10 Things Next Series WWE Ruthless Aggression Should Focus On
Much like the era itself, the Ruthless Aggression docuseries could have been a bit better…
The first series of Ruthless Aggression has come to an end on WWE Network. At first, this series had bags of potential, as a lot of things occurred - many of which are considered major industry highlights - during this time.
While the series discussed the demise of WCW, the first-ever brand split and hinted towards methods of maintaining audience numbers, it missed the mark on several episodes. Rather than focusing on background information surrounding the era as a whole, it instead dedicated programmes to individual wrestlers and factions, and that didn’t seem necessary for a show on a specific period of wrestling.
Not only that, but WWE came across as too self-protective with their revisionist history. While they admitted to entering a time of stagnation and dwindling audience numbers, they also seemed to cover up a lot of the lowlights. However, it is these lowlights that make the Ruthless Aggression Era so interesting. It is the post-war period where things settle, and new foundations are laid. It wasn’t all bad, and some of the genuine positives from today’s product were first introduced during this era. It needs to be accepting, open, and honest.
If there's to be a second series, these are topics it should focus on.
10. The Change To PG
Around the latter half of the noughties, the ‘tweenage’ demographic was a massive emerging market. With the likes of High School Music and Hannah Montana garnering a fresh audience, WWE altered its programming to target a younger audience.
New sanctions were put in place which banned bloodshed - and in the occurrence of a hard-way, referees stopped bouts while wrestlers were treated (which led to a very clunky match between Shelton Benjamin and Christian at TLC 2009) - chair shots to the head, protected or otherwise, were now prohibited, and wrestlers with superhuman attributes (enter Superman Cena) were lauded, which created the dichotomy amongst older fans booing and younger fans cheering.
The introduction of the ‘PG’ era stifled a lot of creativity. Many wrestlers vocally opposed the change - one such wrestler was Batista who retired from full-time competition in 2010. To end series two of The Ruthless Aggression Era documentary discussing this shift would be a good way to explore the after-effects of the era.
9. Acknowledge Benoit
While the first series of the Ruthless Aggression documentary contained limited new information for wrestling know-it-alls, it did contain something quite different: throughout some of the episodes, there was footage of Chris Benoit on the receiving end of moves from the likes of Kurt Angle, Brock Lesnar, and Rey Mysterio. It is so rare to have Benoit featured in any post-2007 WWE programming, it was a surprise to witness it.
During a segment where Heyman was discussing his desire to make SmackDown the ‘wrestling’ brand, he mentioned how he wanted to highlight Edge, Eddie and Chavo Guerrero, Rey Mysterio and Kurt Angle. What stuck out, was the showing of Benoit during this segment without mentioning him by name.
A career retrospective, or any real appraisal, of Benoit, is not necessary. However, an acknowledgement of a period where he was a key figure on programming is justifiable. Otherwise, it creates a jarring conundrum: how can WWE feasibly discuss an era that featured Benoit so prominently and never mention him? It makes the discussion seem incomplete.
As much as nobody wants the events to have happened, they did. The best cause of action is to accept it and move on. To this day, it has been an elephant in the room. Acknowledge the elephant and it no longer remains an issue.
8. Viewing The Indies Differently
In the current WWE landscape, the indie scene has been publicly heralded for helping hapless wrestlers - some who squandered previous opportunities, and others who just needed a new coat of paint - and much footage from promotions such as Ring Of Honor can be seen on WWE documentaries and promo packages. However, for a long time, this was not always the case.
When CM Punk debuted on ECW, commentators would acknowledge his independent career, but quickly dismiss it by saying he was now in the big leagues. A few years later, when Daniel Bryan had made his way onto the awful original concept of NXT, Michael Cole disparaged Daniel Bryan’s wrestling chops on-air, claiming that he was nothing but an ‘internet darling,’ heavily implying that the only product that mattered was the one we were watching.
CM Punk and Daniel Bryan did much to change the perception of non-WWE wrestling, and by the time AJ Styles debuted in 2016, he was welcomed with open arms and his past on the indies and even TNA was discussed.
Of course, with no real competition, WWE needed to change its views, but who were personally responsible for this? Many top superstars have these individuals to thank for the alteration of the glass ceiling, and some public recommendations wouldn’t go amiss.
7. WWE Films
Let’s remove all discussion of how WWE films are critically received. They’re sh*t. End of. However, there must be some commercial success in these endeavours, otherwise, why would WWE Studios still exist?
As WWE movies began shortly after the Ruthless Aggression Era’s inception, it would be interesting for the series to focus on this avenue. Exactly how did it fare commercially? What incentives were there for wrestlers to be in movie roles, other than the time off as CM Punk documented in 2015? And, did it lead to any other cross-promotional opportunities to help bolster the WWE into the multinational corporation it is today?
When the first fully produced WWE Studios movie, The Condemned, was released in selected cinemas in 2007, there was a lot of promotion on WWE programming. Even Santino Marella was a victim of a Stone Cold Stunner when he panned the movie by parodying Amy Winehouse singing, ‘they tried to make me watch The Condemned, but I said “no, no, no…”’
These days, the majority of WWE Studios films are much more under the radar - with the exception being Fighting With My Family, which is arguably WWE Studios' greatest release - but they are still consistently producing. Has the venture into the film industry been a successful one? Surely there must be some justification for the myriad of Marine movies.
6. Hiring More Writers
Before the Ruthless Aggression Era, episodes of Raw, SmackDown, and PPVs were given a format to follow. Certain wrestlers were granted the time to give a promo and would follow a loose rundown on what to say. As long as they mentioned key information - such as their opponent, the upcoming event, town or date - wrestlers would be left to present it as they saw fit.
This led to many wrestlers developing their characters organically. Talent such as Steve Austin and The Rock are two of the greatest examples of how well this approach can work. However, this set up began to change during The Attitude Era, and even more so during the Ruthless Aggression Era.
On an episode of his podcast, Jim Cornette explained how Ed Ferrara was the first writer WWE employed, which set the precedent for how they would conduct creative in the following years. The lack of genuine characters has been a constant hot topic for the past decade. Too many wrestlers are given scripts that don’t resonate with the audience nor correlate with the character they are trying to portray on-screen.
Jon Moxley was candid in saying that it was the creative direction for Dean Ambrose’s germaphobe character that killed his passion for being a WWE superstar. In AEW, without a script, he is one of the best on the microphone and feels like a believable badass.
Too many cooks spoil the broth, and too many writers spoil the current product. Sufferin’ succotash!
5. The Health Of The Wrestlers
The aforementioned Benoit tragedy and the death of Eddie Guerrero in 2005 led WWE to change the ways they screen current and prospective superstars on the roster.
In Nigel McGuinness' WWE documentary (which is a must watch, by the way), he was caught between a rock and a hard place when he was truthful to WWE doctors about a previous bicep injury which didn’t receive surgery (as he couldn’t afford it). WWE refused to take on Nigel unless he opted for surgery out of his own pocket.
This is a small look behind the curtain at how WWE changed its health screenings - even though Bryan Danielson got the job just by lying about his previous injuries.
MVP had to take a hiatus in 2006 after WWE doctors had found an irregularity with his heart. These mandatory screenings were put in place after Guerrero’s death was discovered to be more due to a defect in his heart than his previous drug and alcohol abuse; WWE didn’t want more high profile deaths to move on from.
4. The Style Needed To Change
The Attitude Era isn’t necessarily remembered for its quality wrestling, instead relying on huge spots to supplement its legendary characters. During the Ruthless Aggression Era, the emphasis was firmly put back on the wrestling. Wrestlers such as Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, and Kurt Angle were at the helm of an athletic style based more on realism. Where the Attitude Era failed, the Ruthless Aggression shined (and vice versa).
SmackDown circa 2002/3 was the ‘wrestling’ brand, as documented in series one. However, towards the PG era, the emphasis on quality wrestling had dwindled. There certainly was more good wrestling than in the Attitude Era, but the fast pace of the SmackDown Six days were long gone (as were many of the wrestlers themselves).
After the events of the Benoit tragedy, did WWE purposefully move to a safer style? In recent years, there has been much more available information on CTE and head trauma, which justifies WWE’s move away from unprotected headshots and such, but what brought about the change back then?
3. Why WMXX, 21 And 22 Were In Arenas
WrestleMania XX was marketed as ‘where it all begins again.’ With that, WWE returned to its original stomping ground, Madison Square Garden. It is an illustrious building and an integral venue in the mythos of WWE. It makes sense that they returned there for their big anniversary marquee event.
However, the following year was held in the Staples Centre, a similarly sized arena in Los Angeles. For WrestleMania 22, they occupied yet another arena, in the Rosemont Horizon, Illinois. Why were these two held in arenas rather than stadiums?
The three ‘Manias before XX were in stadiums, and since 23 every Showcase of the Immortals has been in a stadium (including their thirtieth rendition, where WWE seemed to have moved away from acknowledging New York as a home base).
What had inspired WWE to host their biggest events in smaller venues? Was their post-Attitude economy suffering that badly? Before establishing WrestleMania as a weeklong extravaganza, did they receive better deals from their chosen smaller venues? An insight into the economic reasoning behind their decisions would make the second series of Ruthless Aggression must watch.
2. Financial Concerns
Let’s just get it out there: the Attitude Era was huge. Huge. It was the most financially profitable era in the glorious history of professional wrestling. We know this. But of course, what comes up, must come down.
While it was alluded to in the first series of Ruthless Aggression, the actual details of the financial concerns of WWE post-2002 were skipped over. Fans are ready to be told a little bit more involving the actual numbers behind financial problems.
Of course, Vince McMahon’s disastrous attempt at creating the XFL the first time round had to have impacted the economic climate of WWE. Be candid with it. The ESPN 30 for 30 which focused on the American Football failure went into details about how much dosh was lost. If Vince McMahon can allow himself to talk about financial failures to non-WWE specific audiences, surely he would be okay with the occasional admittance to loyalists.
1. Get The F(acts) In!
On 5 May 2002, World Wrestling Federation became World Wrestling Entertainment. There was no announcement that the company’s identity was going to change, it just happened. If you were tuning in to an episode of Monday Night Raw the following day and hadn’t heard the news, you may have thought it was an ill-timed April Fool’s joke. However, throughout the show, vignettes played, showing WWE ‘getting the ‘F’ out’.
In reality, the Federation had been in a long-lasting court case with World Wildlife Fund for the rights of the ‘WWF’ name. After a dispute over international licensing, the World Wrestling Federation was informed it had to change its name.
Presented in the documentary as a ‘tidal wave’ from a creative direction standpoint, this revises the reality of the lawsuit and makes it seem as if Vince McMahon had decided to ‘get the F out’ to shake up the product. Hilariously, Brian Gewirtz mentions how McMahon didn’t want a wrestling company, but an entertainment company. This immediately raises the question: if this were true, why wasn’t it rebranded ‘World Entertainment Federation’ instead?
While Vinny Mac should be commended for his ability to turn any negative into a positive, this documentary presents events in such a fictitious way, it makes it hard to get on board. It'd be great if a new series could need to straighten the truth out somewhat - though don't hold your breath.