10 Terrible Gimmick Wrestling Matches One Tweak Away From Excellence
Close to perfection, but even closer to chaos...
WWE most recent Hell In A Cell debacle (imagine the timeline where that qualifier was required, only don't, because we're in it) was another reminder that even the most treasured stipulations can be blown to pieces by bad booking.
Though Shawn Michaels insisted on getting on top of the structure during its original airing in 1997, his efforts weren't remotely in betrayal of the story being told. 'HBK' was on the run the entire time, and the need to open the door to set free an injured cameraman was all the excuse he needed. Similarly, when The Undertaker blocked his route to the back, Michaels genuinely believed safety awaited him in the heavens rather than trapped in the titular hell.
22 years on, and the company would have long stopped the match. Seth Rollins and Bray Wyatt's contemporary catastrophe was b*llocks at best and career-killing at worst. The true results remain to be seen, but have the company conclusively cocked up the prestige of what used to be known as "Satan's Prison".
It was hell to watch, at very least. As were all of these matches, though in direct contrast to the mesh, these never truly stood a chance. Though they could have...
10. King Of The Road
Why It's Terrible: It's a fight on a moving hay truck where the result isn't even determined by pinfall or submission but by making it to one end of the truck and ringing a bell. It's a weird watch, but admirably experimental.
One Tweak:
9. Punjabi Prison
Why It's Terrible: The bamboo doesn't quite pack the same punch as the solid steel most fans have become accustomed to on cages, cells and chambers.
Also, every single match contested within it thus far has totally stunk.
One Tweak: The convoluted rules sort of suited the silliness of the original Great Khali character, but all the locked doors and spiked bamboo are a) too Crystal Maze to look like they form part of a killer device and b) too self-contained to really make that much sense.
WWE officials working in tandem with the controllers of the cage, or even enforcing such a strange set of stipulations, is quite a needless stretch when there's surely more satisfaction in watching two men make firewood with the remains of the structure from the outset? Lock all the doors from the off and take the sharpened blades from the ends of the inside canes - a one-fall to a finish doesn't force a combatant to try and leave, more to just battle their way to a win in the wood.
8. Blindfold Match
Why It's Terrible: Because not a lot necessarily has to happen - the gimmick requires wrestlers to miss moves as it does hit them in order to make the most of the stipulation.
One Tweak: Blindfold the referee as well.
Virtually every combination of heel/babyface advantage/disadvantage has been fleshed out in this concept to such a maddening degree that the charm of even something like Jack Roberts' enjoyable outing against RicK Martel at WrestleMani has gradually dissolved. It's time to go all in on the slapstick.
The wrestlers, themselves unsure because of the hoods, do their usual bit of back-and-forth with requisite chicanery, but then have the added problem of dragging the referee around with every move. This would lead to some errant-but-cathartic moves hitting one of the officials instead, used to particularly great drama when the heel is being a cheating turd only to find the referee as clueless as their babyface victim.
It allows for a bit of role reversal too - and anything that empowers a babyface in the modern era is better than the established norm.
7. King Of The Mountain
Why It's Terrible: A desperate attempt from Vince Russo and TNA to reinvent one of wrestling's wheels. The end requiring the wrestler to hang a title after a pinfall is somewhat preposterous, and works against what's often quite a unique affair.
One Tweak: Hang the belt from the very beginning.
There's so much happening in a King Of The Mountain match that it looks beyond saving, but ironing out this minor detail would provide such a huge benefit to the rest of the encounter.
For the uninitiated, five men start but nobody can climb a ladder to hang a title (and thus win it) until they've registered a fall on somebody. Said loser goes into a penalty box for a predetermined amount of time, helpless to stop the action until they're released.
I swear to god, bro, it's not that complicated, bro. But for common sense's sake just hang the belt like a normal ladder match and everything else won't see half as hard.
6. Iron Man
Why It's Terrible: It's really, really hard to get right. No falls over 60 minutes can be a total drain, but too many render the match somewhat unbelievable. Especially if the decisions come at the expense of the wrestler's intelligence.
One Tweak: Ban finishers until the final 10 minutes. If two stars have gone hell-for-leather without registering a fall, they've earned the right to unleash their deadliest weapon at the most important moment. If the prior 50 minutes have been dishwater dull, fix all that with a spam session in the final 10.
Going into war without their favourite hold or strike, the wrestlers will also be forced into alternate creative solutions outside of their typical comfort zone, which could act as a reinvention of sorts over the course of the hour. WWE have long given up trying to keep consistency with their characters, so there's no better match than this to make the most of the chaos.
5. Casino Battle Royal
Why It's Terrible: The multiple entry format results in nobody getting any focus upon arrival, as well as asking odd questions of how that all looks backstage. Diffusing the easy pop instead of enhancing it, much of the bout is clouded by confusion as the "suits" are all revealed.
One Tweak: Accept defeat and run it like a regular Royal Rumble.
The suits just aren't that captivating for the audience, even if the last person in the ring is a guaranteed popper. There's too much risk for too little reward - AEW enjoy boasting a diverse, different and dangerous roster compared to their rivals, but there's nothing worse than seeing folk that fit this exact brief getting lost in the shuffle because another wrestler is getting their sh*t in.
As much as it might p*ss on Cody's chips (but if anybody needs that once in a while, it's him), WWE have figured this one out well enough and engineered it accordingly. The mid-match pins and submissions still keep it different from their competition too.
4. Steel Cage
Why It's Terrible: WWE's Hell In A Cell put paid to it being the most violent end to a feud. Many believe WWE had already done this years earlier by introducing the escape-to-win stipulation.
One Tweak: Get back to basics and lock the spartans in there until only one emerges. WWE have potentially cooked the Cell as it is, so they might as well try and reheat the cage back to being the sort of devil's playground it was once known as.
The blue bars instigated by Vince McMahon in the 1980s allowed Hulk Hogan-sized behemoths to climb the structure, but his organisation is now furnished with super athletes capable of doing just as much with the mesh. Beyond that, consider the ending isolated to one single conclusion - knockout finishes only.
At the point at which the opponent can't answer the referee - or anybody - thanks to exhuastion, submission or total destruction, they're done for.
3. Fatal Four-Way
Why It's Terrible: Hard to follow for the fans in attendance (thus impacting the viewing experience to those watching on television), Fatal Four-Ways tend to devolve into split singles matches anyway, often resulting in stars laying on the floor selling unconvincingly rather than trying to get back into the match.
One Tweak: Elimination rules only.
WWE, to their credit, have improved upon multi-person matches by making most of them elimination or gauntlets, which forces finishes and a certain sense of conclusion. For years, Fatal Four-Ways especially were used for the exact opposite reason. One warm body would be there to take the fall in place of a satisfying scenario at the end and fans could often tell at the sight of the poster where exactly the fix was in.
If absolutely forced to endure four then three before a final one-on-one, the last two combatants can at least claim survival in the face of such humiliation.
2. Battle Royal
Why It's Terrible: It's everything and nothing - there's lots to look at, but upon zeroing in it quickly becomes apparent that it wasn't worth your effort in the first place. It flies directly in the face of Vince McMahon's "more is always more" philosophy because a 20-man is marginally better than a 30-man, which is marginally better than a 40-man, and so on.
One Tweak: Only book them with the World/Universal/Whatever Title on the line.
Its bad enough when half a ton of mass aren't generating enough interest to shake an arena to its foundations, but at least force through some fun by the end. WCW's World War 3 matches were a jumbled mess, but the promise of the World Heavyweight Championship or a shot at it was enough to always make the closing stages fascinating.
Making the "nitty gritty" actually gritty again would provide untold excitement, rather than the non-existent type that greets the WrestleMania Kickoff/Saudi Arabia oil money spectacles.
1. Triple Cage
Why It's Terrible: Because both times a three-floored cage existed, WCW did too. The company, far more experimental than WWE but often to a fault, couldn't help adding all sorts of b*llocks and b*llshit to a structure that did enough simply standing there. In 1996, Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage conquered eight men, attacking with frying pans and working downwards.
In 2000, David Arquette surrendered his World Title to Jeff Jarrett just to swerve turn on Diamond Dallas Page. None of those three even took a big bump - that fell to Chris Kanyon.
One Tweak: It's three f*cking cages on top of each other, that's actually enough. Only pro wrestling operating at peak insanity would feel the need to staple more silliness on to something that had every chance of being a fearsome spectre all by itself. Produced by WWE, a triple cage would at least look amazing, and would hopefully deemed dangerous and devastating without the need for ludicrous odds or hampering additional stipulations.