10 NXT TakeOver: Portland Impulse Reactions
NXT's rich past informs an even brighter future as the biggest TakeOver ever is one of the best.
The pressure was on. Portland came around amidst a host of new challenges and changes based on the landscape-shifting decisions made outside of NXT's auspices.
An involvement in the Survivor Series threatened to undermine the titular top matches on the show, but TakeOver: WarGames was a rampant comeback from the hugely disappointing TakeOver: Toronto. NXT on USA has always been (and will continue to be) a different proposition than the old one hour version on the WWE Network. Some significant shifts in priority had seen Tommaso Ciampa slide down the card in the pecking order right as the brand appeared ready to tee him up for a title shot. Rhea Ripley's maiden defence of her newly-won prize was muddied by the involvement of Charlotte Flair. A Worlds Collide show confused the motivations of the entire roster, a mere fortnight before they had to resume and potentially wrap up the programmes that have mostly been in place since last year.
Portland came around amidst a host of new challenges and changes based on the landscape-shifting decisions made outside of NXT's auspices. The pressure was on...
10. Poppy
In Poppy, Triple H has stumbled upon the perfect cheerleader for his "#NXTLoud" initiative.
For several years, 'The Game' has tried (and occasionally failed) to find a sound that suits the black-and-gold brand more than just relying on the CD sleeve from Kevin Dunn's glove compartment as the main roster has since 2001. He's gone old, he's gone brand new, he's gone dark, he's gone dance and on Sunday he went Poppy, again.
Live music performances rarely mesh well with wrestling shows, but just as she had during a scintillating Full Sail University appearance last October, Poppy found the miniscule bit of space between stimulating and stifling. Knocking out both tunes from the show's soundtrack to the sight of the roster knocking the f*ck out of each other on the TitanTron, the enigmatic star is as connected to every blow as she is detached from the rest of the world.
Just as they were for every match, the raucous Portland crowd were bang into it too. Foreshadowing the rest of a f*cking magnificent evening, this was a virtually flawless presentation.
9. Keith Lee (c) Vs. Dominik Dijakovic
An on-brand banger that should temporarily put their incredible series to bed, the Portland opener between Keith Lee and eternal opponent Dominik Dijakovic was a relentless study in elevation.
The match itself was an elevation from some of their NXT TV scorchers, with both men making unique use of their environment to inform a subtext that their feud had received overdue elevation to the TakeOver stage. A period of the battle fought by the announce tables was an elevation of the violence beyond just using their own mass as a weapon against one another.
Their matches made them both stars in PWG before either came to the black-and-gold brand, but their 2019 scuffles represented a turning point for Lee's perception amongst fans patiently awaiting his elevation. After scoring the victory, he used his freakish strength not to inflict more damage on his war-torn rival but to elevate him. Noosting Dijakovic onto the top rope to soak up his own cheers for what will presumably be their last clash for a while was a sweet way to say farewell. For now.
8. Dakota Kai Vs. Tegan Nox
There's a caveat coming at the conclusion of this entry, but much like the match itself, try not to let the sense of disappointment cloud any enjoyment elsewhere.
Before a finish that echoed one of AEW's worst habits, this was absolutely blistering. Literally so, if one imagines how much it might hurt to have a cricket bat explode in the hand, as happened to Dakota Kai when she attempted to make the boundary of the Moda Center with Tegan Nox' head. Whilst she didn't manage to hit her face for a four, the pair hit one almighty six with the rest of a brawl that didn't allow for breath until a run-in brought it to a rather subdued climax.
It was the first time since Kai's TakeOver: WarGames turn that the feud felt as violent and visceral as it needed to as the pair seemed content to kill each other for some much-needed vindication. The smiles of yesteryear gave way to scowls of believable hatred as the kneebraced former friends went for broke...until relative unknown Raquel Gonzalez ran-in and mopped up Kai's mess.
The match was at least immediately decided by the interference, but your writer was exactly as confused as the live crowd as to the who, what and why of it all. This was a shame and may yet get over eventually, but tempered what had otherwise been an all killer no filler fireworks display.
7. Finn Bálor Vs. Johnny Gargano
The pressure on Finn Bálor and Johnny Gargano was vast.
In a preview piece for this pay-per-view, your writer compared the worst case to a lowkey disaster from SummerSlam 1993 between Mr Perfect and Shawn Michaels. They had the job of just doing what they'd done with virtually every other wrestler, and a confusing lack of chemistry went hand in hand with bad booking to forge one of the year's biggest disappointments. With 'HBK' himself probably all over the presentation, this ended up a world away from such worries.
Bálor and Gargano ended up conducting the crowd in a way that actually enhanced the entire show rather than just their own match. There'd been concern in the build up that something would suffer the silence of the Portland natives as NXT put forth its biggest TakeOver ever, but this proved false. Instead, the fans gave patient attention to the gradual build in the early portions of this blinding battle.
'The Prince' was in scintillating and sinister form, finally re-finding himself as a heel despite the iron-forged relationship with the crowd. Gargano underplayed his own creeping aggravation, as if to foreshadow his callous act on the show later that night.
6. Goodbye Cathy Kelley
Undisputed Era and Triple H bring Cathy Kelley gifts. UE thank her for helping them. pic.twitter.com/Bbf9YVg9wO
— Sean Ross Sapp of Fightful.com (@SeanRossSapp) February 17, 2020
Cathy Kelley was given the best possible send-off as she closed out her final TakeOver segment with The Undisputed Era ahead of their major title matches later in the show.
It was typically brilliant fare - without a belt of his own anymore (and one senses that won't go without mention for much longer...) Roderick Strong played cheerleader for the whole group, teeing up leader Adam Cole to eventually banter her off with a tacitly affectionate "You can leave now".
Kelley has been the group's constant correspondent for their respective durations on the brand, with Cole's cold farewell a far gentler nod as she prepared to leave the company following the event.
A touching tribute on the TakeOver post show featured the quartet and Triple H paying tribute to all her fantastic contributions. The Network distracted audiences with total bullsh*t about the Ruthless Agression era but should have aired this show of genuine appreciation and heartfelt thanks instead. Reality always beats fantasy, just as Kelley was always preferable to about 90% of WWE's broadcast team. She'll be missed.
5. Rhea Ripley (c) Vs. Bianca Belair
Rhea Ripley and Bianca Belair fought wars on two fronts at TakeOver: Portland.
The first was the advertised scuffle for the NXT Championship. 'The EST of NXT' fronted to Ripley with magnificent malice, outmuscling the one woman that proved herself capable of dethroning Shayna Baszler in an unexpected payoff to Belair's rivalry with the 'Queen Of Spades' last year. Commentators made note of it - the Challenger had learned lessons from her harsh treatment 12 months ago and was ready to kick the f*ck out of her opponent as well as anybody that doubted her place in the match.
This angle mattered, and helped the pair of them stave off the major worry of burnout occuring during their gripping clash.
A potential WrestleMania match for Ripley had unfortunately left the result of the match in little doubt before the bell rang, but Belair's confidence (and how f*cking fantastic was that entrance robe, by the way?!) hauled the whole thing into unpredictable territory before the Champion pulled through in an unexpectedly gutsy babyface showing.
Objectives achieved against the odds. It was the story of this story from the beginning, if only to help get to the next chapter...
4. Charlotte Flair Makes It Official
Though WWE could have kept her involvement in the NXT Championship a secret in hindsight, an expected appearance at TakeOver: Portland wasn't damaged by the lack of a surprise factor.
'The Queen' looked like a f*cking world beater and a piece of sh*t in confirming that she'd be taking on Rhea Ripley at WrestleMania, with her appearance on the show received as a invasion by the furious locals. It was rather appropriate that Charlotte Flair used the Natural Selection as a throwback - the violent throw forward left the Champion decimated just as it had when her new Challenger used to preside over the brand six years ago.
It was a piece of p*ss for her to look dominant as both Ripley and Bianca Belair sold exhaustion from their battle, but her assault on 'The EST' gave rise to new hope that the eventual climax will be a triple threat. Belair refused to be marginalised by the pair in the build-up, just as she refused to be viewed as a paper challenger here. If this was her write-out of the tale (and potentially NXT as a whole), it'll feel rather hollow regardless of how well it set the table for Flair and Ripley's eventual showdown.
3. The Undisputed Era (c) Vs. The Broserweights
Immaculately paced, furiously fought and spectacularly cathartic, The Broserweights' Tag Team Championship victory over The Undisputed Era offered the one thing missing from Pete Dunne and Matt Riddle's magnificent tear through NXT's virtually non-existent doubles division - the minute prospect that they might they fail.
Having not even bothered to drop in seeds of doubt or miscommunication in the wonderfully daft build, Dunne and Riddle had three separate moments of miscalculation that could have easily resulted in defeat or the snapping of 'The Bruiserweight' or 'Original Bro' on the other at the expense of their f*cking fantastic relationship.
The feeling of panic with every escalating error was palpable in Portland, with Bobby Fish and Kyle O'Reilly so close to capitalising before the Challengers did the same thing they've done all month - combine and f*cking rule.
Undisputed Era's prophy was cracked before TakeOver but now lay in tatters ahead of Adam Cole's main event, but there was no time to dwell on the desperation of the bad guys while celebrations were in order for the best babyfaces on the brand. Yet again, a league without legs suddenly feels like the most solid on the show. NXT deserves the highest praise for making this so.
2. Adam Cole (c) Vs. Tommaso Ciampa
Overbooking done to perfection, Adam Cole's main event against Tommaso Ciampa was the last chance for the rabid TakeOver: Portland crowd to sit on their hands. Instead they could only cover their faces in horror as a parade of sickening neck spots but Ciampa's life and career back on the line as he desperately sought to reclaim what he'd never lost.
Cole's heel hold work here was top drawer - knowing just when to deploy his boy-popping spots without ever giving the crowd time to properly fall in love with him, the Undisputed Era was expert in a position of control and a total piece of garbage the second things went south for him.
A parade of run-ins was a case of WWE main event overbooking done very very well - Ciampa was suddenly a believable winner thanks to all the various obstacles he seemed destined to overcome. This was a match informed by the past as well as the present, including the fractured dominance of Cole's quartet. He'd cling on to his title in the most shocking of circumstances after an electric closing stretch.
1. Here We GarganGo Again
During the TakeOver: Portland main event, Tommaso Ciampa and Adam Cole had tacitly played off their separate histories with Johnny Gargano within the body of the match before the man himself appeared at ringside.
It felt like a strange choice for a match and programme that hadn't really involved the former Champion, until it wasn't at all.
Mileage appears to be varying based on how much people are ready to watch Gargano and Ciampa fight again, but 'Johnny Wrestling's heel turn allows for a completely different dynamic than the last time, and at long last proffers a payoff to the feud cut short by Ciampa's neck injury one year ago.
The series does not need Gargano walking across the Full Sail bridge and pretending to like the dark, but the omens are good based on how the turn took place. Mirroring two of the most heartbreaking moments from their epic arc, Gargano took the time to look and think about his action - a far cry from how he gifted the title to Ciampa at Aleister Black's expense in 2018. He did so in a DIY t-shirt - the clobber he was mocked with by Andrade and Zelina Vega when the pair took advantage of his frail state of mind just after the original split.
There are countless areas to mine and revisit for one bruising final battle. One hopes the last reward is one of spectacular glory for them both.