10 Most Boring WWE Wrestlers Of 2019

Purveyors of the popcorn match.

Mandy Rose Sonya Deville

Thousands of people chant it at a time throughout arenas worldwide, and wrestling promotions desperately try to mask those chants by way of production trickery, but what exactly is it that makes a performer boring?

Things are a bit more complicated than those trolling 'u suck lol' comments on WWE's YouTube videos might lead you to believe. Oftentimes, it's not even the wrestler in question's fault, at least not totally. They're the ones who have to make the best of poor scripting for promos or blatantly crap 50/50 booking scenarios in-ring. Whilst they definitely have a part to play too, they're not 100% responsible for being on lists like this one.

2019 was another big year for women's wrestling (they main-evented WrestleMania, for crying out loud), so it's a bit disheartening to see three females make the top 10 here; more concerning is the fact that one of the division's champs shows up. That inclusion may infuriate some who'd lay blame at the door of WWE's creative team for a bland 12 months.

So, who had a rubbish 2019 and why did they have it? Here's to a happier new year...


10. Sin Cara

Sin Cara Carolina
WWE.com

Another year spent wondering how the fudge Sin Cara was still a thing in WWE.

Hopes are high that the talented dude under the mask, now known as Cinta de Oro in AAA, can revitalise his flagging fortunes now he's free of the promotion's failings. Still, this article isn't about the future, it's about the recent past, and Cara's sucked. He was as inessential a WWE star in 2019 as one could get.

After returning from injury in March, Sin Cara 2.0 entered a string of unmemorable performances and then feuded on and off with fellow Mexican Andrade. It all felt so lifeless to begin with, and somehow ended up worse when WWE decided to add Carolina (or "Catalina" as Raw's announcers kept calling her) for a few weeks in October-November.

By the time Cara was released from contract in early-December, it was a mercy killing for a character who had been on life support for years. The very name Sin Cara was tarnished long before 2019, but those 12 months only added to the boredom.


9. Mustafa Ali

Mustafa Ali
WWE.com

OK, what the f*ck is Mustafa Ali doing here and why isn't there a gathering of angry protesters outside this writer's office door already? That baying mob would have a point; Ali is excellent inside the ring, and he has shown an affinity for cutting likeable babyface promos.

The same likeable babyface promo every damn time. That's the problem.

It says everything for Ali's 2019 that the three main things people will remember from his year are, in order, getting injured and thus facilitating Kofi Kingston's push, losing his forename and talking in pre-tapes on SmackDown. That, in between working solid-yet-obviously-inconsequential matches, is about it.

WWE love the thought of having wrestlers cut the same promo using different words week-after-week. It's what they do, and yet (even knowing the formula) it was intolerable to see Ali yammer on about cultural diversification and healing the world without taking any action.


8. Bayley

Bayley Sasha Banks
WWE.com

It'll take more than a new hairdo for Bayley to cut it as SmackDown's version of Becky Lynch.

WWE need a polite reminder that Bayley, for all her strengths, isn't the most assertive person on the microphone. Unlike 'The Man' over on Raw, she's timid, comes across as forcing the hard gal act and never looks totally comfortable when someone questions her motives. For a villain who apparently doesn't care what people think, that's problematic.

Worse, Bayley has been hanging off Sasha Banks' coattails all year. First, their interminable 'frenemies' storyline finally had purpose when the pair became Women's Tag Champs. WWE soon got bored of that, Sasha disappeared for a spell and Bayley was asked to tread water rather than kick her own legs and make it to shore.

October's change has been purely cosmetic too, and Bayley is back to being Sasha's nervous-looking pal despite being SmackDown Women's Champion. 2020 will be her fourth full year on the 'main roster' and she's still not booked properly.


7. Braun Strowman

Tyson Fury Braun Strowman
WWE.com

Speaking of "not booked properly".

What is it with WWE and turning wrecking ball monsters into BFG-like comedy acts? They're bloody obsessed with this trope, and it's an unhealthy one more likely to hold someone back than endear them to the audience. Braun Strowman is a case in point here. He's quickly being typecast as muscleman goof, and it's not cool.

In 2019, Braun lost his Universal Title shot at Royal Rumble due to injury (a blessing in disguise, in retrospect), feuded with the Saturday Night Live crew at WrestleMania, had a so-so rivalry with Bobby Lashley, won the Raw Tag Titles with Seth Rollins mid-feud and tangled with Tyson Fury. None of it was especially dynamic fare.

It's not that Strowman needs to be champion, he doesn't. It's more that WWE refuse to book him like they did between 2016-2017 when he was a credibly destructive ball of rage. The past 12 months have done nothing for Braun's hopes of avoiding the gentle giant role.


6. The B-Team

The B-Team
WWE.com
"B-Team! B-Team! No, no, NO!".

Those aren't the lyrics to Bo Dallas and Curtis Axel's entrance theme, but they should be. The 'B' doesn't stand for 'Best' either, it stands for 'Boring'. Yawning is what audiences do whenever WWE wheel The Miz's old security team out for a squash match or somehow believe they have any shred of validity as a tag-team act.

The jobber gimmick was done better in the Attitude era by Al Snow's J.O.B Squad, and there's no hope for Dallas and Axel under their current guise. They should be split, Dallas should interact with his brother Bray over on SmackDown and Axel should become a legacy star who occasionally pops up to play solo jobber-to-the-stars.

Any mirthful comedy impact The B-Team had evaporated the longer 2019 went on. They've absolutely become the worst tag-team under WWE's umbrella, and their good-natured buffoonery has got to go in 2020. It's just not over.


5. Shane McMahon

Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Shane McMahon, meanwhile, is over. Nobody can deny that without coming across as a hater for the sake of social media likes. Shane's 2019 heel turn was overdue, and his relentless 'Best In The World' chat did bag him boos from live crowds all over the country.

Then, WWE's writers got lazy.

Look at MJF over in AEW. He might be at the start of his career as an insufferable heel, but he never outstays his welcome with promos and certainly doesn't slow his delivery to a crawl just so creative can fill more programming minutes. McMahon did, especially during segments with Kevin Owens, and it was painful.

Inside the ring, Shane was exposed whenever he couldn't rely on stunts or weapon-fuelled brawling. His punches were the sh*ts, and everybody needed a break from him long before SmackDown's 20th Anniversary episode in October.


4. Carmella

Carmella WWE
WWE.com

The answer to Carmella's shouts of, "What's Up?" in 2019 should've been "everything".

A career heel if there ever was one, 'Mella lacked any fire or connection to fans last year. She was just kinda' there as R-Truth's rapping buddy, and was more useful for giving the multi-time 24/7 Champ piggybacks whenever he needed a quick getaway than actually working matches.

Now, she's poised for a bit of a push as a babyface. WWE's chances of success here rely on two things: Carmella's own ability to foster a kinship with the fans her employers expect to cheer and WWE showing patience. Or, they could just turn her heel again, let her loose as a "Me! Me! Me!" bitch like she was a few years ago and relax.

Again, Carmella is best as an over-the-top money grabbing heel who can back up her words when she needs to. 2019 was not kind to her, but at least it was an easy way for 'Mella to make that cash she's always banging on about.


3. No Way Jose

No Way Jose
WWE.com

Remember when No Way Jose was a promising babyface with bags of personality in NXT? WWE don't. Had they sat the guy down before calling him up to Raw and said, "Jose, we're thinking of turning you into this year's Adam Rose", he would've been forgiven for running a mile and trying his luck on the indy scene.

The conga line act sucks life out of every segment it's in.

This may well sound a bit harsh, but Jose's performances are like house show intermission bonuses wasting valuable television minutes. WWE wouldn't pause Raw to hand out backstage passes to eager young fans, so why are they booking umpteen extras to dance like granddads behind a babyface fans could care less about?

It says everything that Jose lasted two seconds in the 2019 Royal Rumble. That's where he is on WWE's mental pecking order, and it's why he's on this list. They keep sending him out there thinking something will suddenly click; it's creative insanity.


2. Sonya Deville

Sonya Deville WWE
WWE

Who is Sonya Deville, and why should fans greet her like a major star? That's a question WWE's writers need to ask themselves. They also need to remember that not many who tune into SmackDown regularly check out episodes of Total Divas, and that means they don't have any clue about why Deville is in the company or what her goals are.

Right now, she's Mandy Rose's pal and shows halfhearted support for her sexuality by stuffing a rainbow-coloured flag down the back of her ring gear. Yay?

This complete lack of context and depth is on WWE more than Sonya. She's armed with a story and has MMA roots, but she's never once been given the same respect as fellow warriors Ronda Rousey or Shayna Baszler. Using that as motivation would make sense. Instead, she's shown reading magazines backstage.

Deville doesn't come across as a threat to the bigger stars in the female ranks, she's infrequently portrayed as anything other than a childish bully and the whole LGBTQ thing is woefully half-baked when it could garner mainstream press and positive PR.


1. The Viking Raiders

The Viking Raiders
WWE.com

The Viking Raiders are the Raw Tag-Team Champions.

Think about that, then think how sh*te a job WWE has done with them since they were called up to Raw in April 2019. Forget the mass renaming spree creative went on in the first few weeks of their run, because there's something more worrying beyond what the once-proud War Machine get called.

They're almost a full year into their run on the brand Vince McMahon cares most about (which Raw still appears to be) and yet The Raiders continue working rudimentary squash matches against local enhancement jobbers. Their growly LOD-meets-Demolition promo style also works well backstage, but it's clear fans older than 10 don't relate.

2019 wasn't a banner year for the former ROH and IWGP Tag Champs. They're better than this, and they need to be let loose from the creative cage WWE has both in. If SummerSlam 2020 comes around and these guys aren't on the lips of tag-team lovers everywhere again, there might be trouble.

Who do you think was the most boring WWE star of 2019? For more wrestling, check out 16 Things You Probably Missed From WWE Raw (Dec 30) and 10 Best Wrestling Moments Of The Last Decade!


In this post: 
Carmella
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.