10 Most Cringeworthy WWE Tough Enough Moments Ever

Remember when The Boogeyman lied about his age?

As WWE prepare to bring back the Tough Enough concept to screens, there's a heightened interest in the previous seasons of the faux-reality show. Generally speaking, the premise of the show is simple. A group of wannabe WWE superstars work their butts off to sufficiently impress the judges and earn a shiny contract with the biggest promotion around, and have to overcome various challenges related to being a professional wrestler. The overall hardship of the industry has been explored in-depth throughout the 5 seasons to date, along with a hell of a lot of personal trials and tribulations. As the concept has progressed, more reality TV elements have been introduced, including utterly pointless tests such as avoiding being mauled by attack dogs, which is somehow supposed to prepare people for a life in the ring. Whatever the dubious reasons for including such skits are, it's hard to deny that the program is pretty entertaining. There's somewhat of a buzz when WWE announce that they're bringing another series to people, which is a good overall barometer of the show's popularity. This article looks at 10 of the most embarrassing moments that have happened during the show's run, taking in most of the 5 seasons. Whittling it down to just 10 isn't easy, because Tough Enough pretty much encourages embarrassment! These are people learning to wrestle, and being asked to do some pretty stupid stuff, after all.

10. Bill DeMott's Involvement

Ok, first off, it's time to deal with the proverbial elephant in the room. Far from being a joke about the man's weight, this instead involves the fact that Bill DeMott played a huge part in Tough Enough, pretty much from the third season onwards. Even though he'd been released by WWE in 2007, the former wrestler would return as a head trainer for the revived fifth reason of Tough Enough in 2011. As many wrestling fans who keep up to date with the latest news will be able to attest, DeMott's name is mud at the moment in the industry. A lot of this stems from alleged incidents which took place in various WWE developmental territories, as well as at the WWE Performance Center. Reportedly indulging in some pretty serious hazing of trainees, DeMott will likely never be given key responsibilities in the development of young talent within WWE ever again, which pretty much rules him out of the Tough Enough premise going forward. It's pretty embarrassing for WWE that one of their more respected trainers has been disgraced in such a manner, even if many claims set against him remain simply conjecture.

9. Luke Robinson

The core atmosphere surrounding Tough Enough encourages people to be brash. After all, WWE contracts don't just come along every day, and the opportunity to chase one brings out an ultra-competitive streak in people that they perhaps never even knew they had. For Luke Robinson, that meant coming across as a pretty unlikeable jerk, one who would stop at nothing to earn his stripes and enter a bold new world as a WWE superstar. During the fifth season, Luke proved himself to be pretty unpopular with his fellow trainees, mainly because he 'spoke his mind'. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gH2yppoWH08 In reality, this meant he wasn't afraid to try and throw his peers under a bus at any given opportunity, especially in front of the judges. It's difficult to say whether or not Steve Austin somewhat admired Robinson's antics, but it's safe to say that he wasn't really viewed as a nice person. Hardly surprising, because the guy came across as pretty talented - but far too cocky to progress - and any time he was on screen, the man grated on just about everybody.

8. The Boogeyman Lies About His Age

Something which isn't often mentioned during Tough Enough broadcasts is the fact that WWE have imposed a pretty strict age curfew on entering in the past. Obviously, people looking to get involved need to be at least 18, but the company aren't all that interested in entertaining the idea of folks over 35 entering. That proved to be a problem for Marty 'The Boogeyman' Wright during the fourth season of the show. Passing initial tests with flying colours, Wright looked to be exactly the kind of person the competition would attract, but all was not as it seemed. It turns out that the man had blatantly ignored the age limit, putting down on his application that he was 30 years old when he was in fact 40. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DWVXUkSS78Q Quite clearly, this flustered WWE somewhat, as they were clearly high on the man's athletic ability. Wright was disqualified from the show, but would quickly be offered an attempt to redeem himself, going on to eventually become The Boogeyman. Things worked out for Wright, but when he dropped the clanger that he was 5 years over the age limit, he must have been pretty ashamed.

7. Eric Needs Help Getting Down

Much like any show based on reality, it's sometimes obvious when people are allowed through to the final show simply because the producers want to inject some comedy into proceedings. The larger-than-life Eric Watts fulfilled that role nicely during the fifth season of Tough Enough, and it was pretty clear from the outset that he wasn't exactly cut out for a career in professional wrestling at the time of filming. In a fair competition, one entirely based on reality, Watts (no relation to the 'other' Erik Watts of WCW and TNA fame) would have struggled to make it past the first basic fitness tests. A big guy, he was clearly lagging any time contestants had to perform even the most rudimentary of drills, but he did provide ample laughs - often unintentionally - throughout the season. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKfUOz9-fzY Without doubt, the most embarrassing moment for Watts came during the sixth episode of the show, the one during which he would be cut and called a 'disappointment' by Steve Austin. During an obstacle course run, Eric blew up physically, and was unable to finish. Worse yet, the big man was stuck high above the ground, and had to be helped back to safety. In interviews since, Watts has said it was the most "crushing moment" of his life.

6. Cameron's Favourite Match Angers Steve Austin

It's often fascinating to look at how many people involved in Tough Enough who didn't win went on to grab a WWE contract anyway. That's likely something WWE doesn't like people pointing out too often, but it simply cannot be ignored - whereas previous winners like Andy Leavine are nowhere to found, The Miz went on to headline WrestleMania and win the WWE Title. Another non-winner who would wind up on the roster was Cameron, who competed on the revamped Tough Enough in 2011 under her real name, Ariane. Amazingly, the future WWE Diva was the first one to be eliminated from the show, and it really seemed that main host Steve Austin didn't have much time for her. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BlYIl55WRzc In fairness, naming Melina vs. Alicia Fox as your favourite match when talking to someone as respected as 'Stone Cold' may seem a little stupid, but surely it was WWE themselves who were to blame for this, they must have quizzed Ariane on her wrestling knowledge long before the cameras started rolling. The entire segment, where Austin was left bemused by the woman's answer, made for very awkward television.

5. Hardcore Holly Hammers Matt Cappotelli

It was an incident which shocked the wrestling world, and added a hard edge to Tough Enough which had previously been missing. During the third season of the show, Bob 'Hardcore' Holly got pretty damn physical with one of the contestants, a young man known as Matt Cappotelli, apparently on a mission to show that a life in the ring isn't a walk in the park. That's been another theme throughout Tough Enough, veteran stars letting these fledgling young hopefuls know that they have a golden ticket to a career they've worked hard to build, and they're not entirely happy about it. Often, it comes across as bitter, and it's fair to say that Holly took liberties with his lesser-experienced trainee. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yW6_0H44aQw Entering the ring with Cappotelli, Holly beat him up pretty badly, something which had the young man in tears when talking to Bill DeMott afterwards. Likely shocked by what had happened, it's admirable that the incident didn't deter Matt, who went on to win the third season (along with John 'Morrison' Hennigan). Nonetheless, Bob Holly didn't exactly cover himself in glory during the segment.

4. The Big Show Pays A Visit

During each season of Tough Enough, WWF/WWE have enlisted several of their top names to come in and make brief appearances each episode. Again, the main crux of this idea seems to be that the more established stars will mosey on down to the training facilities, watch a little bit of the trainees in action, then lecture them on how easy a ride they have compared to them. It's an interesting strategy, because that kind of talk doesn't really inspire anyone, it just makes them feel inadequate. Surely, WWE should be doing everything they can to prepare these men and women for a life in their company, not making them wonder if they're cut out for it to begin with. During a visit to see the entrants during the fifth season, The Big Show gave Eric Watts some advice on working as a big man, but interestingly notes that conditioning plays a large part. Following this up, the giant repeated his words during a few media interviews. The Big Show isn't exactly renowned for his physical abilities, he was even sent to WWE developmental in 2000 to drop weight, so it came across as pretty strange he was lecturing anyone about conditioning!

3. Daniel Puder Embarrasses Kurt Angle

It goes without saying, Kurt Angle is one of the most legitimately tough men to ever work in the pro wrestling industry. A genuine Olympic Gold Medal winner during the 1996 Summer Games in Atlanta, the 'Olympic Hero' has pretty much done it all in the world of grappling, Olympic and professional. A multi-time World Champion, Angle was enlisted to teach several young Tough Enough entrants a little lesson in respect, humbling them by picking them off on an episode of Smackdown one-by-one. It should have been a simple segment, but things don't always go as planned, and Angle was left red-faced by one Daniel Puder. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_12qn29WKA After putting everyone through their paces with squat thrusts, Angle started picking off his tired opponents, but it was only when Puder entered the ring that it became clear the whole thing was unscripted. Locking in a Kimura Rock on his vastly more experienced opponent, Puder promptly had his shoulders counted to the mat, as the referee realised the hold wasn't meant to happen. It's a good thing he did, otherwise Kurt Angle may have had more to worry about than a red face.

2. The Confusing Case Of Wendell

Wrestling fans will be hoping there are more characters like Wendell to sit slack-jawed at during the upcoming series of Tough Enough. A short-lived cast member during the third season, this man was ripe for the picking as the kind of person who comes across as wholly deluded - it's likely the producers of the show only enabled him to get through casting due to how hilarious they knew he'd be to viewers. Thankfully for those in charge of running the show, that's exactly what happened. During his appearances, Wendell had trainer Al Snow utterly perplexed. From wearing his sunglasses indoors during group meetings, to telling everyone that he'd been inside the ring twice, so he definitely had the edge over the competition, Wendell caused a lot of stifled laughter whenever he spoke. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NrvD1SPdjIE Al Snow perhaps deserves an award for how he handled the guy, it took a lot for him to really lose his cool with him. Acting like the cocky student at the back of the class who just doesn't know when to shut up, Wendell hasn't been seen since, although many fans did think the guy was actually Orlando Jordan!

1. Triple H Gives An Awkward Seminar

The idea was sound enough, but extremely flawed in execution. During the very first season of Tough Enough, Triple H strolled into the ring, delivering quite the promo on what it means to dedicate your life to the then-World Wrestling Federation. There's nothing wrong there, the man was only telling the truth, but the whole spiel about family and tradition wasn't really helped by the fact that 'The Game' then tried to put some of the entrants through their paces, moments after scaring them half to death. Admittedly, the guy did praise some of the punches being thrown, as well as the selling, but the whole experience didn't really seem to help anyone, instead the contestants just kind of stood around looking terrified. What should have been a golden lesson turned into one that was all bluster, more of the same talk of how easy the Tough Enough folks had it compared to the rest of the roster. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4DWg8OHSo0 In essence, Triple H was letting everyone from Tough Enough know that if they were lucky enough to reach the main WWF roster, they'd have big targets painted on their backs because of how they entered the business. Let's not forget, this was the promotion's own idea, so punishing people for being excited and wanting to take advantage of opportunity makes no sense. What other embarrassing or awkward moments from the history of Tough Enough can you recall? Do you remember any of the moments listed here? Let us know down in the comments section!

Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.