10 Superstars Who Had Better Careers Outside WWE

Just how did WWE mess up Mistico so badly?

Despite being called €˜Superstars€™, not every athlete signed to the WWE becomes a Superstar in the true meaning of the word. There are some people who join Vince McMahon€™s company, only for them to regret doing so afterwards. There are some wrestlers who might have been stars before coming to the WWE, only for their stardom to fade while under that banner. At the same time, there have also been some wrestlers who barely made it in WWE, only to become bigger stars afterwards. This list contains ten wrestlers who have been employed at one point or another, by the WWF/E, and their careers were either lackluster and they were let go, or they were fired for one reason or another. Furthermore, each of the 10 entries in this list had a better career elsewhere when compared to the WWE. Some were only employed with the WWE for only a few months, others for several years. Some of them earned the respect of their peers and fans by toiling away in other promotions, only for their momentum to be halted while in the WWE. Others were supposedly destined to be big stars in WWE, and were given lots of camera time, only for things to change suddenly and everything came to a halt. The common feature among all the wrestlers in this article is that their pre or post-WWE careers were better than when they worked for Vince. Regardless of circumstances, here are 10 talented athletes who had better careers before and/or after leaving Vince McMahon€™s billion dollar corporation.

10. Jamie Noble/James Gibson

Jamie Noble Roh Some of you might be thinking that this one doesn€™t count, as James Gibson currently works for WWE as a producer. I€™m taking specifically about his in-ring career. As Jamie Noble, Gibson worked for WWE from 2002-2004 and again from 2005-2009. He didn€™t do much during either run, other win the WWE Cruiserweight Championship once, forming a short-lived tag team with Kid Kash as the Pitbulls, and had small rivalries over some of the Divas. Given his actual grappling talent, he was vastly underused. After his first stint in the WWE, Gibson went to work for Ring of Honor (ROH), where he won the ROH World Title in a Fatal-4-Way against CM Punk, Samoa Joe, and Christopher Daniels, all of whom were and are fantastic wrestlers. As soon as he was released from his WWE contract, he went from challenging for one of the WWE€™s lowest titles, to winning ROH€™s top title. The fact that he was even booked into such a match demonstrated the in-ring skill that he had, which, unfortunately, was overlooked in WWE. His biggest problem unfortunately was his size. Vince McMahon loves big guys who can win a fight in real life. Janie Noble is 5€™9 and barely weighs over 200 lbs. Furthermore, his wrestling psychology was that of a technician as opposed to a cruiserweight or a luchadore, which made it harder for him to stand out as a performer. This isn€™t a new phenomenon, though. For years WWE was ruled by the muscular big men like Hulk Hogan and the Ultimate Warrior, while more skilled grapplers like Bret Hart, Mr. Perfect and Shawn Michaels were out-performing them. While those athletes eventually managed to be in the spotlight, the same couldn€™t be said for Jamie Noble. His last major appearance was in 2009, where he was demolished by a debuting Sheamus, before announcing his retirement from in-ring competition. While he might enjoy his work behind the scenes, his career between the ropes in WWE left a lot to be desired. Outside of the WWE, his size was an afterthought; it was his talent that people appreciated.

9. Drew Hankinson/Festus/Luke Gallows

Drew Hankinson€™s WWE career was filled with weird gimmicks and poor booking. First, he was the Imposter Kane in an attempted remake of the Undertaker-Underfaker era in 1994; needless to say, the supposed blow-off from this feud never happened. Then, he became Festus, who was some kind of slow dimwit who somehow became unstoppable at the sound of a ring bell. Though it seemed like a good idea, Magic-Ring-Bell Festus was just begging to be messed with, which eventually happened: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnzvUL33Hkk After that fiasco, he became Luke Gallows, who was CM Punk€™s first disciple in the Straight Edge Society. At that point, his career seemed to be going in the right direction, until he was released. After WWE, he went to TNA, where his career wasn€™t that much better. He became a member of Aces & Eights, competing under the name D.O.C. (Director of Chaos). However, like his WWE run, Hankinson€™s TNA run was lackluster and he didn€™t really accomplish much, other than being part of a massive group in Aces & Eights. But after that, he made his way to New Japan Pro Wrestling (NJPW). There, he€™s had quite a bit of success, winning the 2013 World Tag League Tournament and the IWGP Tag Team Championship, both of which were with Karl Anderson (more on him later). Since then, he€™s successfully defended those titles against many strong teams, from the Briscoe Brothers, to Togi Makabe & Hiroshi Tanahashi, the latter being NJPW€™s top man. This makes a nice change from dressing up as Santa Claus on SmackDown. Even though Hankinson is now 30, he still has many years ahead of him, so hopefully he€™ll be able to gain more success in NJPW. But a return to WWE would be very unwise for him.

8. Frankie Kazarian

I remember watching this guy debut on Velocity on July 16th, 2005, when he defeated Nunzio. I thought he would actually be on the main roster pretty soon, as he was quite entertaining and had an impressive move-set. However, he was in WWE for less than a year before leaving. He later stated that he chose to leave the company because they didn€™t have any plans to change the Cruiserweight division. At the time, he was small by WWE standards, at 6€™1 and 215 lbs., so he would€™ve fit in the Cruiserweight division perfectly. After leaving the WWE, Kazarian returned to TNA in 2005. There, he had a lot more success, winning numerous titles, and enjoying a lengthy career as both himself and the Suicide character. By 2007, he was challenging Kurt Angle for the TNA World Heavyweight Championship, and soon after won the first Ultimate X King of the Mountain match. Among his various accomplishments include 5 reigns as X-Division Champion, 2 reigns as TNA World Tag Team Champions (with Christopher Daniels, as €˜Bad Influence€™), and won the X-Division King of the Mountain twice. It was clearly a major mistake for the WWE to have let him go. He could have been more successful in WWE if they had given him the opportunity to show off his skills in a revamped cruiserweight division. But alas, some things simply aren€™t meant to be.

7. Místico/Sin Cara

Mistico These days, the name Sin Cara is synonymous with the word €˜botch€™. This applies to both his in-ring performance while in WWE, but also his WWE career in general; it was a big mistake for him to leave Mexico and the reputation that he had there. While wrestling as Místico in Mexico, mainly for Consejo Mundial de Lucha Libre (CMLL), he was widely believed to be the greatest luchadore of his generation. He won numerous awards and titles, including the NWA World Middleweight Championship, the CMLL World Welterweight Championship, and Best Box Office Draw of the Decade (2000-2009) from the Wrestling Observer Newsletter. Think about that last one for a minute: this luchadore was so popular and revered for his skills that he somehow managed to out-draw the Rock, Stone Cold Steve Austin, John Cena, The Undertaker, and countless other top WWE Superstars. He also had one of the most impressive finishers ever seen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jt8qcOSEg-o In WWE, however, things fell flat from the moment he debuted. In his first televised match, in which he faced Primo Colon, he nearly messed up his ring entrance, and fell off the turnbuckle while getting ready to perform his finisher. From there, things went downhill. Rumors spread like wildfire that he had a backstage attitude problem, that he didn€™t want to learn WWE€™s style or English for that matter, and that he thought of himself as a bigger star than most other Superstars in the WWE. It also didn€™t help that he was quite prone to stops in his momentum. He was suspended for thirty days for a Wellness Policy violation, was sidelines for six months after injuring himself at the 2011 Survivor Series, injured his knee towards the end of 2012, took time off in 2013 to deal with other injuries, and dislocated a finger in August 2014. Given these problems, it should come as no surprise that his momentum was halted, and his popularity in the WWE disappeared. It seems that the man behind the mask, Luis Ignacio Urive Alvirde, should€™ve stayed in Mexico. He would have never needed to change his style, and would€™ve solidified himself as a legendary Mexican wrestler. But for WWE fans, his name is forever associated with €˜botch€™.

6. K-Kwik/Ron Killings/R-Truth

Ron Killings debuted in the WWF as K-Kwik in the late 1990s, and had little to show for his tenure other than a reign as Hardcore Championship and a short-lived tag team with Road Dogg. After a short time, he went to the newly-founded TNA promotion, where he had so much more success. He was the first African-American to win the NWA World Heavyweight Championship, and was taken much more seriously as a performer. While he did perform his own entrance music at times, it wasn€™t the central feature of his character. Though it wasn€™t as stellar of a career when compared to other top TNA Stars, such as AJ Styles or Samoa Joe, he was still featured in main event matches and was involved in programs with legends such as Sting. Upon his return to WWE in 2009, however, once again there was little to nothing for him to do. Capitalizing on the potential catchiness of his entrance theme, Killings would sing his entrance theme and dance his way to the ring. However, he did win the U.S. Championship once and the Tag Team Championship once with Kofi Kingston. However, much of his career in WWE has been in the undercard. The only time he was given a main event shot was in a short feud against John Cena, during which he became a conspiracy theorist, while talking to an imaginary character named €˜Little Jimmy€™. Ron Killings is 42 now, so it€™s unlikely that he€™ll get another main event push in WWE. While he did enjoy some mid-card success, he had more success in TNA than in WWE; at least he won a world title over there, which was a big accomplishment back then anyway.

5. Jeff Jarrett

Jeff Jarrett is one of the most well-known names in American wrestling for two reasons. First, he has worked in several wrestling promotions, including both WWF and WCW. On the other hand, he is also known for founding two wrestling promotions following WWF€™s purchase of WCW and ECW: TNA and Global Force Wrestling. It would seem that he is determined to make sure the WWE has at least some kind of competition in the United States. That said, his WWF/E career wasn€™t that bad. He got to work with top stars in Bret Hart, the Undertaker, and D-Generation X, among others. He won the WWF World Tag Team Championship with Owen Hart, and even had his own WrestleMania moment, in successfully defending that title. He also won the WWF Intercontinental Championship six times, which is an impressive accomplishment. Also, he was one of four men to hold the Intercontinental and European Championships simultaneously. However, it€™s outside of the WWE where his career was truly his most successful. He became World Champion in virtually every other wrestling promotion that he entered, from the United States Wrestling Association, to WCW, to smaller promotions like World Wrestling All-Stars and the Continental Wrestling Association. While in WCW, he won their world title four times, and the NWA World Title six times while in TNA. While his success in TNA might be due to his role as a major financial backer, and his success in Tennessee might be due to his connections (his father Jerry had major influence in the territorial days), these arguments don€™t take away from the fact that Jeff Jarrett was more successful outside of the WWF than in it. At least in other companies he didn€™t have to act like a country music singer and spell his name all the time.

4. Ultimo Dragon

Yoshihiro Asai is to this day one of Luchadore€™s most well-known practitioners. A master of innovation and high-flying offence, Ultimo Dragon has held many titles and recognitions in his career. But perhaps his greatest feat was holding ten titles simultaneously: the NWA Middleweight Championship, the WCW World Cruiserweight Championship, and the J-Crown, which was the unification of eight other championships from different wrestling organizations. You know you€™ve made an impact in the wrestling industry when a promotion gets named after you (Toryumon would later become Dragon Gate, and many of its early stars were drained in Ultimo Dragon€™s dojo). And yet in WWE, Ultimo only lasted about a year before being released. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G8eFfncpwHI Despite having an impressive debut match, during which the commentators (and Rey Mysterio) both put Ultimo over as a successful and accomplished wrestler, his career in WWE wasn€™t very successful. Though he competed in U.S. Championship tournaments and challenged for the Cruiserweight Championship, he never accomplished anything while in the WWE. WWE had recently signed Rey Mysterio and they were hoping that Ultimo would be a good candidate to help them build a Cruiserweight division akin to the one in WCW in the 1990s. They had a perfect pairing in Mysterio and Ultimo, and yet it never came to fruition. Aside from Shelton Benjamin, many fans consider Ultimo as one of the most underrated wrestlers and wasted opportunities in recent WWE history. His matches with Rey Mysterio alone could have excited fans in the same way as they did back in WCW and in Japan. So while it was good to see him in a WWE ring, his tenure with Vince€™s company was underwhelming. It€™s a real pity too; WWE could€™ve made money off of that rivalry in the same way they€™ve tried to push Rey vs. Sin Cara. But unfortunately, they didn€™t handle Ultimo€™s career properly, leaving the Cruiserweight division short one outstanding performer.

3. Albert/Giant Bernard

Giant Bernard Yes, that is, in fact, (Prince) Albert/A-Train/The Hip-Hop Hippo/(Lord) Tensai. Matt Bloom€™s WWF/E career has been one long, non-stop game of gimmick-juggling. Despite the fact that Vince McMahon likes big guys, the only major highlights he had were one reign as Intercontinental Championship, an interesting partnership with Test (as T&A, managed by Trish Stratus) and having the distinction of losing to the Undertaker in his only non-singles match at WrestleMania XIX, in a handicap match alongside the Big Show. Considering that his first ring name was that of a penile piercing, it was hard for people to get behind him. Leaving the WWE in 2004 brought him some much needed change. His size and intimidating appearance were put to good use, and he became known as Giant Bernard, and went off to Japan. There, he had much more success, teaming with Karl Anderson (as Bad Intentions, before Drew Hankinson arrived), and had a lot more success when compared to his WWE run. He won the IWGP Tag Team Championships twice, Pro Wrestling Noah€™s GHC Tag Team Championships once, and the World Tag League twice. He even won Wrestling Observer Newsletter's Tag Team of the Year in 2011. These accomplishments proved that, if given the right opportunity, Bloom could actually perform well inside a ring. He truly belonged in a Japanese ring, where strength and workrate were considered more important than charisma and gimmick. And yet, he decided to return to the WWE in 2012, despite his successful tag team with Karl Anderson. He debuted as Lord Tensai, and at the time, the WWE wanted to make a big deal of him. Unfortunately, the differences between Japanese and American wrestling fans proved to be his downfall. What entertained the Japanese bored the Americans, who seemed to enjoy chanting €œAlbert€ more than seeing him Chokebomb his opponents. Not even a clean win over John Cena could help him, and he was soon relegated to jobbing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eVc2p3mMGlo As if that wasn€™t enough, he soon became involved in embarrassing situations, including having to wear women€™s lingerie, before becoming Dancing big guy Brodus Clay€™s partner in €˜Tons of Funk€™, during which time he was sometimes called €œSweet T Tensai€. That team would last through most of 2013, and Bloom would then go on to become a commentator for NXT, and then announce his retirement from in-ring competition in August 2014. I hate to say it, but Giant Bernard should€™ve stayed in Japan, where he excelled at demolishing people.

2. Ken Kennedy/Anderson

Ken Kennedy had everything that Vince McMahon wanted in a top guy: he had the look, he could wrestle, and he could talk. He was basically a gift to the CEO of the WWE from the wrestling gods (no, not JBL). During his first run on SmackDown, he went undefeated, pinning every star one by one, including Batista and the Undertaker. After a feud with the Deadman, which saw Kennedy win by DQ and by way of First Blood, Kennedy soon found himself on RAW, and won the Money in the Bank Ladder Match at WrestleMania 23. It looked like he was going to be a big star. That is, until he got released. It€™s too bad€both parties could have had a lot of success. Rumors have it that Kennedy was supposed to be revealed as Mr. McMahon€™s illegitimate son, and would€™ve had a major push, thus making him a star and Vince even wealthier. Instead, that storyline led to Hornswoggle becoming Mr. McMahon€™s illegitimate son, and we all know how well that turned out€ After working for the WWE, Kennedy wound up in TNA, where he competed under his real name, Mr. Anderson. It was in TNA where Anderson reached the zenith of his career up to that point, winning the TNA World Heavyweight Championship twice. Will Kennedy return to the WWE? No one can say for certain, as his departure came under suspicious circumstances. What is certain, however, is that his career reached even higher points after he left.

1. Johnny Ace / Jon Laurinaitis

Johnny Ace Wcw Yes, Jon Laurinaitis, Mr. People Power, and the living definition of glad-handed, nonsensical, douchebag yes-men (at least, according to CM Punk), was once a highly respected and accomplished professional wrestler€in Japan. Though he never managed to capture All Japan€™s top title, the coveted Triple Crown Championship, he did nevertheless achieve great success as a tag team wrestler. Among some of his tag team partners in Japan included Bart Gunn, €˜Dr. Death€™ Steve Williams, and the legendary Kenta Kobashi. His teaming with Kobashi proved to be one of his best, as the duo won both the All Japan World Tag Team Championship, and the All Asia Tag Team Championship, the latter being the oldest wrestling title in Japan. He also had two Five Star Matches, and won Match of the Year in 1996, teaming with Steve Williams against the team of Mitsuharu Misawa and Jun Akiyama. He was also the innovator of the Cutter wrestling maneuver, which has since gone on to be popularized by the likes of Matt Hardy, Randy Orton, and of course, Diamond Dallas Page. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i152p_unzKc Fast forward to 2002, and John Laurinaitis signed a contract with the WWE, as a backstage agent. His main role was in Talent Relations, eventually replacing Jim Ross as Executive Vice President of that area. During this time, at least, according to shoot videos readily available on YouTube, he was criticized for making WWE€™s working relationship with Ohio Valley Wrestling (OVW) much more difficult, and some of his signings have been a bit controversial. If you€™re wondering who was responsible for the surge in female talent with little to no wrestling background coming into the WWE, Johnny Ace is your man. He also signed Zack Gowen, the one-legged wrestler. While that was indeed an inspirational story, it was a very odd choice to say the least. Laurinaitis appeared on-screen for a while, appearing to be the biggest corporate stooge to ever accompany Vince McMahon. He even wrestled against John Cena at Over the Limit 2012, which was the worst match of that year. A far cry from the man who once performed at such a high level in Japan. Thanks for reading. Be sure to check out WhatCulture€™s WWE section for other interesting articles

In this post: 
Sin Cara
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Alexander Podgorski is a writer for WhatCulture that has been a fan of professional wrestling since he was 8 years old. He loves all kinds of wrestling, from WWE and sports entertainment, to puroresu in Japan. He holds a Bachelor of Arts degree from Queen's University in Political Studies and French, and a Master's Degree in Public Administration. He speaks English, French, Polish, a bit of German, and knows some odd words and phrases in half a dozen other languages.