10 Most Disappointing WWE Matches Of 2016 (So Far)

Can we tell Lesnar the suplex stuff is getting boring now (not me, he'd eat my face)?

Brock Lesnar Dean Ambrose WrestleMania 32
WWE.com

A disappointing wrestling match is particularly crushing - especially one in which our favourite wrestlers are featured prominently, often having never been propelled to that stratosphere before.

2016 has been exasperating in this respect, but that is a direct consequence of WWE's abject and continued refusal to align their pushes with the whims of fans. Moreover, the mandated rematch clause, which sadly isn't going anywhere, is a contributing factor.

So many matches in WWE just get going before some kind of screwy finish gets shoehorned in purely to maintain those WWE Network subscriptions. Consequently, even the better matches have been rendered disappointing as a result of an unbelievable contrivance tainting the finish.

Sadly, sometimes the talent simply don't step up and make the most of their opportunity - or, to use Jim Ross' maxim, erm, 'maximise their minutes'. What follows are the 10 most disappointing matches held so far this year. Some of them were on their way to being damn good, too...

10. Undertaker Vs. Shane McMahon - WWE WrestleMania 32

shane mcmahon the undertaker wrestle mania
WWE.com

It might seem churlish to deem this match disappointing - a non-wrestler was involved, after all. Expectations had been curbed by design.

That said, whomever decided to make this 30:02 match the longest on the card really does want shooting - especially since it had a grand total of one objective to hit. All we needed to see was Shane jump off the cell to cement his face character as sufficient opposition for Stephanie.

That could have been achieved with much more ease and acclaim in well under 15 minutes. For the sake of realism - Undi' had gone toe to toe with Brock Lesnar just six months earlier - Shane should have been subject to an absolute thrashing with no shines whatsoever in the first eight to ten minutes.

This would have garnered considerable sympathy for him. His sole comeback would have resulted in the Cell leap spot, thus saving time for Lesnar/Ambrose - and saving us from an amateurish parade of interminable MMA-inspired sequences.

Worse still, the admittedly awesome Cell spot was undermined by those with sharp eyes. You could see Michael Cole reading from his script. I mean, if ever there was one line for the entire night to memorise...


9. Chris Jericho Vs. AJ Styles - WWE WrestleMania 32

Jericho Styles WrestleMania
WWE.com

The problem with Chris Jericho - and this has been the case since 2012 - is that his mind is sharper than his legs are quick.

To put it another way, he doesn't seem willing to admit that he's a lost a step, and is still intent on attempting to wrestle briskly-paced technical matches with several convoluted reversals and counters.

In this match, which nonetheless was very well laid-out, the quality of the structure was compromised by the noticeable lack of smoothness in the transitions. It seems to take an age for Jericho to counter into the Walls these days, which is especially galling - these counters are meant to be hit with quickness and precision so as to take his opponent by surprise. The decision to book this match was in itself disappointing, too. It had already lost its lustre through overexposure.

The finish, too, was absolutely baffling - another infuriating example of WWE's counter-productive 50/50 booking policy. Jericho is already damaged goods to an irredeemable extent. His win here, as should have been obvious, did not cast a shred of doubt over the outcome of his subsequent series with Dean Ambrose.


8. New Day Vs. League Of Nations - WWE WrestleMania 32

New Day League Of Nations WrestleMania 32.jpg
WWE.com

WrestleMania is supposed to be the night on which the talent raise their game to a level not reached at any other point in the calendar year. They are supposed to go all-out.

What they're not meant to do is wrestle as if they're appearing on a typical episode of Monday Night RAW, which is precisely what The New Day and the League of Nations did here. Circumstances were against them from the start, admittedly.

The League of Nations, who must be assured a place on the list of Worst Factions Ever alongside the Union and X-Factor, were not over in the slightest.

The New Day had only just (sort of) turned face, meaning fans weren't sure exactly how to react. That said, it doesn't seem particular difficult to devise exciting sequences in a short, multi-man tag bout. Yet absolutely all of them where were forgotten almost immediately.

I don't usually advocate excessive and transparent use of legends - especially at the expense of full-time, non-jobbing talent - but the comedy beatdown administered to the League by Steve Austin, Shawn Michaels and Mick Foley was almost merciful.


7. Roman Reigns Vs. Triple H - WWE WrestleMania 32

triple h roman reigns.jpg
WWE.com

It could be argued that expectations weren't in place to render this a disappointment, but Reigns has a stellar match-quality record on PPV - since 2015, at least. His Extreme Rules '15 Last Man Standing Match against The Big Show, of all people, was a blinder.

It was therefore reasonable to hope that he'd manage something special with Triple H, who, when he's in the mood, is extremely adept at putting over a comparatively limited opponent. His WrestleMania record, though inconsistent, has seen him give the rub in defeat by and victory over Batista and Sheamus respectively.

The omens here, however, looked bad from the start. Greeted by an inevitable chorus of boos, Reigns seemed to pout on the entrance ramp. Rather than use the reaction to launch into a more aggressive side than we're used to, he simply walked through his rehearsed sequences without acknowledging or incorporating the crowd's response to his advantage.

A great wrestler is able to gauge and manipulate the will of the crowd. That's why they call them 'workers'.

This match does deserve bonus points for the decision to have Reigns spear the sh*t out of Stephanie McMahon, who had that coming for absolutely ages. That it was Roman who did it, though, nullified the catharsis a little.


6. Roman Reigns Vs. AJ Styles - WWE Payback 2016

reigns styles payback
WWE.com

Content-wise, this was damn good indeed. Roman in particular did very well to keep up with and not get overshadowed by the on-fire AJ Styles. Lost amidst the ire Reigns draws is the uncomfortable truth that his bouts with AJ were comfortably better than Chris Jericho's.

The disappointment was the inevitable screwy finish, which presented itself with a lurching inevitability. It is mandated in WWE that the first pay per view main event match (and most others, come to think of it) between two new opponents cannot end decisively. To do that, another challenger would have to be sufficiently built up in the meantime, and that's just far too much work.

Worse still, this was cut short, just as it was getting really good, by everybody's favourite WWE trope - McMahon Melodrama. By the time the match was restarted by Shane McMahon following Styles' count-out 'victory', the sense of inevitability worsened. It was a matter of time before some other contrived spot would result in Styles' disqualification to bring out Stephanie.

While it didn't suck all of the air from the room at the time, this diminished Attitude Era return still sabotaged what was an otherwise gripping bout.


5. Dean Ambrose Vs. Chris Jericho - WWE Extreme Rules 2016

chris jericho dean ambrose
WWE Network

This one was effectively doomed from the start, so badly thought-out was its concept.

Designed to limit the action portion of the match - which some traditionalists call the important bit - Jericho and Ambrose were forced to climb the cage just to initiate the sequences. In any cage match worth its salt - of which there are so few these days, sadly - the cage escape attempts are meant to prolong the drama.

By the time they slowly scaled down the cage, fans were hardly clamouring for either man to hammer the other with the assortment of weapons, which isn't surprising considering one of them was a bloody mop. We get that Ambrose is meant to be zany, but this choice thoroughly undermined the drama.

The commitment to Ambrose's character was admirable, mind.

This would have been much better served as a variation of Hell in a Cell, with the (re-conceived) weapons dangling from the inside of the walls at arm-height. Though a Hell in a Cell match had only been presented two months earlier at WrestleMania 32, it's not as if an abundance of gimmick matches has precluded similar over-saturation in the past.


4. Tye Dillinger Vs. Andrade 'Cien' Almas - NXT TakeOver: The End

Tye Dillinger Andrade Almas
WWE.com

Again, the content here was more than passable. What disappointed most was both the presentation of the inexplicably repackaged Almas character, and the odd decision to pair him with sentimental crowd favourite Tye Dillinger in the first place. The Full Sail crowd, who were meant to greet Cien rapturously, weren't sure how to react.

The NXT TakeOver debut match is a joy of the modern era. Usually hyped via typically-awesome WWE vignettes, this in conjunction with the salivating prospect of an international superstar appearing in a WWE ring in the first place is cause enough for optimism. On this night, sadly, the formula failed.

Everything about the character is just...off. I understand the desire (though not the need) to unmask him. Kalisto is already filling the special attraction luchador spot left behind by Rey Mysterio. Still, that is no excuse for the woeful apparel he was decked out in on the night. He looked like a feathered circa mid-90's Jeff Jarrett.

The match itself was pretty good, but the joy of the NXT debut is in the novelty - of seeing a star showcase what brought him to the dance. Even the new name is unwieldy.


3. Charlotte Vs. Natalya - WWE Extreme Rules

Natalya Charlotte Extreme Rules
WWE.com

The decision to pair these two together was a sound one, nominally. Not only was it too soon to pair Charlotte against too serious a threat to her recently-acquired Women's championship, these two had previous.

Their match at the first NXT: TakeOver was a 16:49 thriller, the real origin of the Diva's Revolution. For many fans, this was the match which made them realise that, if allocated ample time with which to craft a story, there is very little - arguably nothing - to separate them from the men.

This match in particular created the buzz which Sasha Banks et al. capitalised on to better their efforts at TakeOver: Brooklyn and Respect.

Charlotte and Natalya had wrestled a satisfactory if inferior sequel at WWE Roadblock, but the second revival of their series was a step too far. Compromised by the Ric Flair-as-over-protective-father sub-plot, this gets the dubious nod over their equally-egregious Payback effort for painting Natalya as daft enough to fall for the distraction routine for two matches in a row.

The distraction from Dana Brooke was also infuriating. That WWE announced ahead of time that Ric Flair was banned from ringside just guaranteed there being somebody else in his place.


2. Asuka Vs. Nia Jax - NXT TakeOver: The End

asuka nia jaxx
WWE.com

The problem with Nia Jax is twofold.

Firstly, a monster heel by definition cannot lose all the time, if ever. For a while, at least. The lifecycle is (or should be) as follows: Massive undefeated streak, defeat at the hands of a babyface-star-in-waiting, face turn, repeat. If they can't win during that initial heel run, with their mammoth size advantage, their entire raison d'etre, and their natural aura, is annihilated.

Jax's problem is that there is another, better killer character in her way. Her half-hearted push has been timed poorly. This is something the main roster creative teams should bear in mind by delaying her debut until, say, Sasha Banks is ready to drop the Women's title. Hopefully that isn't too presumptuous a scenario...

Secondly, as was evident here, there is little scope to expand, especially considering her inexperience, on the David vs. Goliath formula. As such, this was an inferior variation of Jax's match with Bayley at TakeOver: London. Without the natural sympathy Bayley generates, the emotion was missing.

The finish gets top marks. We'll give it that. Jax looked positively monstrous after no-selling that first lethal kick to the face. It was just a case of too little, too late.


1. Dean Ambrose Vs. Brock Lesnar - WWE WrestleMania 32

brock lesnar dean ambrose wrestlemania 32.jpg
WWE.com

WWE have painted themselves into a corner with the Suplex City-model Brock Lesnar. The act no longer sparkles, but why in kayfabe would 'The Beast' deviate from what is a simple, devastating, and impossible-to-defend approach? The act was stunning when it debuted - his demolition of John Cena was wonderful and breath-taking for many long-time fans to behold - but the returns are fast diminishing.

This match followed the now-typical Lesnar layout, largely playing out to audience indifference. Some of the action was spirited in places, and Ambrose is always game for absorbing punishment, but the match time was severely misjudged. Undertaker vs. Shane McMahon was almost triple the length, when it only needed to fulfil one objective.

Multiple objectives were required here; Lesnar, fading critically, could have done with adding something new to his game. Ambrose, main event outlier, needed, if not the win, protection in the form of a heroic defeat. At 12:50, he ate the pin far, far too easily. CM Punk at SummerSlam '13 this was not - and many were calling for a herculean losing effort akin to Steve Austin at WrestleMania 13.

Ambrose may well be riding high as WWE World Heavyweight Champion - but how much stronger would he seem if he had bested the Beast? Somebody has got to at some point, else why has he been built up to such an incredible extent? If not your future champion, then who?


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!