10 Most Mind-Blowing Wrestling Secrets Of 2023
Wrestlers controversially switching sides, shoot fights and and the shocking return of a dead brand.
We're a long way removed from the era of all wrestling being shrouded in secrecy, but there's a good chance you wouldn't be on this site without the thirst for backstage nuggets of news, "rumour and innuendo" and scuttlebutt still being forever unquenchable.
There's a great chance the writers here - your current one included - wouldn't have found places just like this one decades ago without the first wrestling newsletters, such was the interest in everything that went on behind the curtain and/or with the cameras well and truly off. The secrets are less salacious than they once might have been, but the facts behind the fiction remain just as intoxicating.
WWE's business has boomed in 2023, and while AEW's domestic success has sagged compared to transcendent terms between 2019 and 2022, one of the biggest shows in industry history at Wembley Stadium suggests that interest in the industry could be at an all-time high.
The market leader and the challenger brand are in good health heading into 2024, but what went on below the radar in the 12 months leading up to one of the business' biggest-ever years?
10. Cody Rhodes Lets A LITTLE More Out On His AEW Exit
The Cody Rhodes documentary "American Nightmare" was - like most things Cody Rhodes in WWE - a stunning over-delivery even if expectations had been set quite high.
Though peppered with all the usual bells and whistles one expects from an extended in-house special, a fascinating tale of career highs and lows was made all the more unique thanks to the specific journey Rhodes had been on between the market leader, the indies and All Elite Wrestling.
Rather than being an elephant in the room, Rhodes' exit from AEW was summarised amicably, but for the first time ever he did let slip a little more about one of the most shocking switches in recent history. At the time, he'd tweeted; "I have loved my time at AEW. Amazing locker room. Amazing fans. Amazing people. The 'revolution' was indeed televised, and I've been incredibly lucky to be part of that" and just about left it there.
In the documentary, he added; "I can't tell you why I left AEW, I can't and I won't. But I can tell you the reasons that were said – that didn't actually matter. I didn't leave AEW because of money and I didn't leave AEW because of other talents. I left AEW because of a personal issue. That's it. The byproduct of leaving AEW is the opportunity to go for the biggest dream I ever had and the first dream I had in my life."
Naturally, that resulted in more speculation, which is perhaps why what isn't known about the story remains so intriguing.
9. The LuFisto Story
The complex case of LuFisto's AEW experience was laid bare on social media in 2023, and with it came something of a referendum on the women's division at large.
What remains of it is well documented here (LuFisto briefly deleted her Twitter/X profile in the aftermath), but the short version is that she worked one AEW date (an April 2022 Dark: Elevation taping alongside Emi Sakura and The Bunny vs Anna Jay, Ruby Soho and Skye Blue), it didn't go particularly well, and there were disagreements with multiple fellow talents, agents and backstage staffers as a result.
Dustin Rhodes, Billy Gunn and Ruby Soho were name-checked in the stories, and in the aftermath, a series of tweets from those within the AEW locker room were posted extolling the virtues of the division, the atmosphere and an alternative take on working for Tony Khan. The furore eventually died down, but it left behind a slightly damaged and fractured reputation, particularly considering the contentiousness around the division's booking that's existed since the company launched.
8. Nigel McGuinness Is READY
https://twitter.com/McGuinnessNigel/status/1695735438776967260
— Tweet
As seamless as Nigel McGuinness' step into the AEW commentary booth has been in 2023, it came amidst rampant but unconfirmed speculation that he had another role in mind too.
Just ahead of the historic All In London show, the former ROH Champion posted an image of himself in fabulous shape, sporting brand-new gear and looking even more ring-ready than when he emotionally wrapped it all up in 2011. McGuinness confirmed he was good to go, generating speculation that a long-teased showdown with old rival Bryan Danielson had quite literally been on the cards before 'The American Dragon' himself was forced off the show with injury.
There are lights at the end of these respective tunnels - a best-kept-secret in 2023 could be a best-built match in 2024, not least with Danielson expressing his desire to wind down sooner rather than later. Wembley is waiting yet again, and if Nigel is still In It To Win It, the two might yet get one final chapter to add to their classic story.
7. TNA! TNA! TNA!
The unlikely return of TNA wrestling was revealed by way of several roster members unearthing the brand as if it were buried treasure.
To plenty of people, this was accurate - over the several since the initials disappeared in favour of a protracted "Impact Wrestling" rebrand, the memories moved from noxious to nostalgic. The horrendous creative mistakes were reframed as features rather than bugs, and the classic matches were rightfully lionised as vital in helping North America move forward following the deaths of both WCW and ECW.
The news being broken as a big surprise inclusion on the company's Bound For Glory pay-per-view was fitting too - this sort of shocker used to be TNA's bread and butter, and the whole shift went months without the sniff of a leak. The October bombshell was reportedly concocted around Slammiversary in July, meaning it was in the plans right around the time the product was at its most nostalgia-fuelled.
6. AEW Turned Down Bret Hart
Bret Hart made an unannounced but very welcome appearance at AEW Double Or Nothing 2019 having gone into WWE's Hall Of Fame for the second time just one month earlier. A wrestling icon introducing the brand new challenger brand's World Heavyweight Championship was a sharp move for the upstart company to make. It was, as of this writing, his last appearance with the group.
Remaining on a WWE Legends contract, 'The Hitman's status with the market leader ultimately got in the way of him sticking around in the challenger brand, but it was later revealed that All Elite Wrestling had already elected not to bring the 'Excellence Of Execution' in on any kind of deal.
Hart revealed that the company wanted him not necessarily as a backstage coach, but as an on-air managerial figure akin to a Jake Roberts or Tully Blanchard. 'The Hitman' only really wanted the agent spot, so the two sides ultimately parted ways.
5. Tapping Up Allegations
Partly down to wrestling existing in a grey area in how talents are paid/contracted and also because allegations of tampering or tapping up in any industry can be taken very seriously, it's possible this minor scandal that broke late in 2023 might come to nothing. But break it did.
Emerging from the embers of Tony Khan's post-Tuesday Night Wars posts on X in October, further information about talent apparently involved in the murky situation was revealed.
Swerve Strickland and William Regal were allegedly wrestlers WWE had shown more than a passive interest in despite both being on AEW deals, and to make matters worse, the whole thing had gone down while Khan was at the side of his ill mother. The furore died down as they typically do, but it brought back into focus just how seriously both sides take all of this in spite of multiple public cries to the contrary.
Wrestlers and promoters alike can tell you there's no war. Bad faith critics can tell you it's bad form to favour one company over another. But that's not how they really see it, and definitely not how they want it.
4. The CM Punk & Jack Perry Fight
At All In London, Jack Perry wrestled Hook in the main event of the pre-show ahead of CM Punk opening the pay-per-view proper with an instant classic against Samoa Joe.
The things that occurred between the closing bell of one match and the opening of the other, resulted in one of the biggest and most contentious chapters of AEW's relatively short history coming to an abrupt and controversial ending.
All of this might well have started as a secret, but it didn't stay that way very long. In this case, it couldn't.
Punk and Perry had clashed over the latter's mocking of the former on camera when he used real glass in a spot despite The Punker's reservations weeks earlier that he specifically not do that. One thing very speedily led to another and a scuffle was serious enough that Tony Khan later revealed he personally felt under threat and that the former Champion had been fired "with cause".
Punk's AEW run was easily - easily - one of the best in the organisation so far, but the untenable reality that had become his status there had reached breaking point arguably the very worst moment.
3. Ricky Starks At The Royal Rumble
Cody Rhodes' Royal Rumble 2023 return saw the 'American Nightmare' return from an injury that had sidelined him since May and win the titular battle royal to secure a place in the WrestleMania main event.
This was all enjoyably predictable for those following along with WWE's central output, but few could have seen coming the presence of AEW's Ricky Starks when the first images of a returning Cody dropped. That's because few should have - the picture came from leaked security camera footage that was obviously never intended for public consumption.
Ever-keen to smile through any crisis big or small, Rhodes took some blame all the same. Noting that "[Starks] should have kept his butt on the bus" and that he'd "make new friends in WWE", he accepted that there'd naturally be some speculation about a talent move even though 'Absolute' was just there to watch his friends. He was right - the rumours of an eventual AEW exit at the end of his existing contract have circled the former TNT Champion all year.
2. The Grim Reality Of The Post-WrestleMania Raw
As multiple changes were reportedly being made during the show itself, Brock Lesnar was prominently featured beating the tar out of WrestleMaia's fallen hero Cody Rhodes, and several planned matches and promos were blown through in illogically quick time, the general vibe around Monday Night Raw just 24 hours removed from a phenomenally successful 'Show Of Shows' was grim.
As the show was on the air WWE continued to be the talk of the town, and not just because they were still stationed in the showbiz capital of the world - the company had been sold in something of a sequel to 2022's biggest story that Vince McMahon was to resign in disgrace. In that time, he'd un-resigned, worked his way back on to the board and overseen a merger with UFC, and now fancied sitting in the big chair on Raw too.
With the mood still sour from the divisive decision to have Rhodes lose to Roman Reigns, a fairly horrendous-looking reality took hold. Until...
1. Triple H Given Full Creative Control
In spite of the ugly energy during Vince McMahon's hostile return, the mega-money deal with Endeavor to bring WWE and UFC under one roof didn't result in the ex-Chairman getting his grubby fingers back on the book.
Remarkably, it was somehow the exact opposite.
When the deal was first done, Endeavor CEO Ari Emmanuel had made it clear just how important McMahon was to the historic deal. Months later and with the wrestling side of the business absolutely booming, it was reported that the top dog didn't believe that the disgraced ex-WWE chief's best place would be in a position to change plans on Raw every week.
As good as gone from the creative process (for now at least), those thoroughly enjoying WWE's impressive output in 2023 were able to breathe a little easier that McMahon theoretically couldn't drop a bomb on the various plans that have clearly been put in place.