10 Stars WWE Should Never Have Let Go
Letting Macho Madness run free in WCW was a huge mistake...

Reports are circulating that Neville is the latest WWE star to ask for his release. Apparently unhappy with the way his career is going in the company, the Englishman wants out, which is a real shame considering he successfully reinvented himself as a heel this year and made WWE's Cruiserweight division worth watching.
Neville would be a real loss to the locker room, but he wouldn't be the first WWE have let go without regretting it later. Not everybody works out like Drew McIntyre did. As someone who needed a break from WWE life to find himself as a performer and ultimately become more successful during his second spell, Drew and his employer benefited from his 2014 release. He's the exception.
There are those Vince McMahon should have bent over backwards to keep instead of either granting their release or failing to find something that placated them. Missing out on years of top class performances due to a lack of creativity from the writers or the feeling that someone is more trouble than they're worth isn't how it should be...
10. Elijah Burke

The 'Pope' D'Angelo Dinero character Elijah Burke played in TNA had real potential. That potential would never be fully realised on Impact, but it could have been on Raw or SmackDown. In fact, the 'Black Pope' gimmick would have worked best on the old ECW brand had WWE been mindful to make it more adult-themed than the main shows.
Crashing onto the main roster in 2006, Burke proved himself quickly as a smooth talker. WWE should have jumped all over him right there, but he was only allowed to show glimpses of his mic skills instead of being encouraged to do so weekly. Burke's core strengths weren't highlighted, and that's a real shame.
By the end of 2008, he was gone, only to show up in TNA by the next year. Again, the rebranded Dinero showed he could connect to the audience and promo with the best of them. Why didn't WWE make the most of that when they had the chance? That 'Pope' gimmick could still work today, especially on NXT.
9. Ethan Carter III

Speaking of ex-WWE stars who found more success in TNA, they don't come much more glaring than Ethan Carter III. As the lazily-named Derrick Bateman on the old NXT show, EC3 failed to impress WWE officials enough to break out from that rotten moniker and last beyond 2013 in the promotion. Lord only knows why.
Looking like a million bucks, Carter has also shown just how effective he can be as a smug heel since leaving WWE. Their loss was TNA's gain, as the silver spoon character he played proved just what a waste the humdrum Derrick Bateman idea had been. WWE's creative team really needed to follow up, but they just handed the guy a name and little else.
Quite how he was supposed to get over is mind-boggling. Had WWE kept EC3 around, he would have been perfect for the emerging Daniel Bryan vs. The Authority storyline in 2013, for example. There, Bateman could have played a similarly entitled character to the one he eventually used in TNA.
8. Chris Masters

It doesn't send a great message to talent when one works so hard to improve his work and then finds himself on the unemployment line anyway. Returning for a second crack at WWE in 2009, Masters worked his butt off to become a better in-ring talent and had noticeably slimmed down a tad from the stiff, muscled monster who struggled between 2005-07.
Primarily working on low-level shows like Superstars, Masters was having some of the best matches on WWE television in that period. It seemed only a matter of time before he'd be called up to either Raw or SmackDown and given something more meaningful to do. Suddenly, after bouncing between both brands, the 'Masterpiece' was gone once more in 2011.
He had improved, but WWE's writers still had no idea what to do with him. That's a poor excuse. Why even hire the guy back in '09 if there wasn't a solid plan for his character? Chris Masters of 2010 is the kind of talent WWE could be doing with today.
7. Shelton Benjamin

Shelton Benjamin recently returned to WWE and now works in a tag-team on SmackDown with ex-American Alpha man Chad Gable. A replacement for Jason Jordan, the veteran looks like he hasn't missed a step. That's probably because he was still a world class worker when WWE nonsensically released Shelton in April, 2010.
Canned alongside names like Jimmy Wang Yang, Kung Fu Naki, and Slam Master J, the obviously talented Benjamin stood out. Whilst those guys were little more than supporting acts, Shelton had consistently shown he was one of the best athletes under contract. If only he could do promos, the man would have been a multi-time World Champ by now.
Even without top notch mic skills though, Shelton should have been kept around. Trimming the fat on the roster is one thing, but throwing someone like Benjamin on the scrap heap is another. WWE should have persevered with Benjamin, or given him a manager to make up for those suspect promos.
6. MVP

It came as a surprise when WWE announced that MVP had departed the company in late-2010, even more so when he joined NJPW shortly afterwards. Later, MVP himself told The Miami Herald that WWE agreed to let him out of the final year of his contract so he could hit Japan. MVP's decision to leave wasn't a knee-jerk reaction.
Growing increasingly frustrated by the lack of upward mobility in WWE, the ex-United States Champion decided to call it quits and try his luck elsewhere. After being drafted to Raw in 2009, it looked like he'd go on to become World Champion, but the creative team proceeded to do absolutely nothing with the character and squandered his potential as a babyface.
That irked MVP to the point of leaving just over four years after debuting. WWE should have given MVP a reason to stick around; he surely would have had assurances been made of progression. Finding a gimmick like MVP's, one that doesn't need repackaging to remain fresh, is rare, so he should've been a bigger success.
5. Cody Rhodes

Was there a more depressing sight in 2015-16 than watching poor Cody Rhodes brave face the awful Stardust character on WWE TV? Clearly wishing the writers would just move on from the gimmick and let him be himself, Cody eventually made up his mind and asked for a release.
It's hard to argue with the results post-WWE. Excelling everywhere from WCPW and ROH to New Japan, Rhodes has become one of the hardest-working men in all of pro wrestling. Just look at his match against Kazuchika Okada during Night 1 of the G1 Special In USA card this past July for proof. Away from the garish Stardust guff, Cody is one hell of an in-ring performer.
Scan the SmackDown roster and it's also obvious that Rhodes would be an asset to WWE right now. Someone with such vast experience and a huge upside like Cody definitely shouldn't have been allowed to grow disenfranchised by the WWE system.
Was it really worth it so Stardust could continue to appear? No, it wasn't.
4. John Morrison

There wasn't one time John Morrison made his entrance (complete with snazzy slow-motion effects) when Jerry 'The King' Lawler didn't sound impressed on commentary. Why wouldn't he be though? Morrison looked every bit the rock star he was supposed to, had an amazing physique, and fans were captivated by his presence.
Best of all, Morrison could work against opponents of all shapes and sizes, progressed on the microphone by channelling his quirky personality, and could sell like few others on the WWE roster. The sky looked to be the limit for him, but Morrison would be gone from the company by late-2011. What a complete and utter waste.
Morrison was only in his early-30s when he made the call to leave WWE. He had years ahead of him as a top-tier performer, but was more interested in seeing what he could achieve on his own away from the McMahon machine. That machine should have done everything imaginable to hold onto Jo-Mo.
3. Wade Barrett

There's a reason Wade Barrett was chosen as the leader of The Nexus in 2010. Sounding like a mix between charming politician and movie narrator, the Englishman was blessed with a voice that sounded different to everything else on WWE TV yet was still easy for North Americans to understand. That's uncommon for a Brit.
Between the ropes, Barrett favoured a smash-mouth style that worked well against everyone from John Cena and Randy Orton to Daniel Bryan and Sheamus. In an era when almost everybody who shows something worthwhile goes on to become World Champion, it's a massive surprise that Barrett didn't go above Intercontinental Title level in WWE.
Another who grew bored of being undermined by silly ideas ('King' Barrett and the League Of Nations being top examples), Wade decided to leave WWE in 2015 and pursue a career in acting. Since then, he has been revealed as the new GM of Defiant Wrestling.
2. Kurt Angle

Just shy of seven years after the Olympian had burst onto the scene, struggles with his health and some personal demons led Kurt Angle and WWE to part ways in 2006. Proving himself time and time again as one of wrestling's best, Angle moved on to TNA and enjoyed a near-10 year run full of brilliant matches and World Title reigns.
It's understandable that WWE wanted to distance themselves from the crazier aspects of Kurt's life, but he was far from washed up in 2006. Just think of all the matches WWE missed out on with Angle; against men like CM Punk and Daniel Bryan, Kurt would have been golden. Now, there's a good chance he will never wrestle either, though he has made a WWE comeback himself.
A return to the ring is inevitable once Angle's current stint as Raw GM ends, but he had so much more to offer WWE. They missed out on an entire decade of Kurt's career, which is shameful when considering just how dynamic a performer he was for the promotion from 1999-2006.
There's still a chance to make up for lost time, but those years can never be reclaimed.
1. Randy Savage

Vince McMahon's plan to make Randy Savage a WWF ambassador and colour commentator could have worked, but the boss would have had to placate Randy's desire to continue wrestling occasionally too. That wasn't on the cards in 1994 though, and led Savage to seek solace in WCW for a full-time wrestling gig.
Defying the notion that he was 'too old' to continue headlining, Savage worked on top in Atlanta for another five years. The idea that he should be put out to pasture didn't make sense. When he made his final WWF appearance on the 31 October 1994 episode of Raw, Randy was only 41 years old. To put that into perspective, AJ Styles, John Cena, and Brock Lesnar are all 40, and even relatively 'new' faces like Braun Strowman and Shinsuke Nakamura are 34 and 37 respectively.
Savage still had a lot to offer, and he proved it in WCW. The problem there is that the tickets he sold between 1994-99 were for McMahon's competition, not the WWF. If only Vince had relented and given Randy that Shawn Michaels feud he so desperately craved, things might have turned out different.
-
Which other stars do you feel WWE should have done everything to keep hold of? Let us know down in the comments section below!