10 Most Unlikely WWE Intercontinental Champions Ever

It's not that they were good or bad, more that they were totally unexpected.

Listen to WWE announcers talk about the belt now, and you'd be forgiven for thinking that the Intercontinental Title still meant a great deal to the company. Such words directly fly in the face of reality - WWE haven't truly presented the Intercontinental Title as meaningful for many years, certainly not for any great length of time. Sure, the strap has arguably gained importance due to the promotion doing away with the World Heavyweight Championship, unifying that belt with the WWE Title, but a lot of that is superficial. It's perhaps merely by default that the Intercontinental Title has been featured more than in previous years, but it's true to say that the ongoing situation with Daniel Bryan has thrust it into the spotlight. In vacating the title, Bryan will ride off into the sunset for the time being. He may have only been able to hold the thing since WrestleMania in March, but at least Bryan was viewed as a worthy champion in the eyes of fans. The same thing simply can't be said for many of the names featured here! There was a time when the Intercontinental Title was deemed WWF/WWE's second biggest title, one ideal to prepare a wrestler for a top line push, but that ideology comes with its own problems, as evidenced here.

10. The Honky Tonk Man

When wrestling fans talk about how the Intercontinental Championship used to be held by the very best in-ring performers the industry had to offer, they often forget that the longest-reigning titleholder in the belt's history was never going to be awarded any five-star awards by Dave Meltzer and the Wrestling Observer. In fact, The Honky Tonk Man never really had many great or memorable matches at all, certainly not for the actual wrestling portion of the bouts. In fairness, that wasn't necessarily what Honky was all about, he was simply an accomplished heel who would always survive by the skin of his teeth, and fans hated him for it. Capturing the Intercontinental Title from Ricky Steamboat in June, 1987, Honky Tonk would hold the belt right up until August, 1988, where he'd be vanquished in quick order by The Ultimate Warrior at Summerslam. When analysing his performance as champ, few can say Honky was anything less than effective, but considering guys like Randy Savage, Steamboat and Pedro Morales had held the belt previously, he was the first unlikely holder of the title.

9. Chyna

Make no mistake about it, Joanie 'Chyna' Laurer isn't featured on this list simply to shoehorn a woman in there, she just wasn't what people would consider a 'classic' Intercontinental Champion. Nonetheless, there was a time when Chyna was one of the most over performers in the entire business, something which was certainly the case when she did capture Intercontinental Championship gold. With that in mind, there's a great chance she wouldn't have held the belt as long as she had were it not for ongoing negotiation problems between Vince McMahon and Jeff Jarrett. With his contract running down and interest from WCW, Jarrett held out for more money from the then-WWF, only agreeing to drop the belt to Chyna at No Mercy in October, 1999 if he got a big wad of cash. McMahon stumped up the money, and Chyna captured the strap. From there, she'd lose it to Chris Jericho at Armageddon in December, before the pair confusingly became 'co-champions', an episode of Jericho's career that it's likely the Canadian would rather forget. Chyna wasn't the best from an in-ring perspective, and the argument from many that she was 'good for a woman' was a little insulting. There have been far better female wrestlers, but none have been given the opportunity to win the Intercontinental Title.

8. Curtis Axel

WWE really tried with Joe Hennig, they really did. In terms of the man himself, he too has given his all, but the fact remains that he's not very over with fans - the guy has had to pretend to be Hulk Hogan in order to get somewhat of a positive reaction, which really says it all. Hennig himself isn't fully to blame however, the creative team need to take some portion of the criticism. Instead of calling the man by a name longtime fans could relate to, Hennig, WWE elected to re-dub him 'Michael McGillicutty' for the first season of the old NXT show, which is absolutely baffling. Who thought this one was getting over? In 2013, McGillicutty was no more, and Hennig was handed the gimmick of 'Curtis Axel', aligned with Paul Heyman and eventually handed the Intercontinental Title. It was a big push, but Hennig the younger isn't the most charismatic man, and being a solid worker isn't enough for a big push. Even having Heyman cut his promos for him, talking him up like he was the second coming of Jesus Christ himself, wasn't sufficient for fans.

7. D'Lo Brown

When D'Lo Brown made his first - unnamed - appearances with the World Wrestling Federation in 1997, nobody could have predicted that he'd go on to become an absolutely essential part of the mid-card scene in less than a year. Wearing a black suit and standing idly by as a henchmen for The Nation Of Domination, the future Intercontinental and four-time European Champion was pretty non-descriptive. Overweight and showing no signs of doing anything other than his on-screen bodyguard duties, Brown became a true success story, shedding the pounds and proving himself to be a guy who could rile the fans easily by doing nothing but shaking his head and pouting for the cameras. In July, 1999, D'Lo was rewarded for the past 2 years by beating Jeff Jarrett for the Intercontinental Title. Brown's run with the belt would be a short-lived 26 days, and he'd lose both the Intercontinental and European Titles back to Jarrett at Summerslam the next month. From there, the man's career started to go into free fall, it was almost like he had been given his time in the sun, but it was now all over. Toiling for the next year or so, Brown dwindled down the card, and it's rather odd that winning the Intercontinental belt did nothing for him.

6. Santino Marella

The Santino Marella who would hold the Intercontinental Title for the second time was remarkably different to the one who captured the belt first time around. WWE were hosting a live episode of Monday Night Raw in Milan, Italy on April 16th, 2007, and in a bid to show his overwhelming power, Vince McMahon tried to make an example of "someone from the audience". Low and behold, Santino was picked at random to face Umaga for the Intercontinental Title, imagine that. Admittedly, the live crowd did go nuts for this, and Marella performed admirably, looking like someone who didn't know whether to laugh or cry at how lucky he was to be standing inside the WWE ring. From there, the story became less believable, as Santino showed himself to be an accomplished grappler once the bell started ringing. Winning the gold, Santino would have another run with the belt the following year. Around this time, the man became the clown prince of WWE programming, and whereas his comedic antics didn't really do much for the Intercontinental Title itself, his overall performances and claims that he was going to top The Honky Tonk Man's reign with the belt were hilarious.

5. Bob Holly

As 'Hardcore' Holly in the year 2000, Bob would find himself sandwiched right in the middle of a power struggle between Chyna and Chris Jericho for control over the Intercontinental Title. Competing against both "friends" in a Triple Threat match at the Royal Rumble Pay-Per-View, Holly would just come up short in his attempts to win the belt. That wasn't the only association the guy would have with the Intercontinental strap, he incredibly won it 5 years before on an episode of the long-forgotten WWF Action Zone program. Holly's extremely brief reign with the Intercontinental Title isn't one WWE consider an official title change, but the fact remains that he was announced as the new champion. Defeating Jeff Jarrett (what is it with that guy?) to bag the strap on the low-level telecast, WWF officials soon ruled that Jarrett's foot had been on the rope when the referee counted his shoulders to the mat, therefore negating the decision. In a hastily-rearranged rematch, Holly lost the now-vacated title, in what has to stand the test of time as one of the most random storylines to have ever taken place on a 'B' or 'C' show.

4. Ezekiel Jackson

Ezekiel Jackson was someone often name-checked as being akin to a modern-day Ahmed Johnson. The physical comparisons were obvious, but it seems a lot of people were actually referring to the fact that - despite the promotion's interest in pushing him - Jackson often looked like a fish out of water, uncomfortable with piecing together more lengthy, interesting bouts. Making his debut as the bodyguard of 'The' Brian Kendrick in 2008, Jackson would eventually go on to join the ill-fated stable led by Wade Barrett, The Corre. Not only did the collective have a terrible name, but they were very much a poor man's Nexus, something which came across to fans tenfold. Nonetheless, Ezekiel Jackson was handed the Intercontinental Title once the short-lived faction was terminated. Defeating his former leader, Barrett, at the one-off Capitol Punishment Pay-Per-View in June, 2011, Jackson only held the title for a scant 2 months before losing out to Cody Rhodes. When fans were busy comparing the man to Ahmed Johnson, they were forgetting that the latter had a connection with fans that Jackson could only dream of.

3. Albert

To younger fans, the name 'Lord Tensai' is synonymous with a short push in 2012, followed by a comedy tag-team alongside Brodus Clay which didn't really get off the ground. It's almost scary to think that Tensai was initially ear-marked for a major feud opposite John Cena, more than a decade after WWE had previously tried to make Matt Bloom into a top line star. Before he'd find significant success in Japan, Bloom filled the role of the character known simply as 'Albert'. An unassuming name to be sure, the same couldn't be said of his previous title, 'Prince Albert', which refers to genital piercings, a sure fire way to create wrestling box office. In all seriousness, Albert was never really over as a singles star, but he did capture the Intercontinental Title. Of all wrestlers, Albert emerged victorious over Kane in June, 2001, but would only hold the Intercontinental strap for just shy of a month, losing it to the incoming Lance Storm in July. It was a short, uninspiring reign for the big man, who would later also play 'A-Train' in subsequent years. Fans chanting 'shave your back' at the man still remains more noteworthy than his unlikely run with the Intercontinental Title.

2. Luke Harper

Let's be honest, when Bray Wyatt led his 'Wyatt Family' onto main roster WWE screens in 2013, many would have had the ring-leading Bray as the first candidate for capturing a title in the promotion. Incredibly, Bray hasn't yet won any championship gold, but it's fair to say that his persona doesn't really require titles to remain over with fans. Backed up by a pair of intimidating, bearded psychopaths, Wyatt was flanked by both Luke Harper and Erick Rowan. At first, Harper and Rowan didn't do much wrestling, but when they finally did it was usually in tag-team competition. Both guys seemed pretty at odds with the usually-slick style of grappling prevalent in WWE, but it worked and tied in with their gimmick very well. Even still, nobody could have predicted that Harper would ever capture a major singles title in the company, at least not as quickly as he did. In November, 2014, the big man shockingly defeated Dolph Ziggler, and even though he would lose the belt back to Ziggler at the TLC supershow in December, it was one Intercontinental Title reign that few could have foreseen coming.

1. Dean Douglas

As Shane Douglas, 'The Franchise' of ECW was a huge star in Paul Heyman's hardcore promotion. Cutting visceral promos and backing his words up with stellar in-ring performances, Douglas was a riot in ECW, but he'd find making the jump up to the WWF in 1995 to be an entirely different ball game. At the time, 'The Kliq' were running wild in the federation, which was now a Hogan-free zone. Rumours were rife that the group, led by the likes of Shawn Michaels and Kevin 'Diesel' Nash, were in firm control of the main event scene and got to choose who was allowed into their little club. If this was the case, Douglas would find that his face didn't really fit. Scheduled to defeat Michaels for the Intercontinental Title at In Your House 4, HBK would never make it to the match, having been beaten up by thugs outside a nightclub just a week or so before. Nonetheless, 'Dean' Douglas, a square teacher who admonished fans for their poor brainpower, was handed the vacant belt, before being dumped in quick fashion by Razor Ramon just minutes later. All in all, the Dean Douglas character would only last a few months in the WWF, before the man would make his way back to the safer pastures of ECW. Many at the time theorised that Michaels could have worked the match, he just didn't want to lose to Douglas. What other unlikely Intercontinental Champions from history can you think of? Do you agree with the choices listed here? Let us know down in the comments section!

In this post: 
Luke Harper
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.