10 Shocking Things You Learn Binge Watching Every ECW PPV

ECW's pay-per-view output was nowhere near as good as you remember, sadly.

Jerry Lynn Rob Van Dam ECW Hardcore Heaven 2000
WWE

"Revolutionary" might be the first word that pops into fan minds when asked to describe Paul Heyman's renegade ECW group. The "mad scientist" vibes Heyman had as a leader gave his ragtag bunch of pro wrestling misfits carte blanche to do pretty much anything they wanted.

That freedom and looseness came as a nasty surprise when revisiting every single ECW pay-per-view ever. No, not the WWE-produced stuff - there's no room for that excellent One Night Stand love letter to hardcore faithfuls, or even the 2006 follow up. There's definitely no space for the dire reboot later that year, or any of the supershow output that followed until Vince McMahon ended his extreme experiment in 2010.

Nah, the original stuff is much more interesting.

Heyman produced 22 pay-per-views between 1997-2001. The only one that isn't on WWE Network/Peacock is a co-promoted event with FMW from December '98, so 21 major events go under the microscope here. You might be left reeling by some of the observations too.

Despite being a huge ECW fanboy in the early-2000s, and someone who will always champion the promotion's impact, this writer has some harsh things to say...

10. Barely Legal = Barely Worth It

Taz Sabu
WWE.com

ECW’s first foray onto pay-per-view was not the ass-kicking hello to new customers Paul Heyman wanted it to be. Being brutally honest, it's one of the worst company pay-per-views you can find, and was kinda a lame-duck of a card that struggled to get going before Terry Funk's emotional ending.

Cult classic? Yes. Great show? Nope.

It's clear looking back that Heyman didn't really know how to properly package his rebels on pay-per-view. In highlight form and backed by killer tunes, ECW's product was fabulous. Running feature length bouts and presenting a cohesive card that built neatly from start to finish proved challenging for the boss though.

RVD vs. Lance Storm, Shane Douglas vs. Pitbull #2, Taz vs. Sabu and the main event three-way could all be considered disappointments. Of the quartet, it's Taz vs. Sabu that let the side down most; that was one of ECW's prized feuds, but it didn't translate well to PPV at all.


9. Hardcore Heaven Improved Things Fast

Paul Heyman ECW Jerry Lawler WWE Raw invasion 1997
WWE.com

Thankfully, it didn't take long for Paul E to get it right.

Hardcore Heaven '97 was a vast improvement over Barely Legal's stuttering start. It had some cross-promotional juice going in, and you simply need to see both the build and execution of Jerry Lawler vs. Tommy Dreamer. The way Lawler played WWF incomer was perfect pro wrestling story work.

Supporting bouts like Taz vs. Chris Candido, RVD vs. Al Snow and the three-way main pitting Shane Douglas vs. Sabu vs. Terry Funk were all better than anything on the first show. Heyman managed to blend significant 'ECW vs. The World' storytelling with a platform for his full-time stars.

Things would take a nosedive in terms of quality come November To Remember later in the year, but Hardcore Heaven was well-named and remains worth your time. The fab entrance-facing hard cam angle always conjures up images of classic WWE shows in MSG, albeit on a smaller scale.


8. New Jack’s Matches Are Terrifying To Revisit

New Jack ECW
WWE.com

The subheading for WhatCulture's recap of New Jack's 'Dark Side Of The Ring' episode was: "Prepare to be disturbed". That sums up this fan's thoughts when looking back on some of the wild man's ECW pay-per-view matches during an ultra-violent run.

Jack just never held back.

There was always something oddly intoxicating about hearing ‘Natural Born Killaz’ by Dr. Dre and Ice Cube blaring in the background as this crazed maniac carved up opponents and potentially broke his own legs performing awkward balcony dives. However, WWE's versions of the shows lack that, making his bouts a gritty curiosity for more than anything else.

Some of the steel chair and other weapon shots are f*cking scary to watch today, because they're so reckless and visibly injure wrestlers. New Jack was out of control, and Paul Heyman didn't exactly keep the dude on a short leash creatively.

ECW's approach was thus; 'Jack, do whatever the hell you want. Just make sure everyone comes back through that curtain!'.


7. Sid Was Over In ECW

Sid ECW Squash
WWE.com

ECW fans could be heard shouting anti-WWF and WCW chants countless times on pay-per-view. The promotion's roster was also pelted with harsh, "YOU SOLD OUT!" choruses whenever they inked a deal with one of the big two. Apparently, wanting to get paid on time was a negative.

That hardcore rebellion falls down a bit when one realises just how over Sid was in the organisation. ECW fans loved the former Sycho Sid/Sid Justice/Sid Vicious like he was one of their own, and his three pay-per-view appearances stood out when looking back on every ECW supershow for this write-up.

Sid beat Kronus at Guilty As Charged 1999, then teamed with Little Spike vs. The Dudleyz at Living Dangerously. His final showing was a no contest with Justin Credible at Hardcore Heaven before he rejoined WCW in June for a quite awful run. Paul Heyman’s legendary ability to hide weaknesses and push strengths to the forefront came into play here.

Sid looked like the man in ECW, and the hardcore crowds loved seeing him squash every f*cker in sight.


6. Insider Jibes Come Off As Small Time

Cyrus ECW
WWE.com

You'll hear some industry critics lambast AEW for taking potshots at WWE on programming like Dynamite and Rampage. Generally, it's considered a bad thing if one company takes a swing at the other, although a fair few fans do still get a kick out of these jabs.

ECW became the king of needless digs in the 1990s.

In retrospect, repeatedly hearing commentators like Cyrus (Don Callis) take a pop at both the WWF and WCW made ECW look smalltime. This sort of thing worked during feuds like the aforementioned Jerry Lawler vs. Tommy Dreamer business, but it just didn't fly as a full-time concern.

Also, hearing Joey Styles, Cyrus and others remark about WCW's production values in the late-90s rings hollow when ECW's own grimy feel is actually one of the group's main selling points. So, it was fine for them to be shabby (because they didn't have as much money), but anyone else doing it was wrong?


5. Joey Styles Was Better With A Partner

Joey Styles Joel Gertner ECW
WWE

Right, so this isn't going to go down well.

Think of ECW commentary and you'll think of Joey Styles. He was a one-man announce booth for Paul Heyman, and he impressively carried entire three-hour broadcasts on his own. That shouldn't be overlooked. Also, please note the wording. Styles was "better" with a partner.

He deserves all the credit in the world for flying solo during numerous ECW pay-per-views, but having someone to bounce off of really helped break things up for Styles. Don Callis, in particular, was great heel foil for Joey, and Joel Gertner should be considered underrated as a colour commentator himself.

They enhanced Styles' performances, but crucially didn't try to meet him 50/50. Joey still assumed maybe...70% of the call, then let Callis and Gertner chime in to give his voice a rest. Some of the announcing in 2000, for example, is the best ECW commentary you'll find in the archives.


4. There’s A Hidden Gem You Need To See

Kid Kash EZ Money
WWE Network

Arguably, ECW's TV library (both the TNN stuff and Hardcore TV) is stuffed full of matches that could be considered hidden gems. However, one has always stood out to this pro wrestling fanboy: Kid Kash vs. EZ Money from Anarchy Rulz 2000. What a bloody match that was!

Go check it out ASAP.

The entire show is worth watching, to be honest. AR 2000 might even be the original ECW's most complete pay-per-view offering, but it's Kash vs. Money (ahem) that gets the most love here. These boys put on quite the show, and mixed WCW Cruiserweight stylings with big bumps and outside-the-ring drama featuring a whole string of other characters.

Literally everything Kid and EZ did was crisp from bell to bell. It's clear to see that both men would've been major players for Paul Heyman had ECW continued on beyond early-2001 - they were ready to become the next wave of breakout stars for him.


3. This Forgotten (And Seriously Guff) Segment

Tommy Dreamer Steve Corino ECW
WWE

Remember that earlier whinge about insider jabs and that sort of thing? Well, it became a major problem during Heatwave 1999, but nobody blinked at the time. That in itself is an issue; hardly any of the ECW marks in attendance gave a sh*t about the "controversial" language Tommy Dreamer and Steve Corino were using.

The whole exercise fell flat then.

Dreamer cut an impassioned promo about making ECW the top wrestling company in the world. Then, Corino told him to shut it and said his time was over due to injuries. Then, in a stupid moment, everyone paused the storytelling to go full-on backstage by using phrases like "do the job", "lay down" and "put over".

It was cutting edge at the time, because the WWF and WCW hadn't done a ton of this stuff, but it's fairly cringeworthy to look back on now and defo sucks viewers out of the moment. "Put over" and "do the job" weren't mentioned elsewhere on the card, so there was an immediate disconnect between this promo and everything else.


2. The RVD/Jerry Lynn Stuff Still Holds Up

Jerry Lynn Rob Van Dam ECW Hardcore Heaven 2000
WWE

Some pro wrestlers were made for one another.

Rob Van Dam and Jerry Lynn relished the chance to showcase their quite stunning levels of in-ring chemistry on ECW pay-per-view. The pair worked some bouts for TV too, but it's matches at Living Dangerously and Hardcore Heaven 1999, Heaven in 2000 and Guilty As Charged 2001 that get the most love.

All of them are valid in their own unique ways. RVD and Lynn were really in a groove by the third one - the fourth is maybe a bit weird because it clearly came across as a swansong moment for ECW, but it's still a great watch and acts like a 'Best Of' highlight reel for the prior scraps.

The best thing about all of these matches is that you could stick them on AEW or WWE television today and people would enjoy them. There's nothing dated about the slick chain wrestling exchanges, or RVD's car crash-style bumping spots.


1. There Were Zero Women’s Matches

Dawn Marie Francine
WWE.com

Nobody's trying to make a big deal out of this, or anything, but it's pretty surprising that ECW didn't present at least one female bout on pay-per-view over the years. This isn't even some damning commentary on how women were viewed in the 1990s - it's more that, well...one would've worked.

Francine vs. Beulah, Dawn Marie or Tammy Sytch would've appealed to ECW's audience if it was carefully handled. Those women did work "cat fight" skits with one another over the years, but they were never put in a proper match. Not even a short, gimmicky one.

The only thing that comes close? Francine randomly pinning Steve Corino at Heatwave '99 after that dire "shoot" business with Tommy Dreamer. Looking back, this guy was a little stunned to find out that Heyman didn't stick a serious Japanese women's match on one of these cards, or go the aforementioned "T&A" route.

Francine is the only woman who wrestled on ECW pay-per-view, and it wasn't even in an official match.

What memories do you have of classic ECW pay-per-views? For more wrestling, check out 10 Most Embarrassing Product Placements In Wrestling History and 10 Wrestlers P*ssed At Their WWE 2K23 Rating!


In this post: 
ECW
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.