rare confluence of the normally safety-conscious WWE and the brutal insanity of mid-90s Japanese women's wrestling.
The match was notable for rapid, impactful action typical of the joshi style, with two particularly un-WWE-like instances of raw punishment. One was a rolling kick delivered with orbital-shattering gusto by Lioness Asuka to the minuscule Chaparita Asari. The second was a monstrous backdrop driver from the equally monstrous Aja Kong, one of the few deliberate headdrop moves ever seen in the WWE.
The match is a curio that illustrates just how tough matches in Japan could be, not just when things go wrong or get too personal, but night after night. What stood out as memorably punishing in the WWE was just another night for joshi's finest.
7. Butterbean Vs. Bart Gunn - WrestleMania XV
The Brawl For All tournament was one of the WWE's least successful ideas. Facing the challenge of demonstrating the murderous toughness of 'Dr Death' Steve Williams, Vince McMahon decided to green-light a 'real' tournament where various undercard wrestlers engaged in extremely messy, tedious shoot fights. Unfortunately for everyone concerned, not only did the grim tournament actually take place, but Williams didn't win.
Bart Gunn did.
Gunn's reward for derailing the WWE's plans was a boxing match with Eric 'Butterbean' Esch. Butterbean was a professional boxer, unlike Gunn, and outweighed Gunn by well over a hundred pounds. Even the most hilariously corrupt boxing commission would never have sanctioned such a criminally one-sided match. But the WWE didn't care.
In front of the WrestleMania XV crowd, Gunn was knocked down in a matter of seconds. The referee should have called it then, but mindful of the event, let the match continue. Butterbean clubbed Gunn into unconsciousness, the referee called the match off, and Bart Gunn's WrestleMania moment was also the most mercilessly brutal in the history of the show.
6. Daniel Puder Vs. The Locker Room - Royal Rumble 2005
When wrestlers decide to show off, or even worse show up someone else on the roster, there are consequences. Daniel Puder did this to Kurt Angle, when during a wrestling demonstration the young rookie put Angle into a legitimate armbar and forced the referee to call a pin before Angle's arm was broken.
Whether he knew what was awaiting him when he walked out for the Royal Rumble match in 2005, only Puder himself knows.
The trio of Eddie Guerrero, Chris Benoit, and notoriously haze-happy thug Bob Holly proceeded to batter Puder until he regretted he had ever laced his wrasslin' boots. The chops to his chest were heavy, meaty, sternum-shuddering impacts. Benoit's back suplex almost brained the cocky young Puder.
Holly weighed in with his Alabama Slam, a move he employed precisely because it could be delivered to be legitimately painful. By the time Puder was bundled out of the ring, WWE's old guard had established their superiority once more.
5. Brock Lesnar Vs. John Cena - SummerSlam 2014
In 2014, John Cena was unbeatable. He was the biggest star in the company, and kept constantly, unassailably strong. A clean win over John Cena was as big a deal as winning a championship. It didn't happen.
And then Brock Lesnar came along.
To establish Lesnar as the end-of-game-boss of wrestling, he was booked to beat Cena. And not just beat him. Annihilate him. Crush him. Above all, punish him.
Famously, Lesnar hit 16 German suplexes on John Cena during their match. Most brutally of all, the first one dumped Big Match John on the back of his head. It was not only booked to be a relentless punishment of the company's biggest name, it actually was, with bipedal murder machine Lesnar putting a little extra salt & pepper on every suplex.
One of WWE's most glaringly savage matches, it marked a seismic change in the landscape of the company where even Cena was not immune to the living weapon that was Lesnar.
4. Kurt Angle Vs. Shane McMahon - King Of The Ring 2001
Shane McMahon, perhaps compensating for being the boss' son, was willing to do things seasoned wrestlers would shudder to contemplate. His drop off the Titantron at the hands of Steve Blackman at SummerSlam 2000 was a high (low?) point of Shane O Mac's relationship with the integrity of his own body. But arguably his least sensible moment came in his street fight against Kurt Angle at King of the Ring 2001.
A memorably excellent and already extremely stiff match was punctuated by a couple of utterly horrendous moments, namely when Angle suplexed Shane through a pane of glass behind the stage. It would have been brutal enough if it had gone right, but it didn't. The pane didn't break, allegedly being made of the wrong type of plastic to break neatly, and Shane thumped down to earth on the top of his head.
Obviously, they did it again, because this was Shane. He insisted Angle repeat the move and what Shane wanted, he got. This time the glass broke and Shane landed 'safely' in a crumpled heap on the concrete.
3. JBL Vs. Eddie Guerrero - Judgement Day 2004
When this match between Eddie Guerrero and John 'Bradshaw' Layfield went wrong, it went really wrong. Sickeningly, stomach-turningly, canvas-ruiningly wrong.
JBL, in classic jerk mode, smashed Guerrero in the face with a chair. It was a typically ruthless unprotected shot that illustrated JBL's disregard for human life, but that wasn't what made the match stand out.
Guerrero bladed to give himself the crimson mask and add the drama of blood to the match, but according to wrestling lore, he cut way, way too deep. He hit a major blood vessel, perhaps even an artery, and his forehead immediately began spraying like a weak-bladdered tomcat.
The amount of blood spurting out of Guerrero bordered on a Biblical plague but, to his credit, he finished the match. Blood got absolutely everywhere with both men writhing around in a gore-smeared mess until the final, merciless bell brought an end to the horror.
2. Perry Saturn Vs. Mike Bell (2001)
This match is an example of wrestling's law of the jungle in action, courtesy of glassy-eyed mental case Perry Saturn. In a match against jobber Mike Bell, Saturn became peeved when Bell messed up a hip toss.
Saturn decided against a sternly-worded email to Human Resources, which might have sufficed in any other industry, and instead attempted to kill Mike Bell. Firstly he dumped Bell out of the ring, ensuring he spiked head-first onto the concrete.
When Bell informed Saturn he had landed on his head, Saturn's sympathy extended as far as hoisting Bell off his feet and delivering a half-spinebuster, half-murder attempt into the ring steps. The back of Bell's already abused skull rang off the metal steps.
It was a particularly egregious example of wrestling's rough and ready sense of justice, with someone at the bottom of the totem pole being taken advantage of by a wrestler slightly higher up, played out live where the recipient had no choice but to see the match through.
1. The Rock Vs. Mankind - Royal Rumble 1999
In the annals of brutal WWE matches, a page is set aside for what the Rock did to Mankind in 1999. An 'I Quit' match is already liable to be rather less tender and loving than a regular encounter. That night, something happened in the depths of The Rock's brain that told him a hyped-up Madison Square Gardens crowd would only be satisfied with an act of homicidal violence against Mick Foley.
The match's climax saw Mankind handcuffed, whereupon the Rock smacked him in the face with a chair. Again, that would be enough for anyone else, but the Rock did it ten more times.
Demanding Mankind verbally submit, Foley replied, "You'll have to kill me," in one of the most dramatic moments in wrestling history.
A concussed, bleeding Mick Foley was consoled by his distraught family backstage as seen in the documentary Beyond the Mat. It was a monstrous, brutal, unforgettable match that spanned the gap between amazing entertainment, and taking it way, way too far.