10 Most Meaningless WWE Royal Rumble Wins

McMahon's booking is rumbled.

The Royal Rumble is one of the best concepts WWE ever innovated. Originally a Pat Patterson idea, Vince McMahon turned the match into an attraction that's only behind WrestleMania in terms of drawing power. It should be a success every time, as it is such a simple formula to get right. The money angle is a popular babyface overcoming the odds and defeating 29 other men in an over-the-top-rope contest. He then chases down a heel champion towards WrestleMania, where he finally defeats the bad guy and takes the treasure. Of course, this being WWE, the Royal Rumble victor has often ended up being a disaster. Far from setting up huge money programmes, the match has all too often set up duds for WrestleMania season. On some occasions, the Rumble winner never even went on to the 'Mania main event, meaning the result was pretty much rendered meaningless. How can the creative team screw up such an easy concept? A lot of the time it is to do with over-thinking the booking, or backstage politics leading to contrived situations. Think back to the way Daniel Bryan was wilfully ignored by WWE back in 2013, when he would have been one of the most meaningful Rumble winners of all-time. There's a history of meaningless winners that WWE wants you to forget.

10. Hacksaw Jim Duggan - 1988

Hacksaw Jim Duggan was "the first Royal Rumble winner", but it meant absolutely nothing for him. Even as a historical footnote, it doesn't mean that much, as technically the first Rumble match occurred in October 1987 with One Man Gang as the victor (it took place on a random, poorly-drawing house show). Furthermore, Duggan's victory didn't go down on pay-per-view, and the match only featured twenty entrants. Even worse, it only went thirty three minutes, and it wasn't the show-closing main event of the show. In terms of what he got for winning the bout, the answer is: absolutely nothing. The WrestleMania title shot for the Rumble winner was a gimmick that only started in 1993, so Hacksaw just had his pride and little else. So with all of that considered, Duggan's victory has to be considered a hollow one. What he won was more like an experimental battle royal, with the booking logic being that he was a big guy and hence a believable winner.

9. Big John Studd - 1989

The second winner of the Royal Rumble was Big John Studd in 1989. On this occasion, it was more like the Rumble fans are familiar with, thirty men competing and around a one hour runtime. It was also the first Rumble event to be broadcast on PPV. But what did it actually count for? Not much. There was no prize for the winner, and at WrestleMania V, Studd ended up as a special referee in the Jake Roberts versus Andre The Giant match. Hardly the sort of spot that is associated with a Royal Rumble victory today. WWE's criteria for booking Studd in the winner spot was basically down to the fact he was big. It wasn't about prestige or a grand plan for him, it was literally just because it made sense for a big man to win such a contest. There was no greater meaning behind it.

8. Bret Hart / Lex Luger - 1994

By 1994, the Royal Rumble had evolved into the match we know it as today, with a WWF Championship match at WrestleMania going to the winner. Except that wasn't what happened that year. In a lame finish, Bret Hart and Lex Luger "co-won" the Rumble after falling from the ring and hitting the floor at the same time. Was it an accident? Was it a work? What's certain is that it sucked, failing to deliver what fans had expected from the bout. Following the confusing finish, WWF President Jack Tunney said both Hart and Luger would get title shots at WrestleMania. In other words, they diluted the importance of the Rumble victory. The match hadn't stood one man out as the next man, it had instead created an "as you were" situation with Hart and Luger fighting it out for the top prize. Luger would go on to lose to WWF Champion Yokozuna in the mid-card of WrestleMania X, before Hart captured the belt in the main event. If that was the desired finish, why not just have Bret go over in the Rumble?

7. Chris Benoit - 2004

Chris Benoit is a different case to the rest of the entries on this list as, at the time, his Royal Rumble 2004 win meant a great deal. It was a watershed moment for smaller wrestlers in WWE, with Benoit winning the Rumble from the number one position in an excellent one hour, coast to coast performance. It was the ultimate way of going over, establishing him as the number one contender for WrestleMania XX. It was also proof that charisma and character weren't always key to success in WWE. Benoit had earned his status through sheer hard work and in-ring excellence. Ultimately, as things stand today, the win is meaningless. It isn't even recognised by WWE. They skip over Benoit's entire career, so there's no bookmark for his Rumble win on WWE Network, for example. Plus, they never mention Benoit's historic feat in their 'Rumble in numbers' video packages. The 2007 Benoit Tragedy means that the Crippler's Rumble win is null and void in terms of WWE history.

6. Batista - 2014

Batista's 2014 Royal Rumble was one of the biggest duds of all time, not just in Rumble history, but in WWE history. The creative got it all wrong, bringing back a major star who no one in the audience really cared to cheer. He came in at number 28, racked up four eliminations, and won the match fourteen minutes after entering. It was meant to be a joyous babyface moment but, instead, fans booed him out of the building. From the audience point of view, it was supposed to be Daniel Bryan's night, and any other winner was always going to have hollow meaning. WWE then sucked the meaning out of Batista's victory, by turning him heel and opening up the opportunity for Bryan to get a main event WWE Title shot at WrestleMania. While Batista did still feature in the main event, Bryan went on to tap him out, thus winning the title in a match which also featured Randy Orton. What had meant to be a great Rumble to 'Mania journey turned into a glorified jobber role for The Animal.

5. Stone Cold Steve Austin - 1997

While it may sound like sacrilege to say anything negative about Stone Cold Steve Austin's WWE career, the fact is his first ever Royal Rumble win didn't count for much. He was actually eliminated, but the officials never saw it. As a result of the oversight, he was able to sneak back in and throw Bret Hart over the top rope. He was a winner, but in the sort of way that wasn't really presented as a legitimate victory. As a result of that controversy, and because Shawn Michaels had vacated the WWF Title, Austin never got a WrestleMania main event title shot. Instead, a four way was booked at the In Your House February special, which pitted Austin against Bret Hart, Vader and The Undertaker for the vacant title. Hart ended up with the belt, only to lose it the next night to Sid, after interference from Austin. That resulted in Austin clashing with Hart at WrestleMania 13. On the plus side, while the Royal Rumble win meant nothing for Austin and the WrestleMania main event, that match with Hart ended up being one of the best WWE bouts ever and made Austin a genuine superstar in a way that a standard WrestleMania main event WWE Title win might not have.

4. Randy Orton - 2009

This had to be one of the worst booked Rumble to 'Mania narratives ever. Randy Orton was a heel, winning the Rumble after entering at number eight. The guy he eliminated last, babyface Triple H, then went on to win the WWE Title at Elimination Chamber. How backwards is that? In this instance, losing the Rumble would've apparently been in Orton's best interest. He could have won the WWE Title sooner than WrestleMania. So now it was heel Randy Orton, chasing babyface Triple H for the title at the Showcase of the Immortals. To make matters even dafter, the McMahon family got involved after Orton abused Stephanie and then punted Vince McMahon. That made the feud personal, the kind of thing that usually requires a Hell in a Cell or No DQ stip. So what did they do? They booked a straight up singles bout for Mania, in which Hunter would lose the belt if he was DQ'd. Adding to the pain, they had to follow the thrilling Shawn Michaels versus The Undertaker match, which was one of the best matches WWE have ever put on. So you had a heel facing a champion babyface in a show-closing main event that the crowd didn't care about. Completing Orton's misery, Triple H retained his title cleanly. The Royal Rumble had meant absolutely nothing, and in fact the victory ended up hurting Orton's career in the long-run.

3. Vince McMahon - 1999

As great as the Attitude Era was for storylines, it wasn't really that productive in terms of excellent in-ring wrestling. The 1999 Royal Rumble was a classic case of that, with Mr McMahon winning the Rumble from the number two position. He actually spent the majority of the match outside the ring, and only won after WWF Champion The Rock came down to distract Austin. That was enough for the chairman to push his nemesis over the top rope. From a wrestling purist point of view, it was entirely meaningless, even more so when McMahon vacated his prize the very next day. The win quite literally counted for nothing, and Austin was awarded the title shot by commissioner Shawn Michaels. Austin did, however, put that title shot on the line when he faced McMahon at the St Valentines Day PPV in February. It was the kind of booking that fans accepted back then. Nowadays, there'd be a riot at the thought of a non-wrestler winning the Rumble.

2. Sheamus - 2012

Sheamus won the 2012 Royal Rumble from the number 22 position, in what has to be considered one of the most underwhelming booking decisions of all time. He was meant to be a big babyface, but nobody really cared about him. Perhaps picking up on the lack of interest, WWE rendered his Rumble win meaningless when they booked his title shot to be the curtain jerker of WrestleMania 28. Even more embarrassingly, WWE booked the match to last just eighteen seconds. Sure, they put Sheamus over as he won Daniel Bryan's World Title. But what did that really mean? An eighteen second curtain jerker title change? It killed the belt and also seriously devalued the Rumble's prestige. So much for winning a spot in the WrestleMania main event!

1. Alberto Del Rio - 2011

Here i is, the most meaningless Rumble victory ever - Alberto Del Rio in 2011. The whole thing was lame, with a less than over heel (who had only been with WWE for six months) winning from the number 38 position in the 40 man Rumble. He was only in the match for nine minutes, with just two eliminations to his name. It was so underwhelming. The true meaninglessness of it is exacerbated by what happened next, as Del Rio received his title shot in the very first match at WreslteMania XXVII. What makes it even worse than the similar Sheamus debacle is that Del Rio didn't even win the title! Instead, he had to do the job, losing to Champion Edge in an average eleven-minute match. The very next week Edge retired, vacating his title in the process. That only made Del Rio's Rumble win even more of a waste. He'd not gone on to the 'Mania main event, and he'd then done the job to a guy who was leaving anyway. What was the point in ever making him the Rumble winner, just to job him in an opening bout? The mind boggles.

WWE Writer

Grahame Herbert hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.