10 Terrible Wrestlers With One Incredible Match
Disco Inferno finds his perfect dance partner, Eva Marie almost wins big, and Sid rules the world!
An awesome wrestler can't do it by themselves.
It was often said that peak Ric Flair could get something great out of a broomstick, and every generation's peak performer has often been tasked with fighting foes with about as much movement, but they still need the body on the other side of the canvas to help them produce their works of art.
"Terrible" might also feel something of a slight on the named stars too, but the titular incredible match makes a fool of your no-bump-taking writer. These men and women were once part of something special enough that it would be spoken about years or even decades later. Who did yours truly ever beat?
In some ways, efforts such as the ones below are what make wrestling an art form at all. In the contests covered, limitations are masterfully obscured by those determined to put forth the best possible emulation of a competitive clash for the paying customers. Masters of the dark arts waving magic wands around less-than-ideal magicians assistants but still generating that all-important emotional investment from the crowd.
No, an awesome wrestler can't do it by themselves. But a bad wrestler typically can't do it at all. And yet, together...
10. Sid (Vs Shawn Michaels, WWE Survivor Series 1996)
Sid had more okay matches than his sometimes-rancid reputation suggests.
Over quite literally beyond belief in 1996, Sycho Sid had hot contests against Camp Cornette and Bret Hart even if they weren't catch-as-catch-can classics, there's a buried treasure with Diesel at In Your House 2 that most people sleep on, and Chris Benoit's WCW World Championship bout with the big man is a choice effort understandably lost to the former's final acts.
But there can only be one true Sid classic. And it took place in front of the most receptive audience he'd ever worked in front of.
The Madison Square Garden regulars were as buzzing to see the big man as they were livid with Shawn Michaels at the tail end of his "Boyhood Dream" WWE Championship run, and the rippling emotions only heightened the drama in an all-time performance from 'HBK' at his 1990s peak.
Michaels flatly refusing to acknowledge the size disparity paired magnificently with Sid's indifference to his range, not least when a finish called for the Champion to be pulled back down to earth to look after his injured mentor Jose Lothario. In attacking the elder statesman, Sid and circumvented Michaels' heart and gone for his very soul. From bell-to-ultra-dramatic-final-bell, the Arkansas giant was never was as imposing again.
9. Nia Jax (vs Bayley, NXT TakeOver: London)
Nia Jax' WWE run will be the source of debate for years, if audiences still have energy to debate a product designed to sap consumers of their emotional energy.
A Performance Center prospect rushed on to NXT screens in 2015, Jax' progression to the main roster also took place with expedited glee from those within WWE that were presumably desperate to add a monster to the talented roster being amassed at the burgeoning peak of a "Women's Revolution".
She never truly lived up to whatever potential she'd shown in training, save for flashes of evocative brilliance in matches with those that knew exactly how to find her fire. Or, to be more specific, Bayley in 2015.
On one of the best runs of her career as NXT Women's Champion, 'The Hugger' got to tell one of wrestling's oldest stories with one of its newest recruits, and Jax was incredible in playing her own part to perfection. An unstoppable monster until she was stopped, the future Raw Women's Champion looked certain to steal the beloved Bayley's belt until the titleholder choked her down and out in a gripping and euphoric conclusion.
8. Jinder Mahal (Vs AJ Styles, WWE Clash Of Champions 2017)
Jinder Mahal's WWE Championship reign was terrible for a lot of reasons, but none worse than how so utterly dull his supercard clashes with the likes Randy Orton and Shinsuke Nakamura were.
He might have bursting out of his own skin physically, but a personality has never once threatened to follow. Mahal was probably the biggest ever case of a title being required to make the man, and at no point did the project really look like a success until the one main event he managed after he lost it. As Mahal's polar opposite, Styles was the most cathartic choice to end the reign of error in a wildly popular Manchester moment, and followed up that victory with another tremendous showing in the company's final pay-per-view offering of 2017.
Mahal seemed open to being the best bit of luggage he could be, working the ribs for the heat and needing to do little else until Styles deservedly retained. That the pair went 23:00 and weren't mercilessly booed out of the building is perhaps the highest compliment to both 'The Phenomenal One' and Mahal's 2017.
7. Tom Magee (Vs Bret Hart, October 7th 1986)
For 33 long and stature-enhancing years, Bret Hart Vs Tom Magee was the ultimate WWE best kept secret. All until 2019, when Bret Hart's exceptional efforts were given a magical and cathartic fairytale ending.
Over the course of a relatively short and hugely one-sided offering, Tom Magee combined just enough of a look and athletic offering that a heart-eyed Vince McMahon considered the successor to Hulk Hogan. This, despite the fact that it was 1986 and Hulkamania hadn't even reached its explosive peak. Magee very obviously wasn't great, but he could do enough as per this.
Both Magee and McMahon were in fact in debt to 'The Excellence Of Execution'.
It was Stu Hart that recommended Magee to McMahon after some time spent in Stampede, and Hart's son Bret that gave the muscular youngster the match of a lifetime in front of his new boss. Follow-up contests exposed the jacked and jumpy youngster as an abysmally green wrestler that failed to emote between the ropes or on the microphone. The spotlight had barely heated up before it was switched off. Hart, meanwhile toiled for five more years in the tag division awaiting one of his own.
6. Virgil (vs Ted Dibiase, WWE SummerSlam 1991)
An epic of near-cinematic proportions just as the story required it, Virgil's Madison Square Garden moment of redemption against Ted Dibiase paid off years of abuse he'd suffered at the hands and money of the Million Dollar Man.
The ex-bodyguard could never do a great deal, but his boxing stuff was believable and his babyface fire looked wild enough to burn down the world's most famous arena on a scorching hot summer night that had already been good to the babyfaces before Virgil took his boss' vanity belt away.
Dibiase pitched his selling majestically too. Timing his control segments with career-best aplomb, several cutoffs seemed impossible until announcers - including Virgil's inspirational friend Roddy Piper - reminded audiences of the vast experience gulf between the two. Virgil wasn't just fighting from underneath physically either - he was fighting back from years of oppression from this deliriously ludicrous cartoon of a human.
The roar generated by the result speaks to the catharsis of what he overcame - the iconic New York building hosted many a legendary moment, but few were louder than this one.
5. Shaq (w/Jade Cargill Vs Cody Rhodes & Red Velvet, AEW Dynamite, March 3rd 2021)
A preposterously entertaining match that over-reached and over-delivered in order to over-achieved, Shaquille O'Neal's second official wrestling match obliterated his efforts in his first and made good on decades of teases.
Controlled masterfully by an in-form Cody Rhodes, the match brought together four wildly different entities to make for one magnificent whole. Rhodes and Shaq had rather listlessly traded barbs as part of the build, the the 'American Nightmare' having more back-and-forth banter with newcomer Jade Cargill than the former basketball star. She brought with her an amazing look, but was completely unproven and untested at this level. Meanwhile, Red Velvet - subbing for a pregnant Brandi Rhodes - had more in-ring time on the clock but a lot less stature in AEW, especially compared to those she shared this sizeable stage with.
The results were impossibly brilliant. Cody and Shaq's exchanges immediately - immediately - hit big with a socially distanced Daily's Place crowd, and O'Neal's powerbomb was almost graceful in its fury. A fireworks factory that kept the sky alight for 12 absorbing minutes before Velvet fell to Cargill, the peak was reached when Cody launched himself into Shaq and through a table. The improbable had been made possible by a company desperate to roar back from the throes of the pandemic's worst restrictions.
4. Norman The Lunatic (Vs Brian Pillman, Clash Of The Champions VIII)
An electrifying sprint extremely becoming of 1989 Brian Pillman if not so much the game Mike Shaw, this Clash midcard match stood aloft as the best from a one-note Norman The Lunatic gimmick as well as Shaw's fairly indistinct career.
Finding the most fame as Bastion Booger in WWE several years later, Shaw was, politely, just a generic big guy who did generic big guy stuff. The industry supported his like at the time in sizeable number, but mainly due to the likes of Pillman and others who were capable of using their flashier, quicker attacks to subdue and subtract obvious size advantages.
'Flyin Brian's at his hybrid best here, going three hundred miles an hour during an opening flourish that finds him unleashing his freakish strength with a suplex that pops the arena daft. A crossbody from the top to the arena floor is wild, further bringing out the best of Norman who later follows with his own splash from the top. The audience erupts at the match-winning crucifix with all looking lost, with Norman having kept up to such an extent that it foreshadowed the eventual babyface turn away from manager Teddy Long's cruel control.
3. Brodus Clay (Vs Curt Hawkins, WWE Raw January 9th 2012)
A bizarre and brilliant transgression from the norm that ever-so-briefly presented WWE has a fun organisation willing to take risks, Brodus Clay's 2012 re-debuted presented a gimmick that never could have been expected and sadly would never be this good again.
The company had teased out Clay's return as a common-or-garden monster for weeks, with the delay seemingly due to John Laurinaitis on and off-screen ineptitude. Instead, the eventual reveal exposed that there'd been an out-of-the-box rethink - the played out killer would instead be a dance-obsessed dinosaur.
The sheer absurdity of that specific pitch was crucial - even in 2022, some fans aren't ready for a wrestling dinosaur in AEW, but the fact that the relic could cut a rug made all the difference. As too did Clay's investment in the bit. Adopting a cartoonish tone as he abused the bewildered Curt Hawkins (faux-apologetic "My Bad"s were punctuated with a p*ss funny "Should I get him?!" as if he'd walked out of a Lancashire social club in 1976), big Brodus immediately endeared himself to children and adults alike with this strange and marvellous creation.
It was never as good again. Toning down and scaling back elements until the magic was lost in place of very generic WWE pantomime inside the body of a performer with obvious in-ring limitations, the joy of the original squash was never again recaptured.
2. Eva Marie (Vs Bayley, WWE NXT November 19th 2015)
Proof if proof be need be that Eva Marie really could put the "everything" in her own nickname, and that NXT was once every bit as gold as its branding suggested, a television main event with Bayley saw apexes converging in masterful, stunning fashion.
Marie had never been more loathed in Full Sail University, backed as she was by the transparent bias of the main roster machine. Michael Cole was installed as an interim General Manager for the night, WWE head official Charles Robinson took officiating duties, and the Challenger was even given her own locker room. Bayley, meanwhile, was soaring as Champion. Workhorse, carthorse and legitimately the biggest star of the show, she wore her heart on her sleeve and NXT's in her soul.
Never had NXT and Raw and SmackDown felt further apart, and for Triple H to spot and exploit this for a gripping and nerve-wracking main event only spoke to his own personal peak as the show's chief creative force.
The match goes a mere 6:45 but the entire 45 minute episode is worth every bit of investment with it. Just over half a decade later, it already feels like time capsule content of a bygone era.
1. Disco Inferno (Vs Dean Malenko, WCW Bash At The Beach 1996)
Disco Inferno occupies a strange space in the modern wrestling universe, though the mere fact he remains in any conversations might be as much to do with his failure to dominate them at his peak.
A legendary Cody Rhodes Twitter burial of the former WCW regular stuck so deeply in his craw that he pivoted towards the position of AEW troll-for-hire when the company formed in 2019. The meat of Rhodes' remarks about the "juiced up double-lifer" was that nothing he ever did left an impression on folk as they left the building.
This banger with Dean Malenko should have been the rule-proving exception, but in a darkly amusing twist, it couldn't be. As good as their minor classic was, they never stood a chance of being part of the car park discourse as fans filed out. The Cruiserweight Championship bout filled the undercard of Bash At The Beach 1996 - a show rightfully remembered for Hulk Hogan's iconic heel turn and little else.
Cody's causticity was on point after all, though Inferno can at least point to one night where he didn't "hide in plain sight".