10 New Directions For WWE After Payback 2023

Could one of the most unlikely WWE returns ever actually happen soon?!

WWE Survivor Series 2023 CM Punk
WWE/AEW

Payback was one of those PLEs that breezes past and few remember in-depth by the time Raw airs on Monday night. In many ways, it was more akin to a souped up Saturday Night's Main Event than a must-see supershow, but enough happened to make the card worth watching.

Now, what's next?

You couldn't have failed to notice who's featured in the banner image. Friendly Phil has had his contract torn to shreds by AEW boss Tony Khan, and is now free to do as he pleases going forward. WWE head honchos like Triple H might ultimately decide against it (he doesn't exactly get on with CM Punk), but you just know the conversation will be had backstage at least once.

Prospective unlikely returns isn't all that's lingering in the near future though. Other, more concrete plans include breakout female stars turning babyface, tag-team partners turning on one another heading into WrestleMania, WWE creative pretending they care about the brand extension again, and John Cena getting physical.

In short, here's everything the writers will probably plot over the next month or two. "Look in my eyes, what do you see"...?

10. Trish Stratus Taking Time Off

WWE Payback 2023 Trish Stratus Zoey Stark
WWE.com

Thank you, Trish.

The iconic female star offered Stratusfaction by the bucketload during her renaissance run in WWE. She's been a real breathe of fresh air as a heel, and capped things off with a stunning cage effort vs. Becky Lynch at Payback. Now, post-defeat and split from protege Zoey Stark, Trish can take a breather.

Fingers crossed this isn't the last fans see of her though - the legend is still in tremendous shape, and she proved that by showing off her athleticism tenfold inside the cage. Being honest, this was one of Stratus' best matches ever, and she should be very proud of it.

Will it be her swan song? Perhaps, but it's obvious Trish still has something to offer this roster. Matches against other, younger stars could be make or break for some careers, and they'd be a real treat at tentpole events like Survivor Series, Royal Rumble or WrestleMania.

Don't stay gone for long, Stratus!


9. Zoey Stark Going Babyface?

WWE Payback 2023 Trish Stratus Zoey Stark
WWE.com

Meanwhile, the future is a little more cloudy for one Zoey Stark. She was arguably rescued from main roster hell by aligning with Trish in the first place, so it'll be interesting to see where she goes from here and if she can stamp her mark on the roster.

That, let's be candid about it, remains to be seen.

Stark has all the tools, but she had a cushy gig playing protege to Stratus. Getting those reactions on your lonesome is a different ball game altogether, but WWE had to give Zoey a shot on her own at some point. Who knows? Things could work out well and she'll be in a featured match at 'Mania next year.

There better be a solid game plan though. Creative absolutely cannot go into this blind and think Stark will carry the same weight she did as Trish's number two. She needs meaningful storylines, some actual character development and killer matches to succeed.

Over to you, writing staff.


8. Austin Theory & Grayson Waller = Tag Team

Austin Theory Grayson Waller
WWE

Payback must bring the curtain down on Austin Theory's association with the United States Title. The former champ was comprehensively beaten by current titleholder Rey Mysterio, and he should move away from the midcard strap into another role. This guy's suggestion? A tag-team with Grayson Waller.

That'd be the best outcome for both young heels right now.

Think about the long-term: WWE could get to a Theory babyface turn if he teamed with Waller for 12 months or so and had some doubles success. Catch fire, and they'd become Undisputed Tag Champs in the making. Then, after that fun, Grayson (the more natural heel of the two) would become jealous of Austin and ditch him.

Anyone who pays attention to WWE's socials could tell you how great Theory is with kids. He's a likeable guy at heart, so it sometimes feels like he's forcing this arrogant villain stuff. Triple H's long-term goal for Theory should be breakout baby.


7. Judgment Day On Every Show

WWE Payback 2023 Judgment Day
WWE.com

Fans of Judgment Day rejoice, because you're about to see a whole hell of a lot more of the gang across both major brands (and possibly NXT if WWE sticks with Dominik Mysterio's North American Title run). Damian Priest and Finn Bálor won the Undisputed Tag straps at Payback, which means they can show up wherever they like.

Seeing JD on SmackDown occasionally sounds lovely.

The group is one of the best things about WWE's product these days, and it sucked to think of them splitting during Priest and Bálor's falling out. Rhea Ripley laid down an ultimatum, and the lads came up trumps by delivering on Saturday night. All is well in Judgment land then.

It'll be fun to see where JD hits hardest; they can compete on all fronts. Rhea can run Raw, Dom can work in a feud on NXT, and the Priest/Bálor combo can do great things over on SmackDown. Shifting the tag belts was defo the right call in retrospect (even though this fan predicted a Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn win pre-show!).


6. Sami Zayn Turning On KO

WWE Payback 2023 Kevin Owens Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Or vice versa.

Look, everyone knew either KO or Sami would turn on the other one when Zayn escaped The Bloodline and reunited with his old pal. This pair just don't stick together forever - they're like brothers who keep fighting, and people are completely fine with that because they always have banger grudge matches.

Another one is surely on the horizon following that Undisputed Tag Title loss at Payback. The guess? Kev teases that he's sick and tired of Sami again, which leads folks to believe he's about to hit a Stunner Steve Austin would be proud of. Then, BOOM! It's actually Zayn who does the dirty.

WWE could actually present both as tweeners if they're careful. Both warring on/off friends can have valid arguments for hating one another again, and that could lead to them beating the snot out of one another come 'Mania 40. If no-one can't wait that long, then they're a stick on for a PLE match before the end of 2023.


5. LA Knight Winning Gold

WWE Payback 2023 John Cena LA Knight
WWE.com

One of John Cena's mission statements during this short WWE comeback will be shining a light on fresher faces management wants fans to care about. LA Knight is 100% one of those - the company has shown some faith in him by twinning that win at SummerSlam with another triumph over The Miz on Saturday.

Putting gold around his waist/over his shoulder is the next natural step.

Rey Mysterio is an industry treasure, but he won't be United States Champ for too much longer. It says everything for the popularity of Knight that fans probably wouldn't even boo him for cutting down a legendary babyface hero and taking the strap. That'd be a win-win outcome for everyone.

The United States belt badly needs some of the good vibes showered on Raw's Intercontinental Title. GUNTHER has been a stunning IC Champion, but his move during the WWE Draft left a gaping hole in SmackDown's midcard. LA Knight is surely about to fill it.


4. John Cena Working Matches

WWE Payback 2023 John Cena Judgment Day Damian Priest Finn Balor
WWE.com

If WWE thinks they can get away with padding John Cena's return full of goofy guest host spots or segments in which he bizarrely plays an old-timey backstage interviewer, then they've got another thing coming. People will eventually want to see JC do some wrasslin'.

One of the most special pieces of talent ever is only available for a finite amount of time, so the writers better not spurn this chance. They must get him in the ring for a match at least once, and it'd be great if that came on TV rather than on some souped up house show tour.

Let's make someone during this brief adventure.

Cena likely wouldn't be against putting another young star over like he did with Theory back at 'Mania. If that's at Fastlane, cool, but WWE might be more tempted to pop a big rating for SmackDown by putting John back in one of those big matches everyone always talks about.


3. Jey Uso Striking Out On His Own

WWE Payback 2023 Jey Uso
WWE.com

Jey Uso won't be working any big matches on SmackDown for a while, it seems.

Obviously, that hinges on WWE's dedication to a brand extension they sometimes forget about. Those who pay close attention to the Draft and care about the results are not rewarded after the fact, so it's kinda laughable they had Cody Rhodes make a big deal over Jey coming to Raw.

This is a chance to press the reset button on brand separation, and make Uso's departure from The Bloodline (and blue show's roster as a whole) mean something. For example, seeing Jey match up vs. Cody or even World Heavyweight Champ Seth Rollins would feel fresh.

Over on Fridays, a bitchy Roman Reigns would quiz Paul Heyman over Jey's progress and wonder aloud if there's any way they could pay off Raw stars to take Uso out. That'd keep this in-fighting family story ticking without any need for direct confrontation between Roman and Jey.


2. Seth Rollins’ Back Costing Him

WWE Payback 2023 Seth Rollins
WWE.com

The clock is ticking.

Seth Rollins was a fine choice as first World Heavyweight Champion when WWE introduced the Raw-exclusive title back in April. He'd go on to win the thing at Night Of Champions in May, and has been roundly considered a workhorse champ ever since.

Change is afoot though. The build towards Seth's latest title defence vs. Shinsuke Nakamura was littered with references to the champion's injured back, and both Michael Cole and Corey Graves chatted a lot about that during Payback. No prizes for guessing where this is going!

It's only a matter of time before the injury catches up to Seth and costs him that belt. Then, he can begin a redemption story arc that sees him grit his teeth and fight through the pain despite Becky Lynch and others encouraging him to rest up.

Time to make Mr. Rollins look like the most determined hard nut going. That'd give him a tougher edge.


1. CM Punk At Survivor Series In Chicago?!

CM Punk
AEW

Stranger things have happened, let’s be honest.

Sure, Triple H and several other key figures in WWE probably have no time for CM Punk personally, but this is business. Punk returning to the WWE scene for a major match or two would pull in significant interest, especially with the weight of the corporate machine behind it.

Would this fan bring back Punk? Yes and no. On one hand, his always feels like the comeback that got away. On the other, Punk became a common denominator for trouble behind the scenes in AEW, and Trips won't want that kind of hassle in his locker rooms heading into 2024.

Survivor Series is in Chicago though, so anything could happen. Nobody can sit there and confidently state that this will never happen. Pro wrestling is f*cking wild, so CM Punk becoming a WWE star yet again is not out of the question.

No, really. It isn't.

Where else do you see WWE booking going after Payback 2023? For more like this, check out AEW All Out 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen and AEW All Out 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.