10 Regrettable Wrestling Revamps

It takes courage to embrace change. Especially if that change is for the worse.

the shockmaster
WWE.com

The business of pro wrestling has long been the home of ridiculous gimmicks, outrageous outfits, and general wall-to-wall insanity. The over the top nature of the industry is an accepted part of the product and is what keeps fans coming back for more.

However, promoters don’t always get it right when they come up with a new persona, and what looks good on paper can often be disastrous in execution. Pro wrestling has seen countless gimmicks over the years, from abbots to zombies and everything in between, which makes it infinitely more difficult to be original. More importantly, it makes it harder still for that originality to be good.

From the LOD-branded Heidenreich and yellow-toothed Gene Snitsky to making Nick Dinsmore portray Eugene and Jimmy Wang Yang becoming a Japanese cowboy, WWE have tried a lot over the past decade to repackage wrestlers under new gimmicks. However, the success is more often than not very limited.

Nevertheless, main event stars like Dolph ZIggler and Bray Wyatt are living proof that a new name and fresh look can translate to success. Sadly for the ten men in this list, that was not the case.

10. Jim Neidhart - Who

Jim Neidhart Who
WWE

When talking dubious debuts, who better to start with? Who - that’s who! Oh forget it...

Born out of an Abbott and Costello joke gone too far (“Who’s on first?” for those interested), the masked gimmick of the man they call Who was a legitimate thing in WWF in 1996, proving once again that Vince McMahon was as out of touch as a pensioner in an Apple Store.

Who was actually former tag champion and Hart Family legend, Jim 'The Anvil' Neidhart. Wearing a mask and gaudy yellow trunks, The Anvil's newest persona seemed to exist solely as a vehicle for “who?” jokes on commentary. Sadly without the aid of a crack pipe, it was clear to see that the gimmick made about as much sense as the Ultimate Warrior in a baseball hat. Oh wait...

To give an idea of context at the time, Steve Austin had just won the King of the Ring two weeks earlier and WCW would form the New World Order the very next night at Bash of the Beach 1996. All of which asks the question once again: what in name of Mantaur was WWE thinking?

Luckily, Neidhart would return the following year to round off his WWF career in style with the brilliant reformation of the Hart Foundation, and the whole gimmick was forgotten.


9. Terry Gordy - The Executioner

Terry Gordy Executioner
WWE

Continuing the trend of mid-90s gimmick garbage, The Executioner was the WWF’s attempt to create credible opposition for The Undertaker during a period where pickings were slimmer than the Gobbledy Gooker’s legs.

Having already feuded with WWF mainstays, Mabel and Yokozuna, Undertaker was programmed with Mankind in a fantastic detour from the usual limited big men he was shackled to. Realising that ‘Taker and Mankind couldn’t feud forever, WWF made moves to create a successor and The Executioner was born.

Not to be confused with Buddy Rose’s Executioner at the first WrestleMania, The Executioner of 1996 was actually legendary Fabulous Freebird Terry Gordy underneath the hood. Gordy made his debut interfering in the “Buried Alive” match at In Your House 11, hitting ‘Taker with a shovel and burying him with the help of several others.

Ironically, the act would be repaid in full the following month, as ‘Taker soundly defeated The Executioner in an “Armageddon Rules” match, Goldust defeated him on Superstars, and Paul Bearer turned on him by striking him with the urn. Gordy would round off his WWF tenure with three straight tag losses to Bulldog and Owen, topping off a pretty sound wrestling burial if ever there was one.


8. Barry Windham - The Stalker

Barry Windham Stalker
WWE

As a former WCW Champion, legendary member of the Four Horseman and all-round wrestling great, Barry Windham had some serious wrestling pedigree when he entered the World Wrestling Federation in 1996. Despite these undeniable credentials, WWF completely denied his them by making him The Stalker.

Windham soon found himself decked out in camouflage like an extra from a Chuck Norris B-Movie. Bizarrely billed as being from “The Environment”, The Stalker was presented as a predatory hunter - supposedly based on serial killer Richard Ramirez - eyeing up the rest of the roster as his supposed prey. Notwithstanding the creepy sexual connotations, the gimmick itself absolutely stunk.

Speaking of stink, his opponent in his debut match was coincidentally TL Hopper, the hygienically-challenged plumber. Hopper was also an '80s star himself, formerly known as Dirty White Boy, now repackaged in mid-90s gimmick sludge. But that’s a another story for another time.

As if all that wasn’t enough, The Stalker also happened to have some of the worst entrance music known to man. Snapping the final string on his ever decreasing pro wrestling bow, Windham’s wrestling output was also limited mainly to strikes, with enough back elbows to earn him a yellow belt at any YMCA.

All in all, a pretty solid effort by McMahon and co to reduce one of the NWA’s best wrestlers to an elbow-toting, face-painted eco-warrior.


7. Goldust - Black Reign

Goldust Black Reign
WWE/ImpactWrestling

When Dustin Rhodes made his way to the World Wrestling Federation in 1995, he took an outrageous gimmick and made it into gold, establishing the provocative Goldust character as a revolutionary persona in mid-90s WWF.

However, as Axl Rose once said, “Nothing lasts forever, even cold November Rain." Runnels must have misheard those lyrics as, when Goldust ran its course, he debuted in TNA as Black Reign in 2007.

The Black Reign gimmick was like looking at a negative photo of Goldust. Decked out in black and silver with a black wig, Runnels new character was essentially a darker, sadistic version of his previous persona. As such, he was utilised predominantly in hardcore matches and extreme rule variants, including the “Shop of Horrors” bout, “Match of 10,000 Tacks”, and the “Monster’s Ball”.

While the character had some promise to it, Black Reign was drowning in unnecessary gimmicks, including his “Darkness Falls” weapon (which was essentially a spike on a stick) and his pet rat, Misty. The latter would even result in what was essentially a “Rat on a Pole” match. No, seriously...

Thankfully, Runnels would quietly leave TNA in 2008 and return to WWE soon after, notably without a rat, spike on a stick, or a black wig in sight.


6. Barry Darsow - Repo Man

Smash Repo Man
WWE

To go from one of the longest reigning tag team champions in WWF history to one of the worst gimmicks in history is quite the downgrade; however, for Barry Darsow, that’s exactly what happened in 1991.

Having had a solid career up to that point, as Krusher Khruschev in NWA and Demolition Smash in WWF, it was quite the U-turn when he began repossessing cars and brandishing a tow rope as The Repo Man. However, the concept was apparently the idea of Darsow himself, who had actually worked as a legit repo man prior to entering the wrestling business. Talk about loading the gun that kills you...

Making his historic TV debut against the formidable assault of Reno Riggins on Superstars, Repo Man got off to a winning start. Remarkably, he would go unpinned on TV for four months and have quite a successful 1992; however, he did come up short each time he stepped on the big stage, with his most prolific loss coming to Crush at SummerSlam ‘92.

Despite being an experienced repo man by trade, Darsow couldn’t steal himself a victory by '93 and spent the majority of the year looking at the ceiling lights. He would make a memorable return to the WWF in 2001 as part of the Gimmick Battle Royal... where he was first out, eliminated in seconds by Michael “P.S”. Hayes.


5. Owen Hart - The Blue Blazer

Owen Hart Blue Blazer
WWE

Perhaps the most regrettable revamp in the history of wrestling, the WWF’s decision to repackage Owen Hart as the Blue Blazer was both questionable and tragic.

Despite earning a stellar reputation for himself over the course of the '90s, Owen was told to revert back to his Blue Blazer character in late 1998. Having worn the mask during his initial run in WWF a decade earlier - including an appearance at WrestleMania V - it was an odd move to have such a popular performer revisit a gimmick prior to his success.

Nevertheless, ever the company man, Owen agreed and made his return to WWF TV as the Blue Blazer in November. Encouraging fans to “say their prayers, take their vitamins, and drink their milk”, Owen got the Blazer over as a dorky heel with his clean cut antics.

Sadly, the gimmick would ultimately prove fatal. In an attempt to parody the superhero-like entrance of WCW’s Sting, Owen fell to his death at Over the Edge in May 1999.

The Blazer gimmick was often rumoured to be punishment for Owen turning down an on-screen love triangle angle between himself, Jeff Jarrett, and Debra. While this rumour has never truly been confirmed, the heartbreaking results remain making this revamp truly regrettable.


4. Chavo Guerrero - Kerwin White

Chavo Guerrero Kerwin White
WWE

When you have a family name with history, integrity, and an iron-clad legacy in the wrestling business, it seems logical to play up to that background and push a star to the moon based on that existing heritage.

Sadly, the wrestling business doesn’t always submit to logic. Why push someone on the basis of tradition when you can repackage them as the exact opposite? That’s exactly what happened in 2005, when Chavo Guerrero re-surfaced as Kerwin White.

Chavo Gu... Kerwin White made his debut riding to the ring on a golf cart, wrapped in a cardigan sweater to the sounds of Frank Sinatra. Sporting a blonde haircut, the middle-class KW was right at home in the mid-card, renouncing his Latino heritage and declaring himself “The great White hope”.

Closing with the line “If it ain’t White, it ain’t right”, WWE crashed through the line of racial sensitivity like a drunk falling into a sand castle. As African-American commentator, Jonathan Coachman, voiced his concern, the crowd was left in awe and the viewing audience at home stunned.

The gimmick would continue for a number of months until the untimely passing of Chavo’s uncle, Eddie Guerrero. The death of Eddie was a wake up call to WWE and Chavo promptly returned to being the proud Guerrero he always was.


3. Shane Douglas - Dean Douglas

Shane Dean Douglas
WWE

Shane Douglas was the talk of the wrestling industry in the mid-90s. A fantastic wrestler with a great look and enough attitude to launch an extreme revolution, Douglas was on the rocket ship to superstardom.... until that rocket crash landed in Connecticut.

WWF had a penchant at the time for assigning gimmicks reflective of a wrestler’s previous career. As such, Douglas - a qualified economics and history teacher - was immediately given a gown and renamed Dean Douglas, a supposed college dean. Complete with introductory classroom vignettes, 'The Franchise' was no more and class was well and truly in session.

The gimmick screamed mediocrity from the get-go and was laced with enough cheese to fill a lifetime’s supply of Big Macs. As such, the fiery former 'Franchise' of ECW had been reduced to corny, mid-card WrestleCrap more akin to The Godwins, Duke 'The Dumpster' Droese, and The Goon, than the company of Shawn Michaels, Bret Hart, and Razor Ramon where he belonged.

It was a criminal waste of Douglas’ talents and, despite an 11 minute run as IC Champion at In Your House 4, Douglas was gone by the close of In Your House 5. Luckily, Douglas resurfaced in ECW in early ‘96 and 'The Franchise' was back in business once more.


2. Terry Taylor - The Red Rooster

Terry Taylor Red Rooster
WWE

As far as drawing the short straw in wrestling goes, there aren’t many gimmicks that are quite as bad as Terry Taylor’s “Red Rooster”.

Before he made the jump to WWF, Terry Taylor was a successful mat technician in the NWA, UWF, and World Class. Like most successful mat technicians of the '80s, WWF gave him a dud gimmick and sent him out the curtain like a lamb to the slaughter... or, in this case, a chicken to the abattoir.

Crowing like a rooster during his promos, Taylor was certainly very successful in presenting himself as a c**k on global television. Unfortunately for him, it was more in the derogatory definition, rather than the barnyard term.

Needless to say, the gimmick bombed and Taylor left for WCW in 1990. After a successful two year respite to lick his feathery wounds, Taylor returned to the WWF in late ‘92; however, his first run as the “Red Rooster” was so disastrous that it even ruined his second run with the company.

As a result, “Terrific” Terry Taylor was never taken seriously and, with a career in the WWF seemingly dead in the water, 'The Rooster' would return home to...well, roost. Taylor retreated back to WCW where he would largely remain until they closed in 2001.


1. Typhoon - The Shockmaster

Typhoon The Shockmaster
WWE

There are few names in the wrestling industry as infamous as The Shockmaster. Shocking by name, shocking by nature, the debut of The Shockmaster is as memorable as it is hilarious.

No stranger to gimmicks, Fred Ottman was the man behind the glitter painted helmet of The Shockmaster. While “glitter painted helmet” could be the title of a camp adult film in its own right, it pales in comparison to the other names he was given prior to WCW.

From Sigfried the Giant and Bubba the Belt Collector to US Steel and even Big Steel Man, euphemistic names were a theme of Ottman’s early career. Naturally, he would go on to his biggest success in the WWF as Tugboat. Ahem...

Nevertheless, by the time Ottman made it to WCW, things were going to change forever for the Natural Disaster as Ottman prepared to shock the world. No doubt about it, that he certainly did. Blasting through the set of Flair for Gold in 1993, The Shockmaster exploded onto the scene like a typhoon. Unlike a typhoon, everyone around broke down into hysterics that continues to this day.

Despite WCW’s attempts to roll with the punches and repackage him as a bumbling oaf, the image of Ottman hitting the deck, face first was immortal the moment it happened.

Truly shocking indeed.


In this post: 
Goldust
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Occasional wrestler, full-time gym rat and lifelong lover of the grapple game. Would probably buy you a shot of Jack at the bar in exchange for witty banter...and preferably more Jack. @MartynGrant88 for more wrestling-related musings and weight room wisecracks!