10 Most Uncomfortable Wrestling Storylines Ever

From the plain stupid and embarrassing to the sickening and the revolting…

Wrestling as a form of entertainment necessitates scripted storylines that are sometimes completely fabricated, and sometimes inspired by real-life events. When the former are used, they€™re meant to forward a storyline between two or more wrestlers in a relatively simple way. When the latter are used, it€™s often to help the promotion in question to jump onto a topical issue and gain more mainstream attention. Sometimes it works, but it can also bite the promotion back if they€™re not careful. In WWE€™s case, they€™ve made several attempts to cash in on real-life events, either involving their own Superstars, or external events over which they have no control. These have been mostly for shock value or to get more people to pay attention to them, but in each of they made big mistakes. Furthermore, there have been some gimmicks and storylines constructed by WWE that have been so bad that they made the audiences wrestling uncomfortable. This article will highlight ten storylines, some based on real-life events and some completely fabricated by WWE that made those watching them uncomfortable. Some of them were due to the subtext of the storyline being inappropriate or unnecessary, while in other cases the storylines were just so stupid, immature or otherwise outlandish that people watching couldn€™t help but shake their heads. WWE has the potential to make both the best and worst storylines in professional wrestling. The ten discussed over the following pages could be lessons for what WWE should not do in the future when building new storylines.

10. Matt Hardy Vs. Jeff Hardy

For years, Matt and Jeff Hardy were presented as inseparable brothers who were among the most popular tag teams in the division. But when they split, the crowd favored Jeff over Matt, and this showed in the difference between their singles careers. Jeff won both the WWE and World Heavyweight Championships and main-evented several PPVs, while Matt languished in the mid-card, never grasping the brass ring like his brother did. So in 2009, Matt turned on Jeff, costing him the World title, and proceeded to make the feud as personal as possible, including referencing a real-life incident in which Jeff€™s house burned to the ground. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Q5hTSS7ukE The feud reached its pinnacle in discomfort when Matt brought in a charred dog collar recovered from what was once Jeff€™s house, indicating that Jeff€™s dog had died in the fire. It was uncomfortable to watch Matt demonize his own brother€™s real-life losses and mistakes, and the charred dog collar only made it worse. When fans tune in to watch a wrestling show, they want to see wrestling with storylines. What they don€™t want to see is tasteless manipulation of real-life loss for the purpose of making an already-personal rivalry more personal€and uncomfortable.

9. Kane & Lita's Child

In 2004, Kane took part in one of the most uncomfortable storylines in recent memory, as part of a weird love angle with Lita. The idea behind the storyline was that Kane asked Lita, who was seeing Matt Hardy at the time, to carry his child. This led to a love triangle of sorts between the three of them, with Kane even €˜marrying€™ Lita on one episode of RAW. However, while Kane was presented as the bad guy in that story, everything changed when Gene Snitsky entered the picture. He attacked Kane, causing him to fall on Lita, which in turn led to Lita €˜losing her baby€™. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xj7Z54vHWEc While it was obviously a scripted and otherwise outlandish segment, it must€™ve been very uncomfortable for many fans, especially those who have lost children from pregnancy complications. Kane€™s reaction to hearing this news was an exaggerated, yet accurate, depiction of what families go through when children are lost during pregnancy. It can become one of the most traumatic and devastating moments in a family€™s life, and once that no one wants to see on a show that should be centered on wrestling above all else. As such, it wouldn€™t be surprising for some fans to have felt uncomfortable when WWE Superstars and Divas mocked Kane and Lita for their love affair.

8. 'Piggy James' & 'Fat' Vickie

WWE has a troubled record when it comes to portrayal of women on their programs. Many have been given the €˜crazy chick€™ gimmick; others have been used for promoted €˜Hot Lesbian Action€™; while others still were given the pretentious bully character. In this third case, Michelle McCool and Layla began bullying fan favorite Mickie James over alleged weight issues. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7l-gnyNoiJg The female audience watching these segments must€™ve felt especially uncomfortable. Young women in contemporary society are bombarded with images every day on what constitutes €˜the perfect body€™, and those who don€™t fit are doomed to ridicule. In this case, Mickie James, who looks great despite any alleged €˜weight issues€™ was made to cry on national TV over her appearance. WWE could€™ve done a simple storyline over how Mickie was the challenger for Michelle€™s Divas Championship, and Michelle didn€™t think she was acceptable competition. Instead, they did a cheap storyline about fat women, which, unfortunately, has been a popular topic in WWE, as they love to emphasize thin models over athletic female wrestlers. There was also Vickie Guerrero, who was constantly at the butt of fat jokes, including from token good guy John Cena and Jerry Lawler. This was taking place at the same time as WWE€™s BA STAR campaign, which must€™ve felt incredibly ironic. To their credit, both Vickie and Mickie had a lot of emotional toughness to be berated for something that€™s so sensitive to many women in today€™s world.

7. Adam Rose & The Bunny

There are some things that simply do not belong on a wrestling show. A grown man in a Bunny suit is one of them. Initially just another member of Adam Rose€™s €˜Party Posse€™, WWE decided that the Bunny should be featured more prominently because he appeals to children. That decision led to widespread condemnation from many fans, and the gimmick was labelled the worst of 2014. Part of that stems from the general childishness of the character, as the Bunny was getting involved in matches. But one of the most bizarre moments of the Bunny and Adam Rose€™s RAW careers, was when the Bunny dry-humped Adam Rose and then made pelvic thrust motions on the entrance ramp. It€™s one of those confusing and pointless segments that don€™t add to any aspect of either character€™s development, or to the show itself for that matter. Fans everywhere felt uncomfortable watching a show where a grown man in a bunny suit was given more screen time than many people on the roster far more deserving of it. It was also discomforting due to childish antics and the kind of sexual moments on RAW you absolutely don€™t want to see. The Bunny has (thankfully) not been seen in RAW for quite some time, yet his (its?) profile on WWE.com€™s €˜Superstars€™ page for some reason. Hopefully it€™s just a temporary error, because no one wants to see that character anymore, not even the youngest members of the audience.

6. Eddie Guerrero, Rey Mysterio & Dominic

Eddie Guerrero€™s feud with friend Rey Mysterio reached its highest (or lowest, depending on who you ask) point when Rey€™s son Dominic was added to it. He was told that he was actually Eddie€™s son, and subsequent segments involved Eddie impregnating a random woman and giving that child to Rey and his wife. The storyline took away from what should€™ve remained a storyline centered solely on the competition of wrestling. Eddie and Rey were fantastic athletes at the time, and the simple story of how Eddie couldn€™t defeat Rey one-on-one was so simple yet so effective a story that it could€™ve written itself. Eddie€™s heel turn and subsequent promos were great, because they underscored the competitive fire that both men had. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ax-F9k3Dry8 Instead, WWE amplified the whole €˜story€™ and €˜drama€™ aspects of their approach, and additional characters, including Vickie Guerrero and a child protective services agent, which must€™ve made things too close to home for some people, especially those who€™ve had to deal with similar family issues. It makes sense for WWE to use its appeal to make tongue-in-cheek references to social issues, but more often than not, WWE makes it too uncomfortable for people watching by going to the extreme and going for shock and hitting too close to home.

5. The McMahon Family Abusing Jim Ross (2005)

On an episode of RAW in 2005, WWE had the storyline that someone was going to be fired. At the end of the show, then-WWE CEO Linda McMahon gave Jim Ross a low blow and echoed her husband€™s infamous words, €˜You€™re Fired!€™ This was done to write JR off of TV for a while, as he was set to have important colon surgery. Unfortunately, WWE went even further with their twisted brand of comedy with this terrible segment: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DVaj31J18AU The segment in this video is uncomfortable to watch for two reasons. One, Mr. McMahon makes terrible puns that show just how bad his style of comedy was (a €˜crack€™ staff, Dr. Hiney, Nurse Slobber-knockers , terrible farting noises, pre-recordings of famous JR lines, etc.). Honestly, the jokes are so terrible and the sound effects so lame you€™d think they were written by a 9-year old. Two, it was quite possibly the single most insulting segment that Vince ever took part in. it€™s one of those segments that just drags on for way too long, and it€™s clear by the end of it that its sole purpose is for Vince to mock the greatest commentator in wrestling history for his own amusement. It€™s moments like these that make people ashamed to be wrestling fans, as it shows everything that€™s wrong with Vince McMahon€™s interpretation of comedy.

4. Chavo Guerrero Vs. Hornswoggle

This storyline was uncomfortable for a different reason. While most of the entries on this list are here because they reflect some kind of touchy subject that can hit too close to home for some viewers, this one€™s here because of just how difficult it was to watch a wrestler as talented as Chavo Guerrero reduced to the worst feud of 2009€and probably one of the worst of the 21st century. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loWNM9H6f7U For reasons that no one fully understands, WWE thought that people skill thought Hornswoggle was an interesting act, and so they had him defeat Chavo constantly throughout the 2009 calendar year on RAW in a variety of ridiculous and over-the-top gimmick matches. These have included, among others: A Cow Tipping Match that featured Chavo in a cow costume (imagine if they did that with El Torito now€); A Sharply Dressed Man Match (i.e. rip off your opponent€™s clothes match); A Blindfold Match where only Chavo was blindfolded; A Falls Count Anywhere Match that involved the €˜paint can€™ sketch from Home Alone; and A Match where Chavo had to wrestle Hornswoggle while on his knees. For people who respected Chavo for his hard work and personal sacrifices, it was downright painful to watch him get humiliated on a regular basis. It was also hard for any fan of the WWE because it was feuds and segments like these that really emphasize the outlandish and stupid sides of wrestling that wrestling fans don€™t want their non-fan friends to see. Chavo would eventually leave WWE and make a name for himself in TNA and Lucha Underground, while Hornswoggle would continue doing embarrassing segments that would lead fans to chant €˜This is Stupid€™. Clearly they remember the discomfort they had in watching Chavo and Hornswoggle put on €˜wrestling matches€™.

3. Exploitation Of Real Life Tragedies

If you were to ask WWE€™s top brass the question €œis nothing sacred?€ they would laugh and answer €˜no€™. Sometimes, WWE likes to use real-life events to further storylines or gain cheap heat. Three particular instances of this stand out more than others. First, WWE exploiting Eddie Guerrero€™s death by having Randy Orton claim that Eddie was €˜down there€in Hell€™ as a means of convincing Rey Mysterio to accept his challenge for his World Title spot at WrestleMania 22. Orton mocked Eddie€™s legacy and accomplishments for weeks, just to get the audience to boo him. It was an unnecessary step that disrespected Eddie€™s family and legacy more than it benefited Randy Orton. He€™s a great heel and didn€™t need to resort to something so cheap and insulting to people who€™ve lost loved ones. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=09Oel4tnpoo The second was WWE exploiting Jerry Lawler€™s on-air heart attack, by having Paul Bearer perform a fake heart attack segment on RAW. This didn€™t really do anything in the grand scheme of things; all it did was provide WWE with one segment geared towards making the audience boo CM Punk. It€™s not like he needed much to do that, but many people, especially those who€™ve witnessed or experienced heart attacks, must€™ve certainly felt uncomfortable when one of the most terrifying, nerve-wracking and sudden illnesses was mocked on live TV. The third one occurred shortly after the second one, when WWE mocked Paul Bearer€™s death. Proving once again that WWE thinks that death is something to be used to further storylines, they had CM Punk dump ashes over the Undertaker, juggle the urn, and alongside Paul Heyman, mock Paul Bearer€™s legacy less than a month after he passed away. While Paul did get inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame, it was uncomfortable to once again watch WWE exploit death for ratings.

2. Muhammad Hassan & The London Bombings

At first, the Mohammad Hasson gimmick wasn€™t that controversial; the character was a wrestler who happened to be Arab-American, wanting to be treated normally and not be subject to prejudice due to America€™s War on Terror and rising Islamophobia in the world. Unfortunately, WWE managed to take something topical that was a legitimate reflection of social issues at the time and screw it up. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sw6naWylTrI During Hassan€™s feud with the Undertaker, Hassan started praying after €˜Taker€™s match with Daivari in SmackDown (in a way that somewhat resembled how Muslims pray), and was attacked by a group of masked men with camouflage pants. They overpowered the Undertaker and even choked him out with piano wire. While that doesn€™t itself sound too bad, it aired in the United Kingdom three days before the London Bombings, which, tragically, killed 52 innocent people and injured an estimated 700 others. The SmackDown match was heavily criticized by mainstream media, and the Hassan character would continue making statements about his Arab ethnicity. Eventually, UPN convinced WWE to remove the Hassan character completely from WWE programming, which led to the character being killed off. Though his career was short and allegedly full of backstage difficulty, for many it was the right decision. Even though it was more of an issue of very bad timing, the masked attack segment during a time of violence and death so close to home, coupled with the general presentation of Arabs in WWE, made for a very uncomfortable situation.

1. Katie Vick

62642145-katie-vick If there was ever a single storyline that exemplified why SmackDown was so much better than RAW during the initial Brand Extension era, it was this one. It remains one of the most disgusting, inappopriate and uncomfortable tales ever told on WWE programming, and did nothing but make everyone involved looks like idiots. For those who still don€™t know what this was about, the storyline was centered on Kane€™s €˜girlfriend€™ Katie Vick, whom he had allegedly killed in a car accident. Then, Triple H, RAW€™s then-World Heavyweight Champion and whom Kane was feuding with at the time, showed a video of €˜Kane€™ (actually HHH wearing Kane€™s mask), having sex with a mannequin, though in story it€™s actually Katie Vick€™s body. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TlpSsklsq2s Yes, WWE did a necrophilia angle on RAW. There are some occasions when WWE wants to use shock value to gain attention and fan interest, but this storyline was just uncomfortable; it had no redeeming qualities to it whatsoever. Fans must€™ve felt grossed out by the concept, especially when Triple H exclaims, €˜I really screwed her brains out€™, and WWE must€™ve lost some fans who thought the segment was just too much, even by the TV-14 standards of the company at the time. No one won from this segment. WWE looked bad, the wrestlers involved looked bad, fans were uncomfortable, and people within the wrestling business shook their heads in collective shame and embarrassment.

Contributor

Alexander Podgorski is a writer for WhatCulture that has been a fan of professional wrestling since he was 8 years old. He loves all kinds of wrestling, from WWE and sports entertainment, to puroresu in Japan. He holds a Bachelor of Arts degree from Queen's University in Political Studies and French, and a Master's Degree in Public Administration. He speaks English, French, Polish, a bit of German, and knows some odd words and phrases in half a dozen other languages.