10 Things Everybody Gets Wrong About WCW
Due South.
Okay, not everybody.
But history is written by the winners, and WWE have farted out as many books, DVDs, articles and even pay-per-view matches as they could get away with in order to perpetuate the myth that World Championship Wrestling was merely a rinky dink southern outfit that briefly out-drew the wholesome family World Wrestling Federation strictly by purchasing all its old stars.
The clichés are now deeply embedded in the fibre of younger fans growing up in a world where WCW literally never existed, despite a wealth of evidence to the contrary on WWE's very own over-the-top streaming service.
As is often the case, the realities were nowhere near as messy as McMahonism would have you believe, nor as blusterous as a Bischoffian address. The truth fell somewhere in between, with a host of the Atlanta outfit's successes and failures alike over-wrought for the benefit of whomever happens to be arguing the toss.
Yes, if the organisation had ultimately curbed the worst of its latter day excess, it may still have existed today. Had this alternate timeline occurred though, what then of a WWE so beloved by its core 'universe' and broadly tolerated by a vast fanbase picking and choosing the bits they like for a princely monthly fee? And how differently would WCW's darkest days be framed, had they won the war?
10. 1989
Most fans old enough to know better but young enough to not care will reminisce fondly on the WCW/NWA output from 1989. It remains perhaps the finest single calendar year for the legendary Ric Flair thanks to standard-raising battles with Ricky Steamboat and Terry Funk over the organisation's beautiful big gold belt.
It's, in essence, everything there is to love about the industry. The Flair/Steamboat matches are wrestling clinics, almost minimalist in style yet luxurious in substance. Better still is the narrative journey Flair's character in particular takes following the trading of the NWA World Heavyweight Title. The cocksure heel at the beginning of their arc, he's a respectful competitor by the end, reclaiming his lost prize as a babyface only to be viciously decked in the post-match by guest judge Terry Funk to move things immediately forward.
Whilst it was true WWE couldn't compete bell-to-bell with the standard of action, this broad thought process overlooks the utterly woeful goings on below the topline.
Divisive ex-Pizza Hut manager Jim Herd had taken over as Executive Vice President in January, and despite overseeing each of the aforementioned classics, he'd still request 'The Nature Boy' dress up as Spartacus for a radical repackaging in an effort to match the cartoonish competition. It would be another failed effort to join The Ding Dongs, The Dynamic Dudes, Ranger Ross on Herd's vast scrapheap. 1989 was the genesis of his catastrophic reign.
9. Nip And Tuck
Monday Nitro's emergence as the dominant wrestling programme in North America is overstated both by the parties that promoted it at the time and those that wish to over-egg its eventual collapse. The 84-week streak of ratings victories over Raw between 1996 and 1998 is incredibly well documented, but the reality of the early days of the head-to-head war doesn't overtly portray the WCW production as the runaway success it was often thought to be.
Ahead of Eric Bischoff finally pulling away in May, the companies were almost equal in weekly number scuffles. WWE even took full control of the battle during Shawn Michaels' maiden WWE Title feuds with Diesel and Davey Boy Smith before 'Big Daddy Cool' and Kliq mate Razor Ramon travelled south.
WCW would score a victory on their final one-hour edition of the show and do the same again a week later on a double length edition that saw the landscape-shifting debut of Scott Hall. WWE would only notch another successful week between then and 1998, but had little reason to fear their rival's complete dominance up to that point.
8. The Bret Hart Problem
With ample justification, Bret Hart's run in WCW is lamented for the company dropping more b*llocks than Austin Aries in a backstage promo, but rarely is any of the blame shuffled over to 'The Hitman' himself.
Bret Hart was every bit as excellent as his nickname suggested, and you've only to ask him if you're a non-believer. But the broken man that left WWE in November 1997 after the most tumultuous year of his personal and professional life (up to that point), was not the iconic 'Best There Is, Best There Was and Best There Ever Will Be'.
Physically shattered from his draining turf war with Shawn Michaels and mentally debilitated after the collapse of his relationship with Vince McMahon, the disinterest between Hart and the Atlanta outfit was frustratingly mutual. Every horrendous booking decision the company made was matched by his abject lack of enthusiasm and commitment.
Bret was better than nearly all the headliners WCW had in their employ at the time of course, but upon realising he couldn't exhibit the type of ability needed to earn a place amongst them, he far-too-willingly fell backwards into the fog.
7. "Raids"
Eric Bischoff has gamely tried to defend himself on this subject numerous times, but like so many prevailing narratives on the era, WWE's mandated explanation often steals headlines.
As an arm of Turner Broadcasting rather than a company stood alone, WCW was a different entity to WWE entirely, but Vince McMahon was no stranger to operating on a different playing field to his opposition. His capitalistic 1980s model flew in the face of historic agreements his father had made with countless US promoters as he barged through territories with his travelling circus of local heroes-turned-inflated megastars.
Scott Hall and Kevin Nash were integral to WCW building on Monday Nitro's early momentum, and his ability to sign them away wasn't greatly different from McMahon's own clout a decade earlier. Similarly, 'Easy E's propensity for poaching ECW talent was fair game in a time when performers would have been insane not to ply their trade with the highest bidder. If Paul Heyman's missed payments and Vince McMahon's financially insecure guarantees didn't equal the certainty of a WCW payslip, that's not a raid, that's just business.
6. Booking Bill
The penultimate year of the 1990s saw WWE re-take the lead in the Monday Night ratings battle, as well as just about every other industry metric. The company was enjoying substantially higher merchandise and ticket sales riding the wave of Stone Cold Steve Austin's emphatic ascension. WCW was almost as popular as it had been the prior two years, but a division of nWo labour and the politicking of Goldberg down the card after he won the company's World Title combined to take much of the bloom off the Atlanta rose.
It mustn't be understated how big the paradigm shift was in 1998, and it makes an oft-held criticism of the decision to blow Goldberg's climactic victory over 'Hollywood' Hogan on television largely moot. The same applies to empty critiques of Kevin Nash's ending of said reign and Big Bill's legendary undefeated streak.
The sight of an enraptured Georgia Dome faithful watching their hero topple the megalomaniacal 'Hulkster' remains one of the company's finest moments, far more so than their pay-per-view attempt to deliver the goods several months earlier at Starrcade. 'Big Sexy' pinning Goldberg in December was an earth-shattering way to end the year. The company are at fault for spectacularly botching any potential momentum with the 'Fingerpoke Of Doom', not for the chain of events that led up to it.
5. Youth Movement
Those who criticise Vince Russo without pausing to consider his positive contributions often do so in spite of the homogenisation of today's product that exists in-part because somebody like him can't get a foot in the door.
A brash ignoramus at his worst, the cocky New Yorker was a fiercely equitable writer at his best, treating every performer on the roster with the same time and respect as one another. In WWE, it made for propping up the Austin-led Attitude Era with a stream of mid-card and future main event stars. In WCW, it was crushed by longstanding politics.
2000's New Blood/Millionaires Club feud was a complete mess, but it was Russo's misguided attempt to bring those machinations to the front and push youngsters by force of will alone. Billy Kidman feuding with Hulk Hogan whilst Shane Douglas finally got his hands on long-term nemesis Ric Flair represented 'Vinny-Ru's desperation to force through a path for talent downtrodden during halcyon days for the top earners years earlier.
As The Giant and Chris Jericho sought fortunes elsewhere and Eddie Guerrero wiped Eric Bischoff's coffee from his shirt, younger talent looked on wondering when any would be considered worthy beyond opening match duties. Fatally wounded by his own incompetence and a ruthless old guard, Russo's regime was no less a noble effort
4. 2001 - A Wrestling Odyssey
Pardon the cliché, but a bitter end encapsulated everything about how it felt to watch WCW capitulate so pathetically and cheaply in 2001. Hard to follow, hard to care and simply hard to watch, the product's downward spiral from the dull days of 1999 through to the hideous error-strewn 2000 saw most leap from the sinking ship long before it finally ran aground.
Something was happening in 2001, though. The feeling was palpable amongst the few that had stuck around for the nadir without realising that rock bottom had been reached, but WCW was gently on its way back up.
The company ran three broadly enjoyable pay-per-views before hitting the wall, all mostly devoid of the nonsense and sheer wrong-c*ckery of the prior two years. Anchored by a 'Magnificent Seven' angle featuring Ric Flair and his gang of heels attempting to rid WCW of all the heroes of the day, the company finally had a modicum of focus. Said storyline was a touch played out, but the writers were at least committing to the bit. Bill Goldberg and Kevin Nash inadvertently adhered to retirement storylines when the company went out of business before they could make their triumphant return!
'The Nature Boy' himself had got his swagger back as the boss of the bad lads, whilst lead heel Scott Steiner's 120-day reign with the WCW Heavyweight Title was the longest in nearly three years. The product hadn't felt as stable in half a decade, then just like that, it was gone completely.
3. Girls, Girls, Girls
Depending on which of them has less heat internally at the time, WWE will ordinarily credit Sunny or Sable with the reinvention of female performers as sex symbols in the late-1990s, but WCW were quicker off the mark with the crowd-pleasing choreography of the Nitro Girls in 1997.
As innovative then as it is dated now, the dance troupe were employed effectively as cheerleaders to keep audiences hyped during commercials and lend glitz to the dynamic broadcast making a play for Monday Night dominance.
Whilst Sunny shone as a manager in 1996 and Sable drew main event-level reactions between 1998 and 1999, the very notion of employing women to perform beyond the realms of the traditional valet/wrestler role was unheard-of before Eric Bischoff and Kimberley Page collaborated in creating the group.
Competition winner Stacy Keibler joined the gang in 1999 and went on to have one of the more successful careers of all active females at the time following WWE's buyout of WCW in 2001. Rebecca Curci and Sharmell Sullivan would go on to marry Shawn Michaels and Booker T respectively, with Sullivan achieving additional fame as Booker's valet and 'Queen' between 2005 and 2009.
2. Arquette
Film actor David Arquette didn't harm the legacy of the WCW World Heavyweight Title any more than a roster full of actual professional wrestlers had done and would again during the company's chaotic final few years.
Easily the most mismanaged major wrestling organisation in industry history by then, the tarnished title was left battered and bruised by relentless twists, turns and tournaments that decided its fate on television and pay-per-view. Once the most treasured icon in the game, the big gold belt had become the cheap imitation of a World Title WWE announcers called it during a Ric Flair's maiden voyage north in 1991.
Arquette himself is unfairly enflamed by the deal. He merely went along with creative direction that Russo, Tony Schiavone and others errantly thought would gain national media attention. The Hollywood star didn't want to be made champion, and donated all his performance fees to charitable causes related to the industry when his business with WCW had concluded.
It was a deeply flawed idea of course, but in no way was it the bullet in the head many passing critics observe. Collaborations with Dennis Rodman, Kevin Greene and Karl Malone had been huge for WCW, and Mike Tyson's involvement in arguably the most important main event in WWE history was a significant turning point for Vince McMahon. 'David Arquette - World Champion' was (particularly at the time) worth the gamble.
1. Dated Critiques
There was a lot wrong with Vince McMahon's petty 'Billionaire Ted' assaults in January 1996, far beyond the fact that they completely misunderstood what had appealed to a section of disenfranchised WWE fans in the first place.
It was wrong-headed enough to suggest that the athleticism was completely superior considering the in-ring innovation sneaking through on TNT, not least when images of Diesel, Razor Ramon and Ahmed Johnson all hitting powerbomb variations was supposed to prove the point. But the increased digs at the expense of Hulk Hogan and Macho Man Randy Savage via crude aged caricatures flew wide of the mark too. Particularly in light of the then-unknown runaway success of the New World Order.
Hulk and Randy may have been a touch older than certain WWE topliners, but WCW performers they were barely two years old. Savage's longterm partner Elizabeth had been reborn alongside Ric Flair, shockingly turning heel that same month to kick off the company's most profitable house show run ever up to that point.
The same logic applied to virtually every ex-WWE star that donned black and white over the next 12 months. As part of Hogan's heel unit, they were both familiar faces AND brand new talent. WCW was far from the old folks home, nor getting by by stealing stars. What was old was very, very new again.