10 Problems EVERY Wrestling Company Has In Common

Have your friends heard of your favourite wrestler?

Chad Gable Scorpio Sky
WWE/AEW

Wrestling fandom is basically AEW Vs. WWE now, and it sucks.

Your writer is drawn into it far too often, and so consider this an attempt to move away from the comparisons that, to be fair, AEW and WWE invite by taking digs at - and going to head-to-head war with - the competition.

Your company excuses sexual predators.

Well, your company excuses sexual predators, too!

Your company gave Matt Hardy head trauma!

Yeah, well, your company was thick as sh*t enough to make Dexter Lumis Ricochet, and they nearly shattered the poor prick's ankle!

Your company just pushes ex-WWE guys!

Your company is PWG with no soul and a big budget!

Your company won't book women's wrestling!

Your company can't book!

And on and on and on it goes, an endless dance that intensifies whenever there's a third dive in two matches on one show, or a show on the other show. There is no tribalism here - there's just a good and a bad company - but neither are perfect.

Outright promoting or failing to condemn predators is also a massive, overwhelmingly putrid issue, but libel laws exist, and that issue is not being conflated here.

10. The Entrance Music Pop

Ricky Starks Darby Allin Brian Cage
AEW

AEW has all but abandoned a very cool early feature of Dynamite.

Those early Elite Vs. Inner Circle brawls were so magnetic because they cast such an immersive spell; everything was so elegantly arranged to account for what the players involved had done earlier in the night, and indeed their headspace in general; MJF very gently teased turning on Cody, Hangman Page, distancing himself from the Elite, stayed on the margins.

Those melees didn't stop when the TV cameras did, and the players emerged to no entrance music because there wasn't a crowd to pop. There was a war to wage.

Regrettably, this is no longer the case. AEW is too similar to WWE in the way these angles are now framed.

This doesn't happen all the time, but it happens too often. It's a very dated '90s thing, the entrance music pop, and it worked back then because why, amid fierce competition, would you squander a single shattering of that iconic glass?

All this weird residual echo accomplishes now - especially with no crowds of significant number - is the reveal of the artifice behind the TV production, thus stretching all-important suspension of disbelief.

Jon Moxley isn't even anywhere near the sound guy, not that it's any better to imagine the wrestlers cueing them up backstage.


9. Commentary

Jim Ross WCW
WWE

There is not one faultless North American commentary unit, though ROH's team are pretty damn good.

IMPACT Wrestling's Josh Matthews is neither credible nor likeable. WWE's very specifically weird commentary, offset for now and in part by the excellent Samoa Joe, is even odder now than it ever was. The pronouns, nicknames and "I was talking to X earlier today..." remain as off-putting as the definitive lack of soul and credibility, but Michael Cole, Vic Joseph and Tom Phillips all never, ever stop shouting. There's no human rhythm to anything they say, and this screeching approach only serves to undermine the moments that do actually warrant an impassioned call.

AEW is better, but not great. Excalibur is tremendous as the knowledgable, heartfelt spot-caller, but it's an indictment that the endearing as all hell Tony Schiavone works to soften Jim Ross. The camaraderie is all very nice, and Ross remains brilliant when calling the action he very clearly still likes, but his misogyny is appalling, his whining deeply counterproductive, and his non-sequiturs distracting. There's a real warmth and personality to the booth, but there are so many segments on Dynamite that the team fail to adequately get over because JR's heart isn't in it.

New Japan is exempt - they have crafted the very best team in years - but, post-lockdown, we don't hear them anywhere near enough.


8. The Inability To Improvise

Miro Sonny Kiss
AEW

In recent months, across both major North American promotions, various matches have totally fallen apart.

Miro's in-ring AEW debut was a catastrophe; very ambitious in its layout, to over-compensate for the idea that Miro and Kip Sabian don't share an organic connection, it packed in too much. After a spot to the outside went awry, deep into the match and in close proximity to the typical modern action-packed finish, the thing went off the rails. Badly. It went off the rails because all four men were flustered and thus unable to remember the next sequence, much less lose themselves and the audience in it.

Over on WWE RAW, a recent injury suffered by Angel Garza caused a match to suffer a similar fate; trained to do whatever comes next, rather than what makes sense, none of the professionals involved could come up with a way out between them; the referee counted a two as a three, without having the wherewithal to do it quickly but not too quickly, and Dawkins, the "winner," didn't have the instincts to sell his happiness at the win.

This is because, for years, most every match has been meticulously laid out in advance. The old working skill has been lost to time - very few know any other way - and while it can guarantee of brilliance, it can't safeguard against disaster. This is an institutional problem in North American pro wrestling.

AEW has done so much to restore its old spirit; perhaps, when crowds return to once more dictate the flow, this is the next challenge the ambitious promotion can set itself.


7. Real, Honest To Goodness Heat

MJF AEW
AEW

The very psyche of the general public means that the real, authentic heat of pro wrestling no longer exists.

We can play along - and a performer like MJF was almost reviled ahead of Revolution, as was KENTA at the apex of last year's incredible NJPW G1 Climax Finals angle - but the collective disposition makes it virtually impossible. Indeed, there's a certain paradoxical core issue at play: even when an angle generates something approaching the old sensation of bloodthirsty vengeance, we, long past the looking glass, know it to be of exceptional craft. Everything we should earnestly hate commands a respect because engineering that hatred is so impossible as to be deeply impressive.

Nothing's shocking - we're too numb to real horrors to entertain the idea that fiction is anything less than what it is - and this extends well beyond our cultural corner. Cardi B's 'WAP' generated mild outrage, in its very graphic embrace of sexual freedom, but the controversy was quaint compared to the boogeymen that were Eminem and Marilyn Manson at the turn of the century.

Wrestling has struggled, and will continue to struggle irrespective of how good it is, because that which ultimately drives it has lost an all-important, unrecoverable feeling.


6. Women's Wrestling

Lana WWE
WWE

This week, Lana challenged for Asuka's RAW Women's Title.

Some proclaimed this was a rebuttal to various takes that WWE had buried Lana for the dig husband Miro cracked on his AEW debut, but it only really proves that WWE doesn't know how to book: how do you go from being hapless table fodder to title contender?

WWE has the best and most committed women's wrestling in the U.S., but the best-booked?

That's relative; even a programme as strong and as detailed as Sasha Banks Vs. Bayley has fallen victim to WWE's usual bullsh*t non-finish chicanery and the dire, carny impulse to banter off a match as an empty promise. The storytelling in NXT is functional - sometimes cringe-worthy, depending on which hapless performer is handed abysmal material that week - and it actively undermines the many superb in-ring talents the brand boasts.

Still, it's committed, which can't be said of AEW, which seems trapped in an endless paradox in 2020. Decimated by lockdown, the talent, broadly, is super-green - but they aren't going to get any less greener trapped in just the one penultimate segment. The booking isn't terrible, but it's dry compared to the details-rich long-term heft displayed across virtually every other Dynamite quarter hour. IMPACT is good if not electric nor deep. ROH has never once excelled where AEW, cruelly, sometimes does.

New Japan simply doesn't bother, and you need only look at the complexion of a modern joshi crowd - contrasted with that of the masses of young girls who idolised their heroes decades ago - to look upon that as a profound missed opportunity irrespective of tradition.


5. Control, And The Management Of It

Keith Lee
WWE.com

To make this abundantly, crystal, perfectly clear: expression is fundamental to professional wrestling. The death of expression is the death of professional wrestling. The professional wrestler does not recite a promo in their mirror in the hope that, one day, a hack dipsh*t with no life experience can put the words "You see..." in front of it.

WWE has killed expression.

In WWE, if you don't have what they perceive to be a telegenic body, you will be made to cover it up with a t-shirt or a lycra tank top. Every word you speak is written on your behalf, and those words are often gloopy soliloquies powered by a laughable synonym swap generator. You're not even allowed to play video games and raise money foe charity on the process. You are, as designated on a t-shirt, literally their f*cking property.

AEW, and this is slight criticism because their approach is far, far preferable, does need to somewhat regulate itself. Can you remember the emotive sight of the blood river that poured from the face of Dustin Rhodes and onto the mat at Double Or Nothing last year?

No blade-job since has resonated with the same heft because it's overdone - sometimes, as in the All out go-home, on the same show. Jim Ross needs to be told to get his head out of his a*se and into the game through that headset more often than he is. Tony Khan is a prodigy of a booker, and it's so crucial that he is as receptive to ideas as he is - but some of those ideas aren't great. He could do with rediscovering the ruthless side he flashed between December 18 and January 1.

New Japan needs to chill the f*ck out with with the ref bumps, count-out teases and main event durations, too. Nobody needs to watch EVIL go 35 minutes.


4. Abuse Of Referees

Aubrey Edwards
AEW

If referees always looked thick, they look f*cking thick now; with VAR and video replay the norm in real sports, there's no excuse - beyond the need to get one in - for the pro wrestling referee to look as dumb as they so frequently do.

WWE's refs look dumb because for years and years now, wrestlers have interfered in matches without - because f*ck your intelligence - bumping them first. The pattern and the frequency of the pattern should have proven instructive to the officials by now. It has not, because stupid people are incapable of instruction.

AEW take the piss in a cake-eating exercise that doesn't truly bother your writer - better a ref look than dumb than a finish - but it's still not ideal. Not perfect. That which would warrant a disqualification does not because AEW does not book DQ finishes. Several matches feature weapon shots and moments of excessive outside brawling that aren't penalised, which works on the "miles better than WWE" curve, but not entirely in and of itself; when FTR go to such meticulous lengths to outwit the referee, it all too often resonates as pointless. The heft of their act is somewhat lacking as a result.

NJPW has long annihilated the credibility of its refs, and just about gets away with it for two reasons: Red Shoes Unno is very endearing, and it happens so frequently that you simply have to get on with it.

A great, authoritative referee adds so much - Aubrey Edwards shutting down Chris Jericho was such a welcome reminder that referees matter, as do the integrity of the rules - but there aren't anywhere near enough of them.


3. Oversized Roster

Scorpio Sky
AEW

A problem specific to AEW and WWE, mostly, though it is a big problem.

WWE hired too many wrestlers in a state of sh*t-scared fright at the looming competition. There's never been more TV time to allocate, and yet there is too much talent to accommodate, and matters aren't helped by WWE's now-definitive inattentive booking. The complexion of that bloated roster doesn't help in that it limits WWE's narrative scope; WWE doesn't ordinarily trust very young, green talent, nor does it embrace the pathos of advancing years, so we're left, mostly, with a massive roster in their mid-to-late 30s, virtually all of whom arrive from NXT as championship-calibre athletes in their prime. This has destroyed the concepts of tiers and storyline advancement from them.

The foundation on which WWE books is as flawed as the booking itself.

AEW has signed too many acts, too, though the imminent "third hour" may correct this. The company wants to do something with Scorpio Sky - he has pinned Chris Jericho and twice now received the big vignette treatment - but the intention is not matched by the delivery. Too often, AEW fans get excited about the prospect of Jungle Boy scoring a big win, or entering a breakthrough performance, and that momentum never really materialises in much.

Nobody needs to see every wrestler work every week, but the AEW audience trusts a development to mean something when it happens.


2. An Inability To Penetrate The Mainstream

The Rock Hulk Hogan Wrestlemania 18
WWE.com

How many nights have you spent aimlessly scrolling Netflix or Prime, only to be confronted by an endless series of thumbnails?

You'll have heard that several of these shows and movies are worth your time, but you can never pick. So much looks like a seven because, in this atomised cultural landscape, so little feels like a 10 that you can't not watch for fear of missing out. And so you scroll, and scroll, because, conditioned by capitalism, it never quite feels like it's premium if it isn't expensive and it doesn't come in a neat, physical package.

Money is flung at so many properties, reboots and purchased originals alike, in a bid to retain a share in an oversaturated market. All we see is thumbnails, and those thumbnails bleed into one another within the same price point, further disrupting a sense of worth long since lost.

This is what wrestling - stigmatised as whole load of old fake sh*te devoid of options by WWE's dual monopoly and decline - is up against.

Here's a truth, that you may not like, but it's truth nonetheless:

By critical consensus, WWE sucks sh*t.

By critical consensus, beyond some iffy moments that AEW does tend to address, the company has met or exceeded lofty expectations.

Neither are mainstream concerns because the very concept of a mainstream is itself dying.


1. The Lack Of Proper Crowds

FTR AEW
AEW

It's all a bit bittersweet, pro wrestling in the lockdown era. It doesn't bear thinking about, but those thoughts cannot be repelled.

Are FTR over? When they're great, they're f*cking great, but certain matches go long and uneven. It's difficult to tell, and to get a grasp on what is and isn't working, we're left to resort to the toxic swamp that is Twitter.

John Silver is over, and he should be generating ovations across the U.S. to the fury of Mr. Brodie Lee. That same AEW audience should be very slowly turning on Kenny Omega. They should be receiving Jon Moxley in full-blooded voice as the goddamn hero he is.

The timid ambience of the ThunderDome doesn't sound too dissimilar to a 2018 RAW crowd, to be fair. But less facetiously, Drew McIntyre is doing a commendable job as the rare, not totally detestable top babyface, and he isn't hearing the praise he deserves.

The noise is back in New Japan, to an extent - and it's electric to hear the conscientious clap-crowds lose themselves when Big Tomohiro Ishii roars back from the dead - but it's just not the same. Ironically, given the ignorant, racist, pervasive take, NJPW fans are the loudest and most impassioned in all of wrestling when those seminal main event goods are delivered.

Wear a mask.

Wear a goddamn motherf*cking mask.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!