10 Misconceptions WWE Has About Their Fanbase

Where does WWE have it wrong when it comes to their fans?

WWE Raw Roman Reigns Fans
WWE.com

Wrestling is fake. It doesn't hurt. The real Ultimate Warrior died.

For decades, numerous misconceptions have existed about professional wrestling and WWE. Many fans of pro wrestling haven often come to the defence of these mistruths, especially when spread around by an outsider, or someone who wouldn't consider themselves a "wrestling fan".

They're all gay. You're gay if you watch them because they wrestle topless and in their underwear. The Montreal Screwjob was a work. They all take steroids and use drugs...

...but misconceptions in wrestling aren't always limited to just the performers or those on the inside. Fans too, especially supporters of the biggest and most heavily criticized professional wrestling promotion in the world, WWE, have also experienced being classified in a certain inappropriate and inaccurate way.

While the wrestlers are often the targets of wrestling outsiders, and we're not talking Hall or Nash, the fans are often miscast by personalities within the wrestling industry. From promoters to talents, office personnel and dirtsheet writers, numerous misconceptions exist as it pertains to WWE fans with a number of them coming from within WWE itself.

10. Fans Love To Boo Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns Smug
WWE.com

Let's start with one of the biggest misconceptions - and that is the notion that fans boo Roman Reigns because it's the cool thing to do!

This is WWE's party line to try and get Roman Reigns accepted as something - anything - other than the rabidly despised character that he currently is. After all, what self-respecting entertainment company focused on "putting smiles on faces" could justify positioning a near-universally despised character at the forefront of their family-friendly, babyface brand?

Fans boo Roman Reigns because they don't like him, plain and simple. Furthermore, they don't want him in the position as WWE's top babyface.

Do some fans boo Roman because they think it's "cool"? Sure. But these are the same fans that will boo any face, and cheer any heel, just to go against the grain. While these fans do exist, they are far from the majority of WWE's fanbase, thus qualifying as a misconception.

Instead of admitting failure in "Roman Reigns, Premier Babyface", Vince McMahon has arrogantly persisted with an insane, by definition, plan of continuing to push Reigns as a fan favorite, despite unanimously negative results time after time, ongoing for 3 years now.


9. Merchandise Sales Are A True Indicator Of A Talent's Popularity

John Cena
WWE.com

WWE would love to have you believe that merchandise sales is a fair factor in determining superstars deserving of more opportunities. Unfortunately, the entire merch game is a fixed deck. The data behind WWE merch sales is a skewed metric since company officials decide whose likeness gets put on what merchandise and, more importantly, how much of each character's stuff is readily available for purchase.

In other words, it's not a level playing field.

For example, concession stands at WWE live events are often full of Roman Reigns or John Cena merchandise but limited on other superstars'. Imagine it this way. Maybe one kid's first choice for a souvenir is a Dolph Ziggler t-shirt but they're sold out; his second choice, a pair of Zack Ryder sunglasses that were never even stocked. Eventually, the kid settles for a Roman Reigns glove because, ta da, there's plenty of those available!

This isn't to say any one superstar's numbers would be plummet if all things were even, but is simply meant to illustrate that, at the end of the day, WWE's flagship performers are determined by top executives.

They can just manipulate the data to support their narrative.


8. Popular Superstars Can Be Created In A Factory

Triple H WWE Performance Center
@tripleh/Instagram

In recent years, WWE has operated under the belief that talents with an ability to "get over" can be cooked up in a factory somewhere, namely Orlando, and that the audience's reaction can be controlled. This couldn't differ more from the formula that made WWE a household name years ago.

Previously, talents worked in front of live crowds for years, developing a character, building a relationship with fans (either as a heel or blue-eye), and then, if they were good enough, they'd be asked to come work for the World Wrestling Federation. Talents had to prove they were worthy of Vince McMahon's previous television time before he'd take a chance on them.

"It's a different time," is the excuse we're often given today and it's exactly that - an excuse.

While that is true, it's no excuse for showcasing half-baked, unproven "superstars" on prime time television. It's not their fault, but many of today's WWE superstars are not of the caliber of past generations. It's inevitable then that, by comparison, today's roster comes across as second-rate and lesser-than when compared to the past.

There's no substitute for experience and while the Performance Center is a great tool, it's not the end-all, be-all for creating superstars that will resonate with today's audience.


7. Live Crowd Reactions Aren't Accurate

WWE Raw Roman Reigns Fans
WWE.com

It's a wise notion - if not incredibly obvious - but while the Chairman of the Board, at nearly 72 years old, still claims to still listen to his audience, Vince McMahon has stopped responding to crowd reactions.

It's interesting to see how WWE's narrative surrounding the benefits of fan reactions has changed over the years. It used to be that listening to the live audience was the best way to gauge fan satisfaction in the product. Especially in passionate cities like New York or Chicago, fan reactions were extremely informative and used as a major tool in determining what the audiences would and would not accept.

In recent years, however, the narrative has changed.

Nowadays, WWE executives ignores disapproval no matter how loud or how widespread it is. WWE will only acknowledge vocal fan reactions if they align with the wishes of Vince McMahon (which is not too often anymore). Otherwise, the reactions are either ignored or relatively disqualified, strongly indicating that McMahon can no longer read his audience.

Instead of embracing these responses like they did previously, WWE arrogantly forges ahead with canned creative plans no matter the amount of backlash and negativity. And those passionate cities once lauded for providing valuable market research are now vilified for the same reason...


6. Reactions In Certain Cities Should Be Ignored

Roman Reigns The Rock
WWE.com

Part of the changing narrative surrounding audiences' reactions involves specific wrestling hotbeds.

"It's bizarro world," WWE's commentators will say, or as Corey Graves illogically put it on RAW After 'Mania 33, "They boo who they normally cheer."

WWE's attitude towards crowds from cities like Philadelphia, Chicago, and Toronto is that they should be ignored and treated as "not the norm". This flawed logic started with WWE ignoring certain cities' reactions. Then WWE decided to ignore just the reactions coming from televised events. Now, they're ignoring pretty much all crowd reactions.

All over the world, fans are watching the product and expressing their dissatisfaction. If WWE wants to ignore responses from the most passionate cities, that's their loss. If WWE wants to ignore paying customers that buy tickets to see their show live, that's also their loss. The sector of fans that WWE actually listens to now has become so granular and so compartmentalized, it's laughable.

The shame of it is that these towns haven't changed; WWE has. These cities have always supported WWE and the company used to listen to them, then react and adjust accordingly. Today, WWE doesn't do enough to win back their most ardent audiences and ignores feedback once considered invaluable.


5. Fans Are Free To Express Their Opinion!

WWE Raw Crowd
WWE.com

A quick glance at any RAW or WWF Pay-Per-View from 1997 will show a big difference in attitude towards wrestling fans and their first amendment right.

In '97, fan-created signs and posters were everywhere! The WWF encouraged this type of participation. In fact, part of the storyline feud between Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart involved the fans' decision to stop supporting the Hitman (in the United States, at least). Commentators were heard touting fans' freedom to express their opinion. Through signs, costumes, chants, cheers, and boos, fans could support whomever they wanted, and WWE encouraged that.

How times have changed.

Nowadays, stories about WWE confiscating signs, moving ticket purchasers' seats, and fans being asked to change their clothing have circulated. For a company that once supported fan creativity and freedom of expression, it's a big turnaround. In the current world landscape, respectful fans have been asked to take down their signs (despite containing no vulgar or foul language), change their shirts, remove their costumes, or risk moving, or in some severe cases losing, their seats altogether.

WWE will still say their fans are encouraged to express their opinion, so long as that opinion matches the company's status quo.


4. Logic And Continuity Are Not Important To Storylines

Vince Mcmahon
WWE.com

One of the biggest gripes of many adult wrestling fans today is the lack of continuity that WWE too often exhibits.

The most recent blunder in continuity came during WWE Payback's House Of Horrors match, which began in an old abandoned house supposedly within driving distance of San Jose's SAP Arena. Despite it still being daylight in San Jose when the match concluded in the arena ring, the initial fight inside the "House of Horrors" showed that it was completely dark outside. Doh!

In addition to continuity, logic is also missing from WWE programming.

Remember when Vince McMahon went to great lengths to prevent Shane from controlling RAW, only to voluntarily empower him the day after Shane lost to The Undertaker at WrestleMania 32? Also, how can Brock Lesnar go months without defending his championship while past WWE superstars have had their titles stripped for failing to defend within 30 days? And how can a wrestler lose and lose and lose, match after match after match, and then be granted a World title opportunity seemingly out of no where?

Why is sports entertainment's logic so flawed?

Quite simply, it's because WWE does not think that storyline logic or continuity is that important to its fanbase.


3. The "Hardcore" Fans Will Always Watch

RAW FEARS RATINGS
WWE

The notion that the most ardent pro wrestling fan will continue to watch WWE no matter what is presented has been put to the test over the past year or so, with some telling results.

For years, RAW steadily drew around 3 million viewers every week, but over the past year, the number dipped below 2.5 million viewers at times and come American football season (September), it's likely to get a lot worse. It's a sign that WWE's once bulletproof audience is no longer wearing teflon; even the most "hardcore" of WWE fans have stopped watching consistently.

While cord-cutting and shifts in viewing patterns definitely factor into the ratings drop, the fact is there are other television programs able to sustain their 3.0+ rating in the same environment that WWE no longer can.

For years, WWE has operated under the assumption that a large section of their fanbase will always watch the product, no matter how bad it gets. While that might be true, that section grows smaller and smaller every year. Fans are fed up with the product they're being presented every Monday night, and it's finally causing even the most supportive fans to tune out.


2. Fans Have Short-Term Memories

Edge Royal Rumble 2010
WWE

Another pet peeve of many modern pro wrestling fans is WWE's tendency to ignore past events, at times treating recent developments as if they had never taken place.

WWE always believed that most pro wrestling fans lacked long term memory and that their only focus was the here and now. Perhaps that was true at one point, but decades of talents triumphantly returning from injury to deafening crowd responses have proven otherwise. Despite talents being MIA for months, sometimes years, at a time, WWE fans have shown, time and time again, that they remember.

Still, WWE's programming often mirrors the mind of an impatient, inattentive, hyperactive subject rather than the 65 year old entertainment company it claims to be. Despite constant reminders that their fanbase remembers long term events and characters, WWE continues to insult their audience's intelligence by presenting such simple, vapid television.

The most popular TV shows (i.e., Game Of Thrones, Better Call Saul) respected the audience's intelligence and it paid off, just like it did for Vince McMahon once upon a time.

In 2017, WWE's writing doesn't need to be as deep as Thrones or as subtle as Saul, but surely it should require a little more brainpower than the Teletubbies.


1. Wins & Losses Don't Matter To Fans

Paul Heyman, left, celebrates with Brock Lesnar after his win over the Undertaker during Wrestlemania XXX at the Mercedes-Benz Super Dome in New Orleans on Sunday, April 6, 2014. (Jonathan Bachman/AP Images for WWE)
Jonathan Bachman/AP

Perhaps more frustrating than anything else, WWE loves telling fans, "wins and losses don't matter."

As much as they may want viewers - and talents - to believe this baloney, WWE knows it's not true. Wins and losses absolutely matter and it's never any clearer than when WWE begins to build a new main event superstar. It goes back decades. Hogan, Warrior, Undertaker, Lesnar, Roman, Asuka. WWE always made sure their win and loss records were protected.

If wins and losses truly didn't matter, Roman Reigns would've lost to The Undertaker at WrestleMania 33 and Brock Lesnar would've been pinned numerous times by now since breaking The Undertaker's Streak at WrestleMania XXX. Hell, The Streak itself would've never existed if wins and losses didn't matter. In addition, Santino would've won the 2011 Royal Rumble, Jerry Lawler could've entered WrestleMania XXVII as WWE Champion, and James Ellsworth could've won the WWE Championship, if the outcomes were truly beside the point.

Wins matter. Losses matter. They're not the only thing that matters and difficult losses can become fantastic victories if booked right. But to say that wins and losses, the entire foundation of sports, are irrelevant to WWE fans further showcases how ignorant and disconnected WWE has become with their casual and regular audiences.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A former stuntman for Paramount Pictures, Matt enjoys sports, water skiing, driving fast, the beach, professional wrestling, technology, and scotch. At the same time, whenever possible. Having attended many famous (and infamous) shows including WrestleMania XV, In Your House: Mind Games, and the 1995 King of the Ring, Matt has been a lifelong professional sports and wrestling fan. Matt's been mentioned in numerous wrestling podcasts including the Steve Austin Show: Unleashed, Talk Is Jericho, and Something To Wrestle With Bruce Prichard. As a former countywide performer, Matt has been referred to as Mr. 300 for his amazing accomplishments in the world of amateur bowling. He is also the only man on record to have pitched back-to-back no hitters in the Veterans Stadium Wiffle Ball League of 2003.