10 Shocking WWE Plans You Won't Believe Almost Happened

How different the history of the WWE might have been.

Vince McMahon The Undertaker Kane
WWE.com

Despite the on-screen illusion that the WWE product is chaotic and spontaneous, the reality is that everything the WWE produces has been penned by WWE writers and cleared by WWE executive powers at WWE Head Office. Simply put, (basically) everything that has happened on WWE TV has happened because the WWE planned for it to happen.

As a publicly traded company that has to answer to shareholders, the WWE don't want to take any unnecessary risks and micromanage every aspect of their product. Even in the halcyon days of the Attitude Era, where things may have seemed like they had been ad-libbed and off-the-cuff, Vince McMahon himself still had to sit down and approve anything before it went out on the airwaves.

Yet while plans usually unfold without any problems, unforeseen events can sometimes change them or in certain circumstances cancel them altogether. Wrestling injuries, backstage politics and even current affairs have all impacted upon a number of WWE plans that few people ever knew were originally scheduled to take place.

These 'plans' that were meant to happen but never did are the subject of much speculation and debate amongst the wrestling community. After all, it could be argued that had these unused plans played out as intended, the WWE could potentially be an entirely different company to the one that exists today.

Incidentally, you can find these stories and a whole lot more in our acclaimed Shocking Wrestling Plans You Won't Believe Almost Happened, which has been reprinted for Christmas 2021 and made available for the first time in two years at https://whatculture.bigcartel.com/.

shocking plans
whatculture.com

Serving as a perfect Christmas gift for any and all wrestling fans, the book can be found in eBook form at Amazon or in traditional paperback form with over 50 pieces of gorgeous original artwork over at shop.whatculture.com, priced £11.99 and as part of a bundle with the sequel Shocking Wrestling Plans You Won't Believe Actually Happened, priced £20.


10. The Bizarre Plan For Mark Calaway's Debut

The Undertaker is one of, if not the, most recognisable characters in the history of wrestling. The Deadman's supernatural shenanigans, his undeniable presence and dedication to upholding kayfabe ensured that his aura remained intact across his iconic career. The Undertaker was and is a franchise in his own right.

Astonishingly, WWE were originally at a loss as to what gimmick it would give to the man who would later become The Undertaker, Mark Calaway.

It may come as a surprise to read that Calaway was initially planned to debut as The Gobbledy Gooker, before the plan was swiftly dismissed as ridiculous by the WWE Creative Team and shelved indefinitely. After debating whether Calaway should be given a Viking gimmick, it was later decided that he would make his debut at the 1990 Survivor Series as The Undertaker.

If Calaway had suffered the misfortune of having to portray what would become the wholly unpopular Gobbledy Gooker gimmick, it would be safe to assume that his WWE tenure would be a short one. Fortunately the WWE Creative Team decided to drop its bizarre plan and instead opted for him to debut as the morbid Undertaker under the management of 'Brother Love'.

Poor Hector Guerrero, though.


9. The Ground-Breaking Plan For Chyna

Chyna WWE
WWE.com

Few would argue that Chyna is one of the most dominant female athletes in WWE history. Her intense physicality all but decimated the female roster with frightening ease, so much so that the WWE Creative Team were keen to challenge gender prejudice by having Chyna wrestle and defeat male talent.

Her feuds with Jeff Jarrett and Chris Jericho, along with her pioneering reign as Intercontinental Champion, stand as times that WWE weren't afraid to take calculated risks. Its biggest risk in relation to Chyna was actually set to take place before her IC run.

Amazingly there were originally plans at SummerSlam 1999 for Chyna to be the first female wrestler to win the coveted WWE Championship. In the build-up to the event she became the Number. 1 contender, and it looked like Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. Chyna was set to close the WWE's third biggest PPV of the year.

Despite her push in 1999, it would seem that the WWE bookers became increasingly less keen on the idea and it was (thankfully) decided that Chyna was not the right choice to carry the WWE Championship convincingly. Still, had Vince Russo had his way, Chyna would be in the record books as the only ever female WWE Champion.

Progressive booking, shock TV or just typical Russo madness? Either way, it never happened and Chyna had to settle for the IC Title, instead.


8. The Unprecedented Plan For Hogan/HBK

At the 2005 edition of SummerSlam an unprecedented match took place between Hulk Hogan and Shawn Michaels. The entire four-week build for what was billed as 'The Dream Match' is best remembered for the conspicuous absence of Hogan, as Michaels had to promote the match singlehandedly as a heel similar from his Attitude Era DX days at the request of Hogan himself.

While this proved to be entertaining, it highlights the fluctuating backstage plans of the WWE and the weakness of bookers in succumbing to Hogan's 'backstage politics.' After all, Hogan was actively dictating not only the conditions of the build-up to the match but had the original plan for a Michaels victory changed so that a heel Michaels would put him over as the baby face winner.

According to both Michaels and Hogan, the WWEs original plan was for them to wrestle a total of three matches with the last match being a deciding rubber match to ascertain who was the better wrestler. These creative differences and changing plans led to an infuriated Michaels overselling Hogan's offense during their SummerSlam match and basically refusing to work with 'egomaniac' Hogan again.


7. The Original Plan For Muhammad Hassan

The anti-West gimmick of the Arab American Muhammad Hassan gained significant momentum in early 2005. To many it seemed as if Hassan was on track to follow in the footsteps of workers with similar gimmicks like The Iron Sheik and, to a certain extent, Bret Hart (who was an anti-American heel in 1997).

As a strong heel with clear in-ring talent, the WWE Creative Team had planned for Hassan to win the World Heavyweight Championship in the summer of 2005, and in doing so break the record for the youngest World Heavyweight Champion set by Randy Orton a year earlier.

However the tragic terrorist attacks in London on 7 July 2005 meant that these plans and indeed the whole Hassan gimmick had to be shelved. Rather than Hassan going on to defeat Batista for the World Title at SummerSlam (the original plan), the company were instead forced by negative media reaction to drop the Hassan character for good. Although unfortunate, it was entirely understandable.


6. The Main Event Plan For WrestleMania XV

WrestleMania XV is famous for showcasing the first WrestleMania confrontation in the rivalry between The Rock and 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin. The original plans for the WrestleMania XV main event were originally very different though. Instead of a Rock/Austin collision, the WWE had planned to make the main event a triple threat match between The Rock, Austin and Mankind for the WWE Championship.

Then on-screen WWE Commissioner Shawn Michaels, who was also working creatively behind the scenes, suggested to bookers that the match should be a classic singles bout. It is speculated that Michaels was lobbying Vince McMahon to have Austin removed from the main event and replaced with Mankind.

Unfortunately for Mick Foley, bookers agreed with Shawn to make the main event a singles match but at the expense of his place in the main event itself. So as the WWE looked forward to The Rock/Austin main event, Mankind was left to enjoy his WrestleMania XV moment in the midcard wrestling The Big Show.

If the triple threat had have gone ahead it would have made the Rock/Austin dynamic significantly different. Who wants to live in a world where we don't have three Rock/Austin 'Mania main events?


5. Game Changing Plans

Triple H Wrestlemania 18
WWE

Triple H has widely been rumoured to have influenced WWE plans throughout his career. What is known for certain is that on two occasions he proactively engineered changes to two separate WrestleManias.

At WrestleMania X8, the main event was initially planned to feature The Rock vs. 'Hollywood' Hulk Hogan but The Game successfully lobbied for the main event to change and feature his WWE Championship match with Chris Jericho instead. As a result, following the Hogan/Rock match an emotionally-spent audience was forced to endure an anti-climatic replacement, which ultimately ended the event on a rather underwhelming note.

A year later at WrestleMania XIX he was at it again, changing the plans for his World Heavyweight Championship match with Booker T. The original plan was for Booker to win and become World Heavyweight Champion, but Hunter convinced management that it was the wrong move and successfully had the match changed so that he would retain the gold (there were also rumours that the Book turned up to pre-WrestleMania Raw taping hungover and in poor condition which may have also played a part in it).

If Booker T had won the World Heavyweight Championship it might have given his gimmick a much needed refresh years before his King Booker gimmick change. What eventually transpired at both WrestleMania X8 and XIX was original WWE plans altered by Triple H to suit Triple H.


4. The Plan For 'Imposter' Kane

In 2006 an unmasked Kane came face to face with a fully masked 'Imposter' Kane. This storyline was rumoured to have been penned following speculation that Glenn Jacobs was contemplating retirement.

As a result, WWE, not wanting to abandon the character, decided to create an 'Imposter' Kane based on Kane's 1997 debut. This would allow the man portraying 'Imposter Kane' - Drew Hankinson, aka Festus, aka Luke Gallows - the opportunity to portray the character hidden from the scrutiny of the WWE fans.

The plan was to have 'Imposter Kane' revealed as the real Kane that the Glenn Jacobs Kane had imprisoned for years before stealing his identity. The plans were dropped when the storyline flopped and Jacobs decided to hold off his retirement. Had Jacobs decided to take his gold watch, we may be watching Hankinson as the masked Kane on WWE TV today.


3. The Doomsday Plans For The Streak

Prior to the shocking events of WrestleMania XXX, plans had existed for The Undertaker's Streak to end at the hands of a number of wrestlers.

At WrestleMania 21 The Undertaker was meant to team with Kane to wrestle Heidenreich and Gene Snitsky, but when 'Taker nixed this following months of horrible matches with Heidenreich, Randy Orton got the nod to face The Deadman and was originally booked to break the streak. Orton eventually refused to proceed with this plan out of respect for The Undertaker, forcing WWE to look for other wrestlers more willing to do the unthinkable.

Mark Henry was at one time lined up to break the streak at WrestleMana 22, which would fit in with Kurt Angle's claim that he was asked to break the streak then instead of wrestling Big Evil in a match at Now Way Out 2006. Angle and Henry either rejected the poisoned chalice or WWE creative thought better of it.

Five years later three men were at least pencilled in to defeat The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXVII. Sting was approached by the WWE but turned down the offer citing his well-known disapproval of how WWE had treated its acquired WCW talent when it bought its rival in 2001.

Interestingly, WWE talks with Sting had developed to such an extent that WWE had acquired the rights to play a Metallica track during WrestleMania. When they fell apart, WWE swapped Sting's theme "Seek And Destroy" with "For Whom The Bell Tolls" as part of Triple H's entrance instead.

Plans also existed for The Nexus leader Wade Barrett to defeat The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXVII after he had assaulted 'Taker at Bragging Rights 2010. The plans fell through as the heat of Nexus and Barrett had cooled substantially prior to the start of the Road to WrestleMania at the beginning of 2011.

Finally, following their infamous UFC confrontation, it is widely believed that The Undertaker was working with the WWE creative team to set up a WrestleMania XXVII match with Brock Lesnar in which Lesnar would end up winning and thus end the streak. He'd have to wait a few more years to get his victory.


2. The Controversial Plan For WCW's Survival

Raw Wcw Nitro

The biggest plan that almost happened but never did involved WWE's purchase of its rival WCW in 2001.

Originally WWE had intended for WCW to continue as an entirely separate wrestling promotion, but remain part of the WWE corporate structure. In some respects this plan was an early prototype of what would become the RAW and SmackDown brand extension.

The plan was scrapped when WWE could not find a workable television slot for a WCW show. Instead the WCW/ECW invasions angle was created as an alternative way of introducing WCW/ECW talent to a WWE audience.

It is worth noting that during the 'Invasion' storyline, the WWE Creative Team was planning to have RAW become a WCW show and SmackDown! a WWE show, which became an instantly unpopular idea when it leaked to fans. Many demanded refunds for prepaid tickets and booed loudly during matches featuring WCW talent in a WWE ring.


1. The Audacious Plan Of Mr. McMahon's Murder

Vince Mcmahon Dead
WWE.com

Had the Chris Benoit tragedy not happened in June 2007, one of the most daring wrestling storylines was planned to unfold for the duration of a year. When Mr McMahon was seemingly 'blown up' and killed in his limousine, the question of "Who killed Mr McMahon?" was to be left unanswered for months.

The plan was for an investigation to slowly uncover evidence that proved that Mr McMahon's murderer was in fact Linda McMahon, who would subsequently be arrested after her husband's video will was discovered and played during an edition of Monday Night RAW. During this segment Mr McMahon would leave the entire WWE in the hands of his illegitimate son, Mr Kennedy.

Mr Kennedy was then to become the number one heel and would use his executive powers to place himself in the WWE and World Heavyweight Title pictures. Meanwhile, Triple H and Stephanie McMahon were planned to reveal their kayfabe second consensual marriage that would allow Triple H to challenge Kennedy for ownership of the WWE.

A feud between Triple H and Kennedy was scheduled to play out until WrestleMania, culminating in a main event match that was to be won by Hunter. He would then be considered as the undisputed owner of WWE, at which point Mr McMahon was to return and reveal he had faked his own death and planted evidence to incriminate his wife for his murder so that he could give WWE to his 'true son.'

The Benoit tragedy forced WWE to abandon these plans when the COO of the company had to break kayfabe and address fans on WWE programming. Besides, it would be in very poor taste to run a murder storyline after the real-life horrific events that had taken place.


Contributor
Contributor

Martin Rowe hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.