10 Strangest Ways To Win A Wrestling Championship
Pinfall, submission, count out, disqualification...and rock, paper, scissors?
What is the purpose of winning a championship as a professional wrestler?
Is it to act as a decisive separation of the best from the rest? Perhaps, but then, what is the best? Jake Roberts, long glorified as one of his generation's most influential talkers and a dab hand between the ropes, never got a sniff at WWE's top prize. Ricky Steamboat, whose pure babyface aura and unrivalled in-ring technique, was a mid-card act for his whole career with the market leaer. Dusty Rhodes, a masterful NWA headliner who became polka dot-adorned comedy fodder in WWE, famously never held the richest prize in sports entertainment.
But Vince McMahon did.
Jinder Mahal did.
Alberto Del Rio did.
Being bestowed with a championship in wrestling is a token of a company's appreciation for how many t-shirts you can sell or how many punters you can draw to a live event. Being gifted with the art of professional wrestling is a secondary asset.
That is why so many title archives became littered with controversy: too many promotions opted for convolution over conciseness. Crowning the hot new act as champion via the traditional method of a pinfall or submission isn't as fun as...
10. Divorce (TNA Digital Media Championship)
The TNA Digital Media Championship, somehow, lives.
A sledgehammer-wielding PCO had sliced it apart during Game Changer Wrestling's 19 January The People vs. GCW card in what was immediately reported by PWInsider's Mike Johnson to have been a shoot, with the gargantuan French Canadian making subsequent scathing remarks directed at TNA executives a mere four days before he was purportedly scheduled to drop the title and exit TNA.
PCO has since left TNA and lost the Digital Media Title...
...in a bitter divorce.
TNA's first live iMPACT! in eight years came with the revelation that Steph de Lander, PCO's in-storyline wife, had divorced him, winning the Digital Media Championship in the settlement. This wasn't the checkmate TNA expected it to be. A self-inflicted failure, it may not be, but PCO's destruction of the belt ripened TNA's opportunity to shelve it. The championship has lacked any creative direction since its fall 2021 inauguration, and its on-again, off-again attachment to upper-echelon talents, such as Jordynne Grace, Matt Cardona, and Joe Hendry didn't do the belt, nor the champions, any favours.
Still, changing a titleholder via divorce is one of those things that the Anthem-helmed promotion will become remembered for. Cue the 'Remember when TNA did that wacky thing???' tweet this time next year.
9. Being Randomly Selected (Various)
Tag Team Championships require two titleholders.
It is, quite literally, in the name.
Naturally, pro wrestling hasn't always abided by this rule. WWE, an organisation so inherently against the idea of introducing Trios Titles despite Paul Levesque's fixation with stables, has often operated Tag Team Championships under the Freebird Rule. The notion that a wrestler can become a champion without competing in a championship-changing match was at its most brazen in WCW and TNA, though.
Of course.
In 2007, Samoa Joe held TNA's doubles titles on his lonesome, which was allowed, but Kurt Angle, who beat him for the straps, wasn't. He had to partner up, ultimately pairing with Sting, though not by selecting 'The Stinger'. Sting had won a four-way bout to earn the right to become half of the World Tag Team Champions, having been in a similar situation himself some nine years earlier when, after a falling out with championship-winning partner Paul 'The Giant' Wight, he felled 'Tall Paul' to earn the sole rights to the titles, later selecting Kevin Nash to defend the belts with.
Such tropes rarely occur now in mainstream wrestling, for the best.
8. Being Low Blowed (WWE World Heavyweight Championship)
The World Heavyweight Championship in WWE - the original lavish, frankly otherworldly Big Gold Belt, not the current piece of bland crap masquerading as the cherished strap - was never without its controversial title swaps.
Triple H was the inaugural champion, but he never won it: Eric Bischoff, then-Raw General Manager, handed it to 'The Game' because he could. Only two years later, the title was held up for the first time, owing to a double pinfall. Triple H, again, was the champion, and he regained the vacated strap, rendering its vacancy pointless. On two occasions, Vickie Guerrero stripped babyface champions because they had utilised moves she deemed banned.
But the most contentious changing of the World Heavyweight Championship guard was when a freshly-heel Christian regained the title by being kicked in the nuts.
Vince McMahon famously didn't 'get' Christian, hence why he rapidly dropped the belt to Randy Orton five days into his original reign, but Christian regaining the championship by being booted in the ballsack, and then, as if that wasn't bad enough, being dismantled by Orton after the fact with an RKO onto an invincible broadcast table?
This was depressing.
7. Finding It In A Bag (WWE European Championship)
Oddly enough, WWE's European Championship was their last well-booked secondary championship until Gunther's rebirth of the Intercontinental Title. Sort of.
It started off ridiculously strongly with a tournament final between Owen Hart and inaugural champion The British Bulldog, and Bulldog was followed by Shawn Michaels, Triple H, the aforementioned Hart, D'Lo Brown, X-Pac, and a still-liked Shane McMahon.
Not a bad starting seven.
But then Mideon won the championship.
After finding it in Shane's bag backstage.
And he was allowed to keep it.
Eh?
McMahon, who claimed to have retired as European Champion, stopped appearing with the championship until, in June 1999, Mideon discovered the strap in 'The Prodigal Son's' travel bag backstage. He was recognised as an official champion following this and would even have a pay-per-view title defence vs. D'Lo Brown at Fully Loaded, where he was mercifully dethroned.
That still isn't totally horrendous, that is until you learn that this was during the period where Mideon risked arrest every week by performing in the buff, with only a fanny pack to cover his little Phineas I. Godwinns. From here, the European Championship floated around the mid-card, never again being held by an authentic WWE headliner until its 2002 merger into the Intercontinental Title.
6. Finding It In A Dumpster (WCW World Television Championship)
WCW flatlined in 2000.
They flatlined the minute Hulk Hogan prodded Kevin Nash in the chest a whole year earlier, truth be told, but by 2000, World Championship Wrestling was internally infected. 2000, mind, was the infamous year in which all WCW championships were vacated amid a mind-numbingly dumb company reboot, in which the infamous Bash at the Beach incident played out in front of a bemused Dayton Beach audience, and in which David Arquette won the WCW World Heavyweight Championship.
It was also the year in which the WCW World Television Championship died.
A company staple since before WCW began operations, the TV Title was retired when Eric Bischoff and Vince Russo conducted the aforementioned reboot. The champion at the time was Jim Duggan, but was he really a champion as such? He didn't defeat anyone for the belt and all defences were made on the tertiary WCW Saturday Night program, so if you weren't aware of his title 'victory', you would be forgiven.
Inverted commas are necessary when discussing Duggan's winning of the Television Championship. He didn't win it: he found it.
In a dumpster.
Three months after it had been dumped.
In a different state.
LolWCW indeed.
5. Winning A Randomised Lockbox (TNA Knockouts World Championship)
The Knockouts World Championship is arguably the best-booked of TNA's championships. It has a strong track record of champions, from Gail Kim and Deonna Purrazzo to Awesome Kong and Jordynne Grace.
But in 2010, its legitimacy faded.
Angelina Love, Daffney, Tara, and Velvet Sky bested Hamada, Lacey von Erich, Madison Rayne, and ODB in an intricate four-on-four elimination bout, wherein whoever scored an elimination would also leave the match, albeit with a key to a mysterious lockbox. It doesn't sound that bad for circa-2010 TNA - but it was horrific.
Tara, the defending Knockouts Champion who was still a hot act in the company, lost the title when she opened her lockbox, which revealed her pet spider, and Velvet Sky won a future opportunity at TNA's women's strap. Meanwhile, Angelina Love, won the title itself, all by getting the right key and without pinning the champion.
Daffney, for those pondering how TNA could possibly set women's rights back fifty years, was ordered to perform a striptease.
Terrible, grotesque booking...
...had it not been for the fact WWE was parading women in similar fashion over a decade earlier...
4. Being Undressed (WWE Women's Championship)
The official Wikipedia entry on how to win an Evening Gown match reads as follows:
"An Evening Gown match is usually contested by two female competitors in evening gowns. The only objective to win this match is the wrestler must remove the evening gown from her opponent."
It is an inherently simplistic, if not morally degrading, match, and WWE wasn't exactly new to the stipulation when scheduling Sable and Debra to contest one on a May 1999 Raw broadcast. The match, fought for the former's Women's Championship, was formulaic for Attitude Era women's matches: slow-burning, little action, and less than a minute in length. Sable won by disrobing Debra - or did she?
Shawn Michaels, WWE's fictitious Commissioner at the time, awarded the match and the championship to Debra on account of her having the nicer "puppies", though the more PG way of putting it is that Debra technically took her gown off herself, Sable having seemingly struggled to remove the red garment. Sable didn't put up a fight either. She just flaunted herself at the hard cam alongside Debra, despite having just been screwed out of her only Women's Championship.
The story goes that Sable was in the midst of a heated off-screen dispute with the company, hence the drab nature of what would be her final wrestling outing for four years.
3. Outdrinking Your Opponent (TNA World Beer Drinking Championship)
James Storm liked a beer.
Or two.
Or three.
Or four, to hell with it.
James Storm likes a pint to such an extreme, borderline alcoholic degree that he made it his predominant personality trait for much of his career. Well, that and apparently being a cowboy who rides silly little beer cooler moped things to the ring. Storm, though, also invented a championship that would act as an accurate representation of who in TNA could drink the most beer, dubbing it the World Beer Drinking Championship.
Storm introduced the beer bottle belt - which was legitimately a replica WWE Championship with a couple of beer bottles Blutacked onto it - at TNA's 2007 Genesis pay-per-view, where he partook in a backstage beer drinking contest opposite Eric Young. Storm decreed that, having seemingly been shoot drinking all night, whoever could walk out the door first would be the champion. He then fell over in a manner not too dissimilar to circa-WrestleMania 39 Shane McMahon, allowing Eric Young to win his first TNA singles title.
Because he drank more beer.
???
In other news, Vince Russo served as a TNA creative writer between 2006 and 2011.
2. Being Given Power Of Attorney (WCW World Television Championship)
It's a trope all too common in the wrestling landscape: champion gets injured, champion selects representative for title defences, elected champion loses title.
It still exists in form - Samoa Joe's AEW World Championship victory was the result of him having substituted for an injured Adam Cole in multiple ROH World Tag Team Title defences - but in July 1998, WCW, a promotion teetering on implosion opposite an explosive Attitude Era-bolstered WWF, took this trope to a new level of Vince Russo-booked absurdity.
Booker T was the World Television Champion. It was his fifth reign with the strap because WCW hadn't yet identified the main event potential that stood in front of them. He was injured, though, and was written off company programming in an instantly-forgotten injury angle where Bret Hart obliterated his knee.
Now what? Would WCW vacate the championship? Would a new champion be crowned in the novel idea of a tournament? Would the belt be quietly retired?
Nope!
Stevie Ray became the new champion because he had signed a document giving him Power of Attorney in the event Booker T became incapacitated. This was Ray's solitary singles gold in WCW(!), yet he didn't defeat anyone to become the champion and he dropped it to Chris Jericho in his first defence.
Stevie looked like a geek. A golden geek, admittedly, but a geek nonetheless.
1. Rock, Paper, Scissors (DDT Pro Ironman Heavymetalweight Championship)
The following is a list of legitimate ways that the DDT Pro Ironman Heavymetalweight Championship has changed hands:
- Writing "I give up" on a piece of paper.
- Goading the champion, a cat, with a cat treat.
- Tickling your opponent and, when they request you stop, having the referee treat it as a submission.
- Dreaming that you've won the championship.
- Stating that the championship is just as much yours as the audience's, with the referee taking this as a forfeit.
- Drinking a can of beer.
- Failing to crush an apple.
- Strangling a towel.
That isn't filler content to up the word count. Each title swap represents the deft, comedic menagerie of the championship, producing the sort of daft antics that make Jim Cornette shuffle around uncomfortably in his armchair - but this was merely the tip of the iceberg. On New Year's Eve 2021, during the 187th ChocoPro event, Yuna Mizumori captured the championship from Toru Owashi by winning a round of Janken: the Japanese version of rock, paper, scissors.
The mainstream North American equivalent to this would be if R-Truth regained WWE's sickly green 24/7 Championship by besting Drake Maverick in a round of Top Trumps.
It was fittingly ludicrous.