10 Reasons WWE's Cruiserweight Division Isn't Working
Where are things going wrong for the (formerly) flippy guys?
For years, fans around the world pleaded for the return of pure cruiserweight wrestling to WWE. Sure, the company had a fairly wretched history when it came to booking junior heavyweights, but the wrestling landscape had changed since the time Hornswoggle was forced to relinquish the WWE Cruiserweight Championship due to fears for his well-being.
Daniel Bryan had almost single-handedly changed the way cruiserweight-size wrestlers were seen, and as 2015 became 2016 there was renewed hope for juniors returning to WWE TV. Then came the Cruiserweight Classic, and all seemed right with the world. The cruiserweight division was to return to RAW after a long, long time away.
A few weeks have passed since the return of the division, and to call it underwhelming would be something of an understatement. Something isn't clicking. The division has gone from a potential breath of fresh air to just another part of the show.
What went wrong? Why hasn't the cruiserweight division been the hit that it seemingly could only be? Is it the fault of the performers, the bookers, the company, or all three?
Here are 10 reasons why the revamped WWE Cruiserweight Division just isn't working.
10. The Worst Possible Introduction
With the Cruiserweight Classic in the books, we all began to speculate as to what form the division would take on RAW. Would it slide back into that barely appreciated but definitely vital WCW slot of opening shows hot? Would the first champion, TJ Perkins, come out to celebrate and get waylaid by a dastardly heel? How would the audience get to know these new characters?
Instead of all the possibilities, what we got was Papa Mick Foley reading names off of a piece of paper as four competitors came out one-by-one to little or no reaction. It gave the impression that Foley didn't have any idea who they were, which immediately set the division on the back foot. Foley is a wrestling fan and an avid viewer of WWE content by the looks of things, so there's no way he would have been ignorant to the names.
The Cruiserweight Division got the Diva's Revolution treatment of 'here's this thing you want but we need to make it look like our authority figures have instigated it all'. It gave the four men far more work to do than was necessary.
9. The Isolation Of The New World
The brand new cruiserweight division also found itself in that least-enviable of positions: having to start practically from scratch. When you are starting anew in any walk of life every single move you make can have consequences, and this is especially true in the high-octane world of professional wrestling.
WWE has tried to present the cruiserweight division as something totally separate from the rest of RAW, and whilst this idea may be admirable it is also somewhat self-defeating. The junior heavyweights have been left on their own to sink or swim, in a position that no other division has. The tag teams and the women seem to frequently interact with the rest of the RAW Universe, so why not the cruisers?
Not only does RAW have a former Cruiserweight Champion in the shape of Chris Jericho on its roster, it also has a huge number of men who have done battle with the men of the division outside of WWE. Men like Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, Neville (more on him later), and Cesaro have faced Rich Swann, Cedric Alexander, and others before. Integration may be key to the cruisers.
8. There Are No Characters
You don't introduce characters by having your General Manager read their names and personality traits off of a piece of paper. He may as well have been saying 'Wrestler A is...', 'Wrestler B has...' and the rest. The live audience isn't given any reason to care, and unless the home audience paid attention to the CWC it wouldn't care either.
As of right now, Brian Kendrick is the only competitor in the cruiserweight division that has a character, and even that is 'I'm older than you all and don't have many chances left'. The WWE audience isn't the PWG audience, and they will need to be given backstories and something approaching gimmicks.
I'm not asking for Cedric Alexander to become a samurai or Tony Nese to start portraying a character similar to Frank Sobotka from The Wire, but the division has been sorely lacking in personality so far. WWE wouldn't just throw its favourites out to sink or swim - why do it with these guys?
7. Casual Fans Don't Like Wrestling
The previous point comes from a bigger issue with WWE and the way we view it. There is a reason Chris Jericho is a bigger name than Lance Storm, why Eddie Guerrero was a bigger star than Dean Malenko, and why Legion of Doom succeeded where Furnas & LaFon failed: the casual WWE fan isn't really interested in professional wrestling.
That isn't to say they don't care, of course not, but the men and women who make up the bulk of the audience are more interested in personality and promo as opposed to 'ranas and wrist-locks. Ric Flair is always going to be a bigger star than Tully Blanchard or Arn Anderson, and it is all down to his style.
The men who make up the cruiserweight division on RAW are all tremendous professional wrestlers, but being good at the technical stuff doesn't mean success in the eyes of the industry leader.
6. The Watered-Down Style
Those hoping to see the same style of wrestling that we enjoyed in the Cruiserweight Classic on RAW have been greatly disappointed. Whilst the pace hasn't slowed down to a complete halt, it has gone down a notch from the 32-man competition, and the crowd responses are suffering as a result.
To date, the live audiences have only really responded to the odd piece of impressive athleticism. If the unique selling point of a division is the style of wrestling, does it not guarantee failure to curb that style from the get-go? It makes absolutely no sense.
By handcuffing the performers you are only ever going to be shooting yourself in the foot. It all adds up to misplaced paranoia on the part of the agents too, as the men they have signed are clearly wise enough to work to their crowd. Brian Kendrick and Rich Swann aren't exactly going to go out and work a Jack Evans vs. Teddy Hart highspot extravaganza.
Even so, just by hinting at restrictions, WWE has hampered the cruiserweight division from the start.
5. The Style Isn't Special Anymore
When WCW introduced its cruiserweight division way back when, the reason for its popularity was how darn special it was. As a young fan, until Juventud Guerrera, Rey Mysterio, Super Calo, and Psychosis arrived I'd never seen springboards, 'ranas, and the rest. They brought something brand new to the table, and stood out as a result.
In 2016, this simply isn't the case. In 1996, you weren't going to see Hulk Hogan or Lex Luger perform anything high-octane, but in the modern age highly athletic wrestling is the norm. Suicide dives are spammed to the point of irrelevance with the big boys. Why would I be excited about Rich Swann doing it?
In the years the cruiserweight division was absent, we've seen the style brought into the main event by Daniel Bryan, Seth Rollins, CM Punk, Rey Mysterio, and more. Cruiserweight wrestling isn't special enough in WWE to justify an entire division anymore.
4. The Wrong Inaugural Champion
The new cruiserweight division needed a bright star as its inaugural champion, someone to drag the division into the new era and immediately make the championship belt seem like the most important thing on the planet. It needed a smash hit, a can't-miss option. Instead, it got TJ Perkins.
Now this isn't meant to be a slight on TJ Perkins. TJP has been around the block a number of times and is referred to as wrestling's youngest veteran for good reason. He is a damn fine professional wrestler, but it is difficult to deny that he isn't exactly thrilling.
Many companies have been reluctant to go ahead with Perkins as their top guy, so WWE choosing him to spearhead the new cruiserweight division seems truly puzzling. WWE had an abundance on options, yet it went with its blandest.
3. Classic WWE Shoehorning
WWE doesn't have a good track record at all when it comes to exclusive divisions. The cruiserweight division has already fallen into the same traps as others, to the point where cruiserweight matches on RAW now already feel like 'oh here's the cruiserweight bit'.
Multiple wrestlers are getting thrown into short segments with no real rhyme or reason, looking aesthetically different but not offering anything outside of that. The cruiserweight division has become something if an anonymous mesh, a group of junior heavyweights bumping into each other in a bright purple shell.
They come out, they wrestle, they leave. There is no room for them to breathe. Messrs. Gulak, Nese, Swann, Alexander et al have their specially-designated time-frame in which to go out and wow an audience, with little help from those whose entire job it is to create narratives for them.
It didn't work for the old Diva's division, and it isn't going to work for the cruiserweight division.
2. Where Is Neville?
It seemed oh so obvious - a surefire way to get over the cruiserweight division and the championship from the get-go. TJ Perkins comes out on the first RAW after the Cruiserweight Classic for a championship celebration, to establish him as the top guy in the division. His celebration is interrupted by Neville, and an instant feud over the title is born.
It isn't just Neville either. WWE and the cruiserweight division would benefit hugely from some established names entering the division and wanting a piece of the action. Neville, Sami Zayn, Enzo Amore, Xavier Woods, and Sin Cara could all feasibly be a part of the division, and you can't tell me that Neville (or any of the others) wouldn't be a better fit for the face of the purple world.
Instead, the former Adrian finds himself losing to Bo Dallas in no time whatsoever in order to further a Dallas/Curtis Axel program. Go figure.
1. WWE And Cruiserweight Wrestling Don't Mix
My final point is the most pessimistic of all, but probably the main one that needs making: WWE just has an abysmal history when it comes to booking cruiserweight wrestling. I can't think of a single time a cruiserweight division was booked in any sort of way that had any lasting significance in WWE, and I'm not just talking about Hornswoggle's well-documented final 'reign'.
Rey Mysterio and Chavo Guerrero feuded over the title during which Chavo's dad won the belt. Gregory Helms held the belt for over a year, and had a grand total of zero memorable stories and defences. Jacqueline was champion for 12 days, before losing the belt back to Chavo (who had one hand tied behind his back).
Until the death of Eddie Guerrero, traditional cruiserweights had little chance of upward movement in WWE. Sure, Guerrero and Chris Jericho won world championships in the company, but this was long after they had transcended the weight division and bulked up considerably.
Until shown evidence to the contrary, WWE will always book cruiserweight wrestling as a distraction at best, a comedic sideshow at worst. Vince McMahon and cruiserweight wrestling simply don't mix.