10 Most Unlikely First WWE World Championship Defenses
A Champion defines oneself on competition, though the first hurdle isn't always what was expected.
The crowning glory for WWE superstars (not named Xavier Woods) is to become WWE World Champion. From the early territory days, to the little thing in bars, to the global spectacle it is today, the end goal for most of those under the employment of WWE is to reign as the top champion; a feat very few actually achieve.
How a World Champion is defined can all stem from that first defense, that first chance to showcase what their era at the top of the mountain will look like. Batista solidified his first World Heavyweight Championship run in a rematch with Triple H, Seth Rollins saw off Randy Orton in his inaugural reign, and Ric Flair toppled Randy Savage, only to run straight into the legendary Genichiro Tenryu two weeks later.
For the following champions though, their first obstacles were slightly against the grain of what was expected. These first challengers were not necessarily the elite calibre expected to set the tone for a title reign, but it was still important to put down these opponents to ensure a reign wouldn't end quickly with a shock loss.
A quick ground rule before getting started. Here, we'll be looking at those championship reigns involving the WWE, Universal, World Heavyweight, and Unified WWE Universal Titles.
10. Roman Reigns Vs. Jey Uso (Universal Championship) - 27/09/20
The Bloodline has been dominating WWE TV for over a year now, with the combined antics of Roman Reigns, Paul Heyman, The Usos, and now Sami Zayn and Solo Sikoa ensuring Reigns' dominance as Universal/Undisputed WWE Universal Champion in a generation-defining two-year reign. However, it wasn't always peachy in The Bloodline...
Back at Payback 2020, Reigns defeated champion Bray Wyatt and Braun Strowman to capture the Universal Title. Five days later on SmackDown, Jey Uso returned from a three-month hiatus (after a long-term injury to his brother Jimmy) to take part in a No. 1 Contender's Fatal-4-Way match which he - incredibly - won. This lined up a match between the two cousins for the upcoming Clash of Champions PLE, the run-up to which featured coy stares between Jey and the Universal Championship belt, as well as formative behaviours from Reigns that would eventually evolve into his 'Tribal Chief' persona.
Roman would see off Jey after Jimmy threw the towel in for him at Clash of Champions, and again in the "I Quit" Hell in a Cell rematch a month later, with Reigns manipulating Jey to say "I quit" by threatening harm on a still-injured Jimmy Uso.
9. Shawn Michaels Vs. Jerry Lawler (WWF Championship) - 08/04/96
Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels wrote a new chapter in their history together with the legendary 60-minute Iron Man match at WrestleMania XII. Assessment of the quality of the match differs between fans, but it will nonetheless remain a cornerstone of WWE's flagship championship, owing to the spectacle of Michaels' entrance, the endurance of both competitors, the sudden-death overtime, the commentary calls of Vince McMahon, and the ensuing stories from the bout's aftermath.
From the glitz and glamour of Michaels' first World Title, came a fall back down to humble royalty.
The night after WrestleMania, the Heartbreak Kid defended his newly-won championship against Jerry "The King" Lawler on an episode of RAW. There were multiple moving parts surrounding the match; Hart was taking some time away, which necessitated a new opponent that came in the form of WCW-bound Diesel, who was on guest commentary for the encounter, alongside McMahon and Mr. Perfect.
The match itself was fairly drab, with Michaels and Diesel trading verbal jibes throughout as Lawler ran out of underhanded tactics fast and inevitably lost. Post-match, Perfect passed Diesel the WWF Championship belt, who proceeded to deck Michaels with it, setting up a title match for that month's In Your House 7: Good Friends, Better Enemies.
8. Chris Benoit Vs. Rhyno (World Heavyweight Championship) - 22/03/04
2004 saw the start of an annual tradition for WWE that would last up until 2011 in the post-WrestleMania draft.
Occurring eight days after WrestleMania XX - which saw the bittersweet main event of Chris Benoit toppling Triple H and Shawn Michaels to become WWE World Heavyweight Champion - the proceeding RAW was a bit of a wasted opportunity. With the chance of some unique match-ups that would've otherwise been a rare sighting in the WWE at that point (the initial draft taking place two years prior), the show was littered with RAW's undercard, such as Rene Dupree vs. Chris Jericho, and Rico vs. Kane.
A more curious inclusion was the first defence of Benoit's World Title, which still wasn't the main event because this is RAW in 2004 and therefore the only main event is a Triple H main event. But still...
The Rabid Wolverine opened his World Championship account against fellow-ECW alumni Rhyno in what would be the Man Beast's sole one-on-one World Title opportunity across his multiple runs with WWE - with Benoit picking up the win with the Crippler Crossface in under five minutes.
7. JBL Vs. Spike Dudley (WWE Championship) - 01/07/04
Alcoholic gun-for-hire/tag team stalwart-turned Wall Street-investing singles star, John "Bradshaw" Layfield broke the hearts of millions in June 2004 when he dethroned Eddie Guerrero of his sole WWE Championship at The Great American Bash in a Texas Bullrope match.
On the following SmackDown!, Bradshaw - in the midst of his championship celebration - boasted that he would be a fighting champion and would hand-pick an opponent for his title that night. After some bickering from the SmackDown! midcard (including Booker T, John Cena, and the Dudley Boyz for some reason), JBL announced that he will fight... lil' Spike Dudley.
To be fair to Spike, he did fight valiantly, refusing the help of his half-brothers and able to get some offense in, and nailing JBL with some corner stomps and a patented Dudley Dog for a two-count. However, it was a forgone conclusion how this match would eventually end, with JBL clobbering Spike with a pair of Clotheslines from Hell (Clothesline from Hells?), before pancaking him with a powerbomb.
This would kick-off JBL's record-breaking WWE Championship reign, with him later making defences against the likes of Guerrero, The Undertaker, Kurt Angle and the incomparable Shannon Moore.
6. Bruno Sammartino Vs. Miguel Torres (WWWF Championship) - 18/05/63
Nothing says "the hipster's entry" quite like 1963 WWWF.
Despite the bulk of his career taking place in the 1960s and '70s, Bruno Sammartino is a name still highly regarded in wrestling circles, largely due to his historic eight-year run with the WWWF Championship, beginning in 1963 after toppling Buddy Rogers at Madison Square Garden. After battling the likes of Rogers, Lou Thesz, Boris Malenko and Gene Kiniski in the months prior, Sammartino had certainly proven himself, and was ready to face any and all challengers, including one Miguel Torres.
Not much exists online about Torres outside of his Cagematch.net profile. After various extended forays in professional wrestling during and post-World War II, Torres largely hit his stride with the sport in 1957, becoming a mainstay with the NWA and the affiliated CWC promotion - the precursor promotion to the modern-day WWE.
However, Miguel wasn't quite what you'd call a "star performer". No records indicate he ever held a championship of any kind (this was his first match for any title in over two years), and by the time of his WWWF Championship shot against Sammartino, he had a record of 2-7-1 in 1963 alone, including a loss to Bruno the month prior.
5. Yokozuna Vs. Crush (WWF Championship) - 12/07/93
If this was a list documenting unexpectedly-*timed* challengers, Yokozuna would likely surpass most/all Money in the Bank cash-ins owing to his now-infamous post-WrestleMania IX main event challenge from Hulk Hogan. However, this is not such a list, and we will instead be focusing on Yoko's second run with the WWF Championship, which he won by destroying Hulkamania at King of the Ring 1993 - leading to Hogan not making another WWF/E appearance for nine years.
Yokozuna celebrated Iron Shiek's wet dream by hosting a Bodyslam Competition on the USS Intrepid aircraft carrier on Independence Day. Because America.
Many stepped up to slam the behemoth to no avail, until former Demolition afterthought Crush stepped up and was actually able to lift the 550-pounder off his feet, before his back gave out and he ultimately failed. Instead, Lex Luger would eventually win the competition because - again - America.
A now-vexed Crush would then challenge Yokozuna for his World Title on the following week's RAW, where he was soundly battered by the champion, who hit multiple Banzai Drops on Crush, leading to him being stretchered out and written off TV to deal with a back injury he legit picked up trying to slam Yoko the previous week.
4. Brock Lesnar Vs. Paul London (WWE Championship) - 09/10/03
There are many strange rules and behaviours in the weird world of professional wrestling, and in October 2003 Paul London committed one of the most heinous acts a wrestler can do: he turned up for work. And introduced himself! The cad.
London rocked up for work at the 9/10/03 edition of SmackDown! for his TV debut, making sure to make himself known to then-WWE Chairman Vince McMahon. Vince - seeing this as a clear act of disrespect - refused the handshake and instead lined London up to go up against Brock Lesnar. It's worth noting that Lesnar was a little unhinged at the time, aligning himself with the boss and finding a new hobby in trying to murder his colleagues, most notably Zach Gowan and Brian Kendrick. Lesnar had also just picked up his third WWE Championship, defeating Kurt Angle a month prior, in the actual greatest Iron Man match of all time.
London gets soundly murderised in the match, with Lesnar squashing him in less than 90 seconds with a series of powerslams, a powerbomb, and an F5 to see the future Tag Team Champion off.
3. The Rock Vs. Shane McMahon (WWF Championship) - 01/05/00 & 03/07/00
The WWF Championship scene in 2000 was the Triple H and The Rock Show as the two traded the richest prize in the biz for two reigns a piece, with Kurt Angle eventually interrupting proceedings with a shenanigans-littered clash at No Mercy in October. In both of The Rock's reigns, he would have to deal the then-heir apparent Shane McMahon, as his status with the McMahon-Helmsley Regime meant that Shane was constantly butting heads with The Great One.
After winning his fourth World Championship at the previous night's Backlash PPV - a match which saw Shane-O-Mac as the special guest referee - The Rock defended his title in a very crooked steel cage match match which saw more guest referees in the form of Pat Patterson and Gerald Brisco. Of all people, it was resident car park t-shirt merchant Earl Hebner who saved The Rock and kept his championship run in tact.
Fast forward two months and The People's Champ has again toppled Triple H in a clunky six-man tag at King of the Ring, and is set to do battle with McMahon once again. This match is far less competitive than their match-up before, with early interference from Chris Benoit stopping the match after less than ten seconds.
2. Hulk Hogan Vs. Yoshiaki Yatsu (WWF Championship) - 01/04/91
At WrestleMania VII, Hulk Hogan - again, in the name of America - captured his third WWF Championship, toppling Iraqi sympathiser Sgt. Slaughter in a feud that was definitely tasteful and absolutely did not age badly.
Hogan only faced two people in title defences between WrestleMania VII and his eventual loss of the belt to The Undertaker at that year's Survivor Series: Sgt. Slaughter and Yoshiaki Yatsu.
Yatsu was a bit of an underlying star in Japan, a former Olympic wrestler-turned-professional who became a prominent fixture in NJPW, first as a singles star - claiming victories over the likes of Yoshiaki Fujiwara, The Iron Sheik, Nobuhiko Takada and Curt Hennig - before linking up with Riki Choshu and friends as part of Ishin Gundan and jumping over to AJPW where Yatsu would become a five-time AJPW World Tag Team Champion.
Yoshiaki would wind up at the short-lived Genichiro Tenryu-led promotion SWS, whom had a working inter-promotional relationship with the WWF. The two companies would exchange talent throughout SWS' two-year stint, including the jam-packed Wrestle Dream In Kobe event in April 1991 where Yatsu battled for the WWF's main prize.
The match would be overshadowed though by the infamous match-turned-shoot-fight between John "Earthquake" Tenta and Koji Kitao.
1. Drew McIntyre Vs. Big Show (WWE Championship) - 26/03/20
It's a surreal experience looking back at the first WrestleMania of the pandemic days. The typical fanfare and spectacle was toned *way* down as the increasingly dangerous COVID-19 virus forced the WWE to host the Grandaddy of the All from the WWE Performance Centre, to a crowd of 0.
Despite the bizarreness of the event, there were a fair share of enjoyable highlights: the triple threat ladder match for the Tag Team Titles, Kevin Owens vs. Seth Rollins, the cinematic matches, the culmination of the Otis/Mandy Rose storyline, and one highlight particularly appreciated by those in Blighty: the crowning of the first-ever British WWE World Champion in Drew McIntyre.
This moment of elation was immediately stunted the next night on RAW, when it was announced that there was a dark match *after* the main event as the Big Show marched to the ring to challenge the new WWE Champion right there and then.
The first WrestleMania dark match since 2011, McIntyre toppled his impromptu challenger but not before a few heart-in-mouth moments where we thought "they're not putting Show over... are they?"