10 Notable Wrestlers WWE Didn't Book For WrestleMania

Not everyone makes it to the big dance ever year.

The fate of performers hoping to get the big WrestleMania payday comes down to the booker's whim. In a number of instances, their hopes are in vain and they don't make it to WrestleMania. The more time that gets allotted to marquee headliners and opportunistic part-timers, the less chance there is for a 'bubble guy' to make it onto the show. You want to try and get every notable wrestler onto WrestleMania as possible, allowing the event to serve as a mostly-completed snapshot in some theoretical WWE yearbook, but it's not always possible. There's always a pre-show match or other alternative means, but there have been iconic wrestlers that didn't even get that. Some notable wrestlers don't even get bailed out by a pre-show battle royal. The list ahead consists of wrestlers that not only didn't perform before the live crowd on WrestleMania night, but didn't even get a peripheral role such as manager, corner-person, or someone that ran interference. No, what lay ahead are snubs, mere spectators to WWE's 'grand spectacle'. In some cases, a few were actually scheduled for matches, only to have the rug pulled out from under them at the last minute. A few of them have gone on to the WWE Hall of Fame. Everyone else on the list has arguable potential to be in the Hall one day. So who got snubbed over the years? You may be surprised.


10. Don Muraco (WrestleMania 1)

For three straight months following the maiden WrestleMania, Muraco worked in WWE Championship bouts against Hulk Hogan at Madison Square Garden, culminating with a steel cage match on June 21, 1985. Yet, Muraco was mysteriously left off a certain Garden card in March of that year, despite being one of the most recognizable heels in the territory. Admittedly, the first WrestleMania wasn't one of those 'get everybody involved in big matches' deals like it is today. As it was, lower-card fodder like The Executioner, SD Jones, and Matt Borne were used to put over stars three tiers above them on the food chain. Had Muraco possessed his 1985 wattage in, say, 2001, and was left off of WrestleMania 17, eyebrows would definitely have been raised.

9. Paul Orndorff (WrestleMania 3)

This one comes with a slight injury disclaimer. By early-1987, "Mr. Wonderful" had concluded a big-money run with Hogan over the WWE Championship, during which Orndorff worked through a serious arm injury. The pain caused Orndorff to take on a considerably smaller schedule into the spring of '87, but he was working non-televised events fairly close to WrestleMania 3. He'd participated in a six-man tag in Omaha nine days before the pay-per-view. It's been reputed that Orndorff was the back-up plan to face Hogan if Andre were to back out of the main event due to injury concerns, or for other reasons. Obviously, that never came to pass, and Orndorff didn't work the big event. I dunno, couldn't he have had two minutes to squash Lanny Poffo or something?

8. Davey Boy Smith (WrestleMania 8)

Five months later, "The British Bulldog" would headline at Wembley Stadium in front of 80,000 countrymen when he captured his first and only WWE Intercontinental title. On April 5, 1992, as McMahon rolled out his best laid plans in front of 60,000-plus in Indianapolis, Smith was nowhere to be found. In actuality, Smith was booked for a one-on-one match with The Berzerker (and was announced on WWE programming), which would most certainly have been a win for Bulldog, given each man's respective place on the roster at the time. Instead, the match was trimmed due to time constraints, and the company's ace European draw (they would tour the region weeks later) ended up omitted. Also, poor Berzerker, who never once got to perform at WrestleMania, in any year.

7. Bam Bam Bigelow (WrestleMania 9)

Following in Bulldog's example, the mighty Bigelow was scheduled to work WrestleMania 9 against "The Ugandan Giant" Kamala, who was well into his phase as a helpless babyface. Given that Bigelow had summarily crushed The Big Boss Man two months earlier at the Royal Rumble, Kamala looked to be the next hurdle for Bammer to flatten on his way up the card. Instead, the match was also scrubbed for reasons related to time. For the next couple of years, Bigelow would enjoy some high-profile moments with the company, the apex being a $250,000 payoff for walking Lawrence Taylor through an enjoyable main event at WrestleMania 11. While Bigelow/Kamala wouldn't have guided WrestleMania 9 out of the cellar it firmly thudded in, Bigelow not making onto the show is still a small crime.

6. Alundra Blayze (WrestleMania 11)

You know what would have spruced up a pretty dang awful WrestleMania? A Womens' Championship bout in which Blayze regains the gold from her intimidating nemesis, Bull Nakano. In fact, the two were given seven minutes on the following night's episode of Raw to act out said match, and Blayze did in fact regain the title after an exciting bout. So why was the match left off of WrestleMania? It's not exactly clear, although Nakano was let go soon following the title switch after she was found in possession of cocaine. While it's possible she may have been denied a WrestleMania payday for her infraction, the timeline of events is a bit murky. Whatever the case, Blayze was denied a WrestleMania match as well.

5. Razor Ramon (WrestleMania 12)

Like Smith and Bigelow, Razor too was scheduled for a WrestleMania match, except his wasn't cancelled the day of the show. Ramon was originally supposed to exact revenge on Goldust, challenging for his Intercontinental title in a street fight. Instead, Rowdy Roddy Piper came out of self-exile to take over the story, humbling Goldust in a Hollywood Backlot Brawl. So why was Razor, who initially appeared on the 'Mania 12 advertising, taken off the card? In February 1996, he gave McMahon notice that he was leaving for WCW in May, so McMahon responded by suspending him for six weeks for a failed drug test. The failure was legitimate; McMahon was likely willing to let it slide if it meant keeping a marquee performer around for WrestleMania. Scott Hall's decision to leave changed his mind.

4. Big Show (WrestleMania 18)

This one's technically a cheat since Show did in fact appear on camera at WrestleMania 18, but he wasn't in the arena. Show's stock in early 2002 had fallen to the point where instead of being in Toronto for WrestleMania, he was 350 miles southeast at WWF New York, entertaining kiddies with a painted smile. All other remaining hands were on deck for the anticipated card, while Show was briefly shown during the telecast playing the role of party host. A mere six days before the marquee event, Show submitted to Kurt Angle's ankle lock in a brief tag team match on Raw. The company faith in Show has ebbed and flowed over the past 17 years, and it's painfully hurt the image of a man that could have been used so much better.

3. Christian (WrestleMania 19)

Shortly before the "Captain Charisma" era kicked off, Christian was Chris Jericho's wisecracking running buddy, helping out Jericho in his high-profile story with Shawn Michaels. Christian remained a vital part of WWE programming at the time, making his omission from WrestleMania a bit puzzling. Within two months of being left off of the card, Christian would win the restored Intercontinental title, and trim off his long locks in favor of the more male-modelish look that he's basically sported ever since. It's hard to imagine the Raw brand in 2003 without Christian's title matches, or his pairing with Jericho, so it's not like he was expendable come March 30 of that year. Just a victim of circumstance, one would assume.

2. Matt Hardy (WrestleMania 20)

WrestleMania 20 featured no less than 50 performers across 12 matches. That total included two Tag Team title matches with eight wrestlers each, a ten-man Cruiserweight gauntlet, and a three-on-two handicap match. Yet, a number of reputable talents were left off of the show entirely, one of which was a man that had been a featured player for much of 2002-03. Hardy brought his popular 'Version 1.0' persona over to Raw in the fall of 2003, where it lacked the smarm-and-charm of his SmackDown run. He floated around the brand aimlessly until taking part in a bizarre feud with Kane in the summer of 2004. While the Cruiserweight title was SmackDown-exclusive, couldn't you have shoehorned Hardy (and The Hurricane for that matter) into the gauntlet for a deserved payday?

1. Cesaro And Kofi Kingston (WrestleMania 29)

WrestleMania 29 was a bit of an odd show, one where no matches really resonated aside from CM Punk vs. The Undertaker. One match was bumped to the pre-show (The Miz vs. Wade Barrett, an Intercontinental title match, no less), and an eight-person tag was pulled from the show altogether. Poor Cesaro and Kingston weren't even able to sniff the card, and Cesaro was United States Champion at the time. Instead, the two engaged in a competitive Raw match eight nights afterward, in which Kingston won the belt. It probably stands to reason that a match pitting the two was considered for WrestleMania at one point, but tossed aside. Well, the world did need that Diddy mini-concert, didn't they?

Contributor
Contributor

Justin has been a wrestling fan since 1989, and has been writing about it since 2009. Since 2014, Justin has been a features writer and interviewer for Fighting Spirit Magazine. Justin also writes for History of Wrestling, and is a contributing author to James Dixon's Titan series.