10 Terrible Wrestling Storylines With Great Matches

When life gives you lemons...

Eddie Guerrero Rey Mysterio SummerSlam
WWE

In wrestling, as in life, it's all about doing the best with the hand you've been dealt.

If the WWE creative team, for reasons unknown, decide that your character is best-served disavowing their legendary family heritage, instead becoming sweater-wearing, golf cart-driving Kerwin White, then there's really no point arguing*. All you can do is make sure you deliver your best work inside the ring.

Turning water into wine is a trick that many wrestlers lumbered with unfortunate scripts have had to pull off over the years, but seldom have they really got much credit. It's just seen as a given that they - as professionals - should be able to put on great matches, even when those matches represent the conclusion of dreadful storylines which we all hated.

That changes now, though, with 10 examples of terrible storylines that, for all their foibles, actually delivered great matches at their climax - occasions when wrestlers themselves have made good on the mission statement of entertaining the crowd, however determined the writers are to leave them bored and confused.

*Actually, Chavo perhaps could have put up more of a fight on that one.

10. Edge Vs. John Cena Vs. Big Show

edge vickie guerrero
WWE.com

Whilst it made sense for Edge to look for an equaliser in his efforts to stave off the threat of The Undetaker, it's probably fair to say that, on the whole The Rated-R Superstar's relationship with Vickie Guerrero was something we all could have done without.

It became weird mid-way through 2008 when Triple H shared with the world footage of the groom-to-be smooching wedding planner Alicia Fox, even weirder a few months later when Vickie took him back, and then just plain silly weeks before WrestleMania 25 when it emerged she had, in fact, been having an affair with Big Show the whole time.

That final reveal was essentially just made so that they could find a way of inserting John Cena into the World Heavyweight Title picture at the last minute (he blackmailed Vickie with the threat of exposing her secret to make it a triple threat match, only to then expose said secret anyway).

It was daft, in short, but watch the resulting matches in isolation and they're not bad. The WrestleMania triple threat - remembered chiefly for Cena lifting both his opponents simultaneously - was a whole load of fun, and the follow-up Last Man Standing bout at Backlash a veritable classic.


9. Main Event Mafia Vs. TNA Frontline

Much of the criticism aimed at TNA during its hey-day was that ex-WWE and WCW veterans were being pushed at the expense of homegrown stars like AJ Styles, Samoa Joe, and Christopher Daniels.

With that in mind, the birth of The Main Event Mafia - a heel stable of 40 and 50-somethings who conspired to keep their younger counterparts from reaching the top of the card - kind of made sense. They certainly wouldn't be short of boos, anyway.

The problem, however, was that there was rarely any sense that the angle was being used to put over said homegrown stars. Instead, we watched MEM hold all of the TNA gold, and then later - for some reason - Joe join their ranks after turning his back on the Frontline.

It felt like a hasty re-hash of the equally perplexing Millionaire's Club from latter-day WCW - but unlike latter-day WCW, TNA still knew how to deliver the goods inside the ring. The Lethal Lockdown encounter in 2009 is still a must-see for anyone who loves a good cage match.


8. Matt Hardy Vs. Jeff Hardy

Jeff Hardy Matt Hardy Backlash 2009 I Quit
WWE.com

Sibling on sibling violence has been a staple part of professional wrestling going back to the days of Owen and Bret, but - to most - the 2009 feud between the Hardys was kind of lame.

Mainly, this was because of accusations of bad taste, stemming from the part of the angle that saw Matt attack his brother and leave him unresponsive in his hotel room at Survivor Series (which brought back some rather unpleasant memories of Eddie Guerrero's death three years earlier).

It also didn't seem like a particularly good time to do it. Jeff had just broken into the main event when Matt decided that they had some issues to work out, meaning that he missed out on a potential spot in WrestleMania 25's World Heavyweight Title match.

Whatever the background noise, though, the brothers did share a pair of impressive matches, first at 'Mania itself and then in a brutal "I Quit" match the following month at Backlash, where the Charismatic Enigma tied his opponent to a table to force a submission.


7. Dolph Ziggler Vs. The Miz

The Miz No Mercy 2016
WWE.com

The Intercontinental Championship is going through something of a rough patch at the moment (if by rough patch you mean the last 15 years of its existence), but feuds like this one showed that fans yearn for a reason to care about it.

In the fall of 2016, Dolph Ziggler was so desperate for another chance to hold The Miz's belt that he put his entire career on the line, agreeing that he would retire from the sport of professional wrestling if he did not emerge victorious from their match at No Mercy.

The pair then shared one of the year's great matches, comfortably stealing the next morning's headlines despite being billed third on the card behind the WWE Championship triple threat and the Randy Orton-Bray Wyatt main event.

It all seemed fine, until the storyline abruptly became pointless (and not just pointless, but a malignant type of pointless) when The Miz won the title back a month later. Dolph, it seemed, put up his livelihood for absolutely nothing.


6. D-Generation X Vs. The McMahons

Vince McMahon Shawn Michaels Unforgiven 2006
WWE

Most already know that D-Generation X versus McMahons in 2006 was stupid for a number of reasons that probably don't need to be repeated here. But, for anyone who missed it, below is a brief overview.

Firstly, there was the fact that Shawn Michaels' original tag team partner was God himself, who made his WWE pay-per-view debut at Backlash, where he and the Heartbreak Kid were inexplicably defeated by the father-son duo of Vince and Shane.

After that came a summer of nostalgic toilet humour - only without any of the nostalgia. Shawn and Triple H got the band back together for the first time in a decade, but with HBK now a devout believer much of the "edge" that made their original act so popular had been dispensed with.

It wasn't enough to make it all worthwhile, but the Hell in a Cell bout - also featuring Big Show - at Unforgiven 2006 was a pretty good one, particularly when you consider the respective ages of those involved (plus, seeing the chairman get his head rammed up the World's Largest Athlete's ass was pretty fun).


5. Kurt Angle Vs. Jeff Jarrett

Jeff JArrett Kurt Angle
Impact Wrestling

Given how upset Kurt Angle understandably seemed when the events of his private life were made public a few years earlier, it was an odd move in 2011 when TNA began incorporating the real-life breakdown of his marriage into their kayfabe TV product.

The storyline essentially involved his ex-wife Karen, now married to Jeff Jarrett, doing her level best to keep the Olympic Gold Medallist from realising any ambitions left unfulfilled in his career (and, of course, ultimately failing).

Apart from the toe-curling awkwardness of watching art imitating life on screen, the storyline wasn't particularly entertaining, and it meant that a non-wrestler was taking up precious airtime that the likes of Alex Shelley, Chris Sabin, and Jay Lethal would have killed for.

In the ring, though, Angle - as ever - delivered, sharing an excellent two out of three falls match with Jarrett at Lockdown, which was contested under what they referred to as "Ultra Male Rules" (but trust us: it was good).


4. CM Punk Vs. Triple H

Triple H CM Punk Night of Champions
WWE

Not since the halcyon days of the Attitude Era has WWE had a three-month stretch quite as exciting as 2011's Summer of Punk. It would have been perfect, too, had it not been for the bizarre intervention from Kevin Nash.

After surprising the Straight Edge Superstar with an attack at SummerSlam, Nash spent the next few weeks keeping us all guessing. Just who had sent that text to him instructing him to beat up the new WWE Champion?

We later learned that it was, wait for it, none other than Big Sexy himself, who apparently commandeered Triple H's phone for reasons still unknown to anyone not named Vince McMahon.

It appears what really happened here is that Nash was ruled unable to compete at the upcoming Night of Champions, and the plans were in turn changed at the last minute. Instead, we got CM Punk and Triple H, who - for two sworn enemies - pulled off an excellent 25-minute bout (albeit one from which the wrong man emerged with victory).


3. Rey Mysterio Vs. Eddie Guerrero

Eddie Guerrero Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

It was virtually impossible for Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero to get into the ring together and not produce, at the very least, a four star match.

It was, however, perfectly possible for them to produce the odd moment of cringe - a point capably illustrated by the unedifying custody battle storyline in which they both became embroiled during the summer of 2005.

For those blissfully unfamiliar with all of the ins and outs, this angle essentially involved Eddie claiming that he was, in fact, the paternal father of Rey's son Dominick (played on-screen by his real-life kid son Dominick - which must have been confusing).

Things came to a head at SummerSlam, when the pair met in a ladder match. Hanging above the ring were documents which guaranteed custody rights to whichever man retrieved them first.

However dumb the object hanging above the ring, though, this was a show-stealing bout, only slightly ruined by the now infamous fourth wall break from Latino Heat, who would berate wife Vickie for missing her cue.


2. AJ Styles Vs. Christopher Daniels

Of all the dumb TNA storylines, the whole Claire Lynch thing was perhaps the worst - not least of all because it involved AJ Styles, a man who unlike any other embodied what the company was (or was supposed to be) all about.

It began when Christopher Daniels ostensibly exposed an affair between wholesome family man AJ and TNA president Dixie Carter. That, so we would later learn, was wide of the mark - instead the pair were caught up in the private life of Claire Lynch, a perennially pregnant extra.

Lynch would then undermine AJ's efforts to go about his normal life by claiming that the Phenomenal One was, in fact, the father of his baby (this, we were supposed to care about, despite having only just been introduced to her a few weeks earlier).

In the end, TNA actually pulled the Lynch character from TV after some overzealous fans began sending the actress abuse for her part in one of wrestling's dumbest ever storylines. Oh, and then AJ and Daniels fought an incredible Last Man Standing bout at Destination X - at least one good thing came of it.


1. Team WWF Vs. The Alliance

Survivor Series 2001 Winner Take All
WWE.com

On paper, the idea of pitting the biggest stars of the WWF against the biggest stars of WCW was a great one. In execution, however, it was poor - largely thanks to the fact that virtually all of the biggest stars of WCW weren't actually involved.

Having failed to agree terms with the likes of Hogan, Sting, Goldberg, Hall and Nash, Vince McMahon instead generously loaned some of his own wrestlers to The Alliance, who cobbled together a five-man team of Shane O'Mac, Kurt Angle, Stone Cold, Booker T and Rob Van Dam (at least two of whom had worked for the competition in the last five years).

All of that is to say that this storyline simply didn't live up to the billing. It came off too predictable and one-sided, much of the intrigue centred around which WWF employees would double-cross their side, rather than how they measured up to their WCW and ECW counterparts.

And yet, despite all of that, the climactic match at Survivor Series 2001 was undeniably brilliant. It probably takes the mantle of best ever five-on-five traditional elimination match, in fact, and at the very least ties with the Austin vs. Bischoff affair two years later.


Contributor