10 Things We Learned From Attending AEW All In 2023
The biggest takeaways from inside the biggest wrestling event of all time.
The one thing everybody could say with confidence before AEW's first ever UK event and first ever stadium supercard was that All In London would be a special, special show.
The much-hyped Wembley debut had been subject to heated debate before showtime thanks to a lacklustre build and the lack of significant singles competition for several of the company's top and/or legacy stars. That said build was creatively par for the course for the company in general was less than ideal too; the sinking feeling that an ostensibly special show could only paper wrestling's craics rather than decorate its past and future with legendary action was impossible to shake.
But then, with every passing segment and match on a balmy evening in North London, the special, special show fulfilled its stunning destiny. The sweeping glimpses of the 81,000+ in attendance weren't just to pad out time or obscure a cold card - they were there to exemplify the scale of happy customers you can create when an audience feels like they got their money's worth.
The planning was simply too impressively lofty for the execution to fail. This much we all knew before a punch was thrown. What came as slightly more surprising news though, was when...
10. It's Still Possible To Pull Off THIS Unconvincing Spot
There's a reason why so many wrestling conventions were conventions before the crash TV and super-service eras greedily subverted and blew through them in an effort to score bigger ratings and even bigger contracts.
The core tenets of pro wrestling have to exist in order to not completely demolish suspension of disbelief, but such matters were once deemed trivial. Maybe that won't always be the case though, particularly if a match that was undercooked on the build delivered one of the best ever versions of a trademark shortcut.
Both Toni Storm and Saraya were vying for Hikaru Shida's AEW Women's Championship alongside Dr Britt Baker D.M.D, and as deluded heels often do in this situation, never once vocalised a plan should both be in a position to win. This is common fodder for three and four-ways and is never not a little dumb, but an early-match shoving contest between the two expertly hid the implosion to come.
Despite the early struggles, Storm's collaboration with Saraya begat the spot in which she inadvertently leathered her partner's mother right in the face. It triggered a sequence that even fellow Outcast Ruby Soho couldn't fix, and ultimately moved Saraya to spraypaint the eyes of her own partner when the match-winning opportunity showed itself.
When we talk/fantasise about "peak AEW", this is what we mean.
9. Mercedes Moné Is SURELY AllElite Soon...
...because if not, showing her on camera on both the pre-show and during/after The Acclaimed's Trios Championship victory over The House Of Black was a choice.
Having posted on X earlier that day that she was in London, the mood for Moné before the show was an all-time high, and the reveal of her looking on gave plenty cause for speculation that she'll be bringing her talents to All Elite Wrestling sooner rather than later.
Still injured following her NJPW Strong Women's Title loss to Willow Nightingale in May, the recovery time hasn't dampened anyone's enthusiasm for seeing her finally lace up the boots for the challenger brand after exiting the market leader in 2022. Unfortunately-timed knocks plagued All In this year (Jamie Hayter and PAC were sure to be on the show had they not devastatingly been ruled out) and Moné was placed amongst the names set to light up London.
In a manner of speaking at least, she did, and it didn't feel like the last time.
The same could also be said for...
8. And Will Ospreay Is Too
Expectations were set high for Will Ospreay Vs Chris Jericho despite the confusing character alignments of the former and the notable occasional misfires of the latter, but the IWGP United Kingdom/United States Champion used wrestling's biggest ever stage and his vocal home support to yet again shine in the spotlight.
Could more of this be on the horizon?
Ospreay is contracted to New Japan for the near future at least, but the AEW/NJPW working relationship should keep them tethered on events like this for the time being. After that, could the 'Aerial Assassin' make the North American number two his new home?
Wrestling is a less binary marketplace to try and conquer than many would have you think, but Ospreay's a unique case in that he really has done just about everything there is to do outside of working for one of the US majors. He may not feel the need to "prove" himself, but the fan demand is very clearly there. As has been the case with his career up to this point, not even the sky's the limit.
7. The Death Of Le Sex Gods
On a show that highlighted AEW's creative flair of old, one of the company's longest-tenured relationships briefly took centre-stage following Chris Jericho's ego-bruising loss to Will Ospreay.
'The Ocho' came up short against the beloved home country favourite, but even if 81,000+ inside Wembley Stadium were on the side of the 'Aerial Assassin', Sammy Guevara was loyal to his Inner Circle/Jericho Appreciation Society general throughout.
Jericho himself wasn't as cordial. Shooing away 'The Spanish God's help after the bell, a disillusioned Jericho left Guevara wondering exactly what he'd done wrong, which served as a nice contrast to the excellent facials from the apprentice when the master was failing to get the job done during the match.
A split is coming, and could Don Callis' muted presence at ringside for Ospreay have actually obscured the next move for the 'Invisible Hand' in this war against his fellow Winnipeggers? Guevara was seeking guidance and mutual respect, and the sly Callis can provide it the further Jericho slinks away.
6. The NXT Layout Can Still Be Great
As the brand ate itself and numerous key performers from the era found their work becoming increasingly more like a parody of what they'd done in the past (or worst, what their head coach had done in the past), NXT's trademark melodramatic main event epic found itself the subject of much scorn from many wrestling fans. Chiefly AEW ones, who'd frustratedly left the brand behind for pastures new right as the worst excesses were reached.
It appears as if there's hope for the style yet.
MJF's AEW World Championship main event with Adam Cole (a notable and divisive practitioner from the time) will have much written on it and deservedly so, but the old black-and-gold influence was both celebrated and improved upon here.
Never in those tortured morality plays did anybody find a moment of levity like the audible laugh break between the knocked out Bryce Remsburg counting one and two. Rarely was the violence as believably transgressive as Adam Cole following through on a table piledriver when MJF couldn't. It's perhaps no surprise then, that even the best TakeOver-style epics weren't trusted on WWE's grandest stage. This was, and proved its worth over and over again.
5. A Coffin Match Doesn't Need To Only Signify One Genre
After a difficult week in professional wrestling following the deaths of Terry Funk and Windham "Bray Wyatt" Rotunda coming just 24 hours apart and 48 hours before bell time, there'd been some calls to quietly abandon the coffin stipulation for Darby Allin and Sting's party brawl with Swerve Strickland and Christian Cage.
This wasn't bad faith heckling or concern trolling. Far from it, in fact. Traditionally the preserve of The Undertaker and or feuds that require somebody being locked inside a death box, the ties life's darkest side are transparent and intentional. But the four men and anybody involved in the arrangement of this match made sure no such spots came even close to disgracing or in anyway disparaging the memories and legacies of two heartfelt favourites.
A joyous fusion of violence and comedy, the match favoured the experience of Sting and Cage as much as it did the bumps of current young guns Allin and Strickland. Rotunda and especially Funk would have loved all of this, and the match that could have been the most disresepctful was in fact one of the most fitting tributes.
4. Stadium Stampede Is A Better Title Than A Stipulation
Nothing on the All In London card was bad, and that's to the entire promotion's credit as mentioned elsewhere in this list. But if any pedantry can be permitted, perhaps let it be for Stadium Stampede being little more than a unique sequel to Double Or Nothing 2023's Anarchy In The Arena 2, which itself couldn't really follow the 2022 original.
It wasn't without significant heat and emotion - Eddie Kingston and Jon Moxley walk the love/hate lines better than anybody else in the industry - and a walk and brawl on this show was a welcome palette cleanser either side of some heftier stuff, but the branding that generated a Pavlovian pop on Dynamite the other week should probably just be left in 2020 along with the other difficulties that era provided.
This isn't a complaint exclusive to All In London either - Double Or Nothing 2021's Inner Circle/Pinnacle battle couldn't follow the creativity and much-needed levity of the gorgeous once-in-a-lifetime (hopefully!) original.
3. The Yin And Yang Of Having This Man
It was shocking rather than surprising when news filtered out about a potential backstage fight between CM Punk and Jack Perry before Punk's show-opening (!) scrap with Samoa Joe. Shocking because such a thing felt unbecoming of anybody on what stood to be such a celebratory occasion. Unsurprising because we have obviously been here before.
There was a key difference between Brawl Out and whatever actually happened during All In, and that was Punk getting to flex his immense and frankly incredible in-person value after the fact rather than being forced away by injuries and/or personal animosities.
The scenes played out before the Real World Champion even hit the ring. This could have had disastrous consequences for the advertised card, not least with events allegedly occurring so close to Punk's spellbinding opener with Samoa Joe. Instead, they were brushed aside much like the criticisms of Punk's ability to captivate.
The measure of the man remains hard to parse, but he triumphantly left his on-screen value beyond any reasonable doubt. Even if, increasingly, every time feels like the last one.
2. Queen At Wembley From 1986 Is THE Influence
It's Queen.
It's Queen and especially Freddie Mercury and especially their 1986 special that define England's colossal national stadium
Not Bret Hart and Davey Boy Smith's 1992 epic, nor Jimmy Montgomery's dramatic double save for Sunderland in the 1973 FA Cup Final, nor Live Aid, nor Elliot Embleton and Ross Stewart's winners for Sunderland against Wycombe in the 2022 League One Playoff Final, nor Blur's tear-jerking reunion double-header or even Sunderland's heroic and unfair 1998 Championship Playoff Final defeat to Charlton Athletic (voted the greatest game in the history of the ground). It's Queen Live from 1986 that left the most indelible memory in the minds of the planners and performers within AEW, and the evidence was everywhere.
From The Young Bucks' outstanding take on Freddie's iconic look to Saraya's undeniably mammoth "We Will Rock You" entrance and Chris Jericho's criminal attempt at the singer's idiosyncratic call and response, this was comfortably the legendary show 2023's Wembley debutants were looking to top.
1. Tony Khan Finally Masters Placement And Pacing
And what a night to do it!
Even if one ignores the results, content of the matches and/or potential aftermaths of the stories that are continuing through London and onto Chicago next week, the match placement and placing - two hugely important areas of assembling a big show, and ones Tony Khan's fallen afoul of in the past - were both impeccably handled.
Ingenious, marvel stuff end-to-end. After a full year of backstage drama between CM Punk and The Elite taking much away from many peoples' enjoyment of the front-facing product, all the key players had done their duties by the end of the third match. This was both remarkable restraint and a humongous flex - not only did Khan clearly have belief in his matches to deliver, but he wanted the main event especially to be pulled as far away from any of the tribalism or turf wars that have informed much of 2023.
There's a twist there too - the live experience of this Punk/Elite stuff is a joy. People have fun backing their favourites a la pro wrestling, nobody gets bitten, and the arena becomes a furnace for every second move. To position this all during a giddy first hour minimised drama but came at some significant risk. Khan was richly rewarded for his gamble.