10 Most Shocking Wrestling Betrayals
Eat your heart out, Benedict Arnold.
One thing WWE has taught its viewers over the years is to never trust anyone. Whether it’s honourable babyfaces revealing their malevolent true colours to the fans or long time factions imploding, few characters ever remain noble.
Wrestling factions are typically formed so the members can support one another. Teaming can lead to reinvention, hot angles and all manner of hijinks. It’s all great for a while but eventually the members will start to clash and tease feuds with one another. Soon enough, friendships have imploded and betrayals lead to blood feuds.
There are other times when a lone wrestler betrays their promotion and their fans, often pushed too far by one too many setbacks. Wrestling’s even had its fair share of romances over the years and by this point, it should be rather obvious how most of them end...
Betrayals often make for thrilling moments in wrestling, remembered by fans for years to come. Such angles conclude old storylines and introduce new ones for all of the wrestlers involved. From the heartbreaking to the wholly unexpected, let’s take a look at 10 of wrestling’s most shocking betrayals.
10. The Destruction Of DIY
NXT TakeOver: Chicago was a fun show full of fantastic action to send the fans home happy. Everyone was having a great time right up to the heartbreaking last five minutes. In a dark and depressing turn of events, the injured Tommaso Ciampa turned on long time pal and tag partner Johnny Gargano after their loss to AOP. The logo had come up, we thought the show was over and yet tragedy still struck.
Ferociously assaulting his former comrade in arms, Ciampa would not be seen again for months, leaving a devastated Gargano in his wake. Bitter about his injury and a perceived lack of respect from fans, Ciampa wanted to be remembered for better or for worse. Fans were left slack-jawed, horrified at the violent demise of a beloved underdog team.
What followed was a twist and turn filled rivalry that goes on to this day. Best friends turned bitter enemies has been a popular trope in professional wrestling but few have taken it to such an emotional extreme. Ciampa’s betrayal of Gargano remains a seminal moment in NXT's (and professional wrestling as a whole's) history.
9. Sgt Slaughter Turns His Coat
Many stars of the WWE have run with patriotic gimmicks through the years to varying levels of success. One of the most all-American characters to have ever hit the squared circle was Sgt. Slaughter, an '80s fan favourite best known for his grisly feud with Pat Patterson. Slaughter’s schtick was so all-American that he was even offered the chance to do public service announcements for the G.I. Joe cartoon series.
During Operation Desert Storm in Iraq, Vince McMahon decided a cheap heat angle would work wonders for their ratings. Slaughter was brought back and rebooted as a staunch supporter of Saddam Hussein. Destroying the US flag and turning on the country he’d once been so proud to represent, Slaughter soon nabbed the WWF Championship.
Slaughter’s heel turn and the subsequent angles drew a great deal of negative press at the time. The hope had been for such controversy to spike up buy rates heading into WrestleMania VII but it was not to be. Many fans were disgusted by the angle and disappointed that a title rematch between Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior was now off the cards. Nonetheless, the betrayal was completely unexpected and one that shocked and deeply upset fans everywhere.
8. The Mega Powers Implode
Two of the biggest and brightest stars on offer during the enormous wrestling boom of the '80s, Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage’s Mega Powers team was a huge draw. Fans went wild at the sight of the pair’s legendary handshake and immense crowd support followed the team into their matches.
Given the size of their respective egos and the fact that Randy Savage was the reigning, defending WWF Champion of the world, a split seemed inevitable. Even so, the break up was made shocking by its primary reason: Miss Elizabeth.
Savage grew increasingly uncomfortable with the closeness between his wife and Hogan. He very visibly loathed the sight of her managing Hogan and grew incensed after Hogan accidentally caused his elimination at the 1989 Royal Rumble. Furiously paranoid, Savage assaulted the Hulkster after their tag bout at The Main Event II, completely destroying their blockbuster partnership in the process.
A dramatic title feud and WrestleMania V main event followed suit as Savage descended further into heel territory. One of the great angles of the wildly successful Golden Era, Savage’s betrayal of Hogan remains a classic moment in professional wrestling history.
7. Orton’s Evolution
2004 was a frustrating time for Triple H. He’d tapped out at WrestleMania XX and failed in various attempts to get the World Heavyweight Championship back from Chris Benoit. By SummerSlam, Triple H was out of the title picture completely, feuding with Eric Bischoff’s nephew Eugene.
Triple H’s Evolution stablemate, Randy Orton, had stepped up to the plate, defeating Benoit for the title and besting him once again in a rematch the very next night. Triple H was less than pleased at his golden boy’s success and his own sudden lack of spotlight. Putting the thumb down, Triple H (along with Batista and Ric Flair) turned on the celebrating Orton immediately. After beating the young champ to a bloody pulp, Hunter would employ nefarious methods to take his title back at Unforgiven the next month.
The segment itself is often referenced and the thumb down and sudden change of expression was brought back for Batista’s face turn on Triple H the next year. While Orton’s subsequent face turn didn’t exactly lead to superstardom, the Evolution betrayal was a heated and unexpected moment. Rumours had previously swirled of a slow burn build to a Triple H vs. Randy Orton main event at WrestleMania 21. The feud exploding onto the scene eight months in advance left many surprised, as did Triple H’s decisive victories.
6. Kicking The Leg Out
Royal Rumble 1994 saw a family dispute violently explode when a furious and frustrated Owen Hart assaulted his older brother Bret. Owen had spent years living in the long shadow of his more successful brother. Widely regarded as the superior of the two, Bret was already a former world champion and it only seemed a matter of time before he regained the gold.
The brothers lost their tag titles to The Quebecers that evening with Bret falling under the weight of a severe knee injury. Owen’s frustrations came to a head, believing Bret’s hubris and lack of faith in his brother had cost them the gold. With several months of onscreen build and years of off screen tension heavily implied, Owen finally snapped and turned heel. He floored his injured brother with a stiff kick to the injured knee. Venting his frustrations, Owen’s mic time would lead to one of the most (in)famous promo botches ever: “And that’s why I kicked your leg out of your leg!”
Regardless, the betrayal was a dramatic and well developed one that led to one of the greatest opening matches in WrestleMania history later that year.
5. DX Degenerates
Four years after his career-ending back injury, Shawn Michaels reformed D-Generation X with long time pal Triple H. The two came out to the old DX theme, sporting DX shirts and performing the classic entrance on a July 2002 episode of RAW. Everything seemed fine and dandy as Triple H riled up the crowd for the faction’s signature catch phrase. Much to the shock and horror of the audience and the commentary team, Triple H hit the still retired Michaels with a Pedigree out of nowhere.
Instead of a stroll down nostalgia lane with a DX reunion, fans were about to get the most epic feud of the Ruthless Aggression Era. An incensed Michaels would make his return to the ring at SummerSlam and the two would engage in blood soaked battles for the next two years.
Triple H revealed he never considered Michaels his friend and had only stuck with him in the '90s to further his own career. Considering himself the bigger star of the two, Triple H no longer needed Michaels and began a lengthy heel run during which time he founded Evolution and embarked upon the infamous Reign of Terror.
4. Leaping Through The Window
The beginning of HBK’s marvellous solo career came in 1991 at the expense of long-time tag partner and buddy, Marty Jannetty. Pulling a fast one on both Marty and the fans, Michaels rocked his former friend with some Sweet Chin Music before throwing him head first through a barbershop window.
Tensions between the two had been called into question at the time yet the malice of Michaels’ action remained a sinister surprise. The destruction of the fan favourite Rockers team turned HBK into a widely reviled heel as he steadily made his way up the card, eventually winning the Intercontinental Championship. Jannetty would attempt revenge on his new foe on several occasions, including challenging Michaels for the IC title at Royal Rumble 1993.
While Michaels became the legendary Hall of Famer we know today, Jannetty sadly never amounted to much. Frequently fired and rehired by WWE, his career has lived permanently in the shadow of his incredibly successful former partner. Such was the difference between the two that they are the measuring stick by which newly solo tag team wrestlers are held against to this day.
3. Love Hurts
To think this all started over one Canadian dollar. Late 2003 saw a bet arise between amigos Chris Jericho and Christian over who could get with their workplace romantic interest first. For Jericho, it was Trish Stratus and for Christian, it was her best friend Lita. We’d never get the winner in this wager thanks to Stratus overhearing the two. Throwing her initial flirtations with Y2J to the curb, she called him out on his behaviour and Jericho made the effort to be better behaved.
This was all well and good until Christian totally demolished Stratus in an intergender match on RAW. Horrified at the actions of his former friend, Jericho did battle with Christian at WrestleMania XX with Stratus in his corner. Revenge never quite made it to the table for Jericho, however, as Stratus cost him the match and proceeded to get off with Christian. Devastated, Jericho had lost both his tag partner and his love interest in a matter of weeks and now the two were teamed against him.
Stratus had been a babyface for years up to this point and the vindictive nature of her heel turn was a shocker. More surprising still was how duped both Jericho and viewers were by her and Christian’s antics heading into the show of shows.
2. The Architect Ascends
The Shield was unstoppable. Coming off back to back pay per view victories over Evolution, they arrived on RAW at the peak of their powers the next night. Roman Reigns was scheduled to wrestle Randy Orton in the main event that evening. When Orton and Triple H came out with the reveal of a new plan to dismantle The Shield, no one guessed it would be Seth Rollins and a steel chair. Burying the chair in Reigns’ back, Rollins than pulverised Ambrose with several shots before leaving with The Game and Orton.
Seemingly out of nowhere, Rollins’ heel turn left us all feeling as shocked as Dean Ambrose looked that night. Tensions had been teased in The Shield, mostly between Reigns and an increasingly heelish Ambrose. Rollins had been the level-headed one, talking sense to his wayward team mates and leading them back to their winning ways.
Rollins’ out of the blue betrayal led to all three members moving on to their solo careers and stories, often butting heads and reuniting in equal measure right up to Ambrose’s departure in 2019.
1. Hulkamania Runs Vile
“So this is where the big boys play huh?”
The Outsiders, Kevin Nash and Scott Hall, set the wrestling world on fire when they began their invasion of WCW in 1996. The angle sparked a great deal of controversy. It was initially implied that the former Diesel and former Razor Ramon had been sent by WWF to kill Ted Turner’s promotion from within.
At Bash of the Beach 1996, The Outsiders faced Sting, Lex Luger and Randy Savage in a match where they promised their third man would be there. Towards the end of the bout, Hogan makes his way down. Fans cheered, assuming Hogan had seen enough of Nash and Hall’s antics and was here to save the day. Instead, Hogan hit Savage with the legdrop and revealed himself as the leader of what was soon dubbed the New World Order.
Hogan’s heel turn enraged fans to a level rarely seen with many hurling rubbish into the ring and one even jumping the barricade. Hogan’s betrayal led to his Hollywood Hulk Hogan persona and the beginning of WCW’s dominance during the Monday Night Wars.