10 Most Important Wrestlers In NXT History

Celebrating the men and women who put Full Sail on the map.

neville wwe
WWE.com

NXT has become one of professional wrestling’s most widely-respected brands. Debuting in 2010, NXT’s original format saw trainees from WWE’s Florida Championship Wrestling paired with main roster wrestlers. Episodes featured the pros mentoring the rookies through a series of challenges before a live audience, with weekly eliminations until a sole survivor was crowned the series’ winner.

The reality TV format continued for a few years, but NXT became its own fully-fledged promotion in 2012. FCW closed, NXT took its mantle as WWE’s developmental territory, and the brand took off.

Today, NXT isn’t just home to some of wrestling’s brightest prospects, but some of the most talented wrestlers from around the world. Trainees like The Revival rub shoulders with industry veterans Samoa Joe and Austin Aries, making for a rich, diverse talent pool that can always be relied on to deliver a quality wrestling show.

NXT has undergone a swift evolution in its four-year lifespan, and their dedication to in-ring action over everything else has really put them on the map. WWE have cherry picked some of the world’s finest wrestlers to help build NXT, and their work has been invaluable. Triple H’s management deserves credit, but NXT’s reputation for wrestling excellence was built on its performers’ backs.

For all the skilled workers that have passed through Full Sail University, some have had a bigger impact than others. Not including the original reality format, here are the 10 most important wrestlers in NXT history.

10. William Regal

William Regal Cesaro NXT
WWE.com

William Regal is one of the most respected wrestling personalities in the world. A globetrotting veteran, he was a near-flawless performer for three whole decades, and he’s now universally-admired for his dedication to the wrestling business.

That’s not why he’s here, though. William Regal only wrestled a couple of matches in NXT, but his all-round contribution to the product cannot be denied. His match - and feud - with Kassius Ohno was a real highlight of NXT’s early TV shows, and a compelling reason to tune in while the brand was finding its feet. They wrestled in April 2013, working a classic, hard-hitting European style reminiscent of Regal’s mid-career wars with Finlay in WCW.

Regal’s most notable NXT performance came that November, however. His match with Cesaro was an outstanding display of technical wrestling, and a callback to Regal’s peak performance years. It’s just a single match, but it was absolutely vital in drawing early eyes to NXT, and many first time viewers became long-term fans there and then.

Moreover, Regal is currently invaluable in his role as NXT’s General Manager, trainer, and talent scout. Regal’s conservative, restrained role on NXT TV supplements the action rather than detracts from it, and he’s been invaluable in bringing some of NXT’s most highly-thought-of superstars through the ranks.

Though his in-ring role was limited, Regal’s impact on NXT cannot be downplayed.


9. Shinsuke Nakamura

shinsuke nakamura nxt champion
WWE.com

He might have only been with WWE since January, but Shinsuke Nakamura is already playing a huge role in NXT. The current NXT Champion debuted in April at TakeOver: Dallas, and became one of the brand’s franchise stars from the moment he walked out to face Sami Zayn. He remains NXT’s most popular wrestler today, and while it's unclear how much longer he’ll stay in developmental, his presence is vital at the moment.

The King of Strong Style is an A1 performer. Few of his peers are in the same class, and while he does have a tendency to take it easy in weekly TV matches, his ability to pull off a world-class match on the big stage can’t be denied. Furthermore, he’s a uniquely charismatic performer whose oddly captivating mannerisms and idiosyncrasies command attention, making him the ultimate pro-wrestling showman.

He’s the most important wrestler in NXT today, and that’s why he’s on the list. With Finn Balor and Sami Zayn gone, Nakamura has assumed the role of NXT’s hero. He’s the multi-talented babyface that the show is built around, and the fans pin their hopes on, and without him, there’d be a huge void in the main event scene. NXT need a wrestler like him to anchor the card, and with no obvious successor at the moment, they’d be lost without him.


8. Cesaro

Neville Cesaro NXT
WWE.com

Like William Regal, Cesaro only wrestled a handful of matches in NXT, but his impact on the brand’s early fortunes unquestionably helped their development.

His first appearance came in April 2013, when he appeared at an NXT event to successfully defend his WWE United States champion against Neville. A few weeks later, Cesaro would continue appearing on NXT to start a feud with Sami Zayn, and the end result was one of the most significant matches in the brand’s history.

Initially squaring off on a standard edition of NXT TV, Zayn scored a huge upset victory over Cesaro, which the Swiss Superman avenged a month later. The victory saw Cesaro earn an NXT Championship shot against Bo Dallas, and while he ultimately fell short, it was another strong match that helped bring NXT to a bigger audience.

The real money match took place in February 2014, however. Cesaro and Zayn faced-off at NXT Arrival, the brand’s first ever live special, and their 2/3 falls clash blew the roof off. As the night’s opening match, it didn’t just set the tone for the rest of the show, but for all every special event that followed. NXT’s big TakeOver shows are a huge reason for the promotion’s reverence, and it all started with Cesaro vs. Sami Zayn.


7. Charlotte

Bayley Charlotte NXT
WWE.com

Few wrestlers have had a bigger impact on modern-day WWE than NXT’s Four Horsewomen. Together, Sasha Banks, Becky Lynch, Bayley, and Charlotte are responsible for one of the biggest movements in women’s wrestling history. Their talents forced a huge shift in WWE’s focus, and while the “Divas’ Revolution” had its ups and downs, all four are now considered among WWE’s most respected performers.

WWE’s women are finally treated on the same level as their male counterparts, and it all started in NXT. As Ric Flair’s daughter, Charlotte always had an easy “in” to the wrestling business, but her hard work and dedication means she deserves every drop of success. Her feud with Natalya was an early NXT highlight, and one of the brand’s first women’s matches to really attract widespread attention, and as Women’s Champion, Charlotte was a dominant and assertive figurehead for the division.

She’s supremely athletic, and while not as clean and technical as some of her peers, Charlotte has become one of WWE’s most effective heels. The Natalya match remains her career-best effort, but her March 2015 showdown with Banks edges it close, and her main roster work further illustrates the dramatic improvements Charlotte is making as a performer.

Charlotte was the foundational champion on which NXT’s revered women’s division was built. For that, she’s more than earned her spot here.


6. Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins NXT Champion
WWE.com

It’s easy to forget Seth Rollins’ time in NXT given his incredible success since transitioning to the main roster. Whether through blowing the wrestling world away with The Shield or serving as The Authority’s corrupt corporate champion, Rollins has become one of WWE’s biggest stars, most exciting performers, and a guy the company will rely on at the highest level for years to come.

He entered WWE developmental after signing from Ring of Honor in 2010, and when FCW became NXT, Rollins played a huge role. He entered the Gold Rush Tournament to crown the first NXT Champion, and after working his way to the finals, Seth overturned Jinder Mahal to claim the belt.

NXT’s roster wasn’t as talent rich then as it is now, and Rollins stood out among his peers. While the Finn Balors of the world benefited from working with Shinsuke Nakamura and Samoa Joe, Rollins was wrestling Mahal and Curtis Axel. Nonetheless, his efforts were never anything less than stellar, and he held the belt for close to five months before dropping it to Big E.

Rollins’ run started the trend of highly-successful indy wrestlers running amok in NXT. He helped establish the promotion as a high-workrate show, and it’s hard to imagine what the brand would look like without his early run.


5. Neville

Adrian Neville NXT Arrival Champion
wwe.com

Neville’s main roster transition has been rough. From the daft entrance cape to his current non-activity, his fortunes on Raw haven’t reflected what he was able to accomplish in NXT, and that’s a shame. He’s one of the most under-used talents in WWE today, and while best known for his high-flying ability, Neville is an incredibly well-rounded performer capable of putting on a great match with almost anybody.

He built his reputation in NXT. Initially teaming with Oliver Grey, he broke-out as a singles star after feuding with his former ally Bo Dallas. Neville became number one contender to Bo’s NXT Championship in November 2013, and while it took numerous attempts to get there, he ended Dallas’ record-breaking title reign to become champion at Arrival.

Thus began the title reign that put NXT on the map. Holding the belt for 287 days, Neville was the custodian who oversaw NXT’s transition to a world-class wrestling show in its own right. While the Horsewomen built NXT’s women’s division, Neville’s work in the main event scene coincided with the company’s rise to prominence, and his clashes with Tyler Breeze, Tyson Kidd, and Sami Zayn were instrumental.

Neville lost the belt towards the end of Sami Zayn’s own rise to prominence, and their feud remains one of the brand’s most compelling stories. By the time Neville headed for the main roster, Zayn, Kevin Owens, and a host of others were ready to step into his shoes. His work was done.


4. Bayley

bayley nxt london
WWE.com

Splitting up the Horsewomen’s individual impact is tricky, but Bayley’s personality really separates her from her peers. The ultimate squeaky clean babyface, she was NXT’s most altruistic and likeable character, and connected with a huge portion of the audience. Bayley’s underdog story and rise to becoming NXT Women’s Champion were booked perfectly, and WWE’s main roster writers would do well recreate it during her current Raw run.

Bayley is at the heart of some of NXT’s most important matches. Her two one-on-one clashes with Sasha Banks in 2015 are rightly remembered among the year’s best, with their TakeOver: Brooklyn match widely regarded as the best women’s wrestling match in WWE history. When Bayley eventually bested Banks, it was a hugely cathartic moment that delivered on every emotional level, and with Bayley’s heart, workrate, and inherent likeability, it was impossible not to feel happy for her.

Moreover, Bayley was entrusted with holding the fort when Sasha, Charlotte, and Becky Lynch were called up to their main roster. Bayley remained Women’s Champion in their absence, and played a vital role in helping the division rebuild itself. Asuka would eventually emerge to knock her from her perch, but NXT’s celebrated women’s scene would’ve been paper-thin if Bayley hadn’t stuck around.


3. Finn Balor

finn balor nxt champion.jpg
WWE.com

Hideo Itami was NXT’s first major acquisition from the Japanese wrestling scene, but Finn Balor followed shortly after. The former NJPW Junior Heavyweight Champion debuted as Itami’s tag team partner against the ascension. This was back in December 2014, and when Balor debuted his Demon body paint gimmick at TakeOver: R Evolution, it was clear he’d soon become a star at Full Sail University.

It didn’t take long for him to hit the main event scene. Balor defeated Kevin Owens to become NXT Champion in July 2015, and compounded his dominance by besting KO in a ladder match at TakeOver: Brooklyn. He then entered the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic as Samoa Joe’s tag team partner, thus beginning the biggest angle of his young WWE career.

Joe turned on Balor shortly after the tournament’s conclusion, kicking-off a long, gruelling feud in the process. Joe and Balor battled over weekly TV shows and TakeOver live specials with the NXT Championship on the line, and while Balor defeated Joe in London and Dallas, Joe eventually took the belt at an April 2016 house show.

Finn’s reign ended at 292 days (another record), and by the time he departed, he was considered NXT’s icon. He’d risen to become the brand’s top babyface during Sami Zayn’s injury absence, and a vital foil for the bloodthirsty Joe. Without Balor to inherit his role as the fan’s biggest hero, NXT would have had a gaping hole at the top of the card when Sami fell to injury, and Balor’s skill, theatrics, and showmanship make him one of NXT’s most notable wrestlers.


2. Sasha Banks

Sasha Banks NXT
WWE.com

Charlotte had a longer reign as Women’s Champion, Becky Lynch is more technical, and Bayley more lovable, but nobody had a more memorable run through NXT’s women’s division than Sasha Banks.

Banks debuted for NXT back in 2012, though it took her a while to develop the villainous “Boss” persona that made her a star. She started coming into her own while teaming with Summer Rae, but really started breaking out as a singles wrestler upon entering the title chase. What she lacked in natural talking ability Sasha more than made up for with presence and her pitch-perfect performances as The Boss, and her intangibles are off the charts.

Nobody could match Sasha’s star power and “it factor”. She was hugely popular at Full Sail, even when working as a heel, and her title run produced some of the best singles matches in NXT history against Becky Lynch and Bayley. Charlotte might have given the NXT women’s division its first great champion, but Sasha was its first genuine star.

Over a year removed from her NXT run, and Sasha is currently playing a prominent role in Raw’s Women’s Title scene. The Four Horsewomen’s WWE destinies are intrinsically linked, and while Lynch is separated from the others in SmackDown, all four will form the backbone of WWE women’s wrestling for years to come. It started in NXT, where Sasha was the star of the pack.


1. Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn NXT
WWE.com

Throughout his time in WWE developmental, Sami Zayn was the face of NXT, its most popular athlete, and a participant in some of the brand’s most notable stories and matches. More than anyone else, Zayn embodies the everything that NXT stands for, and the heart, grit, and his slow build to becoming NXT Champion is one of the best underdog stories that WWE have ever told.

Zayn was the lovable loser. Though talented, he could never win the big one, and that became the theme of his feud with Neville. Sami would fight valiantly to come within touching distance of glory, and fall at the last hurdle every single time.

Neville wasn’t shy in pointing that out, but Sami wasn’t hindered by his failings. He came back stronger every time he fell down, and Neville’s words served only to fuel him towards glory. When he eventually topped his long-time friend for the NXT Championship, the entire locker room poured out to celebrate with him: a testament to the character he’d shown to make it through such an arduous journey.

Zayn’s importance extends far beyond great stories and matches, however. Zayn’s win didn’t just validate him as NXT’s top star, but it validated NXT’s rise as a whole. From his Arrival bout with Cesaro to his last match in Dallas with Shinsuke Nakamura, Zayn was the glue that held NXT together, and his rise to prominence mirrored that of the brand itself.

Guys like Finn Balor and Nakamura weren’t around when Sami started. It was Zayn who helped build the platform on which they’d later succeed, and Zayn wasn’t just the face of NXT by the time he left, but a symbol of the promotion’s growth. He deserves to be remembered as a trailblazer and trend-setter in NXT, and without him, who knows how the brand would be viewed today.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.