10 Precise Moments Wrestlers Should Have Retired

The Last Rides.

Finn Balor Kane
WWE

Retirement is now impossible, apparently, if it was even a thing in wrestling in the first place.

The critical praise heaped on the Boneyard Match at WrestleMania 36 compelled many sadists to project another decade of destruction for the Phenom. He can do tonnes more of these, they said with relish. How much more Undertaker do you people want? He's been in WWE for 30 years. His original set of hips belong in his bloody urn, man. He has other interests, you know.

He wants to save the tigers, and you're trying to book him in more cinematic matches, shooting him from different angles, again and again and again and again! Jimminy Jillickers, can't you let an old cop retire in peace?

He's probably delighted at this development. Wrestlers pure hate retiring. It's a money thing. It's a limelight thing. It's a professional pride thing laced with a tragic pathos: when the body is in decline and the performances suffer as a result, this only strengthens the resolve to atone. But atonement is impossible. It's a depressing cycle of dire matches in which legends fade before your very eyes - often in Saudi Arabia sweating like Triple H on a Thursday afternoon.

Were interventions possible, these are the save points for entire legacies...

10. The Undertaker - WWE Extreme Rules 2019

The Undertaker Drew McIntyre Extreme Rules
WWE.com

The Undertaker is very much trapped in that paradox: he can't go anymore, but wants to go one more time to go out on his sword.

He doesn't want to tarnish the legacy he has already tarnished irrevocably with years' worth of performances that have ranged from plodding to disastrous to career-threatening. He wants "one last ride" to reverse a narrative that is threatening to pour soil on his legend. The thing is, he got it right and went out with pride last year. Or else he would have, had he actually went out, and not felt emboldened to do yet another WrestleMania. "It" of course was his fantastic performance at Extreme Rules.

A wild convergence of factors resulted in his best night in five painful years: a hot crowd thrilled by this rare offseason appearance; an unexplored, fresh, complementary tag dynamic with Roman Reigns; smoke; mirrors; a heel, in Shane McMahon, begging for a hand to be clasped 'round his throat. 'Taker was great in the match, relishing the limited role and the roar of the crowd that willed him into it from the apron.

There's an episode of Seinfeld where Jerry teaches George an old showman's trick to avoid embarrassing himself:e should abruptly end on an unplanned high note.

This is the key to the Last Ride.

He didn't do it after Extreme Rules, so the next time he goes five minutes without embarrassing himself, he should take inspiration from George Costanza and just call an audible.


9. Ric Flair - WWE WrestleMania XXIV

Ric Flair Shawn Michaels Wrestlemania XXIV
WWE

It's incredibly obvious, yes, but Ric Flair probably should have retired immediately after his retirement match.

It was just so perfect. Flair entered the match years and years removed from his physical prime, but the genius of the match and its unparalleled pathos lay in its embrace of that fact. He didn't try to ignore father time but claw desperately at the minute hand in a desperate bid to bring it back - and because he was such a genius, he did. Shawn Michaels was phenomenal in his role, too, bumping like he was 20 years younger because he could still do an impression of his youth.

Flair cheated in a wonderful subversion of traditional pro wrestling storytelling. The fans wanted Flair to play dirty, where for years and years they vocally resented him for it. In the end, of course, they broke your heart. To get that story over, they had to force you through chef's kiss melodrama to remind you that you did care deeply about the man who, realistically, you could have done without seeing rot in the midcard, moving around a bit too weirdly.

He buggered it up in TNA by no-selling both the stipulation and the pathos that got it over - there was no nuance to his work, just the cold mechanisms of stocking dad rock CDs in December - but nobody much cares.


8. Hulk Hogan - WWE SummerSlam 2006

Randy Orton Hulk Hogan
WWE

Hulk Hogan couldn't work a Firefly Fun House match.

Bray Wyatt could try to lead him into the recesses of his mind and confront the Hulkster with his shadow self, but it wouldn't work. The issue here is that Hogan's mental walls are a fortress of bullsh*t all the way to the taps, brother. He is incapable of self-reflection, which wouldn't make for riveting drama. Perhaps Wyatt could attempt to unlock Hogan's mind in the form of a quiz show with a 'Hangman' portion. Bray is looking for a word to follow 'Jiggly jiggly' to allow Hogan to face the ugliness of his racist past, but his mind wanders to his daughter's a*se cheeks.

"What was the question again, brother?"

So it's probably best that Hogan work his last outing in a traditional match - not on a TNA UK house show tour but the stage built on his blood, sweat and juice: WWE. His entire TNA stint was mutually destructive. He should have done the honours for Randy Orton at SummerSlam 2006, even if it meant Orton repeating this fact for the rest of eternity, as WWE promos tend to go. An asterisk always seemed to haunt Orton as the man WWE tried to present him as.

This would have scrubbed it from the record.


7. Bret Hart - WCW Monday Nitro, October 4, 1999

Bret Hart Chris Benoit Owen
WWE Network

Bret Hart has had literally two bad opinions: he thought Edge Vs. Randy Orton from WrestleMania 36 was a good match, and thought it was a good idea to work a match with Vince McMahon in 2010.

This wasn't some delusion, rooted in a deep pathos, that he could still go. He literally couldn't, nor was he legally permitted to bump, rendering the whole overbooked and genuinely harrowing business a genuine ordeal for his most ardent fans. Bret Hart was an artist. It was perhaps a restorative and necessary experience for him personally, irrespective of how it (fractionally) marred his professional career. He needed to close the loop.

But - and I write this with the greatest will in the world, and the most profound respect for a man etched into my personal Mount Rushmore - he hasn't really stopped banging on about Montreal, so...was there much point?

Bret Hart wasn't right for WCW and WCW wasn't right for Bret Hart, except on one remarkably sensitive, artful, moving night: October 4, 1999, Monday Nitro, the site of his powerful - in action and tone - technical wrestling tribute to brother Owen with Chris Benoit.

That was the last pinnacle in a career full of them - literally, in an alternate, exponentially less cruel universe.


6. Shawn Michaels - WWE WrestleMania XXVI

shawn michaels the undertaker
WWE.com

Shawn Michaels, the cheeky bastard, was very keen on making the distinction of his comeback clear. The very first person to say "Don't call it a comeback!" in earnest, he wanted you to not expect a classic. He wasn't performing any new material, you see. He was just playing the greatest hits. That's bullsh*t.

Whoever played their greatest hit with Kane?

Crown Jewel 2018 was an hilarious disaster in which Kane lost his wig and had about as much luck covering for it as the Saudi Arabian kingdom. Triple H tore his pectoral muscle. The Undertaker was so gassed that he nearly lost a dying breath versus hair match when - brilliantly - he couldn't get it out of his eyes. Just use your hands mate.

Michaels meanwhile entered a relatively respectable performance, but the disasters endured by his fellow professionals still couldn't shine his own stint. This was Michaels brazenly lowering himself for more small animal-exploding machine gun money, and he knew it.

He should have left the memories of WrestleMania XXVI - in which he was the defiant, cocky, seminal Showstopper to the end - alone.


5. CM Punk - WWE Royal Rumble 2014

CM Punk Royal Rumble 2014
WWE

CM Punk should have retired as he did at the 2014 Royal Rumble because it was the most iconoclastic, punk rock way to go. People understandably want one last Punk run.

They see dream matches with the generation he inspired, they see a creative regime in dire need of more of that ether, they see that WrestleMania main event - against or at the expense of Triple H, as long as it involves the Game crawling on his hands and knees to hear Punk scratch his balls through a walkie-talkie.

They see unfinished business, but the grand return, the new tron, the kissing and making up with a company that post-Saudi has never felt more pejoratively corporate: that isn't punk rock, and as the man has already half-proven with his Backstage stint, it's not anywhere near the same without the intoxicating anti-establishment vibe.

Punk abruptly removed the lead from the guitar and told the promoter to go f*ck himself, leaving the crowd confused under squalling feedback.

That's the way to go: with a carefree El Torito comedy spot, not a super-serious 25 minute Triple H methodical slog.

Not by re-signing to a major.


4. Mick Foley - WWE WrestleMania 22

Edge Mick Foley
WWE.com

Mick Foley did a dreaded TNA run and it was both damn shame and merciless self-own.

A genuine legend treated like a low-level staffer who had caught Vince McMahon minutes before he ate his din-dins, Foley left his commentary role under the defiant, understandable - but wrong - notion that he still had something to leave behind in the ring. And then he left the ring during a World Title match to treat himself to a quote "restaroonie" in what was a very pointed metaphor for a very, very postmodern run that eroded both his in-ring legacy and his legacy as the man behind the performer.

Foley was always so switched on. He always communicated, to the fandom he was always dialled into, that he wasn't going to embarrass himself in the ring. He was anti-establishment in mentality - he walked out after Montreal, he excoriated WCW in ECW - but in TNA became the establishment, wallowing in entitlement.

He should have hung 'em up - his wrecked body told him to no less than six years earlier - after doing the job to Edge at WrestleMania 22. It would have allowed his ingenious legacy to best register; there were none better at making stars.

Even bookers, half the time.


3. Kane - WWE Royal Rumble 2018

Kane Finn Balor
WWE.com

Christ, remember when Finn Bálor worked a total banger with AJ Styles at TLC 2017, a match so good and serendipitous it was felt that fate had intervened to reverse the rotten luck Bálor had endured since SummerSlam 2016?

And then a clearly ancient Kane, in piss-poor shape, attacked him on RAW the next night? And it deprived fans of what they liked about Bálor? And then Kane won the feud to set him up as a challenger for Brock Lesnar's WWE Title?

Jesus Christ.

Kane was at least an inessential character in the years prior to that, and a mildly amusing one, as part of the Authority. That sort of sucked sh*t, too, because Seth Rollins when he was really, really good had to deal with him for too long, but at least we weren't meant to receive him as the monster of old.

Kane was completely past it. Known as a "night off" for years, working that slow and regimented WWE style with metronomic muscle memory precision, this dynamic was woefully uninspiring, boring, destructive, and should have only been arrived at on the condition of his retirement. He's a mayor anyway! He's fine.

r/SquaredCircle reckons auras can be transferred by simply having a younger supernatural dude beat an older one, so let's go with that, at the 2018 Royal Rumble.


2. The Big Show - WWE RAW, September 4 2017

Big Show Braun Strowman
WWE.com

The Big Show worked a more than half-decent secret WrestleMania 36 match against Drew McIntyre, and prior to that was only of any real use, in recent years, when he put Braun Strowman over big in a super-fun Steel Cage match in 2017 in what was inferred as an informal passing of the big f*cker torch.

But WWE didn't make that explicit. A torch is one thing; a scalp is something else entirely. For once, they could have been less subtle about things.

This wasn't built as a last stand, there was no ceremony to it, and it was rather undermined when Show came back inexplicably, as he is wont to do, in 2018, the abiding - and more potent - memory of which is urine. When recalling Big Show's sporadic twilight years, people are far more likely to remember that time he made Drake Maverick piss himself, as opposed to the time he "made" Braun Strowman. This was no Cactus Jack makes Triple H/Randy Orton deal, either. Is Show capable of that at his advanced age, with his virtually meaningless blur of a legacy (odd bangers and banter notwithstanding)?

Whenever he goes out - and he deserves the pomp and circumstance after such a loyal tenure - he absolutely must turn mid-match in an affectionate nod to his abiding legacy.


1. Triple H - WWE WrestleMania XXX

Triple H Daniel Bryan WrestleMania XXX
WWE.com

In one sense, Triple H did virtually nothing of worth after his superbly crafted and very selfless loss to Daniel Bryan at WrestleMania XXX. He worked and lost an awesome Daniel Bryan match, not a methodical Triple H match, and the result was a euphoric, snarled F*ck-you to the "B+ player" sh*te he actually believed, else why was Bryan originally meant to work Sheamus in New Orleans?

He did less than nothing for Sting in an arrogance-fuelled disappointment. The Roman Reigns match was boring and didn't arrest any narratives. The Seth Rollins match was objectively good, but nobody cared a great deal about it, really. Rollins was no less or more over in its wake, which was a huge indictment of a programme WWE invested so much in. His win over Batista at WrestleMania 35 played out to crickets. All Triple H did at WrestleMania for years was make it longer and more exhausting than it needed to be.

But that Ronda Rousey match was so damn great.

Triple H retires at XXX - imagine if he'd put his career on the line, thus making what was an excellent formality the biggest WWE match ever - and comes out of retirement to help his missus out.

Nobody ever really retires anyway.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!