10 Storylines WWE ENJOYED Ruining
A legacy of letdowns.
It shouldn't and probably isn't in WWE's DNA to ruin great wrestling.
Their product, for better and worse, is a show that never ends. Their structure is one that affords, justifies and actively encourages this ludicrous schedule. When it comes to audience, theirs is a vocal-but-patient and loyal one, even though 2019 marked the first year that they wouldn't be responsible for over half of the company's revenue. As a business, it is a system that shouldn't function so successfully from a financial point of view whilst it fails so profoundly and producing common sense creative and well-structured storytelling as an end product. Indeed, in spite of best efforts (or...some efforts at least), fans and television executives want to spend money on WWE, and WWE thus don't want to ruin the reason way.
Apart from when they do.
It can't have escaped your attention that Ricochet's recent loss to Brock Lesnar was stark in how brutal and basic it was. 'The One & Only' beat every big man on Raw and was then hauled into a studio to give a bit of a "and I'm gonna beat Brock too" speech for a video packages ahead of the eventual squash. And this was a squash. He lost again a few days later on Raw in what might yet prove to be the start of a redemptive arc, but imagine not needing that redemption in the first place.
Sometimes, the decision makers honestly just can't help themselves...
10. Christian's Return From TNA
Vince McMahon gave so little of a sh*t about Chrisitian when he had hold of him that he wanted to cover his face up with a blue dot, and yet as soon as 'Captain Charisma' made the life and career move to give upstart promotion TNA a crack, The Chairman marked his cards,
Christian's February 2009 return to the fold was, by most trusted accounts, due to come as part of the ongoing storyline between Edge and Jeff Hardy. This made sense - both men had deep connections to Christian's past, and with Matt Hardy being carefully included as a babyface, could have made for a prosperous four-way future with WrestleMania on the horizon.
Common sense booking dictated this, which is why fans vocally predicted it around Royal Rumble weekend during a Hardy/Edge WWE Championship clash. Allegedly raging with the "leak", McMahon swerved everybody and put a heel-turning Matt in the spot, leaving Christian to...debut unannounced on depleted third brand ECW.
"It's...Christian" was Todd Grisham's offensively understated response, while Matt Striker announced (!) that he was speechless. If only, and if only we hadn't lost the inevitable Hardyz/Edge & Christian reboot some 10 years on from their inaugural wars.
9. Eugene
WWE were never ever ever ever going to make a character with undefined additional needs work, not least in a far less accepting, understanding and informed time than thankfully exists today. But when they gave the joy of the persona a shot, it was predictably the best thing on the show.
Nick Dinsmore's portrayal was obviously somewhat patronising, but the worker in him managed to extract an enormous amount of sympathy and support for the character. He had an earnest charm that the rest of the "Rrurrrrhtlesssh Aggressshrrrshhion" d*ckheads and dudebros couldn't muster in a month of Mondays, and was thus was one of the most over babyfaces on the show as a result.
Enter Triple H and his f*cking talons.
'The Game' saw something getting over and wanted a bit of that, thanks very much, even if it made little sense for him and his cronies to use the savant skills of the new star. The plan failed because of course it did, resulting in the group and Hunter specifically abusing Eugene for his involvement. This was Dead Man's Shoes without the violent redemption, and became a trope as a result. Mohammad Hassan, Kurt Angle and even Vince McMahon tortured the poor soul for cheap heat in a coarse reminder that the bullies in this organisation always get to win.
8. The Invasion
They really, really f*cking enjoyed this one. Or at least some of the wrestlers did.
It's genuinely hard to put yourself in the place of one of Vince McMahon's loyal soldiers in March 2001. You read or hear the news that the boss has finally put the competition out of their misery and you - you and your colleagues and your hard graft - have won the war you've been in while making all this money the last few years. It's WrestleMania next week too - a big payday and a big party. Wrestling's worked out pretty well, all told, eh?
Or has it? The Chairman's making bank, but what about you, Bradshaw? Is there place for an ageing bar brawling tag team with some younger, hungrier combos potentially looking for work because of your actions? What about you, Undertaker? WCW had an awful lot of stars and if any of them can be convinced to come in, they might have a bit more novelty value than this biker look you've been working. What about you, Steve Austin? Your work's never been better but the clock is ticking and there's never been a larger locker room nipping at your heels. What about you, Haku? Well, you only f*cking re-signed in January so it's pretty rich to hang out in that WWE gang anyway.
There were a myriad of reasons why the Invasion failed, top down. There are just as many as to why the existing talent would have wanted it to go exactly as it did.
7. Bray Wyatt
Count the ways WWE bent the Bray Wyatt character before it eventually broke for good in 2018. Or don't because you'd have more than the entries in this list and an awful lot of disappointment to wade through in the process.
The debut against Kane was a borderline catastrophe. His failure to comprehensively defeat CM Punk and Daniel Bryan in that tag feud after the fact was weird. His inability to convince Bryan to join the family. His loss to John Cena at WrestleMania. His trick-playing against him coming too little too late for anybody to give a sh*t. His feud with Chris Jericho had a reductive effect on 'Y2J' pulling him into the midcard one year after 'The Eater Of Worlds' debut. One year, all of that.
Not exactly The Undertaker's 1990 to 1991 Survivor Series run, is it?
Imagine that, but every year unless broken up by injuries and yet more false hope. Wyatt's story was one of failure after faliure briefly perforated by a rule-proving exception. His colleagues thought him a genius, many of them saw it for themselves in the flesh and bones of FCW Promo Class. His supporters held firm that all that talk of buzzards and Abigail would one day actually arrive at a grand payoff.
His only hope, was his total reimagining...
6. The Fiend Bray Wyatt
But they just can't do this sh*t anymore.
Your writer's taken pelters for giving up on this gimmick as the Hell In A Cell main event was still in progress, but the decision was made in tandem with the writing team and/or their maniacal old boss that allowed it to play out as such.
An unmitigated disaster for both men, the title they fought for, the structure they wrestled in and the very future of the pay-per-view that has worn the gimmick out over the past decade, The Fiend's premature Universal Championship match against Seth Rollins failed to deal with the problem the matchmaking had created. Neither man could lose so thought the company (wrong), as the first f*cking chapter of the story took place within what was once the absolute final resting place for a blood feud. And the stuff spewing from Seth Rollins' mouth at the end of the show didn't count.
Fiend recovered when he won the title a month later, we were told. Fiend had recovered because he was selling loads of merch, we were told. Fiend recovered because the Daniel Bryan matches weren't totally unwatchable, we were told. Fiend recovered because he was going over Goldberg ahead of the inevitable showdown with Roman Reigns, we were told. Fiend recovered because Wyatt knocked one out of the park on the empty arena SmackDown to build to his match, we were tol-
5. Dean Ambrose Turns Heel
We know WWE enjoyed this one because Jon Moxley confirmed as much when explaining exactly how involved Vince McMahon was in this ha-ha-hilarious ideas generation process. The Chairman loves his f*cking props, loved the idea of Dean Ambrose literally getting sick in the presence of the fanbase and Seth Rollins, and seemingly loved flushing a load of money away too.
The 'Chronicle' feature on Ambrose's return from injury the prior summer had been an absorbing WWE Network production with a twist. It carefully contorted kayfabe in with the pained reality of his rehabilitation to tacitly inform an eventual turn. It was the lone saving grace of what proved to be the last major angle of the 'Lunatic Fringe's WWE career.
It's possible that this story started covering an unravelling psyche, particularly after his Roman Reigns' leukaemia absence around the same time. The sickness was engulfing everything that propped Ambrose up - from his friends to himself. The sickening reality was McMahon's comfort in reducing him to prop comic heel instead of prop comic babyface - it was little wonder the company fell back on using The Shield again just four months after they seemed permanently put out to pasture.
4. Michael Cole Vs Jerry Lawler
Commentator feuds are theoretically rotten for business.
The announcers are there for three key purposes; maintaining the veneer of bonafide sporting competition, verbally aiding the story being told in the ring and providing any other marketing, promotional or storyline information the company wants the audience to have a handle on.
They can't do any of the above when they're fighting each other. It's why Jim Ross despises some of his own angles despite the quality of some of his promos and why Randy Savage considered it a life sentence away from the ring when Vince McMahon wanted to place him there permanently in 1994.
But Cole and Lawler's aggro was a perfect storm. It was at long last the opportunity for fans to get a cathartic release at Michael Cole's expense all while 'The King' got to enjoy his first ever match on the 'Grandest Stage'. Cole had been a pr*ck, Lawler was the actual wrestler - the piledriver/fist drop combo could be spotted from the very start of the Road To WrestleMania.
Not by WWE.
They saw months of rematches and the opportunity to humble and humiliate Jim Ross. Who the hell are we to just want a bit of closure and the announcers to go back to announcing? Cole screwed Lawler out of the WWE Championship in November to formally trigger their unease. He lost, at last, in May.
3. Braun Strowman - A Big Man Can't Win A Big Match
There were two early tells in the Braun Strowman story that highlighted just how much Vince McMahon favoured Brock Lesnar over his new 'Monster Among Men'.
On the April 3rd 2017 edition of Raw, Strowman was rather confusingly sent out to "put Lesnar on notice", whatever that meant, before backing down when 'The Beast' actually offered him out for a quick scuffle. 'The Monster Among Men' was embroiled in a programme with Roman Reigns at the time so, if you were willing to reach as far as WWE were asking, you could justify it with the thinking that he was saving himself for 'The Big Dog'.
And if he was, it worked. Strowman was one of the few to get the conclusive measure of Reigns, and took that momentum into an explosive SummerSlam fatal four-way main event that he didn't lose. If only the same could be said for his disastrously disappointing singles swing at the Universal Champion two months later.
Strowman Vs Lesnar at October's No Mercy felt like a moment in the making, but WWE bottled it for a Roman Reigns rainy day at the following WrestleMania. Braun lost easily to Brock, then failed to get near him in a triple threat with Kane at January 2018's Royal Rumble, then lost again to him when the two men briefly went into battle at October's Crown Jewel.
Braun couldn't even be generously classified as a flat-track bully - McMahon pushes bullies.
2. Jinder Mahal's Boom And Bust
Time is getting kinder to Jinder Mahal's WWE Championship run, if only because WWE at large gets crueller towards its audience.
The manner in which Brock Lesnar flattened Kofi Kingston for that same title was a terse reminder that the thing only really matters now when the company tell you so. When the 'Modern Day Maharaja' dethroned Randy Orton a month removed from being a rank-and-file jobber at Backlash 2017, the shock was such that WWE spent as long looking for forlorn faces in the crowd to express it as they did the new titleholder.
Mahal looked a million dollars and it was thought he could draw the same in markets WWE hadn't fully tapped into, but his elevation felt far, far too forced. Fans never embraced it, and unlike natural comparison John Bradshaw Layfield, Mahal never particularly grew into the role as a performer. Even before he lost the title to AJ Styles ahead of a potentially ludicrous Survivor Series bout with Brock Lesnar, Paul Heyman mocked the very idea of his existence and the match in a scathing assessment of his failure in the role.
Well beaten in rematches against Styles in December, he jobbed to Triple H on the one international house show he was supposedly the draw for, and was working comedy spots with The New Day the next month.
1. The Small Rise & Large Fall Of Legacy
Whether or not Legacy happened too soon after Evolution for Randy Orton to believably portray the Triple H-style leader of his own gang of youngun's is mostly besides the point. These goobers, with 'The Legend Killer' as the lone exception, were set up to perpetually suffer.
It took long enough for the group to take shape - Cody Rhodes and Ted Dibaise were always destined to be Orton's goons but a strange transitional period for the stable saw Manu and Sim Snuka both make plays to be at 'The Viper's beck and call, fundamentally devaluing the pair of proper members before the stable was even solidified.
They were a goon squad within weeks anyway, and not a particularly good one. Orton got a Rumble win and allowed the pair to be used and abused as his lightweight heavies for a while, but their eventual split was about as dynamic as one of the 'Apex Predator's longer matches. They let him down, they sort-of abandoned him, he swore revenge having been babyfaced by mates turning on him yet again, and went and got it.
The WrestleMania XXVI triple threat payoff was exhausting and tepid, much like the bulk of the group's ill-advised existence.