10 Things That Have Lost All Meaning In WWE
Wrestling continues to evolve, but much has been lost along the way.
Vince McMahon might be one of the most divisive men in wrestling history, but nobody else has done more to further the sport's evolution. For better or worse, the WWE Chairman's ambition and innovation hasn't just shaped his company's fortunes, but those of the industry as a whole.
He'll eventually retire with a long, storied list of accomplishments.
Ideas that might seem progressive don't always manifest as such in the real world, however. Creations like WrestleMania and the WWE Network have pushed the sport forward, but the company's single-minded "entertainment first" approach has been detrimental in a number of ways, and tarnished plenty of tools that were once central to WWE storytelling.
WWE programming increasingly feels like a light soap opera, where actions have little to no consequences, and fans are rarely rewarded for long-term investment. Without serious competition, the company can essentially do as they please, resulting in an increasingly safe, homogenised product.
Many things that once held serious prestige within the sport have been diluted along the way, and while several can be partially attributed to wrestling's natural evolution, each has lost its edge, importance, and impact...
10. The Royal Rumble
The Royal Rumble might be one of the most anticipated events on WWE’s annual pay-per-view calendar, but it hasn’t felt like a truly prestigious event in years.
Moments like Daniel Bryan’s exclusion in 2014 and Triple H’s crippling predictable 2016 victory have stripped the Rumble's lustre, and while WWE still love to push the idea that "anything can happen," the match isn’t even a reliable source of major shocks anymore.
The company haven’t used the Rumble to make a new star in years, and each of the past five winners had already established themselves as big-time superstars prior to their victory. This year’s incarnation was full of huge names, but produced no surprising returns. Randy Orton’s victory ultimately did nothing to enhance his status within the company, and his ensuing WWE Title run was utterly joyless.
It’s becoming increasingly harder to get excited for the Rumble. Pulled apart by years of predictability and uninspired winners, it does nothing to elevate the status of its participants anymore. The Rumble is no more than a shortcut to a title shot, and with the last truly great incarnation coming as far back as 2010, it’s hard to see things changing anytime soon.
9. Go-Home Shows
Before the pay-per-view market collapsed entirely, WWE’s go-home shows used to be some of the year’s most exciting weekly TV episodes.
With the big event looming, the company knew this was their last shot at building intrigue and increasing buyrates and while they weren’t always successful, WWE would at least try to up the stakes to convince you, the viewer, to part with your hard-earned cash.
This is no longer the case. Nowadays, WWE’s go-home shows are among the year’s blandest and most skippable, and generally provide little incentive to tune in to the PPV five or six days later. You can almost guarantee that the company aren’t going to write any significant story developments into these shows, and thus, they’re barely even worth your time.
This is largely down to the change in consumption methods. Video streaming services have totally changed the way we watch wrestling, and the WWE Network has become most fans’ new go-to option. The company don’t need to convince you to buy a pay-per-view when they already have your subscription money, which means they’ve little reason to take risks on their go-home shows anymore. This explains the decline, but certainly doesn’t excuse it.
8. Tag Team Wrestling
It’s hard to remember the last time tag team wrestling truly felt important in WWE. The last boom period was unquestionably the turn of the century, when Edge & Christian, The Dudley Boyz, and The Hardy Boyz were routinely having the most exciting matches in the company. There have been a few highlights since then, but nothing close to that level, and the scene feels extremely unimportant in 2017.
The New Day became one of WWE’s most popular acts during their record breaking run as Raw Tag Team Champions, but they weren’t exactly faced with deep competition, and their reign became a joyless march towards Demolition’s landmark by the end. On SmackDown, they’re entering a desperately shallow division that isn’t even guaranteed airtime every week, and face an uphill battle to turn it around.
Things aren’t much better on Raw either, and while the likes of the Hardys and The Revival help bring credibility to the division, it’s never treated with real importance. Tag wrestling isn't going to be as prominent as it was in the ‘80s, but it’d be nice if it was treated as something more than a midcard sideshow from time to time, particularly given the vast array of talent at WWE’s disposal.
7. The WrestleMania Undercard
WrestleMania will always be the event around which the wrestling calendar is built. As a spectacle, WWE’s signature pay-per-view is unmatched, and while it doesn’t always promise great matches, it usually guarantees plenty of memorable moments. It has come to define WWE’s “entertainment first” approach over the decades, and while its main events still carry a certain level of prestige, the same can’t be said for the undercard.
Unfortunately, WrestleMania line-ups have become an annual challenge to cram as many wrestlers onto the show as possible, without giving them any real reason to be there. The result is a usually a series of poorly built and hastily assembled multi-person matches with little to no backstory, thus rendering huge chunks of the five to six hour show skippable.
Making it onto the ‘Mania card used to mean something. It was a reward for dedication, hard work, and getting over with the crowd, but that’s no longer the case. While the likes of Samoa Joe missed out this year, it often feels like WWE only pad the undercard with these meaningless matches as a way of justifying WM’s increasingly ridiculous runtime, and in the end, the viewers are the real losers.
6. Finishing Moves
Of all the things WWE have ran into the ground over the years, few have lost their importance quite like finishing moves.
A wrestler’s signature manoeuvre used to be a certified killshot. When they hit it, you could be 99% sure the match was over, and finisher kick-outs were so few and far between that each one felt like a huge moment, and practically guaranteed an explosion of shock from the audience.
Nowadays, barely a big match passes without one competitor kicking out of the other’s biggest move. Fans have seen it so many times that these moments no longer feel significant, and the trope's value as a storytelling tool has been lost. WWE's biggest matches always seem to drift into an endless stream of finisher kick-outs, and while this can still build to an exciting conclusion (see: John Cena vs. AJ Styles), it only makes the aggressor look weak.
The most effective way to reliably win in WWE’s main event scene appears to be by spamming finishers over and over again. False finishes have become the norm, and the moves themselves have lost all credibility through their complete lack of protection, making it hard to view them as effective match-enders anymore.
5. Traditional Face & Heel Alignments
Wrestling’s old face/heel alignment scale is broken.
Good guys are no longer good guys, and bad guys are no longer bad guys. Both sides frequently flirt with shades of grey, and as a result, traditional “white meat” babyfaces like Bayley and Sami Zayn come off corny, and WWE’s villains are often those drawing the largest cheers of the night.
When Braun Strowman sends Roman Reigns (the most reviled “face” in WWE history) to the hospital, he’s met with chants of “thank you Braun,” not choruses of boos. The paradigm has shifted, and fans are going to cheer for the people they like, not those the company have presented as “face” or “heel.”
This isn’t even necessarily a problem, and probably has more to do with evolution among the fanbase than anything else, but alignments have never been as unimportant as they are today. WWE have admitted themselves that they don’t care whether the likes of Reigns are cheered or booed, so long as they’re provoking a reaction.
They've either forgotten how to book convincing heroes and villains, or moved on from old fashioned face/heel character archetypes, and while they unquestionably want you to root for and against certain wrestlers, the lines have been irreparably blurred.
4. The Hall Of Fame
While WWE would have you believe that reaching the company’s Hall Of Fame is the ultimate professional wrestling honour, a quick skim through its inductees shows that this isn’t always the case. Sure, it’s home to some of the most important wrestlers in the sport’s history, but it’s also crammed with filler entries who don’t stand up to scrutiny, particularly when directly compared to the HOF’s most notable omissions.
With all due respect to Rikishi and The Godfather, did either man really leave a bigger mark on the business than Bruiser Brody or Owen Hart? There are obvious political reasons for these exclusions, but each raises a huge question mark on the Hall’s credibility, despite WWE’s continued assertions that it represents the pinnacle of pro wrestling excellence.
Pretending the HOF is anything more than a fun distraction during WrestleMania season is foolish. It doesn’t matter what you’ve done in the business: if Vince McMahon doesn’t want you in the HOF, you’re not going to be inducted. Positions are earned on personal relationships over merit, which makes it hard to take the selection process seriously, and leaves it feeling like nothing more than an exercise in vanity.
3. Gimmick Matches
Gimmick matches used to be a novelty, but it’s hard to get excited about special match stipulations when you see them multiple times each year. It feels like every second WWE pay-per-view comes packaged with a specific gimmick these days, and the company can barely restrain themselves when it comes to slapping a wacky stipulation on their biggest bouts.
Good things inevitably lose their appeal when they become the norm, and that’s exactly what has happened here. Hell In A Cell used to feel legitimately dangerous, but then it became an annual event, with last year’s PPV watering things down to ridiculous new levels by presenting three HIAC bouts in one night. This is but one example, and it’s hard to think of a single match stipulation that WWE haven’t ground to dust over the past few decades.
These contests would have much more impact if the company exercised a little restraint, and only booked them once or twice a year, but that’s never going to happen. Gimmicks have become as homogenised as anything else in the company.
There’s nothing special about them anymore, and while they still produce plenty of good matches, their appeal has been greatly diminished.
2. Wins & Losses
Few things have hurt WWE over the past few years quite like 50/50 booking, and the system is one of the biggest factors contributing towards the company’s inability to build new stars. As soon as a wrestler scores a big win, you can almost guarantee he or she will take a loss on the next show, preventing them from building any kind of lasting momentum, damaging their credibility, and hindering their ability to get over.
There are a few exceptions, of course, but if you were to round up each member of the current WWE roster’s win/loss records, the majority of them would be close to a 50/50 split. A wrestler can’t move up the card if they're unable to string more than a couple of wins together, and as a result of trying to get everyone over at the same time, WWE have produced a roster with plenty of great workers, but few genuine stars.
It often feels like WWE decide their match outcomes on a coin flip, rather than using wins and losses as storytelling tools. As a result, it’s very difficult to get worked up about specific match outcomes anymore, as they’re soon forgotten, and are rarely of significance to the performer’s ongoing story.
1. Championships
Titles are supposed to signify a wrestler’s superiority, particularly at the top of the card. Their existence gives performers a clear goal to work towards, and grabbing one should be the ultimate acknowledgement of their status as one of the best in the business. This means nothing when the titles themselves hold very little value, however, and the bulk of WWE’s current championships have become glorified trinkets.
Kevin Owens was booked like a chump throughout his recent Universal Title run, while current champion Brock Lesnar hasn’t been seen since early April. The WWE Championship has been ground to dust by years of shambolic booking and lacklustre, undeserving champions, and the midcard belts have been on a slow decline for decades, despite the occasional spike in credibility.
This is just the tip of the iceberg. Capturing gold should feel like an accomplishment, but when a guy like Jinder Mahal can go from career-long jobber to WWE Champion in just over a month, it’s impossible to view them as such. Titles used to hold legitimate drawing power in wrestling, but WWE lost that a long time ago, and their belts have become mere fashion accessories to whoever holds them.