10 Most Boring Wrestlers Of 2023

Wrestlers in WWE and AEW guilty of putting fans to sleep throughout the year.

Matt Hardy boring
AEW

Becoming dull is pro wrestling purgatory.

Nobody wants to be boring. Just ask Lance Storm! His WWE career hit a new low when 'Stone Cold' ripped the p*ss out of everyone's favourite mega-stoic technical wizard many moons ago. Storm surely knew what everyone else watching also knew: Steve Austin outing him as drab was a death knell and a half creatively.

2023 has housed some true snores, and you'll be surprised by the folks responsible. Look, this isn't meant as some mean-spirited hatchet job on folks trying their best, but you've got to call 'em like you see 'em. This year hasn't been kind to the performers featured here, and watching them has often been rather painful.

There's a nice mix of WWE and AEW to keep things interesting too.

Something else is worth saying. These wrestlers aren't necessarily bad overall. In fact, most have produced countless memorable moments over the years, but 2023 was...difficult to watch. Does that mean they'll all go on to repeat the trick in 2024? No, probably not. Well, hopefully not, otherwise their performances might become some new fangled cure for insomnia.

10. Lacey Evans

Lacey Evans
WWE.com

Here's a WWE career that properly fizzled out.

Lacey Evans struggled for relevance before being cut loose over the summer. A return to her military gimmick roots flat out didn't work, and creative didn't help matters by flipping Lacey between babyface and heel like they couldn't make their minds up what was best for her.

Being brutally honest, that's because they couldn't. There was a clear disconnect between Evans and the people calling shots in the company, and that bled over onto TV. A weird off-screen mini-feud with Sgt. Slaughter and his daughter (accidental rhyming there) also got fans talking on social media for the wrong reasons.

Throughout all of this, Lacey was just very boring. Her vignettes got old quickly, and people sat on their hands when she did finally show up in person again. One could practically hear crickets during Evans' matches and promos, so perhaps it was only a matter of time before she toddled off to do something else.


9. Jinder Mahal

Jinder Mahal
WWE.com

It's gonna be a reeeeeeal struggle for punters to care about Jinder Mahal or his Indus Sher buddies again. The trio was recently spotted having a little chit chat with new Raw GM Adam Pearce on the Monday night flagship, but a pressing question must be asked here. Will this lead to anything meaningful?

Will it b*llocks.

Turning up randomly to talk backstage (or, at least, have a "private discussion" with authority figures) is nothing new for Mahal and pals. This sort of thing never seems to go anywhere, which is why you'd be hard-pressed to find much conversation about what the future holds for Indus Sher online.

It seems the fanbase at large is pretty sick of Jinder. If that sounds harsh, then ponder this. The dude hasn't actually done much of anything worth caring about since shockingly capturing the WWE Title way back in 2017. That, for those keeping score at home, was six years ago.


8. New Day

The New Day
WWE.com

You might well be pretty stunned to see these lads here.

After all, Kofi Kingston is a beloved former WWE Champion, and Xavier Woods an ex-King Of The Ring who has been consistently entertaining during his run with the promotion. Or, has he? 2023 hasn't been great in that regard. Woods was used to promote Pizza Hut on PLE a short while back, for example.

Those getting the pitchforks out will also point to Kofi's lengthy time on the shelf due to injuries. That's fair, but freshness is a real worry with New Day. Big E's in-ring future is anyone's guess, and the gimmick is one of WWE's stalest heading into the new year.

The old comedy flourishes of yesteryear feel played out, and that strips away a lot of what made New Day such a cherished part of company furniture for so many years. Sadly, despite missing a large chunk of 2023 due to injury, the team is less New Day and more old hat.

They're crying out for change.


7. The Hardys

The Hardys Matt Jeff Isiah Kassidy
AEW

Admittedly, Matt and Jeff have been having fun in random, exhibition-style tag matches on Rampage during the latter half of 2023. That isn't quite enough to save them from inclusion here, because well...the brothers have visibly slowed with age, and the lack of slick daredevil ring work eliminates most of their appeal as a duo.

Watching Matt amble around the ring and Jeff flail around awkwardly is actually kinda upsetting for long-time fans. Of course, The Hardys have every right to try extend their careers, but they've nothing left to prove to anyone and have become a pale shadow of their former selves.

For anyone wondering, no - Isiah Kassidy's sex noises haven't saved the day.

Matt and Jeff were once must-see workers who'd thrill and offer something genuinely different. Now, they're making up the numbers of All Elite's 'C' show, yet still yakking on about becoming AEW Tag Champs someday. That'd be a mistake from Tony Khan.


6. QT Marshall

QT Marshall Powerhouse Hobbs QTV
AEW

AEW's QTV skits range from goofy and passable to an outright waste of valuable airtime. On the plus side, they've provided talents like Harley Cameron and Aaron Solo a chance to develop some character that'll stand them in good stead long-term. Then, there's faction leader QT Marshall.

It just isn't clicking, is it?

QT is clearly valuable as a trainer behind the scenes, but few fans give much of a hoot about anything he does onscreen. The QTV stuff is often skippable, and his attempted union with Powerhouse Hobbs went absolutely nowhere before Tony Khan pulled the plug and moved on to something else entirely.

It's a challenge to take Marshall seriously as a threat to anyone above midcard during matches. He also hasn't even been the most engaging personality in segments centred around his own faction. Hell, Johnny TV has benefitted from those silly skits way more than the supposed star of the show.

Recently, QT announced his resignation from AEW, wrapping his commitments by the end of the year. The change will do everyone good.


5. Charlotte Flair

Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Heel Charlotte Flair is capable of producing the goods and deservedly standing proud as a focal point of the entire WWE women's division, but the writers haven't focused on bad Charlotte in 2023. Nah, they've focused on bad Charlotte. As in, the babyface variation that's painfully see-through and 100% intolerable.

Flair's fake smiles are guff enough, but the pretence that she's some well-meaning veteran looking out for everyone from Shotzi to Zelina Vega is impossible to believe; that's especially true when Charlotte is still cutting semi-heel promos about running roughshod over the competition and holding belts aplenty forevermore.

It's a jarring clash of alignments, basically.

Babyface Flair is cringeworthy to witness, chiefly because it's obvious Charlotte doesn't have any faith in the process herself. She even said so during an interview with Steve Austin for WWE Network/Peacock in 2022, and it's doubtful anything has changed since she prioritised being heel over a goody two shoes.


4. Hit Row

Hit Row
WWE.com

Top Dolla is gone, but Ashante Adonis and B-FAB remain. Fingers crossed they're not reminded behind the scenes that they may well be Triple H's worst ever rehires. The group tanked first time around and most pointed a finger of blame squarely at Vince McMahon. There's no such excuse for a second flop.

That's on Hit Row.

The trio's babyface banter played before silence, then they tried to mix things up a little by going heel. That failed to get any kind of response out of live audiences either, and things somehow only got worse from there. Their miserable run dipped to the point that Michael Cole was brutally burying Dolla on live television.

Cole's verbal takedowns proved to be the most entertainment WWE was able to squeeze out of the stable before canning a guy presented as their default leader. Hit Row managed to turn WWE programming boring whenever they appeared on screen this past year.


3. Natalya

Natalya WWE
WWE.com

Can WWE creative stop viewing Natalya as some Women's Tag Team Title division saviour who can buddy up with any straggler to form a tandem worth watching? Nattie had multiple partners in 2023 alone, including Shotzi and Tegan Nox. Neither benefitted much from their ties to the veteran.

It's a rinse and repeat approach, and a lifeless one. Then, when Natalya isn't picking up more tag partners than anyone else on the roster, she's suddenly thrust into the role of "credible" singles strap challenger. Few think she'll come out on the winning end going in, thus rendering those matches pointless in the end anyway.

Around and around the cycle goes.

Natalya has earned her stripes and wrestled a crap ton of matches for WWE, but the writing team's humdrum way of handling her is tedious as all heck these days. Look out for that next tag alliance or babyface title push, people!


2. Ronda Rousey

Shayna Baszler Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

Teaming with real-life pal Shayna Baszler and winning the Women's Tag gold should've been a step in the right direction for ex-MMA badass Ronda Rousey. Instead, the pair experienced a short run as champs then splintered for a feud that ended with one of the least-impressive SummerSlam matches of all time.

After that, Ronda left WWE and subsequently announced her retirement via Instagram in October.

Ronda has since shown up in ROH and on the indies, but this was an abrupt end to pro wrestling life for Rousey. She never actually appeared too in love with the industry anyway. That came across loudly to many fans watching, which is why those people refused to accept Ronda as one of their own. Her outspoken nature made it clear she wasn't keen to be accepted anyway.

Rousey used to be one of the most dangerous and captivating talents in the biz, but those days were long gone by the time calendars turned to 2023. Wonky, stilted promos and unimpressive matches clashed to make 'Rowdy' Ronda one of the most boring around.


1. The Dark Order

The Dark Order
AEW

Would somebody please stop this pain?

AEW's product has moved on from Dark Order, and it's high time Tony Khan realised it. Evil Uno, John Silver and Alex Reynolds regularly come across as an indy stable on episodes of Dynamite, Collision or Rampage, and that's a real problem in a major promotion that wants to grow.

In short, the trio lack menace. They're whimsical when babyface, but borderline-goofy when going the heel route and playing hard cases (or trying to). That isn't good - fans shouldn't giggle at Silver's wide eyes or treat The Order like some 'Z' list Ministry Of Darkness without The Undertaker.

Perhaps Silver, Reynolds and Uno could land in different spots if they were given the chance. That's worth a go, because there's next-to-no value in continuing down The Dark Order path any longer. This faction cannot linger around for the entirety of 2024.

Which other wrestlers have bored you throughout 2023? For more like this, check out 10 Obscure WWE Tag Teams You Totally Don't Remember and 10 Lost Gimmicks WWE Should Bring Back!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.