10 Terrible WWE Gimmicks That Were One Tweak Away From Perfection

The Nearly-But-Not-Quite Men.

Marc Mero
WWE.com

The Hell In A Cell main event between Seth Rollins and The Fiend needed more than just a finish to salvage what was clearly a train careering off the tracks, but the collapse of the contest yet again highlighted a raft of internal fragilities.

Modern day WWE operates in spite of itself, with talent constantly skating on razor-thin ice thanks to the lack of metrics solidifying their standing. On her WWE Network 24 Special, Becky Lynch referred to 2019's 'Show Of Shows' as "my WrestleMania". She espoused this with beaming pride, but there was a subconscious understanding of the broken system wrapped within it - making it on the grandest stage wasn't going to cement her status the following year as it once might have done for Hulk Hogan, Stone Cold Steve Austin or, latterly, Roman Reigns. She was grateful for her turn but knew it was just that.

Characters and gimmicks aren't intentionally abused by the clunky creative machine, but they're so often hindered by the damaged mechanisms. WWE has failed enough times to show itself as an imperfect model, but there was a time when even the duds were earnest efforts.

In 2019, the company willfully hijacked the progress of Bray Wyatt and Seth Rollins in that rancid main event in a way they'd never have done for some of the following accidental aberrations. Partly because they couldn't have sustained it, but also because the gimmicks themselves were surprisingly close to finding success...

10. Bray Wyatt (2013 - 2018)

Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

Where better to start in times of tumult for The Fiend than with the man behind the mask that, at one point, really did have the whole wrestling world in his hands.

The Bray Wyatt that left NXT for the main roster in 2013, was every bit as sharpened as his unique vignettes suggested because the character was afforded the one thing it absolutely fundamentally needed to thrive - success.

Sounds simple, but Wyatt's persistent inability to simply just f*cking win did irreversible damage to a gimmick that's hard enough to sell in the modern age. 'The Eater Of Worlds' had - so we were made to believe - indiscriminate magical powers yet couldn't use any of them do hold a wrestler down for three when it mattered. For years it was all flexes and hexes until he was forced to front his inhuman abilities against superhuman pro wrestlers.

The likes of John Cena, Randy Orton, The Undertaker and virtually every other topliner that came into contact with him saw through his hocus pocus as entirely bogus, beating him with ease and robbing the mystique in the process. Yet, little changes - it appeared for months as if the same mistake wouldn't be made with The Fiend, but Wyatt could well be doomed yet again as the rebadged baddie.


9. The Prime Time Players

Prime Time Players
WWE.com

"Millions of dollars, millions of dollars, millions of dollars" was the sort of goofy sh*t too good not to get over in the grey and grim early 2010s WWE landscape, yet a bizarre insistence on never truly committing to the Darren Young/Titus O'Neil team as a team ultimately put paid to their enjoyable act.

There's a misconception that every tag team has to reach an end destination and spit out singles stars, but both Young and O'Neill never looked as good as when they could elevate each other. Their time together on misfit broadcast NXT Redemption was a bizarre and brilliant success in an environment engineered to craft nothing but abject failure. Their two runs on the main roster between 2012 and 2015 were axed with nominal rationale - on both occasions, the characters coming out of the double act were weaker than the ones portrayed within it.

A "tweak" is only ever really the smallest of changes, but it was this WWE couldn't resist with O'Neill and Young. From over to very-f*cking-not-over, their trajectories were twice tanked as a result.


8. James Ellsworth

James Ellsworth
WWE.com

Wrestling's so often as much to do with timing as ability or aptitude, and though James Ellsworth earned longer in the spotlight than most comedy acts because of his remarkable gift for taking a beating, he was another victim of WWE's propensity for over-egging the pudding.

Initially a "chinless insect" with his fabulously frightened catchphrase, Ellsworth was every bit the man "with two hands and a fighting chance", but his 2016 interjections in the AJ Styles/Dean Ambrose WWE Championship programme trivialised the men and their matches. In finding a new spot form him alongside Carmella, the company effectively acknowledged just how irritating they'd made this genuinely charming little oddball become, with their over-reliance his undoing.

As with the good timing at the start of his run, he overstayed his welcome on the backend of a middling WWE run. There's a time to stay, and a time to f*ck off, but WWE didn't really get this right. As was, Ellsworth could have been an all-time great punchline character. Instead, that joke wasn't funny anymore, nor was it interesting, or annoying, or really any kind of engaging, valuable emotion.


7. Marvellous Marc Mero

Marc Mero
WWE.com

What kind of boxer can't actually knock folk out? Not a good one, nor a "Marvellous" one, despite his personalised branding and the support of megastar-in-waiting Sable.

Such was the immediate crisis Marc Mero faced upon his return from injury in late 1997. Going down with a knock earlier in the year, Mero had previously dazzled as the 'Wildman', with his flashy arsenal overwhelming a corny gimmick and lack of popularity in the locker room. The company he returned to later in the year had changed dramatically in his absence, not least in its need for heels following the meteoric rise of Stone Cold Steve Austin through the babyface ranks.

Abandoning the "call of the wild" (whatever that actually was), Mero drew on his Golden Gloves history to inform a turn to the dark side as a p*ssed off version of his former self. Unfortunately, sharing a stage with 'The Toughest S.O.B' undermined his every action.

Negating to batter folk with his fists of fury, Mero only really threw hands when he could cuff somebody in the balls for a cheap win. Like everybody else, he was a willing victim for 'The Rattlesnake' too, further denting his chances of getting the workable persona over.


6. Ted Dibiase (1994 - 1996)

Ted Dibiase Irs
WWE.com

So few folk were watching WWE in the mid-1990s that it was easy to miss Ted Dibiase even retiring from in-ring action in WWE during the brief gap between his transition from full-time wrestler to retired manager/commentator. It's perhaps because of this that he never really quite felt like the loaded stable boss his Corporation so desperately needed.

For all the money he supposedly had at his disposal, Dibiase's hires were never all that successful, nor did he particularly hold many of them to account for multiple drab losses in the years he ran the group. Of all the dorks and losers linked to the team, only Bam Bam Bigelow paid the penalty for a heavy defeat, but in at least making the WrestleMania main event in 1995 he bettered the efforts of his colleagues. His firing resulted in the closest he ever came to a proper run atop the company.

Years later, Vince (and to a lesser extent Shane) McMahon fit this identical role to perfection. Obnoxiously rich folk paying goons to do their bidding, the bosses had believable clout Dibiase lacked despite all his years as the roster's richest wrestler. A bizarre case of what could have been, Dibiase's lack of an eye for talent undermined everything the company were trying to achieve with the gimmick.


5. Nailz

Big Boss Man Nailz
WWE.com

Nailz was only short the logical extension of his backstory (and perhaps a great deal of wrestling talent, and not being so short tempered with Vince McMahon, and not requiring a voice modulator every time he spoke) from being a persona that ultimately could have shone beyond his original feud.

He told the world that he'd been locked up and abused by the Big Boss Man for a crime he didn't commit, causing deep depression during his oppression. WWE never bothered to acknowledge it, but the timeline actually matched up with their internal continuity.

Boss Man debuted in 1988 as an evil prison guard intent on using the same brand of violence he'd enjoyed as a bully cop, but turned babyface in 1990 thanks to his time in his new profession. The man Nailz remembered was that guy, not the fun-loving 1992 babyface he assaulted and abused for most of the summer.

Terrifying and believable before a rather simple and relatable explanation, this humanising quirk could have fleshed out a rather one dimensional gimmick beyond his jumpsuit and prison patter.


4. The Gobbledy Gooker

The Gobbledy Gooker
WWE

Had The Gobbledy Gooker been everything he was supposed to have been, he might have stood a chance.

WWE wanted a kid-friendly mascot to f*ck about between the matches, like every mascot at every sporting event that's ever happened. This in itself wasn't so daft a deal - WCW later took the concept forward, and one senses this would have been Pharaoh's role for AEW had Cody not nearly cooked him over a pyro barbecue on pay-per-view earlier this year.

What WWE f*cked was his build, his arrival and his introduction. There's one fleeting chance to made a good first impression, and Survivor Series 1990's Gobbledy Gooker debut was categorically not it.

The mammoth egg he laughably emerged from was ridiculous, but drew enough interest before the event that, as a payoff, he was an immediate disappointment. When has a mutated turkey been anything but?

As a gentle introduction to the halfway point of a house show, or comical visual aid between television squashes, the odd concoction could have been a charming aside. As the giant reveal from a giant f*cking egg, it was dead before it hatched.


3. Giant Gonzalez

Giant Gonzalez
WWE.com

Figure this f*cking gear out, man.

Giant Gonzalez was a rare case of the madcap wrestling minds actually being right about one quality being enough. Jorge González may not have quite been his billed eight foot, but much like his ability to stand down Sid Vicious in WCW sold the idea well enough, his Royal Rumble 1993 annihilation of The Undertaker was made completely believable thanks to his remarkable height.

Not all that great at looking particularly villainous despite the origin story of his character (manager Harvey Wippleman went into the wilderness and returned with him as per a promise to one day "drop a bomb" on The Undertaker), Gonzalez was at least a delivery on the promised payoff. His abominable snowman get-up didn't half trivialise the terror.

In a rare case of WCW doing Sports Entertainment bullsh*t better than WWE, El Gigante was given knockoff spaceman threads with the implication that he perhaps wasn't of this world. Though he didn't boast the best physique, spraying on abs and biceps (along with fur) didn't remotely enhance the aesthetic.

Just how would a giant of his awesome force dress? Well, anyway he damn well pleases. That was the agency Gonzalez wasn't ever afforded.


2. Fake Razor Ramon & Diesel

Fake Razor & Diesel
WWE

This isn't an effort to defend the indefensible.

But...

Presented entirely without context, the idea of sending out fraudulent versions of old gimmicks was patently absurd. Even with a broad explanation it's still quite ridiculous, but had WWE committed to the original concept with the same vim and vigor of Jim Ross on Night One, it might have stood a chance.

JR's scathing assault on WWE owner (but, in kayfabe, babyface commentator) Vince McMahon was one of the promos of the year, instantly creating a heel persona that was more than willing to destroy his employers from the inside. His first method of attack - pure embarrassment. "Razor" and "Diesel" were intended to be laughable - mockeries of both the company's plight and the charmingly cheesy picadillos of Vince McMahon's promotional style.

Rather than simply parodying the men, Ross' narrative that he was a star-maker could have resulted in Vince and his fanbase fuming at the sight of this imposters. Enraged at the flagrant arrogance of a man he'd accidentally allowed into his organisation who was now revelling in wrecking it via these humiliation tactics.

Instead, the pair somehow just became part of the roster. Commentators that once fumed over the fakery just started...calling them Razor Ramon and Diesel. Embracing the act legitimised it, despite the illegitimacy being the beating heart of what was supposed to work to begin with.


1. The Ringmaster

Ringmaster Ted Dibiase
WWE

Steve Austin was so close to perfection in 1996 that actually found it in 1997, but it took his separation from Ted Dibiase six months into his WWE run to instantly strip away everything that simply didn't quite click about the gimmick.

Being the Million Dollar Man's top charge at that point was to be damned with the faintest praise in the entire company. As noted elsewhere in this list, Dibiase's Corporation were a busted flush within a year of formation, and even less functional than that by the time Austin was just about the last guy still lingering around the fallen star.

Without the gaudy, dated Million Dollar Championship and the inadvertent barrier of Ted doing his talking, the only thing the future 'Rattlesnake' was a master of was his own destiny.

The tweak was so blindingly obvious that he even managed to use a storyline defeat to his advantage in making it happen. Dibiase promised to leave the company if Austin lost to Savio Vega at May 1996's In Your House: Beware Of Dog 2 (in reality, WCW's real millions had won his signature). In an inspired post-mortem on his loss, Stone Cold implied that he threw the contest to ditch the dead weight.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Marc Mero
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.