10 Rejected Wrestler Names WWE ACTUALLY Pitched
"You call yourself a Gorilla but you're out here hee-hawing like a jack*ss!"
"Getting stupid stuff over" is company policy now more than ever before.
It's WWE's take on the big lie; tell something long and loud enough and through sheer force of will it'll become true. In the company's case, they just force their own garbled lexicon on everybody until it's easier to just except it. Wrestler names are not immune to the phenomenon.
"Dolph Ziggler" was the old go-to for this, but look how long he's stuck around and how even longer it's been since anybody mentioned how daft that moniker is. "The Viking Experience" nearly killed The War Raiders, but the mix of the two somehow salvaged yet another impending calamity. The given first name of the guy set to one day run the company is Triple.
WWE pays teams of people to come up with names that can be crossed out by Vince McMahon when he thinks of something even worse. Where better to start than with one of the more infamous examples for one of wrestling's most famous stars?
10. Chilly McFreeze / Otto Von Ruthless / Ice Dagger / Fang McFrost (Stone Cold Steve Austin)
WWE seem to love this story, oblivious to the fact that it removes them from the origin story of one of their most important figures.
It's well known and well-told, but Steve Austin wanted something akin to the chilling serial killer Richard Kuklinski when he asked for a temperature-based tone to replace The Ringmaster. What he got was right out of the worst excesses of the company's cartoonish instincts. The repetition of the "Mc" sound is funny, but saddling your toughest, cruellest character with "Ice Dagger" before he even gets over with the gimmick is no laughing matter.
The second part of all this was Austin's then-wife telling him to drink his tea before it went "Stone Cold" - a lightbulb moment for the pair of them that was both awesome in its aura and packed with the alliterative powers Vince McMahon loves to market.
Much like the Austin 3:16 promo, this wasn't in WWE's script.
9. Mason The Mutilator (Mankind)
A feature of the stunning illustrations for his character Mick Foley first shared in his awesome first autobiography, Mason The Mutilator was one of several the company drafted before a compromise with Foley himself landed on Mankind.
Jim Ross has noted before how he really had to "sell" Cactus Jack to Vince McMahon, and it's likely that the Chairman assumed he was getting an actual human being adjacent to the WCW/ECW wild man he'd presumably been forced to see some footage of. A caged, locked up maniac was the image that went with the original moniker which - much like the aforementioned ideas for Steve Austin - were so married to a daft gimmick that they were doomed from the start.
Mankind, much like the original version of the character, was extremely ambiguous and subverted the word's everyman quality by played with the literal. 'The Deranged One' was anything but the pleasant human he'd been uniquely billed as.
8. Reginald DuPont Helmsley (Triple H)
Really, is Reginald DuPont Helmsley that much further from the name WWE ultimately settled on, or the reality of what became of his name once he managed to convince the company to just let him go with the abbreviated version instead?
Hunter Hearst Helmsley was some cartoon villain alliteration for some cartoon villain times, but looked good on a spotlight being reflected onto the canvas, or in magazines that still wanted to put the capital letters in luminous yellow. Reginald DuPont Helmsley could have eventually been shortened to RDH and - in the spirit of many of the guys he hires today - would have suited the post-2010 superworker era of indie wrestling. It's proof really that anything, including 'The Game's original moniker can stick given long enough to cling on.
Any long name indicative of his former gimmick needed to go the second his relationship with Shawn Michaels moved to the other side of the curtain. He'd been established as Triple H by commentators enough in the past that the shift was relatively easy.
7. The Mastodon (Vader)
You'd be forgiven for thinking that's what Vader was called in WWE, considering how much Vince McMahon called him this every time he was on screen anyway.
It's funny to listen back to those calls with the benefit of hindsight. McMahon, the gaffer, doing whatever he wants and what he obviously felt quite deeply by beating viewers over the head with his bizarre nickname, as if this psycho killer he'd just signed was actually an...extinct...elephant...thing?
We all know now of The Chairman's penchant for dinosaur bones after that hulking great T-Rex head gifted to him by Triple H finally made it on to pay-per-view at Money In The Bank 2020, but his presumable dislike for name is only matched by his obvious adoration for his own creation. End result "Vader" was of course shortened from the full "Big Van Vader" he'd gone by for the bulk of his career, itself a monument for McMahon's stubbornness and need to own as much of his performers as he can.
6. Hirohito (Kenzo Suzuki)
Eesh.
Kenzo Suzuki was a flawed project from the very beginning as the mid-2000s threw more sh*t at the wall to try and get over underneath the scant few performers Jim Cornette had kindly readied for megastardom in his famously stacked OVW class of 2002.
For every John Cena and Batista there were about 20 guys WWE either signed or failed profoundly to develop as the next ones. Japanese star (and occasional tag team partner of Hiroshi Tanahashi, who nearly came on board instead) Kenzo Suzuki was ultimately the latter, but almost lost his real name to the horrifically misguided one above when he stepped bravely into the the parts unknown that was and is Sports Entertainment.
A single promo snuck online to highlight just how much very real and painful history would have been drilled into with the character before the company saw sense and let him go with what they eventually settled on. That his run was so unremarkable highlighted just how disastrous the name could have been - the company would have welcomed completely unnecessary controversy, all for a midcarder that wasn't even an effective fit.
5. Riot & Rage (Edge & Christian)
To the man himself for some memories of WWE's desperation to give him a one-word name and gimmick that they themselves didn't exactly understand.
Speaking to Sean Mooney on his podcast in 2018, he said, "No one had any idea. Including me, honestly..So at one point it was thrown around that I was going to be a deaf mute. I was just going to be this guy. This ‘angry guy’ and I thought ‘oh my gosh what do I do with that?’ Talk about dead in the water. There’s nowhere to go there...Initially Edge was just supposed to be this - I was told - a tortured soul. I just finished a dark match. I didn’t think it through in terms of the cadence of a crowd being able to chant that. I shot myself in the foot there, but it was better than ‘Rage’ or ‘Riot’ which were their two ideas".
Edge and Christian didn't still didn't get that promo time as members of The Brood until they left Gangrel's side in 1999, but "Riot" and "Rage" probably wouldn't have gotten away with the hijinks that got them all the way over year later - nothing says tortured souls quite like kazoos and streamers.
4. Buddy Peacock (Daniel Bryan)
A break for WWE's creative heads now, if not the processes themselves.
Buddy Peacock is a ridiculously lame wrestling name, as unremarkable as Michael McGillicutty or Braden Walker, but somehow even more a p*ss take of the company's wretched recent history labelling their talent. As if the mind thinking it up might actually have been trolling those that had asked for one in the first place. It almost certainly was.
As if he's not already proven this hundreds of times over in his remarkable decade-long stay with the company, Bryan's a polymath. He can do it all between the ropes and on the microphone, with a patter game behind the scenes as impressive as the physical gifts he's shared with the world.
Bryan submitted 10 names himself as per the company's request, before landing on the surname switch via William Regal. He later told Chris Jericho on his podcast that Peacock was his favourite, along with Lloyd Boñier, ("pronounced as boner") before Daniel Bryan was the agreed-upon answer.
3. Shrug Shadow (Razor Ramon)
Scott Hall preyed on Vince McMahon's lack of cultural awareness when he aped Tony Montana in front of The Chairman, scoring the character that rapidly became one of the most vital presences on on a diverse and ever-changing roster in 1992. He just shouldn't have shrugged his shoulders in his impersonation.
The Chairman adored the moxie of it all and couldn't wait to produce the vignettes that ultimately aired of 'The Bad Guy' being a total piece of sh*t to everybody in his orbit ahead of an in-ring debut. But what about his name?
McMahon's fondness for alliteration was back again, and just days removed from Hall batting back some pretty awful pitches, wrestling apocrypha has it that Razor Ramon spawned from Road Warrior Hawk's starting suggestion Deadbolt and a conversation of what might go well with "Razor" with Tito Santana. But what of those aforementioned horror shows? The future 'Outsider' needed what he'd stumbled upon - "Shrug Shadow" would have been a tough sell, even for WWE's coolest customer.
2. Adam Hole (Mr Kennedy)
John Laurinaitis signed the wrong one-legged wrestler, took Jim Ross' remarkable Talent Relations legacy and lost an entire generation of wrestlers with his own warped version of it, and once pitched Adam Hole as a wrestler's name because it would read like "A-Hole" and that might make a few people laugh once.
The creative team had agreed that Ken Anderson was an a*shole, see, and, in conjunction with Anderson himself all got together to try and label a performer that was fast becoming a Vince McMahon pet project.
Jim Ross revealed Laurinaitis' inane suggestion during an episode of his podcast centred around the man that eventually became Mr Kennedy. The name - inspired by McMahon's middle name - would have taken on greater significance had the company managed to get through the father and son storyline between them in the middle of a nightmarish 2007. Utlimately, it became something Kennedy had to leave behind when he departed WWE two years later.
Something about the original pitch must have stuck too - Mr Anderson embraced being an a*shole as a key part of his persona upon signing with TNA.
1. Space Corps Holly (Bob Holly)
It just f*cking rhymes man.
Explaining away a long absence from television when Hardcore Holly returned to television in 2006, somebody within WWE apparently thought a change might be in order to help the Attitude Era hanger-on blend in more with this new Sci-Fi C-brand. This itself is laughable - Holly was returning to Extreme Championship Wrestling, a brand that suited his old gimmick perfectly even if the show was a mutated version of Paul Heyman's legendary brainchild.
But mutated it was, and as evidenced by the zombie that got battered by The Sandman and various rumours about aliens landing in an ECW ring one week. From this strange, strange time, Space Corps Holly snuck out as a possible next move for the hard-as-nails Alabaman. The backstory had him going to NASA during his long injury break, and returning with his colleague - a f*cking monkey - in a giant astronauts suit.
Presumably he'd take off the gear to wrestle in, but it sadly never made it past the poor, poor drawing board. Whole thing sucked anyway.