10 Reasons WWE Should Never Return To Saudi Arabia
The Saudi Saga: Stating the obvious to an audience of one who doesn’t listen.
WWE has been no stranger to critical brickbats of late. Whether it be their woefully inconsistent TV shows, under attended live events or their suspect business practices, they’ve taken a kicking from commentators and fans alike.
However, their deal with Saudi Arabia and the subsequent stadium events have been poorly received even relative to the current products low standards. WWE have come under fire from both moral and creative standpoints. The company are set to receive a reported £450 million a year from the deal but the reaction to it has been almost universally negative.
Still, these, “WrestleMania level events,” look set to continue as planned. According to reports from PW Insider, WWE’s next Saudi Arabian shindig is set to take place in late October, once again using the name Crown Jewel.
But let’s not fret. Nothing lasts forever. WWE’s deal with the Saudi General Sports Authority is only set for 10 years and we’re already over a year in. That’s less than nine years left. That’s nothing. It’s only very nearly a decade. Honestly, it’ll be over before you know it.
After all, with new upstart babyface organisation AEW on the horizon WWE can easily afford to keep sabotaging their own reputation for years to come. Right?
10. Dead Crowds
In the Attitude Era, everyone was over. You don’t need to be told that. Even if you weren’t there you’ll have read this point before in many, many other articles. It’s about the least original thing you can read about wrestling on the internet. But that doesn’t make it any less true.
Go back and watch those old episodes of Raw and the atmosphere is electric. Then compare that to Stomping Grounds or this year’s Extreme Rules. It’s hard to sustain crowd interest throughout such B-level pay-per-views these days, let alone three hour TV shows.
You can even see it at WrestleMania 35. Good matches between talented wrestlers struggled to rouse much enthusiasm. Fans were completely fatigued from hour after hour of wrestling.
All of which is nothing to the lukewarm indifference of the Saudi Arabian Crowds. They don’t cheer the faces or boo the heels. There’s not even so much as a bit of go-away heat for Baron Corbin.
They only really come alive for the biggest of legends. Or anything involving Mansoor.
None of this looks good to the viewer at home or makes it any easier to invest in already lukewarm matches.
9. Running Out Of Legends
WWE have given some big names some big pay days in order to provide suitable main events for the first three Saudi Shows.
Why have they done this? Because these shows are a Vince McMahon passion project over which he takes extra special care and attention? No. If that were the case he’d probably just stick Baron Corbin in the main event again.
No, the Saudi Shows get legends because the Saudi General Sports Authority demand it. Their money holds more influence over Vince than the WWE Universe ever has.
Trouble is, WWE is rapidly running out of big enough names. Most legends famous enough are either too old to go in the ring or too busy in Hollywood to bother.
What big stars the company could attract have been burned through. Can you see Shawn Michaels, Goldberg or The Undertaker returning for another Saudi jaunt?
We’ve already seen WWE put a sumo wrestler, any sumo wrestler, in The Greatest Royal Rumble. It was the closest they could get to providing the long dead Yokozuna.
what comes next? An ersatz Steve Austin? A replica Rock? Gilberg?
8. Poor Reception
Three shows in and none of them so far has had a positive critical reception. Subjectively, The Greatest Royal Rumble was fun, with a great Iron Man performance from Daniel Bryan. On the other hand, the 51 man Battle Royal was a mess.
Elsewhere neither the match layouts or the performances have stood out. Perhaps it’s the oppressive heat but the wrestlers seem to struggle to get out of first gear.
Looking back at TGRR, Crown Jewel or Super Showdown the few stand out moments aren’t dazzling displays of athletic ability. It’s the embarrassing botches that will live long in the memory.
We’re not getting great wrestling, nor do we get exciting storyline beats or unforgettable promos. Plus most matches are then redone better at other events giving us little reason as fans to tune in.
Booked and wrestled like house shows but promoted as, “As good or better than WrestleMania,” it’s hard to imagine a casual fan tuning into Super Showdown and then making a point to mark WrestleMania weekend on their calendar.
These shows are terrible. That this point only makes number eight on our list speaks volumes.
7. Logistical Nightmares
Leaks suggested November 1st would be the date of the next Saudi Arabia event. This would however mean a clash with SmackDown’s new Friday night slot. So what would WWE do? Cancel?
They’ve moved or cancelled shows before for less lucrative reasons. This year they’ve cancelled a string of SmackDown house shows in order to accommodate the Wildcard Rule of all things.
Still, it’s hard to see Fox delighting in WWE missing an episode of TV less than two months into their new deal. Could WWE present audiences with a pre-recorded SmackDown Live!?
What’s the alternative? A two hour Smackdown and a “WrestleMania level” pay-per-view Live on the same night?
With so many superstars overseas who would be left to appear on TV? They’d only have Daniel Bryan, Kevin Owens, Aleister Black, Sami Zayn, Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair, Asuka and every other woman on the roster....it’s starting to sound pretty good actually.
Now it seems the next event has been bombed to a Thursday. Still, it’ll be a tricky ongoing issue for WWE if they’re beholden to the scheduling whims of the Saudi General Sports Authority.
6. Dissenting Superstars
There was a time when superstars stood up to Vince McMahon. Protective of their characters, they would demur over certain storylines or refuse to put other guys over.
This included the industry’s biggest names like Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels. Most notoriously there was Hulk Hogan’s backstage catchphrase, “that doesn’t work for me, brother.”
These days things are different for the most part. Many are aware that WWE is their best chance of steady employment and a decent living. Others are fans who grew up watching the product, helping to foster a “happy to be here” mentality that precludes serious dissent.
Nonetheless, several superstars have refused to travel to Saudi Arabia. It underlines just how controversial these shows are. These guys are happy to cut embarrassing promos or succumb to 50/50 booking(or worse) but refuse to take a Saudi payday.
It's not a good look for the company but more than that it must cause innumerable storyline headaches. To give just one example, Kevin Owens is about the most popular face in the company right now. WWE should be thinking about handing him a title. However, if they do they’ll have to take it back off him twice a year because he’ll refuse to defend it in Saudi Arabia.
5. LGBT Rights
Just a heads up, things get a little more serious from here on in. Other WWE events might be accused of dead crowds or dull matches. The Saudi Shows have a unique set of rather uncomfortable problems.
Saudi Arabia has one of the worst LGBT rights records in the world. Homosexuality is illegal and punishments for homosexual acts include not just prison but public whipping and chemical castration. Practices that would be considered barbaric in WWE’s United States home.
Advocating for LGBT rights is also illegal in Saudi Arabia. So Finn Bálor deserves some credit for tweeting a photo of himself at a Saudi stadium wearing an equality t-shirt. Even then he probably waited to be safely on a plane home before tweeting. It’ll be interesting to see if he makes the next trip.
Continuing to work with the Saudi Sports Authority isn’t an endorsement of the countries attitudes to LGBT people but it does represent a tacit acceptance. Where Bálor makes a statement his bosses prefer to keep their mouths shut and line their coffers.
This would all be terrible for any openly LGBT wrestlers on the roster. Luckily, as we’ll see, they’re not taking Sonya Deville with them anyway...
4. Women’s Rights
In 2016 The World Economic Forum released a Global gender gap report that ranked Saudi Arabia 141st out of 144 countries for gender equality.
In 2018 WWE ran what amounted to propaganda films during their Greatest Royal Rumble event. These clips presented Saudi women’s new right to drive as a progressive development and not what it was. A belated step bringing Saudi Arabia into line with the rest of the world on one issue while still lagging behind on many others.
Things are improving, very slowly, for Saudi women but they still face issues such as segregation and employment restrictions.
As a fan you could conceivably watch these events and have no knowledge of the Saudi Government’s attitude to the LGBT community. Their attitude to women is a bit more obvious due to their refusal to let women wrestle.
The Women’s revolution has been WWE’s biggest PR coup in recent years. They’ve taken loads of credit for finally pushing women’s wrestling. This despite being the company most responsible for trivialising women’s wrestling and training generations of fans not to care.
The Saudi sausage fests threaten to undermine all this goodwill. Suddenly it looks like WWE only care about women until somebody pays them not to.
3. Sami Zayn
When Sami Zayn was excluded from The Greatest Royal Rumble it was reportedly an attempt by WWE, “to respect the local culture of Saudi Arabia.”
Subsequent reports suggested Zayn, a Canadian with Syrian heritage, is banned by the Saudi Kingdom from appearing because of his Syrian roots.
Whoever is making the call, the idea that a full time roster member is excluded from certain events because of his ethnicity should be unacceptable in 2019.
Given his charitable work for Syria, it seems unlikely Sami would want to get on the plane to Saudi Arabia anyway but there’s more to it than a biannual bumper payday. This exclusion has the potential to shape Zayn’s career over the next decade. It could already be happening.
Its a shame to see such a talented wrestler and talker reduced to what is essentially jobber status at this point. The guy was a champion in NXT and it would be great to see him pushing for main roster gold. Still it’s hard to see him being inserted into the title picture ever now, not when WWE know they can’t use him for their two most lucrative shows every year...
2. Jamal Khashoggi
On the 2nd of October 2018, the Saudi journalist and dissident Jamal Khashoggi was assassinated in the Saudi consulate in Instanbul by agents of the Saudi government. This came after the alleged use of Israeli spyware to hack his phone.
His crime? Writing articles that were critical of the Saudi government and royal family. He also opposed Saudi intervention in Yemen.
Khashoggi had fled Saudi Arabia the previous year. He lived in self-imposed exile, afraid to return and was only visiting the consulate to pick up documents ahead of his planned wedding.
Khashoggi’s death shocked the world’s media and he was named “Person of the Year” by Time magazine, who called him, “a guardian of the truth”.
Beyond this particularly high profile case, many other Saudi critics have been reported missing under suspicious circumstances.
This is trivial relative to a man’s death of course but it was terrible timing for WWE. Exactly a month ahead of Crown Jewel. Some expected WWE to distance themselves from the Saudi Government at this point. If anything they doubled down on controversy by using the event to bring the problematic Hulk Hogan back into the WWE fold.
Still, the assassination of a Saudi journalist by the government made WWE’s continued involvement with Saudi Arabia untenable in the eyes of many.
1. It’s Hurting The Business
Depressingly, none of the preceding reasons have soured Vince McMahon’s love of Saudi money. There is however one thing that may yet rouse him from his indifference. Vince might finally take notice if it starts effecting the business.
After all, disgust at the Saudi deal inspired #CancelTheNetwork. A campaign that was probably easy to ignore before Network subscriptions dropped off.
Q2 reports Have revealed that domestic and international subscriptions are both down from the same quarter last year. This despite Q2 including WrestleMania, normally peak subscription time.
TV ratings have also continued to drop at an excelerated rate since the Saudi deal started. They are now far below what Fox are apparently expecting when SmackDown moves there in the Autumn.
Yes there are other reasons but all the negative publicity can’t be helping. Lucrative as the Saudi gigs are WWE need weekly TV and Network subscribers.
After all, when you really boil it down, WWE make television shows. Ted Turner bought into the wrasslin’ business. Vince McMahon makes movies. If he wants to continue, he still needs a fan base willing to engage with the product. That product’s association with the Saudi Kingdom makes it increasingly unappealing.