10 Reasons Why Vince McMahon Will NEVER Shake Off The WWE ‘Stigma’
Chairman Of The Broad
The hype and buzz around January 4th's Wrestle Kingdom 12 was unlike anything in the industry since a miniature earthquake caused by TNA exactly eight years earlier.
On that famous 2010 night, the Orlando outfit launched an ill-advised assault on a stale WWE product, flooding their talented roster with stars of old ostensibly employed to raise the company's profile underneath Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff's headline arrivals with the group. If the strategy didn't already mirror 'Easy E's Monday Nitro philosophy over a decade earlier, the company also went on air in direct competition with Monday Night Raw and kicked off an hour earlier to convince fans to stay put with a dynamic alternative.
Two things undermined the whole exercise. Perhaps most crucially, the product wasn't a dynamic alternative. It was a tired retread, offering little difference to the nostalgia WWE would often pepper into their broadcasts on birthdays or anniversaries. Problematic for the group was that McMahon bucked the usual trend of completely ignoring them to instead deliver the seismic return of Bret Hart on his show as a counter.
It highlighted how quickly Vince's default setting was still so sound. WWE is so often a frustrating beast, but few promotors have overseen as many globally recognised creative success stories as McMahon himself. If only those moments of audience satisfaction were scant succour for the man himself.
10. The Content Of His Own Network
Vince McMahon's entire creative legacy sits within his own over-the-top streaming service, but his decision to exorcise some of his most perverse demons on-screen over the years has resulted in something of a conundrum for his future efforts beyond his wild world.
Keen during the persona's late-1990's peak to blur the lines between the 'Mr McMahon' visage and the slightly-less-bonkers real version of himself, Vince now pays for his gimmicked sins with legitimate penance.
With the world looking upon the industry he stands atop of as little more than a jumped-up circus, his struggle to be thought of as more than just a ringmaster is undermined by the character he so expertly portrayed. In WWE lore, he's an evil genius pushed to psychopathic lengths, exhibiting unabashed cruelty and bizarre comedy in equal measure.
No matter what he tries to sell, the man will always be the cartoon promotor. It's an inescapable dilemma he's created all by himself.
9. Here Come The Ghouls
Rarely without the funds to protect himself from the damage of absurd decisions, McMahon subsequently can't help himself making them. His rampant success within WWE has given him similar free reign to establish a corporate culture that seems almost entirely detached from how a 'normal' organisation would need to be structured.
In Titan Tower, McMahon is surrounded by loyal acolytes including his own children. Stephanie McMahon may have started life as a secretary answering the phones, but there was little justification to channel her into the creative process in the early 2000s. And even less to rationalise keeping her there after so many stories suffered under her stewardship.
Tasked with keeping relations sweet between wrestlers, McMahon has instead delegated the powers unofficially to locker room leaders - those stars or long-tenured talents that marshal the dressing room under a code of unwritten laws. Just this year, more bullying allegations were levied towards JBL following years of hearsay about the Texan's maltreatment of his colleagues right under the noses of his superiors. Business norms such as incredibly harsh ribbing and 'Wrestler's Court' simply wouldn't fly in other worlds, and ironically it's Vince himself that often looks the least able to detach himself from the system he helped cultivate.
8. Scandal
Vince McMahon will almost definitely never write a book about his life as so many others around him have since Mick Foley ushered in a boom period for wrestlers committing their lives to libraries. Why would he? All the really juicy stories are probably the ones he can't even tell.
Furthermore, most of them have been rehashed in some form or another by the countless scribes that try in vain to nail down the complexities of his ludicrous personality.
WWE - and by proxy McMahon himself - has had the lot. The murky underbellies attached to sex, death and drugs have all briefly been forced to the front following one catastrophe or another, but as just a wrestling promotor, Vince routinely escapes relatively unscathed. Such fire escapes aren't flung open for those in organisations allegedly considered more legitimate than his knockabout stunt show.
He seemed not to realise that during the first and second times his wife Linda ran unsuccessful political campaigns in 2010 and 2012 (more on that later), and bit back pathetically with a 'Stand Up For WWE' campaign that begged fans/apologists for their support in response to the negative media the company received. 'Alpha Entertainment', the mere second it attempts something credible (if it even does), will face identical scrutiny.
7. Friends Without Benefits
1296011Never in America's short-but-decorated history has an association with a President been considered so toxic.
Regardless of political leanings, agendas or biases, Vince McMahon's long-standing mutually beneficial relationship with Donald Trump has now become yet another stick to beat him with as he endeavours on an audacious new path.
Divisive on a good day, Trump's White House tenure will undoubtedly go down as the most contentious in US political history regardless of if he manages four years, eight, or even survives until next week without inadvertently triggering a nuclear war. Though he's never been better placed to kick open any doors Vince requests, staying in bed with 'The Donald' looks contrarian to a fault, even for the notoriously competitive McMahon.
During a humorous aside on the massively missed Talking Smack, Daniel Bryan shared the rage he heard in his headset discussing his distaste for Trump and the American right wing shortly before the election, but the company kept relatively partial beyond that. Would McMahon be able to stifle his usual hubris for the greater good again?
6. The Pro Wrestling Paradox
McMahon may desperately crave mainstream acceptance, but it will always be a sticking point that the one thing he managed to over-perform in was pro wrestling.
It's the industry that fed his fortune, his ego and his belief that he could do so much more outside of it, but the unfair aspersions cast upon it by the mainstream entertainment industry at large will permanently restrict his expectations.
To refer back to his most powerful friend, there are few arenas Donald Trump has not wealthily pushed his way into based on arguable success elsewhere. He's successful slapped the 'Trump' branding on all sorts en route to the White House in a way McMahon still hasn't done with his various food, music, film and book divisions over the course of the last two decades.
Splitting off from WWE entirely, McMahon's 'Alpha Entertainment' offshoot is perhaps as much to combat the huckster stereotype as it is re-position himself as more than just 'the wrestling guy'. History suggests a combination of his own sports entertainment bluster and a jagged relationship with the media won't allow for the clean break he needs.
5. His Wife
As Administrator for United States Small Business Administration under President Donald Trump, Linda McMahon currently holds a position that may have benefitted her husband had it not been for the glaringly obvious conflict of interest. Presumably Vince wouldn't like anything he associated with to be considered 'small' at all, but as a new business in an overcrowded marketplace, 'Alpha Entertainment' perhaps could have done with the assistance from governmental forces.
Instead, Linda now serves as yet another inexorable tie to a leadership regime fiercely dividing a nation and the wider world. A foot solider for Donald Trump, McMahon's position already stank of cronyism considering her past political failures following her decision to step down as WWE CEO in 2009.
The President hasn't been shy of alienating associates thus far, but how she serves in the role and for how long is almost irrelevant. Many will not forgive nor forget the McMahon/Trump legacy, and will take a sideways look at anything even tenuously linked to an administration they despise.
4. His Kids
Shane and Stephanie McMahon are now the adult versions of the spoilt rich kids they portrayed in their earliest days as television full-timers. Bullishly domineering (albeit as both a babyface and heel respectively) the brother and sister combo's sense of entitlement is at times the most sickening part of the product they only get free reign of because of their surname.
McMahon's next move could result in more time away than his precious product than he's ever had. He famously had people lined up to help him continue running the company from prison had he gone down on steroid charges in 1994, and even now only seems content because his son-in-law is so deeply ingrained in a product he clearly still loves.
Beyond the backstage work of 'The Game' though, can he really trust the authoritative nous of his d*ckheaded progeny? Shane and Stephanie will always portray inferior versions of their own father, and presumably uphold a similar reputation behind the scenes. There's never been a more prosperous time for performers to step away from WWE, not least if your bosses kids are chasing you out of the door while he's not around.
3. His Tastes
Not that he'd ever contemplate such a thing, but is it possible Vince McMahon hasn't made a success of anything else beyond wrestling because people don't care for his visions of the things they already like?
It's a big enough problem in the one thing he already does really well! During a fascinating podcast interview, ex-WWE writer Tom Casiello spoke about the intriguing AJ Lee/CM Punk/Daniel Bryan love triangle of 2012 noting that Lee's brief illogical tryst with Kane was entirely driven by McMahon's fascination with the dated character.
'The Big Red Machine' was the focussed performer in one of WWE Films' highest profile ventures too. By-the-numbers horror flick 'See No Evil' was a modest commercial success at the box office and via DVD sales, but was savaged by critics for its lightweight content. Writing for WWE at the time, Dan Madigan was tasked with crafting something workable as a plot for the film but encountered yet more McMahon insanity when Vince insisted Kane's character Jacob Goodnight had a three foot penis.
The impossibly stupid suggestion didn't make the cut, but plenty more did. Just as they did with the gimmicks in the WBF, the out-there rules within the XFL or the excessive Kid Rock on pay-per-view soundtracks.
2. "A Millionaire That Should Be A Billionaire"
They were CM Punk's most caustic words in a promo littered with acidic barbs, if only for how painfully true they were at the time.
Yes, McMahon has since returned to the ten-figure club, but a host of spectacularly bad short and long term decisions between 2000 and 2016 ensured that his original stay there was a brief one. The birth of the XFL during his wrestling product's most successful period ever was the most ostentatious example, but he dropped countless b*llocks on a smaller scale.
Internally, he seems destined to drive WWE into further homogenisation, stifling characters, charisma and creativity as he goes. How on earth is this the model for a successful enterprise in an entirely different industry? Yes, McMahon has the resources to employ people to do just that on his behalf, but when has history ever suggested he'd do something like that?
Whatever 'Alpha Entertainment' curates, it's likely to be in his image. Even the name alone denotes his ego and all-too-regularly-publicised 'grapefruits'. In this company, WWE and everything else he's ever been at the helm of, Vince has insisted upon being the top dog. No other spot will do.
1. NXT Vs WWE
WWE is such a complex beast in 2018 that its own back room is almost entirely separate from the shop front. The positives and negatives of this have shown themselves constantly over the past few years too.
NXT TakeOver events are universally praised for seamlessly blending contemporary and traditional styles of sports entertainment and pro wrestling respectively. Overseen by the self-styled student of the profession Triple H, they're everything he ever aspired to be as performer, only substantially more entertaining.
Somehow, the main roster is neither of either. Five hours of live television each and every week brings out the absolute worst of Vince McMahon's micromanagement. Characters and arcs suffocate under the need to super-serve, evidenced most now by the once-nuanced figures that graced Full Sail University before their main roster graduation. Half survive and few thrive upon making the jump, in such volume now that the failures can't be considered unlucky.
Can he possibly make a brand new venture prosper outside his comfort zone when he can no longer use his maligned 'genius' to transpose internal success stories in his own 'universe'? McMahon's one of the greatest workers of them all, he'll make you think he did even when it collapses.