10 Reasons WWE's Cruiserweight Division Has Fallen

For 205 Live, the damage has been done - and it's time to rebuild.

Jack Gallagher Clown
WWE.com

Fans, for years, longed and clamored for the return of a Cruiserweight division in WWE. The timing was never right, until 2016, when the Cruiserweight Classic was held as a WWE Network-exclusive event, featuring some of the best wrestling the company has promoted in the last decade.

Of course, the CWC was what opened the doors for Cruiserweight wrestling to be brought back to WWE programming full-time. Once it was officially announced that the division would be brought back on Raw, starting in September 2016, speculation ran wild as to how the aerial artists would inject new life into the dull three-hour format of the show, and how they would be handled.

Unfortunately, since the Cruiserweight division was botched from the get-go, it was all downhill from there.

Even the inception of 205 Live couldn't help the Cruiserweights, and for a solid year or so, there was zero buzz surrounding the scene. Something that started out with so much promise and excitement gradually deteriorated into the exact opposite of what the CWC was all about.

It wasn't until Triple H was given control of the Cruiserweights that the division finally took a turn for the better, but these were the 10 factors that contributed to its initial demise...

10. Lackluster Debut Of The Division

Brian Kendrick Gran Metalik Rich Swann Cedric Alexander
WWE.com

For months, WWE promoted the pending return of the Cruiserweight division through a series of vignettes that aired weekly on Raw. However, when it finally came time for them to make a major impact on the flagship show and showcase their skills to the world, the Cruiserweight competitors fell flat.

Let the record show that it was hardly the fault of the talent involved. The Fatal 4-Way pitting Cedric Alexander, The Brian Kendrick, Gran Metalik and Rich Swann against each other was good, yet far from what viewers had come to expect from them in the Cruiserweight Classic. It also didn't help that the then-Cruiserweight champion, TJP, was nowhere to be seen on Raw that night.

Worse yet, their match was placed so late in the evening that it was difficult for fans to care, when in reality, it really should have kicked off the show. Plus, Mick Foley was put in charge of handling the in-ring introductions, which, to be honest, he did a poor job with.

It was apparent at that point the Cruiserweight division wouldn't be what fans hoped it would be.


9. Tajiri's Release

tajiri WWE
WWE.com

Part of the appeal of the Cruiserweight division returning was WWE re-signing so many former faces that helped make Cruiserweight wrestling as prominent as it was back in the day. Plus, they would lend credibility to the up-and-coming athletes new fans weren't familiar with.

The Brian Kendrick filled that role remarkably well, and Tajiri was set to join him soon after the division's debut on Raw. After all, The Japanese Buzzsaw had a decent run for himself in the Cruiserweight Classic, proving he still had plenty left in the tank.

After weeks and weeks of vignettes hyping his debut on 205 Live, he resurfaced at long last at the onset of 2017 and defeated Sean Maluta in an impressive showing. Although he suffered a knee injury that sidelined him from action for a month, he still appeared to be in line for a feud with Kendrick upon his return to the ring.

Tajiri then mysteriously disappeared from programming, despite being cleared to compete. It later emerged that he was released by WWE due to his "old age" and the company opted not to use him.

With the division already light on star power, it was an odd move for WWE to ax the one notable name fans actually cared about and could have contributed to the success of 205 Live.


8. Getting Alicia Fox Involved

Alicia Fox Bouquet Of Flowers
WWE.com

Romance angles in wrestling rarely work out, especially in WWE. Oftentimes, they're horribly handled because the company can't do "sports entertainment" the right way, and that was what happened with the Cedric Alexander-Noam Dar-Alicia Fox love triangle.

At first, it looked like Fox would be a nice addition to Alexander's act. He got over with the audience big time in the Cruiserweight Classic, but he had been lacking that special something on the main roster. Dar was even worse off, considering he wasn't remotely interesting as a character and he was never given enough time to show off his abilities in his matches.

Combine all that with how Fox was barely being used on WWE TV in the fall of 2016, and it seemed a decent idea on paper to put them together. It quickly went off the rails, hindering the quality of 205 Live more than it helped it.

From the awful acting to the forgettable matches, nothing about this angle was entertaining in the slightest. No offense to Fox, but she had no place on a show that should have been focused purely on in-ring action.

205 Live has been better off without her over the past number of months.


7. Kalisto's Anticlimactic Cruiserweight Debut

Kalisto raw
WWE

Needless to say, Kalisto should have been a part of the rechristened Cruiserweight division from the beginning. It was a mind-boggling move for him to be shipped to SmackDown Live in the 2016 WWE draft, where he would do nothing of note for the one year he was there.

By the time Kalisto finally arrived as a member of the 205 Live roster in the fall of 2017, fans had already been conditioned to not care about him. A former two-time United States champion joining the ranks should have been a big deal, but you could have heard a pin drop when he was introduced as the newest Cruiserweight on the 2 Oct. edition of Raw.

The follow-up to his debut was pretty poor as well. He unseated Enzo Amore for the WWE Cruiserweight Championship one week removed from his arrival on 205 Live, and although it was cool in the moment, the title change was also premature. That was made evident three weeks later when he lost the belt back to Enzo at TLC and was quietly dropped from the title picture shortly thereafter.

Kalisto was never going to be a game-changer for the brand, but it didn't take long for WWE to make him just another Cruiserweight, reinforcing the perception that nothing on the show mattered.


6. Jack Gallagher Goes Heel

Jack Gallagher Heel Turn
WWE.com

WWE fans took a liking to Jack Gallagher almost immediately during the Cruiserweight Classic.

Not only was he flashy in the ring, but he simply had a presence about him that was hard not to love. His colorful attire combined with his throwback in-ring style made him an instant fan favorite in the CWC, leading to fans petitioning for him to be brought in for Raw's Cruiserweight division soon after.

It took a little longer than expected, but Gallagher finally debuted on 205 Live at the end of 2016, and was positioned as one of the top babyfaces on the brand. In fact, he was the only Cruiserweight to compete in the 2017 Royal Rumble match before taking Neville to the limit in an exceptional title clash at the Fastlane pay-per-view.

Once he failed to clinch the championship, he floundered for the remainder of 2017 and transitioned into a flop of a feud with The Brian Kendrick. That then led to Gallagher going heel, an asinine decision considering how popular Gallagher still was with a portion of the audience.

Sure enough, the heel turn did nothing but kill any momentum he may have had left, and now he has never meant less.


5. Rich Swann Gets Busted

rich swann
WWE

Rich Swann had been a cornerstone of the Cruiserweight division since its grand relaunch in September 2016. In fact, he knocked off The Brian Kendrick on the pilot episode of 205 Live to capture the WWE Cruiserweight Championship.

Even long after he dropped the strap to Neville at Royal Rumble 2017, Swann was featured at the forefront of the division for the remainder of the year, and for good reason. In addition to being a great wrestler, he had boatloads of charisma and managed to stand out from the rest of the roster.

He eventually earned himself another shot at the Cruiserweight title by winning a series of matches on Raw late last year, and likely would have been the one to take the title from Enzo Amore at some point. But, before he could contend for the championship, he was suspended indefinitely by the company after it was reported he was arrested on charges of domestic violence. Swann was ultimately released in mid-February.

By that point, the Cruiserweight division couldn't handle yet another significant loss, making Swann's departure one of the final nails in the coffin for the Cruiserweight division.


4. Neville Vs. Austin Aries Gets Bumped To The WrestleMania Kickoff

WrestleMania 33 Neville Austin Aries
WWE.com

On paper, Neville vs. Austin Aries for the WWE Cruiserweight Championship was one of the most anticipated matches at WrestleMania 33. There is also little doubt they ended up having one of the best bouts of the entire night.

Despite that, the two were bumped to the WrestleMania Kickoff show days ahead of the event, sending fans into a frenzy.

Aries went on record at the time in saying that he didn't see it as a "demotion" but rather as a way to "elevate" the Kickoff show. While that very well might be true, WWE not having room for Neville vs. Aries on WrestleMania spoke volumes as to how highly (or not-so-highly) they thought of the division.

As if that wasn't bad enough, it was revealed a few months later that they wouldn't even be included on the U.S. WrestleMania 33 DVD release as a result of the event running much longer than it should have. This meant that Aries and Neville weren't receiving any royalties. It was almost as if their match never even happened.

Props to the two for delivering an awesome outing in spite of the circumstances, but they deserved better. This would be far from the last time a Cruiserweight title match would be relegated to the Kickoff.


3. Enzo Amore

Enzo Amore
WWE.com

First and foremost, WWE breaking up Enzo Amore and Big Cass when they did was an absolutely dumb decision. Proceeding to put Enzo in the Cruiserweight division was even dumber.

There were so many reports coming out about Enzo being an annoyance backstage that WWE turning him heel was hardly surprising. The character change actually resulted in Enzo cutting some of the best promos of his career (for a few weeks, anyway), but it didn't change the fact that he was incredibly awful in the ring and was doing nothing to permanently bring new eyes to 205 Live.

From his series of mediocre matches with Kalisto to the nuclear "heat" he apparently had backstage, he wasn't the champion 205 Live needed, and thus it was shocker his reign lasted as long as it did. He did more to set the division back than he did to further it, which is why his abrupt dismissal in late January turned out to be a blessing in disguise.

With Enzo no longer at the helm of the division, 205 Live is just now coming along to what it should have been the whole time.


2. Neville Walks Out

Neville WWE
WWE.com

After not getting off to the strongest start, the Cruiserweight division desperately needed a star to build around heading into 2017. TJP, The Brian Kendrick and Rich Swann tried their best in the role of champion, but none of them were doing the type of numbers for 205 Live officials were likely looking for.

Enter Neville.

Fresh off his return from injury in the summer of 2016, Neville had basically become "The Man That Creative Forgot" after being left off Raw more often than not. Not only did his debut on 205 Live give the show a shot in the arm, it presented him with the opportunity to turn heel for the first time in his WWE career.

Of course, Neville took the ball and ran with it, quickly winning the Cruiserweight Championship from Swann and declaring himself "The King of the Cruiserweights." He went on to have a career year for himself by defending his title against all comers, and it was going to be a major moment when he was inevitably dethroned.

Regrettably, his second title reign came to an anticlimactic end at No Mercy, when he was beaten by Enzo Amore. And with that, the death of the division was nigh. You couldn't blame Neville for wanting to walk out after that.

Once Neville went home, he left behind a void that has yet to be filled.


1. Holding 205 Live After SmackDown Live

205 Live Empty Arena
CC BY-SA 2.0 Wikimedia Commons

205 Live was doomed to fail before it even began, thanks to WWE's oh-so-wise decision to hold the show immediately after SmackDown Live instead of... well, any other time.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that your typical crowd will be bored by the time 205 Live rolls around, having seeing all the true stars during the SmackDown taping. Why would they stick around for a bunch of matches that are no more exciting than what they see every week on Raw, featuring wrestlers they know nothing about?

Any other company would have realized that there was a problem with this format and chose to tape 205 Live at some other time or on some other day. WWE, on the other hand, has instead ignored the issue and proceeded with 205 Live airing after SmackDown. It is now commonplace for fans to sit on their hands during the 205 Live tapings.

It would be considerably easier for the taping to be held before SmackDown, when the crowd is still electric, or have it emanate from Full Sail University all together.

205 Live will suffer until this is resolved, because it has been the biggest knock against the show since its inception.


Contributor
Contributor

Since 2008, Graham has been a diehard pro wrestling fan and, in 2010, he combined his passions for WWE and writing when he joined Bleacher Report. Equipped with a master's in journalism, Graham has contributed to WhatCulture, FanSided's Daily DDT, Sports Betting Dime, and GateHouse Media. Along the way, he has conducted interviews with wrestling superstars like Chris Jericho, Edge, Goldberg, Christian, Diamond Dallas Page, Jim Ross, Adam Cole, Tessa Blanchard, Ryback, and Nick Aldis among others.