10 Modern Wrestling Tropes We're Totally Sick Of

Robotic commentary, overused dives, and everything in between.

Michael Cole oh my
WWE

It's easy to start feeling like you've seen everything in professional wrestling, particularly in this modern era.

Every major promotion in the world is available within a few clicks. The WWE Network is an impossibly vast treasure trove, AEW is on FITE for those who can't catch it on live TV, NJPW World unlocks Japan's biggest promotion, sites like IndependentWrestling.tv give smaller stages a big platform. Even YouTube is stuffed to the gills with free, legal content. Spend any time dipping into these deep, deep services and you'll likely see every recurring theme, motif, or device a thousand times over.

Here, we break the most tedious of these overused tropes down. These are the bits and pieces that leave us sighing, rolling our eyes, and losing our suspension of disbelief. They aren't all inherently bad (though some definitely are), but each has been made trite and ineffective thanks to frequent spamming.

Some of the tropes within would be fine if used in moderation and yes, there are only so many ways to tell a wrestling story, so some repetition is to be expected. Still, the extent with which they're currently leaned on breeds tedium...

10. "OHHHHH MYYYYYYY!"

Michael Cole
WWE.com

Michael Cole does exactly what his employers ask of him. In this regard, he is the perfect employee and should be absolved of much of the blame for his robotic commentary style. What he's doing is nothing more than what his boss wants, with his constant sloganeering, rehashed catchphrases, and formulaic shilling consequences of the restrictive framework under which every WWE main roster announce must work.

But good grief, is it hard to listen to.

"It's Boss time!" is tedious and "here comes 'The Big Dog!'" more so. Nothing, however, comes close to "ohhhh myyyyyy!", Cole's go-to line whenever someone returns.

You can set your watch by it. Really, there are times when SmackDown's play-by-play man might well be replaced by a monkey operating a soundboard, so repetitive is his approach. Again, this is the production style's fault, not Cole's, as each of his fellow announcers is afflicted by the same condition to varying degrees. When Cole steps away, a Tom Phillips or Vic Joseph will step up and become just as tedious.

At least you feel what Mauro Ranallo is saying on NXT, as eyeroll-worthy as his reference spam can be.


9. Rematch After Rematch After Rematch...

Tetsuya Naito Kota Ibushi
njpw1972.com

There's no level of enthusiasm that endless repetition won't dull. "Too much of a good thing" is more than a cliché; it's a very real concern, and in wrestling as in any other artform, overindulgence is a zeal-killer.

Zack Sabre Jr. and Hiroshi Tanahashi are two of the best wrestlers on the planet, but going one-on-one five times between March and September 2019 killed interest levels in their final showdown at NJPW Destruction in Beppu, despite each bout's obvious quality. Tetsuya Naito and Kota Ibushi's story is much the same, having faced each other three times in as many months last year. By the end, the pairing felt boring, uninspiring. Those terms should never be applied to the names Naito and Ibushi.

WWE supposed binned their old automatic rematch clause for fallen champions back in December 2018. They've done a better job of varying their pairings since then, but shows like the rematch-heavy Stomping Grounds 2019 show the problem never really went away. "The feud must continue!" is an appropriate meme.

Week-by-week storytelling is difficult and a certain volume of rematches is to be expected; spamming them is lazy, dull, and uncreative.


8. Kickout Spam

Johnny Gargano
WWE

Few things top the drama of a huge, well-built kickout at the crescendo of an epic wrestling match. If the accumulations are progressive and go over as intended, it's the ultimate theatric explosion. Kazuchika Okada is a master of this. His timing is impeccable as he shoots his shoulder off the mat a fraction of a second before the referee's hand falls for the third time. It's one of the many reasons why his closing stretches are becoming the stuff of legend - 'The Rainmaker' has mastered the art.

Others, unfortunately, have not.

Constant kickouts are used to generate artificial drama in almost every promotion on the planet. Nowhere is immune to it, with moves that should be match-enders bantered off at will, leading to a less satisfying viewing experience and a world in where big manoeuvres have very little value. Will Ospreay's Hidden Blade and Kota Ibushi's Kamigoye were introduced as concussive, skull-splitting blows, but each was kicked out of less than a year into their existence. Adam Cole's Panama Sunrise is basically useless. The Canadian Destroyer is now a transitional early-match move. The list goes on.

Protect the finisher, flip the format, and found more subtle, creative ways to create drama.


7. Show-Opening Promos

Seth Rollins Raw Promo
WWE.com

Not every show-opening promo stinks. Such segments being positioned at the top of a card doesn't mean they automatically suck, and episodes of Raw, SmackDown, Dynamite, and more will often kick off with a decent-to-good diatribe from a high-level talker or two, with promotions at least wise enough to keep those who work the stick away from this crucial tone-setting slot.

The content of these things can be fine; it's the formula that stinks, but only when it becomes a habit.

Where's the excitement in a wrestling show that starts off the exact same way every single time? It gets dull when you know you're going to have to sit through 10-15 minutes of talking before getting to the action 99% of the time, even when the segment is used to set things up for later in the evening. Even that's a formula, though. Fans know that when someone comes out to for the opener, their rival is only ever a few minutes away, making the whole thing a joyless, repetitive slog.

Show-opening promos can be effective when used sparingly, but they've lost much of their power through overuse. An episode of Raw or SmackDown starting without one feels like a rare treat as a result.


6. Endless Nicknames

Braun Strowman
WWE

WWE Speak is a problem in and of itself. Rampant overscripting has created a roster of athletes that don't communicate like actual human beings, spouting stilted terms like "championship opportunity," calling the audience as "the WWE universe," and referring to the wrestlers as everything but "wrestlers" like a gang of cheesy corporate androids.

One of the maddening components of this is the idea that every wrestler on the roster needs at least a handful of nicknames to feed into the robot commentators' algorithm. 'The Monster Among Men,' 'The Swiss Cyborg,' 'The Joshi Judas,' 'The Striking Man From Amsterdam,' 'The Extraordinary Man Who Can Do Extraordinary Things' (thank god this one died), 'The Golden Goddess,' 'God's Greatest Creation,' just... stop. End this madness, refer to people by their real names (or at least something indicating their pedigree, IE: "the four-time Intercontinental Champion), use nicknames sparingly, and quit blurting these phrases out every 10 seconds. It's nonsense.

Yes, it's a different way to say somebody's name, but WWE's talking heads are insistent on beating you over the head with them until you either lose your mind or buy the relevant t-shirt.


5. Distraction Finishes

Distraction Rollup Finish
WWE

The great irony of distraction finishes in pro-wrestling is that they're designed to keep the victim protected in defeat but rarely result in anything other than the complete opposite, making the poor sap look like an idiot.

These things rarely work. The loser invariably comes off as an absent-minded dolt who took their eye off the ball and was taken out of their game by something as simple as an entrance theme hitting or a manager hopping onto the apron. The victor gains little either, as they're often portrayed as lucky fluke artists who had no business being in the ring with the person they've just "bettered" in the first place.

At best, distraction finishes are a mildly annoying way to prolong a storyline without somebody taking a more definitive fall, but at worst, they are a credibility-shredding disaster (see: Asuka, Carmella, and James Ellsworth). That they still go down every single week is maddening, too. What happened to in-ring storytelling? Have we forgotten how to spin a yarn around an old-fashioned clean fall? Presumably yes, and it has created a reactionary environment in which more definitive defeats are immediately met with calls of burials online.


4. Diving Into Moves

Fabian Aichner
WWE

Observe the above gif.

Fabian Aichner is a tremendous professional wrestler of skill, speed, power, and agility, a credit to Imperium and NXT UK, and one of the more underrated performers under WWE contract, but, like... what the hell is he trying to do here? What is he attempting to achieve within the context of the match?

If attacking Adam Cole was his intention when he climbed the turnbuckles, he must've changed halfway up. Aichner tries nothing here. He leaps forward with his legs and arms down, making no attempt to strike or land on the NXT Champion, jumping right into the Superkick. A pop-worthy moment? Sure, but it makes no sense in what is supposed to be a simulated combat environment.

This isn't an attempt at picking on Aicher specifically because stuff like this happens every single week, across every promotion you can think of. It's the kind of objective phoniness that makes the sport look like a cooperative dance routine, not a contest, and a surefire immersion-breaking every time it happens - which is often.

Wrestling is fake. The toothpaste can never be put back in the tube, but spots like this will never not be objectionable.


3. Gimmick (Match) Pay-Per-Views

Seth Rollins Hell In A Cell
WWE.com

This isn't a rip on the Royal Rumble or Survivor Series. Though technically gimmick pay-per-views, they are timeless concepts that can still be as effective today as they were back in the day, even if the build towards the latter gets a little dopy as wrestlers start fannying around with red and blue t-shirts.

The issue isn't with those Big Four shows (or events like Money in the Bank); it's with Elimination Chamber, TLC, Hell In A Cell, and even TakeOver: WarGames and they harm they deal not only to the stipulations, but logic and storytelling.

This year's WarGames special saw the wonderfully nuanced narratives in NXT's women's division thrown aside for the sake of a clusterf*ck. It turned out to be a great clusterf*ck, but the build was too convenient, too contrived, to ignore, and the same goes for the significantly worse men's bout.

With the main roster PPVs, wrestlers are thrown into these brutal matches regardless of whether or not their feuds have enough heat to warrant it. Hell In A Cell feels particularly worthless now. These bouts used to come together because two wrestlers were willing to die to put the other away; now, they come together because they're on a calendar.


2. "The Hardest Part Of The Ring!"

Samoa Joe Rey Mysterio Apron Powerbomb
WWE.com

A simple one, this, but still worth mentioning: how many times do we need to be reminded that the apron is, indeed, "the hardest part of the ring?"

Commentators blurt this line out almost every single time somebody has their back cracked on the apron. It's as if they see the viewers as goldfish who couldn't possibly have picked up that this area is significantly stiffer than the rest of the squared circle, or perhaps they assume that everyone tuning in is watching wrestling for the first time. Regardless, it's a pain in the *ss.

The frequency with which such spots are executed is another problem, as a move loses impact when you see it several times within the same broadcast. Apron spots should be huge, crushing moments, and potential match-enders, and should be saved for rainy days. Instead, they're transitional. A Canadian Destroyer on the apron means about as much as a basic vertical suplex in 2020.


1. Here, Let Me Catch You...

Roman Reigns dive
WWE.com

Dives are overused, this is true, and there isn't a single promotion on the planet that wouldn't benefit from issuing an edict limiting them to just one or two per show, but they can still be great when they look like they belong in scripted combat.

The recent Will Ospreay vs. Hiromu Takahashi clash provides the perfect example. One breathtaking sequence saw Takahashi counter one Sasuke Special into a countered German Suplex and try to toss Ospreay against the ropes, only for Will to somehow adjust, slip back into the ring, dash, dive, and finally take Hiromu out. Simultaneously balletic and impactful, it succeeded because Takahashi was too awe-struck to avoid the second Sasuke Special. The suspension of disbelief was maintained.

This was perhaps the best kind of dive. The worst? Any situation where one or more wrestlers is chilling on the outside, patiently waiting for the attacker to hit their move for a prolonged period of time, thus making it look like the fakest thing in the world.

Catching is critical, obviously, but there's nothing real-looking about cameras focusing on men and women standing around passing time for their cooperative role.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Michael Cole
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.