10 Reasons Why WWE's Stagnation Will Never End
Even in wrestling, comfort is the death of ambition.
It's easy to be critical of WWE's current state, but the company aren't in a bad spot at the moment. Their market share is untouchable, revenue is through the roof, and there's plenty to enjoy across their many brands if you're willing to cherry-pick. Things could be a lot worse, basically.
The problem is that each of their good points is tempered by a disappointing low. Revenue might be high, but profit margins and Network subscription counts aren't hitting targets, and ratings are as dismal as ever. They're not even close to going out of business, but the company aren't moving forward either, and that's a problem.
WWE have flatlined. They operate solely within their comfort zone, which mitigates risk, but offers only limited opportunities for growth. Even when the company give the impression that they're progressing, they rarely take anything more than a couple of steps forward at a time, and it has been this way for years.
Stagnation is a disease for WWE, and curing it would mean tackling a multitude of deep-rooted problems at once. Sadly, this is an impossibility for a company so content on coasting from one quarterly report to another...
10. The Weekly Variety Show
Raw and SmackDown are professional wrestling's biggest variety shows. Rather than catering to only one or two sects of their audience, the promotion try to appeal to as many different fan groups as possible, which is understandable. They're not a niche entertainment company, but an unstoppable titan who have sat atop their industry for close to two decades now, so of course they want to satisfy a wide range of consumer needs.
Unfortunately, this strategy is one of the main reasons why WWE's weekly programming is so inconsistent. Celebrity appearances like the Ball family on MizTV exist to pop the mainstream audience. Raw and SD usually feature at least one good-to-great match to keep workrate-focused fans happy. Their attempts at comedy are often laughably bad, but are clearly aimed at appealing to those who share Vince McMahon's sense of humour.
Those who value in-ring action above all else won't always pop for Enzo Amore segments, and vice versa, meaning that no single audience segment will ever feel completely satisfied by an episode of Raw or SmackDown.
It'd be wiser for WWE to ape the original brand split's approach, where Raw was sports entertainment central, and SmackDown was a wrestling-centric island away from the madness. Sadly, the company are instead focused on spreading too many different themes and tones across both shows, creating a product that's never universally satisfying.
9. Superman: Redux
It's easy to understand why Vince McMahon keeps leaning on Superman-esque babyfaces to carry his product. Taking this approach with Hulk Hogan is what helped drag his company to mainstream prominence in the 1980s, after all. It's what the Chairman knows, and if his rule has taught us anything, it's that he'll always revert to his old failsafes when it comes to main event booking.
The problem is that the audience moved on from this approach a long time ago, and Superman pushes have outlived their use. Having endured it with John Cena for years, we're now doomed to Roman Reigns occupying a similar role for the foreseeable future, with his No Mercy victory over 'The Face That Runs The Place' reaffirming this.
The WWE hierarchy are hell-bent on pushing smug, unsympathetic protagonists to the forefront, and while Reigns is undoubtedly a talented performer, this isn't the role he was born to play. He's noticeably uncomfortable as 'The Guy.' Yes, his push has produced no demonstrable downturn in business, but this isn't the '80s, and bulletproof heroes don't get over anymore.
It looked like WWE had abandoned the approach prior to No Mercy, but Reigns once again donned the red cape after surviving four Attitude Adjustments at the PPV. Sadly, this'll likely be his role until at least WrestleMania 34.
8. No Incentives
WWE's purchase of WCW has turned out to be one of the worst things to ever happen to professional wrestling, as it ensured that Vince McMahon's company will never have serious competition again.
Their market position is infallible. Impact Wrestling, NJPW, the British indies: none have the necessary resources to ever topple WWE's ivory tower, and barring a sudden influx of mass investment, they'll never dent the McMahons' market share. It's just not realistic.
WWE know this, too. They're safe in the knowledge that they'll always be the industry leaders, no matter what direction they take their product, because the odds of ever going out of business are minuscule. This lack of legitimate competitors means that WWE have no incentive to take risks, listen to their audience, or push their product forward, and it's one of the biggest factors preventing them from advancing.
Vince McMahon won the Monday Night Wars because WCW's success forced him to adapt. Without that threat, the Chairman has no real reason to change his methods. The hardcore audience will never abandon him, and with revenue pouring through the doors in record volumes, him and his company are content to coast on inertia.
7. Pushing Unpopular Performers
There are exceptions, but WWE generally do a poor job of taking stock of their crowd reactions and altering their course accordingly. They're going to push who they want, when they want, and they don't care what the audience think about it.
Roman Reigns has been far less obnoxious in 2017 than he was in 2016, but his No Mercy performance suggests that he's about to be positioned as WWE's franchise player once more, giving weight to the idea that he's being shoved down the audience's throats. On SmackDown, Jinder Mahal shows no sign of getting over as a major heel, yet he continues to hold the WWE Championship instead of guys like Shinsuke Nakamura, whom the fans would love to see in the spotlight.
The company obviously can't cater to their audience's every whim, but they must be receptive to how the fans are reacting to certain stars. Main events should be WWE's biggest selling point: instead, they're a convoluted, frustrating mess, populated by "top guys" that nobody wants to watch. Realigning this is key to ending the company's stagnation, but it doesn't look like happening anytime soon, unfortunately.
6. They Can't Compete Artistically
WWE's competitors will never be able to challenge the promotion in business terms, but they have the company beaten on an artistic level. The smaller companies' viewerships pale in comparison, and they lack the resources to ever pose a threat to WWE on that level, but their content excels in ways the McMahons can never hope to better despite their huge financial advantage.
WWE's hefty restrictions means they'll never match NJPW in terms of in-ring drama. That's not to say the industry leaders don't produce great matches, but they certainly don't deliver with the same regularity or consistency. In terms of wild, outlandish storytelling, Lucha Underground have them trumped. For pure workrate and staggering athletic spectacles, there are companies like PWG, RevPro, and countless others.
The problem here is that the fans WWE might be looking to attract are already having their needs met elsewhere, stifling the company's potential for growth. Why would someone who prioritises great matches go to WWE over NJPW? There's no reason to do so, even if WWE adjust their focus accordingly, meaning there's little the company can do to entice these lapsed fans to return.
5. Endless Repetition
WWE operate primarily on patterns, particularly on a creative level. Coming up with fresh, original wrestling content can't be easy in 2017, but every major WWE angle feels like a retread of something that came before it. This is fine when it's done well (there's nothing new about Braun Strowman's monster push, but it rules regardless), but leaves the product feeling cripplingly predictable when it's not, which is usually the case these days.
The vast majority of WWE storylines end with the same babyface redemption moment. Authority vs. wrestler feuds dominate many major PPV arcs. Every top face is an anti-hero, and every heel is a yellow-bellied coward. Each episode of Raw and SmackDown opens with an in-ring segment, and on a micro level, characters like Bray Wyatt and Jinder Mahal cut tiny variations on the same boring promo every single week.
The company's staunch adherence to such formulae is killing their product, and removing the incentive to tune in every week. WWE have never been so telegraphed, and while the sport used to thrive on surprise and suspense, such moments are becoming increasingly rare in the modern era.
4. Everything Is Manufactured
Above all else, modern WWE storytelling is focused primarily on "making history" and "creating moments." Storylines have deteriorated to a point where it feels like many angles and feuds are designed solely to write the participants' names into the record books. WWE are no longer content to let these landmarks occur naturally, but now race towards them with single-minded focus, creating a broken, disjointed storytelling model that has sapped all the emotion from those moments when the wrestlers finally reach their grand accomplishment.
The New Day's record-breaking Tag Team Title run ultimately meant nothing, and neither did John Cena's 16th World Championship win, or Sasha Banks and Charlotte headlining Hell In A Cell 2016. Why? Because they were done just for the sake of doing them. They were manufactured, not organic, and this made them entirely unsatisfying.
Such stunted storytelling has become so commonplace that an angle like Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins' reunion feels genuinely refreshing, as it's one of the few recent occasions where the company haven't shortcutted their way to a "historic" conclusion. Stories like this are key to WWE moving forward again, but appear to be a dying art.
3. The Product Insults Our Intelligence
Vince McMahon thinks you're stupid.
It may sound harsh, but the company's product wouldn't be so insultingly derivative if it wasn't true. WWE have been taking their audience for granted for years, but the current era is characterised by hand-holding and absurd levels of simplicity.
If WWE think there's even an outside chance that one of their angles might be misconstrued, they'll hammer you over the head with it again and again and again. It's incredibly frustrating, but it comes with the PG territory, and while the rating has been a considerable net positive for the company as a whole, it'd be nice if the storytellers didn't treat us like infants.
This has manifested in a number of different ways, from minor issues like immature comedy skits to wider problems like their insistence that they're an entertainment organisation, not a wrestling promotion. They expect you to buy into every narrative without question, and that's a huge problem.
It's incredibly hard to feel positive about a company that takes your intelligence as a consumer for granted, and the approach only adds to the mainstream perception that wrestling is a childish artform that isn't to be taken seriously, thus harming its growth.
2. Profitability Over Creativity
WWE exists to generate profit. Logic dictates that creating a high quality product that people want to invest themselves in would be the best way to do this, but not with this company. The McMahons will bend over backwards if given the opportunity to make a quick buck, and while it's hard to blame them for wanting to cash in on valuable commodities, this focus on profitability over creativity is killing their storytelling.
Jinder Mahal's WWE Title push was designed primarily to boost business in the untapped Indian market. It came at the cost of SmackDown's main event scene, which has become a dull, unwatchable mess since his ascension. On a similar note, WWE are now seemingly on the verge of hot-shotting a full on Shield reunion within the next few weeks, burning what should be a hugely memorable moment with just one month of build. Why? To boost ticket sales for TLC - a lowly B-level pay-per-view.
Creating something that people want to watch should produce a natural upturn in profitability, but WWE seem to think otherwise. Sadly, the fact that Jinder's push came as the result of a cynical money-making ploy than a long-term storyline is one of the main reasons why he has bombed so hard, highlighting this approach's critical flaw.
1. The Star-Making Machine Is Broken
Stars sell tickets.
It sounds like an oversimplification, but it's true. Having a roster stuffed with wrestlers that people actually want to watch is always been key to any successful wrestling organisation, and while WWE are still clinging onto the likes of Brock Lesnar and John Cena, their talent pool is frighteningly low on star power.
Guys like Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins, and Dean Ambrose are great performers, but they don't scream "megastar" like their predecessors. The way they've been presented means it's impossible to see them on the level of a Steve Austin or The Rock, and that's a massive problem. Even when WWE happen upon a potential star, they're rarely able to maintain their momentum, as illustrated by Braun Strowman's dismal No Mercy loss to Lesnar.
The reasons behind this are legion, with 50/50 booking, oversaturation, and micromanagement all to blame. The problem shows no sign of easing off either, and the company will be forced to rely on guys like Bill Goldberg to come back and pop ratings. Unfortunately, WWE's current "stars" just aren't up to the task.
WWE can't improve without fixing their broken star-making machine, but this would require a fundamental overhaul of the way they book talent. It's never going to happen.