10 Things That Didn't Go The Way AEW Wanted
Missed signings, misjudged character presentations, productions issues, and the overhype problem.
Make no bones about it, AEW right now is the most consistently entertaining, engaging, rewarding and sensical wrestling promotion on the planet. While organisations such as WWE, IMPACT Wrestling, the NWA, GCW and New Japan Pro Wrestling all have varying levels of upside to their products, it's Tony Khan's All Elite Wrestling that's the hottest in the game at present.
Despite the regular praise AEW's weekly shows, TV specials and quarterly PPVs receive, that's not to say that Khan and his organisation hit a home run with everything they do.
Every wrestling promotion is going to strike out at times, especially one that was started completely from scratch barely three years ago. Whether it's production issues, expecting audiences to immediately know who lesser-known talent are, ill-advised character presentations, or merely promising something that you ultimately can't deliver on, there are plentiful examples of things not quite as AEW envisioned across its relatively young lifespan.
With that in mind, then, here are ten such examples of those times when Tony Khan and All Elite Wrestling failed to get things exactly as they would've liked.
10. Missing Out On Ben Carter
Highlighting what a brilliant showcase AEW Dark can be, Ben Carter and Lee Johnson absolutely tore it up on the 22 September 2020 edition of AEW's premiere YouTube show.
Carter had previously lost on Dark to Ricky Starks, but his second match under the AEW banner is one that truly put the young Brit on the radar of many a wrestling fan. Likewise, this was a contest that also marked the then-unsigned Johnson out as a talent to keep your eye on.
In a ten-minute affair, Carter and Big Shotty mesmerised in a fun, frenetic encounter that saw the Prodigy of Pro Wrestling pick up the win over Johnson. That match itself was followed by Carter facing Scorpio Sky on Late Night AEW Dynamite, and the AEW faithful were abuzz with one of the hottest prospects on the market possibly becoming officially #AllElite.
Unfortunately, the AEW signing of Ben Carter never came to fruition.
Despite interest from both AEW and IMPACT Wrestling, Carter would soon formally sign with WWE and be assigned to the NXT UK brand, with the high-flyer later explaining how he'd already agreed a deal in principal with WWE before he wrestled for AEW.
These days performing under the Nathan Frazer moniker, the 23-year-old has continued to impress, most recently putting on a brutal, brilliant battle with NXT UK Champion Ilja Dragunov earlier this month.
9. Christian Cage Signing Can't Live Up To Tony Khan's Hype
You won't find a bigger Christian Cage fan than your writer here, but the AEW arrival of of the five-time World Champion didn't go down as well as Tony Khan would have hoped.
This was nothing to do with Christian himself, but it was a case of Khan hyping something up to such an extreme level that he was always going to struggle to appease his audience. Ahead of AEW Revolution 2021, Tony went hard in promoting - initially via Paul Wight - that a "Hall of Fame worthy" signing would be revealed at the PPV.
Of course, Christian is unequivocally a Hall of Fame talent by any definition, but the hype and hoopla drummed up by Khan meant that he gave the wrestling world the chance to dream up all kinds of scenarios. And when that opportunity to dream presented itself, the excitement levels generated by the AEW President meant that people were expecting a CM Punk, a Brock Lesnar, a Kurt Angle, a Batista.
No disrespect to Christian Cage, but he isn't viewed at being quite at the level of the likes of Punk, Lesnar, Angle and Batista by the mases, and thus him walking out at AEW Revolution felt a little underwhelming. Rather than getting the big-time reaction that Tony Khan thought this signing would get, the main response was an apathy-laced golf clap.
8. Dr. Britt Baker, Top Babyface
Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. is absolutely killing it in AEW these days, having become one of the biggest stars in the company. Still, the early days of AEW were a rough, rough ride for the Role Model.
In the formative months of AEW, Britt Baker was positioned as an all-smiling, baby-hugging, granny-kissing babyface who was clearly earmarked to eventually become the poster girl of the women's division. While Baker would indeed become that poster girl, it took a major character shift to get there.
Despite Riho being the inaugural AEW Women's Champion and the initial top hero of the division, Britt was being groomed to be the real top babyface of the women's ranks. The problem was, her babyface act struck out week after week when it came to connecting with the fans.
There was nothing tangible to this act, there was nothing for fans to grab onto, and Britt and her promos were as vanilla as vanilla could be - to the point that her good gal schtick started to receive notable boos from audiences.
Baker herself has stated how it took her a while to find her footing in AEW, with this not only the first time she was on mainstream TV, but her AEW tenure being the first time the Good Doctor was really required to cut promos. Thankfully, once the powers that be realised the disconnect of the Britt Baker character, the subsequent heel turn and a new arrogant, clinical edge took Brittsburgh to an entirely new level.
7. Jeff Hardy Lets The Cat Out Of The Bag
Following his bungled, unfair WWE release at the end of 2021, many speculated that Jeff Hardy would eventually end up in AEW alongside his brother Matt. While that has now indeed happened, any sense of uncertainty over the Charismatic Enigma's future landing spot was ruined by Jeff himself.
In the case of most big-name new signings, a promotion will tend to lean more towards a surprise debut. For Hardy, the only element of surprise left was the when he would arrive in AEW rather than if he'd arrive in AEW. And even then, Matt Hardy had already publicly declared when exactly his brother's WWE non-compete clause was set to expire.
As for Jeff, he let the cat out of the bag on his AEW signing by outright telling YouTuber Jared Myers, "I'm going to AEW. I'm so excited, I'm so nervous and excited," before later adding a "f**k WWE" for good measure. From that moment on - a fortnight before Hardy's AEW debut - it was just a case of pondering when Jeff would land in Tony Khan's All Elite Wrestling.
While there's no reports of any sort of heat on Jeff Hardy for ruining the surprise, one has to imagine that Khan would've preferred Jeff not to have taken away some of the shock factor of seeing the three-time WWE World Champion in AEW.
6. The Dark Order Arrives To Crickets
The AEW fanbase is typically a smart one, with the vast majority of those fans having plentiful knowledge of grapplers who aren't necessarily mainstream stars. So, when the Super Smash Bros. arrived at Double or Nothing 2019 to crickets, that tells you all you need to know.
That initial silence was followed by a "befuddled" Alex Marvez questioning who this pair was, a disinterested Jim Ross wondering what the f**k was going on, and Excalibur doing his best to talk up this new threat whilst steering clear of outright identifying Player Uno/Evil Uno and Player Dos/Stu Grayson.
Even more telling was that the silence of those in attendance at the MGM Grand on that night was only broken when a "Who are you?" chant started up.
Despite Excalibur doing his best to make the arrival of the Super Smash Bros. feel like a big deal, and despite AEW clearly wanting the duo and their goofy minions to be perceived as a major force, this all fell as flat as a fart in church. Then again, that's something that could be said about a good chunk of those first few months of what would soon become the Dark Order.
5. "It's The Butcher, The Blade And The Bunny!"
"The Blade! The Blade emerging from underneath the ring, and he has blindsided Cody and taken him out. And the Butcher! The Butcher not far behind, emerging. The Butcher and the Blade are looking to sell chaos here! We've not seen them before. The Butcher and the Blade have made their presence known in AEW at the expense of Cody. Oh, oh now we know who brought them here - it's the Bunny! It's the Butcher, the Blade and the Bunny!"
Uhu...
Speaking of ropey AEW debuts, the Butcher and the Blade managed to have an even less impactful arrival than the aforementioned Dark Order.
Taking place on the 27 November 2019 episode of AEW Dynamite, this tag tandem emerged through the ring to attack Cody Rhodes following the American Nightmare's submission victory over Matt Knicks. Already signed to AEW at that point, Allie would shortly appear at the Butcher and Blade's side, with her now going by the moniker of the Bunny.
The diatribe at the top of this entry is what Excalibur excitedly spouted upon seen this trio target Cody - all while a puzzled Jim Ross kept interrupting to question who the f**k these people were and how the f**k Excalibur had this information.
Those in attendance had zero idea who the Butcher and the Blade were, and again the "Who are you?" chants started up as poor Braxton Sutter and Andy Williams did their best to appear menacing as they beat down Rhodes. Sure, they had a badass look to them, but the handling of the debut of the Butcher and the Blade felt almost comical, and it also handed plentiful fuel to those naysayers who were looking to throw shade at Tony Khan's upstart promotion.
4. The Domino's Pizza Fiasco
Many raised an eyebrow when it was announced that Nick Gage would be taking on Chris Jericho on AEW Dynamite in a Deathmatch as part of MJF's Five Trials of Jericho scheme. In Gage, AEW was bringing in someone famed for ultra-violence, his criminal record, and for nearly murdering David Arquette live on PPV.
To say MDK brings controversy is like saying The Rock was okay at promos; it's an understatement of huge proportions.
Would AEW allow Nick Gage to do Nick Gage things on their flagship television show? Would AEW really put their inaugural World Champion and a true legend of the industry in harm's way by having him go all in on a Deathmatch?
The answer to these questions is that, yes, while this Death Match wasn't as gnarly as some of Gage's other outings, it was still extreme when compared to what was usually seen on AEW programming. And in one such 'extreme' moment, the King of Ultra-Violent Wrestling took his patented pizza cutter to the forehead of his opponent.
In terms of how this didn't go the way AEW intended, said attack took place during a commercial break just as an ad for Domino's Pizza was airing. So, as Domino's was trying to shill its pizza to the masses, the picture-in-picture accompaniment was the visage of Nick Gage slicing open Chris Jericho's head with a pizza cutter. Mmm, appetising...
Domino's were quick to release a statement lambasting the spot and detailing how they were assessing their advertising presence on TNT and AEW. This controversy would eventually die down, but it was an awful look for AEW at the time.
3. The Debut Of Mr. Brodie Lee
The late, great Mr. Brodie Lee will forever stand as a key player in the history of All Elite Wrestling, with him correcting the course of the doomed Dark Order, bringing a rarely-seen level of brutality to the company that legitimised the TNT Title, and his tragic passing and the handling of that sad situation being pivotal in CM Punk and Bryan Danielson signing with AEW.
While it was entirely out of everybody's hands, the AEW debut of Brodie didn't go how anybody in AEW had envisioned it.
That debut was meticulously planned to happen in the Rochester, New York hometown of the real-life Jon Huber on the 18 March 2020 episode of AEW Dynamite. Mr. Brodie would indeed debut as the Exalted One on that Dynamite outing, but this unfortunately took place in a completely empty Daily's Place in Jacksonville, Florida.
Of course, the initial plans for the big hometown debut of Mr. Brodie Lee were scuppered by the COVID-19 pandemic. By wretched coincidence, Lee's debut fell on the first Dynamite episode to take place in an entirely empty venue. The world was in shock and uncertainty about the unravelling pandemic, and AEW was left with no choice but to either a) completely cancel all future programming, or b) continue on but have to perform in front of zero fans at Daily's Place.
2. Cody Rhodes Does Something Heroic, Gets Booed Out Of The Building
We'll never know if the recent actions of - and reactions to - Cody Rhodes were going to lead to a monumental heel turn that would've positioned the American Nightmare as the top villain of Tony Khan's promotion. By all accounts and purposes, Cody had no interest in embracing the hate, which makes so much of the last year or more of Rhodes' AEW antics all the more head scratching.
In 2019, Cody was the top singles act babyface in AEW. And more still, fans treated him like the top singles act babyface in AEW.
Regardless of how Rhodes was continually utilised as a hero throughout his entire tenure with the promotion, the last year bordered on farcical when it came to Cody.
What if Cody fights the foreign menace of Anthony Ogogo while cutting promos about equality? Sections of the crowd veered away from Rhodes. What if Cody symbolically leaves his boots in the ring and cuts an emotional speech teasing retirement? Sections of the crowd veered away from Rhodes. What if Cody talks about being a proud first-time father? Sections of the crowd veered away from Rhodes. What if Cody literally sets himself on fire? Sections of the crowd veered away from Rhodes.
The list goes on when it comes to examples of AEW and Cody doing all they could to position the performer as a figure who audiences should want to get behind. Multiple, lengthy absences, Triple H-lite claims and a certain 'my sh*t don't stink' smug aura were just some of the reasons why fans struggled to react to the three-time TNT Champion with anything but boos.
1. An Explosive Main Event Goes Off The Air With A Whimper
Jon Moxley and Kenny Omega is easily one of the greatest rivalries in the short lifespan of All Elite Wrestling. The Death Rider and the Best Bout Machine have beaten the tar out of each other in several bouts, and their rivalry was one of the most heated that AEW has yet to see.
The problem is, the big moment of their big match ended up being a total dud.
When Mox and Omega did battle in an Exploding Barbed Wire Deathmatch at Revolution 2021, audiences expected a war - and a war we would get. Kenny would retain the AEW World Title on that night, largely thanks to help from the Good Brothers and Don Callis. Post-match, the heels continued to put a beating on Moxley until the ominous doomsday clock hit the one minute mark. That meant that there were just 60 seconds left before the ringside area was completely blown to sh*t.
Realising his long-time pal was about to be set ablaze by an all-mighty explosion, Eddie Kingston ran to the ring and covered Mox, sacrificing his own body to save his buddy. In what was intended to be the ultimate tribute to the infamous Terry Funk vs. Atsushi Onita No Rope Exploding Barbed Wire Deathmatch of 1993, the end result was laughable as Kingston and Moxley had to lie there and sell the situation while a few sparklers went off around them due to an issue with the planned pyro for this spot.