10 Most Controversial WWE Firings Ever

WWE isn't afraid of courting controversy. It also isn't afraid of firing pregnant women.

Dawn Marie
WWE.com

WWE is a business. The world's largest professional wrestling company may well be in the business of entertaining millions of fans around the world, but the desires and wants of its so-called WWE Universe are second to those of its shareholders, of its investors. The bottom line of the bank balance is what drives WWE.

With big business comes difficult decisions, especially when it comes to the hiring and firing of talent. Vince McMahon and company have a fairly wretched track record on the latter, often releasing large numbers of performers at a time, creating a working environment that runs on fear and insecurity. Other times, the company fires a performer for saying a word that rubs the boss up the wrong way.

The operative term here is 'fickle', but it isn't as if WWE has ever really denied being so. The slavish dedication to profit margins and dollar signs means nothing is off-limits. You can be fired for getting pregnant, you can be fired for the misdemeanours of your lover, you can be fired for confronting racism. You can be fired on your wedding day, on your honeymoon. Any time, any place, any reason.

WWE isn't afraid of controversy, and it certainly isn't afraid of looking like the bad guy.

10. Charlie And Jackie Haas

Charlie Haas And Rico 1
WWE.com

In the summer of 2005, the big rumour in the pro wrestling world was that Brock Lesnar was on his way back to WWE. The Beast Incarnate wasn't going to be coming for chump change, so Vince McMahon made it abundantly clear that he was going to make some roster cuts in order to balance the books, should Brock decide that the squared circle was where he was supposed to be.

In July of that same year, 18 performers were released by WWE. Some were veterans, others were rookies, but two just so happened to be a newly-wed couple returning from their honeymoon. Charlie and Jackie Haas (formerly Jackie Gayda) had just completed a two-week jaunt celebrating their newly-legally bound relationship when they were served with termination papers and wished the best on their future endeavours.

Stay classy, WWE!

To make matters worse, the whole cost-cutting measure was another false step by the company, as Brock Lesnar didn't return until 2014. Charlie and Jackie Haas weren't exactly indispensable to WWE but both had plenty to offer, be it in the ring or outside, especially at a time when WWE had no interest in bringing in experienced talent from the independents.


9. CM Punk

Cm Punk
WWE.com

No matter how outdated and illogical the institution of marriage may seem to you, most will be in agreement that serving termination papers to someone on their wedding day is a bit of a low blow. Such events are supposed to be a celebration of love and companionship, not days remembered for pink slips and unemployment.

CM Punk's departure from WWE was just about as acrimonious as it could have been. The Straight Edge Superstar walked out on the company in 2014, disgusted at years of hypocrisy and political nonsense that compromised the quality of the product and made life inside a living hell, or something close to it. At the very end of his emotional and physical tether, Punk walked out.

He wasn't officially released until months later, receiving his future endeavours as he prepared to walk down the aisle with then-WWE superstar, AJ Lee. WWE naturally claimed that the timing was a coincidence, although anyone willing to believe that should check out this sweet deal I've got on old rope. Vince McMahon isn't known for letting sleeping dogs lie, and the timing of CM Punk's sacking could not have been more choreographed.


8. Dave Finlay

Fit Finlay loves to fight.jpg
WWE.com

WWE loves the military. If it involves waving flags, wearing camouflage, making grandiose speeches and showing the world the American way, you can bet your bottom dollar that Vince & Co are going to be involved somehow, somewhere. The US Army is second only to Vince in the WWE hierarchy of care, although you could argue that the list doesn't extend much beyond that.

Disparaging the military, therefore, is never a good idea, as legendary wrestler Fit Finlay discovered in 2011. Then working as a backstage producer, Finlay decided it was a good idea to have The Miz interrupt a rendition of the American national anthem at a live event in Illinois. If ever there was a creative decision to get some molten heat, this was it, but the whole thing spiralled out of control. Members of the US Army National Guard were in attendance, you see, a key WWE sponsor, and the whole gimmick soon became a PR nightmare that was going to require a fall-guy.

The Belfast Brawler was that guy. Eager to show the NG that the situation was being taken care of, Finlay was given his marching orders and released. He was rehired a year or so later, but the controversy surrounding his 2011 release lived on.

Imagine being sacked for having a heel interrupt a song? Wild.


7. Cost-Cutting

Luke Gallows Karl Anderson
WWE

Back in May, excellent wrestling business blog Wrestlenomics predicted that WWE is on track to post an operating income of $280million in 2020. Despite the creative hole that the company seems to have fallen asleep in, the financial side of WWE has never been better, and not even a global pandemic could put a hole in that. Put simply, WWE has cash to burn.

Despite its financial joys, the company decided that it needed to cut back on its wage bill. In April of 2020, WWE released more than 30 employees, largely wrestlers but also a number of producers, commentators, agents and coaches. WWE releasing talent isn't unusual but what was surprising about this was the sheer number of people let go.

That and the fact it happened at the beginning of a global pandemic, a time of unprecedented job-related fear and financial uncertainty. If ever there was a company in the world who didn't need to release anyone, it was WWE. If ever there was a time that this company should have kept everyone on board, it was April 2020. A simple equation in theory, but WWE is a world where 2 + 2 can sometimes equal you're fired.

Many of the released performers have turned up in other promotions but the bitter taste remains. These are men and women who were promised security, verbally and in writing, only to be jettisoned so that an incredibly profitable company could impress shareholders.

Despicable.


6. Brad Maddox

Brad Maddox
WWE.com

We all have pro-wrestling-related hills that we are willing to die on, and one of mine is that Brad Maddox was criminally underrated and underused. Released in late 2015, Maddox was barely used in a competitive fashion, spending his main roster tenure as a referee and then as RAW General Manager.

Maddox was released out of the blue in November 2015, after saying something at a live event that rubbed Vince McMahon up the wrong way. Yeah, that really is all there was to it.

Maddox took on R-Truth in a live event dark match that month, and bad guy Maddox cut a promo on the crowd before the bell. This is pretty customary in the live event world, as the irritating heel riles up the crowd early on, ensuring everyone gets behind the babyface coming out to beat him. Nothing to see here, move along.

The problem was that Maddox called the crowd 'cocky pricks', and this didn't sit well with Vince McMahon. Yes, Vince McMahon, a man who once said the N word on television, took exception to Brad Maddox using the word 'pricks'. Maddox was immediately released, never to be seen in WWE again.


5. Mr. Perfect

Mr Perfect Brock Lesnar Ariplane
WWE.com

To the joy of everyone in attendance, 'Mr. Perfect' Curt Hennig made a dramatic return to WWE at the 2002 Royal Rumble. Hennig made it all the way to the final three before being ousted by eventual winner Triple H. The result wasn't as important as the performance, as the legendary Hennig seemed to have rolled back the years after stagnating in WCW. Brief feuds with top stars followed before Hennig moved down the card, but fans were more than happy to see the iconic former-Intercontinental Champion back.

It all came shuddering to a halt in May 2002. The roster had just completed a gruelling European tour and were heading back to the US, on a journey that became known as the 'Plane Ride From Hell'.

The name isn't an exaggeration. The ride was a perfect storm of madness, alcohol and primal macho behaviour. Ric Flair got drunk and exposed himself. Sean Waltman chopped off Michael Hayes' ponytail. Goldust attempted to serenade ex-wife Terri Runnels over the PA, but not before sexually harassing a stewardess.

In amongst it all, close friends Curt Hennig and Brock Lesnar had a friendly grapple that soon turned into something a little more competitive. The two Minnesota-natives were soon going hell for leather on a plane that was actually flying through the sky, ramming into the sides of the air bus and generally making everyone a little nervous. They got a little bit too close to the emergency exit before wrestlers rushed in to separate the two.

The two were in deep trouble when the plane landed, but Lesnar's status as the next big thing gave him a security that the veteran Hennig simply didn't have. Perfect was released, never to return. He passed away the following year.


4. Alberto Del Rio

alberto del rio
WWE.com

Alberto Del Rio is a divisive figure in the professional wrestling world. A precociously talented performer of legendary stock, Del Rio also had a knack for rubbing people up the wrong way, for being a spiky character backstage and for bouts of bullying behaviour. This reached a terrible apex in May 2020, when Del Rio was arrested after allegedly sexually assaulting a woman and threatening to abandon her child in the middle of a road.

Del Rio's first WWE run came to an end in 2014 in controversial circumstances. The official position was that Del Rio was released due to 'unprofessional conduct and an altercation with an employee'', but there was a whole lot more to it than that. The 'unprofessional conduct' in question was a slap and the 'employee' was a racist.

The incident happened backstage, after WWE's Manager of Social Media Live Events (an actual job, believe it or not) made a racist joke about Mexicans, directed specifically at Alberto Del Rio. El Patron wasn't around to hear the joke but word soon got around, and the nine-time world champion confronted the racist goon. No apology was forthcoming, only a mindless grin, so Del Rio took matters into his own hands and slapped the idiot. Needless to say, he was soon released.

On the one hand, slapping a colleague isn't the most measured way to deal with a backstage dispute. On the other, racism is completely intolerable. Del Rio was back with WWE a couple of years later.


3. Zahra Schreiber

Zahra Schreiber
Hayley Scott Photography

Many of the releases in this list can be filed under the 'unreasonable' heading, business decisions made with little sense and even less humanity. None of this applies in the case of Zahra Schreiber, a former WWE developmental talent best known for being the ex-girlfriend of Seth Rollins and prominently featuring the swastika in old social media posts.

No, not a typo there. Schreiber was release in 2015 after old Instagram posts resurfaced, posts that saw Schreiber seemingly showing off what can only really be described as Nazi Germany merchandise, no matter how the images were sold. It was the last in a string of controversial incidents surrounding Schreiber, coming months after nude photos of her and Rollins were leaked on social media.

There were also allegations of racist and offensive language used across a variety of social media platforms. The Nazi imagery was the last straw though, with Schreiber's claim that she didn't associate the swastika with Hitler falling on deaf ears, by which I mean entirely logical ears.

Many of WWE's more controversial firings leave the blame squarely at the feet of Vince McMahon and the company, but this was the total opposite.


2. Matt Hardy

Matt Hardy
WWE

It is difficult to convey to a generation of reality-obsessed wrestling fans just how hot the 2005 feud between Matt Hardy and Edge started off. It was unlike anything WWE fans had seen before, a truly despicable heel and a vigilante babyface, a blood feud born out of real-life events that didn't just blur the line between reality and television; it smudged it beyond all recognition.

The feud came about when Lita (then Matt's girlfriend) had an affair with Edge, a betrayal that somehow led to Matt Hardy getting the boot from WWE. Hardy was on the way back from a serious knee injury, and the liaison had taken place while Matt was out. Some sources even claim that Edge had promised to look out for Lita on the road, although that might well be too juicy to be true.

What isn't up for debate is that Matt Hardy was fired because his girlfriend cheated on him with a company favourite (or more specifically, because of his distraught online reaction to the betrayal). The fans were understandably outraged, and almost overnight Edge became the biggest heel in the company.

In a rare moment of awareness, WWE seemed to understand that they had misread the situation and rehired Matt, kicking off a subsequent feud with Edge. The feud was a tremendous success, the heartbroken Hardy finally getting sweet revenge on the friend and lover that had so callously betrayed him.

Not really, the two had a feud that Edge won in decisive fashion, and Hardy was soon back slumming it in the lower part of the card. WWE gonna WWE.


1. Dawn Marie

Dawn Marie
WWE.com

The Holy Grail of controversial WWE releases, the company's decision to let popular valet Dawn Marie go in 2005 still draws heady sighs and angry head-shaking to this very day. To cut a long story short, Dawn Marie was released while she was pregnant.

Dawn Marie's name was another among the mass releases in summer 2005. She was four months pregnant at the time, with fans already somewhat clued-in after her final appearance at ECW One Night Stand that year. It was a despicable move on WWE's part, one that even the most hardened of cynics may have assumed was beneath even them, but nothing is out of the question when it comes to the ruthless cut-throat nature of WWE.

Understandably, Dawn Marie soon filed a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, citing wrongful termination. The case was reportedly settled in 2007, closing the lid on one of the most shameful business decisions Vince McMahon has ever made, a pretty big claim but an entirely justified one.

Will WWE top these heartless and cruel reasons for firing people in the future? Depressingly, that seems inevitable.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Dawn Marie
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.