10 Secrets To A Guaranteed POP In Wrestling
Dead crowds are all too common in wrestling these days. This list might help...
Getting over isn't easy.
It can take years, plural, and in most cases it does.
Consider Steve Austin; a combination of his talent, drive, the balls and agency with which he overcame dire booking, and the WWF finally grasping a seismic cultural shift elevated him to megastar status. Wrestling Observer Newsletter readers and wise industry minds like Paul Heyman in 1990 and 1992 respectively knew that had the tools to get there one day, but it took nearly a decade for those holding the booking pencil to recognise it.
The talent themselves need the experience to develop the know-how.
Sometimes it can take a while for even the most talented wunderkind wrestlers to shed the midcard-leaning areas of their game. Using Will Ospreay as an example, who used to howl with agony every time he took a bump on his neck a few years ago, sometimes a wrestler overcorrects things for which they have been criticised before learning how to show and not tell.
Getting over and mastering one's craft is a slow and complex process, even for those destined to be great.
Or is it...?
10. Getting The Tables
Picture the scene.
It's a Monday night. WWE is several weeks away from promoting a Premium Live Event. There isn't a great deal going on, which means Triple H - who at the time of writing, anyway, still has the book - is going to phone this Raw in. There's no need to do anything massive, there's major competition on cable, and so he's going to indulge in his favourite pastime: unreasonably inflating the length of a wrestling match in hopes that his stans will hop online and deem it a "banger".
It's Dominik Mysterio Vs. Karl Anderson, no disqualifications, in front of a mausoleum of a crowd in some backwoods market or other. Nobody gives a single toss as the 12th minute of generic nothing action approaches. A smattering of "We want tables!" chants go unheard until the 17th minute, and then, when "Bright Lights" draws one from under the ring, the fans go bonkers. Doesn't matter how sh*tty the match is. Doesn't matter that they don't care about anything else. This is a generation of passive fans who have been programmed to go wild at the admittedly very satisfying sound of compressed sawdust exploding.
That's obviously snark, but it isn't even hyperbole; at Hell In A Cell last year, for a couple of depressing moments, it didn't matter that Cody Rhodes, his body bruised internally to a disgusting extent, was entering the most heroic performance of almost anyone's life.
When he was about to eat a table, those fans turned f*cking feral.
9. Removing An Article Of Clothing
A generation of wrestling fans, those who make up a not inconsiderable part of the audience these days, was raised on Hulk Hogan tearing off his yellow vest and conveying his vast, super-heroic power to the audience.
As that audience matured (grew pubes), Vince McMahon realised that booking women to show off their skin would also allow that audience to react. Of course, Jerry Lawler was 49 years old in 1998 and didn't have the "excuse" of being a hormonally ravaged teen, but Sable was 31 in 1998, so it was all performative.
It wasn't just the pimpled, N64-playing, Sunny D-quaffing boys who delighted in this sort of thing amid the Attitude Era; the squeals of women were heard all throughout arenas when Jeff Hardy took his top off to get his demented aerial stunts all the way over. But it was mostly the lads, let's face it.
Though nowhere near on the same scale, Angel Garza initially got over as one of the few highlights of the early NXT on USA era by, midway through his matches, removing his tights, throwing them at his foes, and working the rest of his matches in trunks.
Kazuchika Okada generated one of the loudest pops in the history of New Japan Pro Wrestling by switching from flared trousers to his classic trunks in 2019.
It's not particularly big nor clever, but it is relatively over, or rather was in 1998: truly, the Road Dogg of in-ring secrets.
8. Saying The Word "Sh*t"
Human beings are simultaneously very complex and very simple.
In a warped way, it's almost wholesome, or reassuring, that people still clutch the pearls or express shock when they hear the word "sh*t" in a public setting. It means that the fabric of society and the conduct expected within it hasn't yet frayed into outright anarchy, which quite frankly would be thoroughly justified. Saying the word "sh*t" on national television has been permissible for several years at this point - they even drop "c*nts" on It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia now - but it's a no-no in school and in the workplace.
When a wrestler in AEW - and it's always AEW, let's face it - says the word "sh*t", it is guaranteed to generate a reaction.
"I'm going to beat the living sh*t out of you!"
"You haven't done sh*t since you got here!"
"You're a piece of sh*t!"
"You're sh*tty!"
Can they say that?
They can, because they do so virtually every single week, but it still evokes a big massive "Ooooh!" reaction. The word "sh*t" has somehow retained the power to momentarily turn everybody into Mary Whitehouse, and virtually every AEW wrestler is brazen in their quest to wield its power.
7. Saying The Word "B*tch"
"Crap" doesn't work.
It's a lamewad way of saying "sh*t". Fans know that there's a better word. So that's out. Unless it's New Japan Pro Wrestling, saying the words "c*nt" and or "f*ck" are verboten.
Nobody on AEW TV has chanced a "tw*t" yet, but given how happy the average wrestler is to grab low-hanging fruit, it's extremely likely that, if it were allowed, you'd have heard a heel say "Your personality is as dry as nun's tw*t" on Dynamite by now.
Jungle Boy apparently got in trouble for calling Christian Cage "a p*ssy", so that's also off the table. Cody Rhodes once said "d*ck" - once - but nobody has said "c*ck", so all references to a penis are outlawed as well. Then again, Tony Schiavone frequently calls MJF a "pr*ck". Rick Ross said that Keith Lee is a "big motherf*cker", which won't happen again.
Does anybody say "You're an a**hole"? It's not altogether common. The options for a cheap expletive pop are limited.
So what's left?
Why, the word "Bitch!" of course.
It's eternal. The hard "B" sound adds emphasis to the disrespect. It's fun to say and listen to.
A wrestler can get themselves in superb cardiovascular condition and perfect their difficult craft over a painstaking span of years, but most of the time they're not as over as a consonant.
6. Insulting The Local Sports Team
Certain ancient wrestlers will harp on relentlessly about the lost art of getting heat.
It isn't lost because this generation of talent isn't as good as Bully Ray, whose means of drawing a reaction was saying things along the lines of "Your c*nt aunt bathed my balls with her tongue you [horrendous slur]".
It is lost because people don't really care about much anymore, desensitised as they are by the conveyor belt of horror that is everyday life. People either can't bring themselves to care, or care too much about their escapist fantasy as a coping mechanism, and develop parasocial relationships with the people involved. Ultimately, a Twitter user is more likely to get a toxic reaction for burying a wrestler than the rival with whom that wrestler is feuding.
But mostly, when the heel mocks the babyface, the reaction is at best performative. It's amusing half the time. With rare exceptions, the psyche of the general public is out of step with wrestling's traditional method of evoking emotion.
Unless!
The fans really feel something, still, when their local sports team gets insulted. Sport is real, closely bonded to the DNA of those who love it as a family tradition, and makes up their regional identity. It really hurts when the local team fails, it penetrates the calloused husk developed across this hellscape of a century, and even the most basic heels grasp this.
5. Saying Something Reprehensible
A massive thank you to the pro wrestlers who sacrifice their bodies for the entertainment of millions is probably overdue - thanks - but by the same token, the vast majority of them are brazen carnies better approached from a considerable distance.
Picturing their WhatsApp message threads is amusing.
There'll be some boring nuts and bolts stuff in there as they toss around ideas for their upcoming match, but the etiquette of the insult is something else. They have to delicately phrase what they'd like to say as an insult to avoid situations like the one that arose between Eddie Kingston and Sammy Guevara last summer.
How do they approach this?
"Now, I would never dream of suggesting that you're out of shape, but this seems to be the sentiment online. You know how these marks get. All that said, can I call you a fat disgusting blob on TV? It'll get a pop!"
And a pop it does get, which is why it happens. And the thing is, a wrestler is considered a mark for themselves if they don't go along with it, too - which is why you hear things like "Your beloved family member died recently, and that gets me off!", the taboo of which is a veritable pop generator.
4. Executing A Canadian Destroyer (If You Ordinarily Wouldn't)
In a typical week of pro wrestling in 2023, the wrestling fandom will see:
A classic or near-classic match; an unbelievable unscripted promo; a returning or debuting talent; a wrestler pissing blood; a crazed table spot; an MP4 of Komander or El Hijo del Vikingo rewriting the laws of physics with their literally unbelievable aerial work; a promise of yet another great match, like Bryan Danielson Vs. Konosuke Takeshita, set for the week after...
The modern wrestling fan is inundated with brilliance, constantly, across countless facets and genres of the medium. At this point, nothing can be "brought back" as a popular, long-forgotten standard. Enjoy the wrestling world as it exists right now, because it's almost impossible for it to get much better. So how, in the face of this normalised wonder, can a wrestler even hope to get over?
There are no "You don't see that every day" moments left - unless the wrestler is smart about it.
One can always execute a Canadian destroyer - but only if they are one of the 15% of wrestlers who don't include it in their standard repertoire.
It's as much a crowd appeal as wrestling move at this point: sucking up in the coolest way possible. John Cena should have tried it between 2006 and 2014. He didn't, but the very savvy Dustin Rhodes did; in doing so, he got over in early AEW as an anti-bad faith actor willing to respect and mix it up with the new generation of wrestlers to get over with a generation of fans with shifting tastes.
See also: Bad Bunny, who drew a gigantic pop with a destroyer at WrestleMania 37 because it is a complex and athletic move he seemingly had no right to execute.
The destroyer is such a popular move that it has literally altered the wrestling landscape...
3. Bumping On The Apron
The apron isn't the hardest part of the ring. The metal ring post is the hardest part of the ring.
Still, it's all a work, and commentators have insisted that the apron is more or less a concrete floor for so long that the fandom has long accepted it as a fact. And, because fans readily accept its danger, a pro wrestler will bump themselves stupid on the thing knowing that their agony won't be in vain.
The spot/sequence is so popular, in fact, that AEW configured its very ring in order to facilitate as many apron bumps as possible in relatively safe fashion.
The distance between the ropes and the actual, brutal edge of the ring is by design sufficiently large enough for wrestlers to work on it as they would the actual canvas. The illusory structure of the ring enables the talent to appear that they have mastered the impressive art of balance and they bump, in most cases, without quite smacking their heads against the sharp, awful corner.
Moderately worked or otherwise, as much as people (your writer included) complain about excess in wrestling, the apron bump still elicits a guaranteed bump in 2023.
2. Kicking Out Of A Finisher
When all else fails, let somebody kick out of your finish. Works every time.
Unless they're one of the very best professional wrestlers of all time, this is something that the vast majority of pro wrestlers do rather often to chase that high of a molten crowd under their complete control.
Kenny Omega needn't rely on the trick.
The man is such a genius at structuring a match that he doesn't have to do this. He can orchestrate a louder pop by teasing a move, by registering how much the execution of a move is going to be unhinged in its apparent danger before it is even struck. He has perfected the pacing and rhythm of a match so that everything within it matters. Consider the Wrestle Kingdom spot, in which he battered Will Ospreay's head through an unforgiving Japanese table.
It was actually tame, by the standards of the wider match anyway, but the visual was so stunning, and the danger level had been set so high, that it registered as nothing less than the babyface fight of Ospreay's life.
Since few others are this clever, if they want to make a TV match feel big and turn up the volume, the 2.99 kick-out and NXT face hasn't stopped working yet.
Mostly, anyway.
1. Performing A Rare Inter-Gender Spot
This isn't a defence nor criticism of inter-gender wrestling.
It is pointless entering into that debate. It would be preferable to discuss Dax Harwood, William Regal, the ethics of art and Chelsea Green, what Disco Inferno has to say, or whether or not Top Dolla or the Young Bucks wear cooler sneakers. It's impossible to talk about the form without somebody booting off.
It's all risky. Simulated man-on-woman violence is something sponsors will not tolerate, and when the roles are reversed, the conversation takes a phenomenally bleak turn by those who could do with developing meaningful relationships to grasp a better understanding of how the world actually, sadly works.
All that stated, it is a guaranteed pop.
Rhea Ripley is more over than most WWE acts outside of the top stars, and she frequently takes out men. On the November 28, 2022 Raw, Mia Yim executed a body slam on Finn Bálor to an ultra-rare eruption of a Monday night pop. For whatever reason, done sparingly, an inter-gender spot wakes up the dead.
Perhaps that's the point, and something the business can take on as a lesson, even if it isn't applied literally; wrestling is so excessive, in every area between gimmicks, returns, and back and forth high-end action, that something the audience hasn't been exhausted by elicits something loud from them.