10 Most Surprising WWE Royal Rumble Winners Ever

Of all 28 Royal Rumble Matches, which 10 winners were the most shocking?

Matt Davis For decades, the Royal Rumble winners have come to include some of the most popular, heavily-promoted, successful main event level superstars in the history of sports-entertainment. More often than not, the man who walked away as the winner of the Royal Rumble would go on to bigger and better things, specifically the WWE Championship, many times within that very same year. There were years, however, when the superstars that were chosen to win the Royal Rumble came as a complete shock to the viewers, some times in a good way and some times making the whole match feel incredulous. It shouldn't come as a surprise to hear that superstars like Hulk Hogan, Steve Austin, Shawn Michaels, and John Cena are all multi-time Royal Rumble winners, but not all of the winners of the yearly January battle royal always made the most sense. Despite the historical significance and prestige that the Royal Rumble Match has come to be associated with since its inception, the selected winners did not always pan out, and some of the choices have come to be considered less than wise. Whether fueled by a desire to change the title picture, to push talent that may have otherwise been less than main event caliber, or simply to fool the audiences, the WWE has made some surprising, even strange choices over the years when it came to deciding their Royal Rumble winners...

10. Bret Hart & Lex Luger (1994)

The finish of the 1994 Royal Rumble was surprising not so much because of the men that were eventually announced as the winners, but the fact that, for the first and thus far only time in WWE history, there were co-winners of the 30-man battle royal. By announcing both Bret "Hitman" Hart and Lex Luger as the victors in 1994, WWE ventured down a slippery slope with a very controversial ending in which the #1 contender heading into WrestleMania X was unclear. The next year, the 1995 Royal Rumble contained another questionable finish leading many fans to wonder if ambiguous endings would become the new norm. Was a cliffhanger to the yearly January classic going to happen at every Royal Rumble now? Luckily, the company got back to the basics the following year when Shawn Michaels won without any controversy, but for a couple of years in the mid-90s, the WWE's booking of the Royal Rumble's finish left fans very surprised.

9. Ric Flair (1992)

Never before had the Royal Rumble Match meant so much. Often regarded as the greatest Royal Rumble Match in WWE history, the 1992 contest featured an historical moment from many perspectives when Ric Flair won the famous battle royal and with it, the previously-vacated WWE Championshp. Flair had defected from the NWA/WCW in mid-1991 and appeared on WWE television that Fall. Previously, big-name talents from the rival organization had been relegated to the mid-card or made into comedy acts not dissimilar to Dusty Rhodes. Because of this, it was a bit of a surprise for Vince McMahon to not only feature him at the very top of the card but to christen with him his company's most prestigious title in a match that also featured Vince's top superstars. For Flair to shine, even for one night, over WWE legends like Randy Savage, Hulk Hogan, Roddy Piper, Ted DiBiase, The Undertaker, and Jake Roberts was a sight to behold and one that would not be revisited very often by Vince McMahon.

8. Mr. McMahon (1999)

In 1999, Vince McMahon was not viewed as even a part-time wrestler by the fans and audiences of WWE. He was a former ringside commentator who only recently began flaunting his real-life ownership of the company on-screen, and he had yet to step into the ring for a real, official match. He teased a couple matches on television and even participated in the Corporate Royal Rumble on RAW just prior to the '99 Rumble PPV, but fans were still curious about what they would see from the WWE patriarch when he stepped into the ring at the Royal Rumble. In addition to McMahon's lack of in-ring experience, fans expected the main event of WrestleMania XV to center around Steve Austin's quest to reclaim the title. Even in January, that seemed to mean an obvious main event match against The Rock which likely meant the 30-man battle royal would be won by Steve Austin for the third straight year in a row. Needless to say, the result came as a shock when the inexperienced and puffed up Vince McMahon secured the victory.

7. John Cena (2008)

Similar to Edge in 2010, John Cena's entry into the Royal Rumble stunned audiences in 2008. What prevents this entry from ranking higher on the list though is that the moment Cena entered the Rumble, it was quite clear he would walk out the victor. The entry into the Royal Rumble itself was more surprising than the victory, and since this article is looking at the most surprising winners, John Cena in 2008 ranks lower than others might have guessed. Still, Cena's victory was shocking because no one expected him back from a torn pectoral muscle less than four months after suffering the injury. Edge was in a similar position in 2010, returning to win the Rumble despite being a surprise entrant, and both men were already main-event level talents that made their Royal Rumble victories surprising in some ways, but not the most unexpected.

6. Alberto Del Rio (2011)

It was the 2011 Royal Rumble when the yearly battle royal began being used to push some of the upper mid-card superstars, rather than centered around true main event feuds. The World Heavyweight Championship was without question a secondary title in WWE by this point and the winner of the 2011 Royal Rumble challenged for this title instead of making it to the real main event of WrestleMania. Instead of CM Punk, Randy Orton, or John Cena walking away as the winner, it was WWE newcomer Alberto Del Rio that was given the win. Del Rio was pushed heavily upon his debut in June 2010, but was forced into the main event scene and wasn't truly over when he won the Royal Rumble. This became even more apparent when, at WrestleMania XXVII, Del Rio was put in the opening contest, not exactly the position that winning the coveted battle royal promised. The previous three years' Rumble winners were not successful in their claims to capture their respective world championships at WrestleMania, but it was arguably Del Rio's victory in 2011 that sent the Royal Rumble Match into a downward spiral as it started to lose some of its prestige.

5. Sheamus (2012)

The 2011 Royal Rumble put the match on a downward descent and the 2012 Royal Rumble saw the bottom drop out. Taking nothing away from what he has accomplished throughout his WWE career, but giving Sheamus the Royal Rumble victory in 2012 just reeked of desperation on WWE's part on many levels. The company was desperate to try and get Sheamus over as babyface, they were desperate to try and swerve the fans by changing the winner at the last minute from the recently-returned Chris Jericho, and they were desperate to try and make the Royal Rumble some sort of fail-safe, bail-out plan where one victory could get a superstar over. Like WrestleMania XXVII, WrestleMania XXVIII in 2012 also featured the Royal Rumble winner jerking the curtain when Sheamus defeated Daniel Bryan in their infamous opening contest that lasted 18 seconds. WWE was clearly misguided in their thinking that by simply awarding any talent the Royal Rumble victory, they would be seen as an instantly over, credible, bonafide main event superstar. The company seems to have learned its lesson since then. Say what you will about the predictability of some of the recent Royal Rumble winners, but since 2013, they have all competed in the true main event of WrestleMania.

4. Hacksaw Jim Duggan (1988)

Hacksaw Jim Duggan may be the most surprising name to be featured on this list as he was a mid-card wrestler for most of his career. Several factors contributed to the biggest accomplishment of Duggan's career, but nothing changes the level of surprise the victory caused. For one, the Royal Rumble was a brand new concept and 1988 was the first year the match took place; it wasn't yet exclusive to being won by main event talents. It also featured only 20 superstars and was broadcast live on the USA Network, not Pay-Per-View. The event also took place around the peak of Hacksaw Jim Duggan's career as 1988 was the year in which Duggan main-evented Madison Square Garden against Andre The Giant. Andre was responsible for Duggan's loss to DiBiase in the WrestleMania IV tournament for the vacant WWE title. Despite the short-lived main event feud with Andre, Hacksaw was not seen as a main event superstar before or after his brief run at the top in 1988. So while there was some logic to giving Duggan this win, the WWE's choice for the first ever Royal Rumble victor raised more eyebrows than most other Rumble winners over the years.

3. Stone Cold Steve Austin (1997)

For younger fans that were not around or not following WWE during the rise of Stone Cold Steve Austin, this entry may be a bit of a head-scratcher. But in January of 1997, it was very surprising to see Austin win the Royal Rumble since he wasn't expected to main event WrestleMania 13, which, of course, is what came with winning the Rumble match. In early '97, Steve Austin had only just begun his ascent to the top of the WWE roster. Although Austin had a brush with the semi-main at the 1996 Survivor Series, it would still be several months until he became a main event mainstay. WrestleMania 13 was expected to feature a rematch of the classic WrestleMania XII main event between Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart. So when Bret was "eliminated" in that year's Royal Rumble, despite being the last legal man in the ring, fans were shocked. Austin had been thrown out by Bret, but was able to sneak back into the ring before the referees noticed. Austin's victory shocked fans who expected a Bret/Shawn rematch and even though that match didn't happen at WrestleMania 13, Austin didn't get the main event spot either.

2. Big John Studd (1989)

Especially considering potential alternative winners that year such as Ted DiBiase, Andre The Giant, Hulk Hogan, Randy Savage, Bad News Brown, or even Big Boss Man or Akeem, Big John Studd winning the 1989 Royal Rumble was a surprising selection that, certainly in hindsight, seems like a waste. Why Studd was chosen to go over has more to do with the way WWE viewed the Royal Rumble Match at the time and less to do with Big John Studd and any huge, main-event plans for him. In 1989, the company was only just getting used to what exactly the Royal Rumble Match was and how it could be used. It would be a couple more years until WWE realized just how big of a deal the battle royal could be, so John Studd winning in 1989 wasn't thought of as the huge achievement it would later come to be perceived as. In fact, the company used the victory as a way to re-introduce the audience to the big 6'10" superstar whom recently returned to the company after a two-year hiatus. John Studd was a big-name talent that wrestled for years under the World Wrestling Federation, but he failed to capitalize on the January victory when he left the company, this time for good, just a few months later. It helped make Studd's Royal Rumble victory one of the least impactful and most surprising in WWE history.

1. Yokozuna (1993)

Considering the WWE landscape around the time of the 1993 Royal Rumble, the relatively unknown and newcomer Yokozuna winning the 30-man battle royal and going on to headline WrestleMana IX was the most shocking victory of all the Royal Rumble winners. The 1993 match was the first time that the winner would be considered the #1 contender to the WWE Championship and face the champion at WrestleMania. Yokozuna had debuted in WWE just several months prior to the Royal Rumble and his highest profile match was with Virgil at the '92 Survivor Series. The main event scene at this time was occupied by Macho Man Randy Savage, Ric Flair, Bret Hart, Mr. Perfect, and Razor Ramon. While the Hitman defended the title against Razor at the '93 Rumble, the other three main eventers were participants in the Royal Rumble Match itself. Many fans predicted Mr. Perfect or the Macho Man to walk out as the #1 contender considering how logical and highly anticipated a match with Bret Hart, or even Razor Ramon, would've been for WrestleMania IX. So when the winner was Yokozuna, the "Japanese" sumo wrestler who had yet to feature into even a mid-card feud with another WWE superstar, fans were stunned and it became the most surprising Royal Rumble victory ever.

Contributor
Contributor

A former stuntman for Paramount Pictures, Matt enjoys sports, water skiing, driving fast, the beach, professional wrestling, technology, and scotch. At the same time, whenever possible. Having attended many famous (and infamous) shows including WrestleMania XV, In Your House: Mind Games, and the 1995 King of the Ring, Matt has been a lifelong professional sports and wrestling fan. Matt's been mentioned in numerous wrestling podcasts including the Steve Austin Show: Unleashed, Talk Is Jericho, and Something To Wrestle With Bruce Prichard. As a former countywide performer, Matt has been referred to as Mr. 300 for his amazing accomplishments in the world of amateur bowling. He is also the only man on record to have pitched back-to-back no hitters in the Veterans Stadium Wiffle Ball League of 2003.