10 Precise Moments Wrestling Fans Rejected Internet Darlings

Wheeler YUTA and HOOK beware - buzz doesn't necessarily equal being over forever...

Bray Wyatt Spooky Lil Kid
WWE.com

Like everything else, pro wrestling fandom is susceptible to fashion and recency bias.

In fact, wrestling is probably more affected by this because it never bloody stops, and because it never stops, there's always something to herald as the TV match of the year or the best promo you've heard MJF cut. The worked shoot was considered a career high, but was it really better than his manipulative supervillain origin story?

Or did it just happen more recently?

This also swings in the other direction; because wrestling never stops, it's rather easy to get bored by even exceptional things. Remember when the Blackpool Combat Club, a total blood-soaked triumph of a star vehicle, worked one too many trios matches and it all threatened to get a bit meh?

Are fans fickle? Or does the lack of an offseason accelerate the expiration date of wrestling itself?

It's an interesting notion. How does ardent support - so fierce that these fans dedicate so much of their time endorsing their favourites online in the hope that management will somehow listen - wither away and just die? Does this process happen over time, so much so that you barely notice it until it happens?

Sometimes - but there are defining moments...

10. Johnny Gargano - WWE NXT, November 7, 2018

Johnny Gargano
WWE

"You either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villain."

This is

A) What actually happened to Johnny Gargano midway through his programme with Tommaso Ciampa from 2016-2020

and

B) The plagiarised purpose behind his heel turn; NXT attempted to turn an excellent grudge feud into a sprawling saga of comic book movie scope, and the results were risible.

The ambition was beyond pretentious.

Wrestling fans simply wanted to watch the babyface wrestler triumph over the heel wrestler in a storyline that justified its length. It all went to sh*t by the end with the masturbatory parody of an "epic" match that was 'One Final Beat' in April 2020. It was an unintentionally hilarious story of two former friends agonising for an hour about what they had become, but what they'd really become were poor actors. By then, it was already over for Gargano.

It was effectively over on the November 7, 2018 NXT, when Gargano cut an excruciating tweener promo under the delusion that he was the Winter Soldier when in fact he was Tobey Maguire in Spider-Man 3. The story was so removed from what it was that Adam Cole evolved into the fan favourite role. Gargano's incredible performance at TakeOver: New York was a blip; he was never the top babyface ever again.

To his credit, Gargano sensed this, too, and reinvented himself as a comedic goober - only deliberately, this time - as the leader of the Way faction towards the end of his WWE run.


9. Edge - WWE WrestleMania 36

Edge Randy Orton sleeper
WWE.com

Edge's return was a universally popular moment beloved by everybody who saw it. Which was nobody, because Kevin Dunn missed the spot, but you get the idea.

His warm interaction with Randy Orton mutated on Raw into one of the better WWE angles of its modern history. There was an emotion, gravitas and craft to the betrayal angle rarely felt in this frivolous landscape. WWE struck a rare emotion, and then intensified it to risible parody at the bleak, empty WrestleMania 36. The intensity in the match was laughable.

Heavy grunting, scowling faces, harsh bumps clanging against metallic objects: it was more an experimental industrial noise record than a violent pro wrestling match. Usually, a "war" describes a match that is very extreme. Here, it described the length, which was approximately five days. Edge once buried Billy Gunn for not being entertaining, which in hindsight was a bit bloody rich. Edge's return went from joyous to joyless in about three months.

Of course, Edge was received at WrestleMania 37 as one of the biggest and most popular stars in the industry - the pop he generated was deafening, and his performance in the Triple Threat main event was terrific - but there's a vast difference between the hardcore fan and the WWE lifer.

The WWE lifer reacts favourably to Edge, at least when he's playing babyface, and the hardcore fan buries him for cutting promos with a laughable pseudo-intellectual bent.


8. Seth Rollins - WWE Raw, February 27, 2017

Seth Rollins Corey Graves
WWE

Seth Rollins is two, clashing types of wrestler sharing the same skin.

At his best, he's a superb and arguably underrated in-ring performer. He's not the coolest wrestler, and he's WWE through and through, so he'll never be truly revered in snob circles.

He's also a highly driven or frankly smug fellow, which has often prevented him from connecting with crowds in the tippy-top role. He's not a Jon Moxley or Steve Austin type. He isn't impossible not to root for.

So he's neither a true babyface nor a true heel, and to support that point, he's currently playing a heel that fans seem rather keen on getting behind but has previously been rejected - twice - when playing babyface. At the second attempt, in 2019, Rollins was rejected by fans because he was never the guy to begin with, and his meltdowns on Twitter when cosplaying as the guy were cringe-worthy. Standing Up For WWE Rollins wasn't anywhere near as good as Blonde Streak Rollins

The first was so telling that he probably shouldn't have been entrusted to play the top babyface a second time; on the February 27, 2017 Raw, Rollins poured his heart out about his comeback from injury but was pelted with chants of "CM Punk!"

This underscored his demotion from internet darling status; he evolved from great workrate heel to babyface poser.


7. Dolph Ziggler - WWE Royal Rumble 2018

Dolph Ziggler Royal Rumble
WWE

In truth, Dolph Ziggler entered his unfashionable era at some point in 2017.

There's no shame whatsoever in being a fantastic upper midcard worker, but because true main event talent was so lacking at Ziggler's peak, a headline run was projected onto him. Was it always beyond him?

He was never a great promo, didn't exude true intangible superstar charisma, and his working style while superb was too selfless to the quality of a match. When Vince McMahon looks for qualities in a headliner, bumping isn't one of them. That's what he looks for when he's after somebody who makes his headliners look good.

By Backlash '17, he had become the guy who works with the fashionable guy, as opposed to the guy who hardcore fans thought should be beating John Cena. The contrast with Shinsuke Nakamura underscored his new role, but this wasn't too far removed from his minor modern masterpiece of a series opposite the Miz in the autumn of 2016. If there was time for Ziggler yet, WWE squandered it throughout the year by positioning him in the star-maker role.

By the 2018 Royal Rumble, his irreversible stigma was complete when fans were totally disinterested by his return from a worked shoot storyline in which he vacated the title.

The number #30 slot is as good an indication of who's over as any, and Ziggler was not over.


6. Shinsuke Nakamura - WWE WrestleMania 34

shinsuke nakamura aj styles
WWE.com

And everything will proceed cyclically.

In 2017, Dolph Ziggler became the de facto 'WWE guy' when the more fashionable Shinsuke Nakamura defeated him at Backlash in a shockingly average encounter. It was felt that maybe Ziggler had become jaded, or that this was Nakamura being told to slow it down and make the crowd wait for it as an early main roster "test".

Still, fans persisted. It wasn't the first time WWE, a wrestling promotion, had conspired to make a world class talent look mid. The failure of the subsequent programme with Jinder Mahal was naturally blamed on Jinder, who couldn't be elevated, and fans were thus still behind Nakamura as he capped off an electrifying final four to win the 2018 Royal Rumble.

This was it; took a year longer than it should have, but really, given Roman Reigns' career arc, Nakamura was rocket-strapped by modern WWE standards. Positioned in a can't-fail spot, opposite known, incredible opponent AJ Styles in front of 60,000+ fans, Nakamura failed.

The match was a dull, lethargic sequel to their blistering NJPW Wrestle Kingdom encounter, and the penny dropped: Nakamura hadn't been "main rostered", but was all too happy working the WWE style.


5. Bray Wyatt - WWE Extreme Rules 2014

Bray Wyatt Spooky Lil Kid
WWE.com

As someone who attended WrestleMania XXX in person, Bray Wyatt used to be over. Countless fans turned up in Hawaiian shirts and straw hats in support of him.

Over as in "over," not "any supernatural gimmick is automatically over to the subset of fans who are into that sort of thing". He was actually over, not "over to goths", which is one of the stranger fandom phenomenons. They'll likely bloody owt if there's a ghostly voice, cryptic symbol and images of dolls in a cut-heavy vignette. "Are we witnessing the birth of the next Undertaker?!" they say at the merest hint of a creepy music box tune.

Bray's debut hardly went well. He was pelted with chants of "Husky Harris!" on his main roster bow, and the SummerSlam '13 match with Kane positioned him as the next Firebreaker Chip more than the next Undertaker - but an incredible series with the Shield raised his stock. The quality of his programme with John Cena wasn't as important as the fact that he won it, but he didn't, and the quality was in fact so dismal that fingers were as burnt to a crisp as the Fiend was at TLC 2021.

The interference of a spooky child was such hack horror sh*t that many fans watched later, more promising developments - like the early stages of the first Randy Orton feud - with extreme caution.


4. Ricochet - WWE Raw, January 20, 2020

Ricochet WWE
WWE

Ricochet's act was practically engineered to get over in front of a specific audience.

Incredible aerials, kick pads, that bit in the match where does a pose so you know when to applaud. That's a snarky, reductive look at his genuine in-ring excellence, but it simply means that even on autopilot he could generate noise - which is just as well, since he works for WWE.

NXT wasn't so much developmental but an exercise in deluded procrastination for the world-class workrate guys of the late 2010s. They knew they were f*cked one day, if they had a brain in their head. What was Vince McMahon going to do: watch a shooting star press and experience an existential crisis under the belief that everything he thought he knew about wrestling promotion was wrong?

No.

He was going to watch that shooting star press and say "Slow down, it is too exhilarating".

Ricochet is a decent promo rendered abysmal by WWE's scripting, more so than normal, and his career all but died - until he leaves, anyway - on the January 20, 2020 Raw. He interrupted Brock Lesnar and claimed he wasn't afraid of him. Then, in a terribly unconvincing line poorly delivered, he asked Lesnar if he was scared. Lesnar kicked him in the balls, and Ricochet could not have looked like more of a f*cking geek.

Actually, that isn't true - he lost to Brock in 90 seconds at Super Show-Down - but by that point, fans had lost such faith in Ricochet that nobody expected the annual David Vs. Goliath "Brock can actually go" match.


3. Cody Rhodes - AEW Revolution 2021

Cody Rhodes
AEW

The stigma of a rejected internet darling isn't irreversible. This doesn't mean pro wrestling fans are fickle; rather, it means that the wrestler has reinvented their character, or turned heel or babyface.

Or, in the case of Cody Rhodes, jumped from one promotion to another.

Upon returning to WWE, he got over huge as a babyface that might have done as much as his AEW run to solidify his legendary status. He became a top star in a promotion that can rarely build them without indulging the devices he apparently relied on. He didn't bleed nor set himself on fire; in working a superb trilogy with Seth Rollins, he proved that he's as good at timeless pro wrestling as anyone.

In AEW, he was doomed.

With his charitable initiatives in mind, he was insistent that he didn't want to turn heel in an ambitious, unprecedented bid to endure the heat and retain the credibility of his character. It didn't work; every committed bump was interpreted by fans as an ego-fuelled overcorrection. This was first felt at Revolution 2020, not '21, and the narrative persisted online throughout his tweener-adjacent TNT Title run. He really annoyed people by barely selling Penta El Zero M's arm-breaker spot on the March 11, 2021 Dynamite, and the distanced crowd at Revolution let him have it in response. He didn't win the Face of the Revolution ladder match, but his gutsy return spot underscored his perception amongst the fans who really didn't want to him to return.

Cody is a fantastic pro wrestler with stunning range, but the thought of the besuited, articulate executive playing Terry Funk was too much for the audience to accept.


2. Shawn Michaels - August 10, 2019

adam cole johnny gargano
WWE.com

The Bret Hart Vs. Shawn Michaels rivalry will never die, even if Bret himself seems to prefer burying Goldberg and Triple H these days.

The tribute spots folded into various CM Punk and FTR matches have brought into further focus a rejection, amongst hardcore fans, of Shawn's more excessive impulses. Shawn was almost universally beloved when he was active, even amongst those who didn't quite receive him as a great guy. His hair-tugging, I'm-sorry-I-love-you melodrama added an emotional layer to his work elevated by his immaculate veteran selling, but this worked only on earned occasions.

Retiring a hero and mounting the ultimate challenge of breaking the Undertaker's WrestleMania streak justified his histrionic performance style, but it grew rather grating when he projected it onto his NXT "kids" - or tenured world-class wrestlers, more accurately - when he took on a producer role.

NXT fell out of fashion in 2019, not helped by the cooler, less scripted upstart AEW, and Shawn was a not inconsiderable part of its decline.

NXT developed an indulgent, corny quality and Shawn's influence was felt in the big match parody that was Adam Cole Vs. Johnny Gargano III at TakeOver: Toronto (2019), which was just the interminable Badd Blood 2004 match with Triple H, with added thigh slaps and a sad element of forced cosplay.


1. Zack Ryder - February 13, 2012

Kane Zack Ryder
WWE.com

"So you want Zack Ryder to get a push, huh...?"

Stephanie McMahon was once roundly criticised for the hilarious idea that WWE was "no different to" the works of William Shakespeare, and while the playwright was rather fond of exposition, that's not what she meant. However, Dante himself would have marvelled at the ironic hell punishment that WWE served Zack Ryder for...

...getting over to a level that might have made WWE money.

Ryder tried to pave his own way to stardom via the 'Z! True Long Island Story' web series, in which he played an endearing, self-deprecating character very well, but because it wasn't in the plans, he was almost resented for it. And while the gimmick was deeply midcard, the endeavour should have been rewarded. It wasn't. He received a push, all right, but that push - after a token United States title win over Zack Ryder that was, if anything, a cruel taste of the good life - was literal. He was put in a wheelchair and pushed off the stage by Kane when playing a multifariously injured incel.

This was such a clear and explicit "Don't support this geek lol you a**holes" message that even the "Let it play out!" crowd gave up on Ryder that instant.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!