10 Things WWE Regrets About Backlash

Not the most ideal name for a pay-per-view.

John Cena Backlash
WWE.com

WWE is almost assuredly going to regret promoting the upcoming Randy Orton Vs. Edge Backlash rematch as the "greatest ever".

It's so obviously untrue, even before it happens, that people have struggled to even rip the piss out of it. It's almost pathetic. The billionaire company with an horrendous worker's rights record and a penchant for a bit of the ol' blood money has somehow conspired to evade scathing criticism because there's nothing else to say beyond "It is extremely unlikely to be the greatest wrestling match ever".

Because it's not going to the greatest wrestling match ever, is it?

There's no crowd, it's on WWE's main roster, and Randy Orton works like a member of the NXT core demographic driving a minivan up a mountain en route to Yosemite National Park.

What were they thinking?

That's not a rhetorical question. What, to them, constitutes great? It will be long. Edge will do something heinous, and inconsistent with his otherwise virtuous character, and stare at his hands to express his inner conflict. Did I want to do this? He will ask. Or did I have to do this? Is man inherently violent? And if so, why?

In any event, WWE will endure a hailstorm of image-damaging scorn, much like when...

10. Pissing Off Steve Austin In 2002

Austin Undertaker
WWE

Vince McMahon seemed intent on cycling Steve Austin out in 2002. At Backlash, he worked the Undertaker. And he did work.

It was a long, drab match, so much so that it must have felt like a company-wide conspiracy that incorporated the otherwise sparring production and creative departments. Austin lost a near-half hour slog to the Undertaker the month after he was originally scheduled to job for Scott Hall and two months before he walked at the notion of jobbing to Brock Lesnar on free TV.

The match was a grind. Couldn't Rob Van Dam and Eddie Guerrero done more with those five-to-eight baggy minutes? Or did they want Austin, almost completely broken down, to endure them? Austin was a paranoid figure in 2002, but just because you're paranoid...

And, all the while, a familiar ghost had returned to haunt him: Hulk Hogan, who was rewarded for an abject performance with the Undisputed WWE Title Austin never once won after the unification. Austin in appalling contrast had destroyed his body to elevate it to its former glories above the "trinket" Hogan had buried it as all those years ago, and was outdrawing Hogan on SmackDown as his analogue on RAW.

Booking like this hastened Austin's departure in June, and Austin's departure hastened the end of WWE as a mainstream concern.


9. Normalising Goldberg In 2003

Goldberg The Rock
WWE

WWE f*cked it in 13 minutes, which is impressive going, unless you're a pro wrestling promoter tasked with not f*cking an already established megastar performer in record time.

That they did at Backlash, at which Goldberg, the last shortcut to a main event superstar they had, went 13 minutes in a match that didn't remotely flatter his explosive, stiff-as-f*ck skill-set. They went back and forth in accordance with the usual rhythms of a usual WWE match, and borrowed a WWE trope that heeled Goldberg momentarily, as if exposing and normalising him wasn't bad enough.

He executed a Rock Bottom deep in the match, and the fans did nay like that. It felt like an overtly obnoxious flex - as if Goldberg felt he was superior to a WWE guy - which wasn't ideal, given that even a star of Goldberg's magnitude had something to prove in the eyes of an audience conditioned to perceive WCW as the enemy.

Rock took a a suspicious amount of time to get up, which most noticed except Goldberg himself, who ate the ring post when attempting a Spear.

An aloof moron who worked overlong matches: that was the name of Goldberg's three-disc bio-DVD, had he not f*cked off in anger.


8. Strapping Hulk Hogan In 2002

Backlash 2002 Hulk Hogan Triple H Legdrop
WWE.com

Vince McMahon, bless him, got very giddy immediately after WrestleMania X8 and the deafening euphoria surrounding Hulk Hogan's impromptu babyface turn.

With his perspective coloured by VHS crackle and the vast sums of money he raked in at the time, Vince went back to the '80s and immediately strapped the Hulkster at the next pay-per-view: Backlash. The storyline that led him there wasn't particularly compelling - most all-face programmes aren't - and the rushed nature of it detracted from the theoretical magic moment of Hogan's one, last sentimental title reign. There wasn't much doubt, nor drama, nor real tension. Hogan and newly-minted Undisputed Champion Triple H - who did the professional thing here, and didn't call Hogan an awld c*nt or anything - did the bog-standard miscommunication game before delivering the sudden and desperate title switch.

It didn't draw; it was up on the prior year's number, but only incrementally. The wave of nostalgia at WrestleMania behaved as waves do, and once it subsided, fans were left with Hogan as Hogan - not some grizzled, weakened version on the comeback trail.

He didn't so much come back as teleport forward, and it failed to truly convince.


7. Booking THAT Finish In 2018

AJ Styles Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

At Backlash 2018 - one of WWE's most piss-poor and damaging modern pay-per-views - they booked a non-finish in a No Disqualification match, the likes of which are (or were) only ever booked to guarantee the fans a finish.

The No Disqualification match is a mea culpa of sorts, offered up by the peace-seeking carny wrestling promoter. OK, OK they say.

We've f*cked you a little bit with these run-ins: here, have some blood and a conclusion.

This promise of resolution and violent retribution has sustained the booking cycle since the days of the WWWF, but WWE broke it, the trust of the audience, and, of course, the four collected testicles of Shinsuke Nakamura and AJ Styles at Backlash 2018. They ran into one another's balls shin-first and collapsed together, failing to get up for the referee's ten count. Wouldn't you just know it?

WWE had cause to run this match back for a fourth time, the lazy convenience of which held your time, money and emotional investment in complete contempt. Everybody naturally asked why AJ, the victim of so many targeted attacks, couldn't just wear a cup.

Because that way, WWE would have to tell a different story with its writing staff of 30-plus people.


6. Most Of Backlash 2001

Two Man Power Trip Steve Austin Triple H Undertaker
WWE.com

WWE had an opportunity to reverse the events of WrestleMania X-Seven - which the crowd effectively no-sold, because the closing angle felt like a mistake more so than a transgression - at Backlash.

They did not, and proceeded, even in the absence of The Rock, to tell the Two Man Power Trip storyline that was designed to ultimately get Triple H over as the top babyface in the company. Its main event saw Triple H and a profoundly miscast Steve Austin work the Brothers of Destruction in a match with ostensibly major winners-take-all stakes, but the sudden and convoluted insertion of them - via last-minute title switches and the increasingly tedious McMahon family legal chicanery - rendered the feature attraction warty and scattershot.

It was a carny main event only a WWE fan could love, but there were fewer of them, after the Austin heel turn, leading to a poor buy rate. The undercard also reeked of Monkey Tennis desperation: the wildly divergent Ultimate Submission and Duchess of Queensbury Rules matches felt less like adventurous creative and more like an obligation to do something - anything - different.

The show accelerated WWE's steep decline in popularity and was, in short and without hyperbole, the beginning of the end.


5. Ruining Daniel Bryan's Babyface Comeback

daniel bryan big cass
WWE.com

WWE tried to elicit a "That's cute" response from fans in the early days of Daniel Bryan's 2018 comeback, when fans really wanted more of a "Holy sh*t the awesome GOAT-tier wrestler and good dude is back after it was thought impossible, this is magic" vibe.

They had no reason to feel that, because Big Cass, while a serviceable hot tag power guy, was just the sh*ttiest of WWE heels* removed from his entertaining undercard act with Big Cass. He did the lumbering, aloof, slow schtick that is meant to annoy you, and not outright beg for a sh*t-kicking. Bryan worked Cass because both were medically cleared on the same day. This was plausible enough motivation for a match on SmackDown, but not a two-PPV deal that surgically removed what it was people loved about Daniel Bryan in the first place - you know, the dynamic, scintillating pro wrestling matches.

Just because a story can be told, doesn't mean it should. If Nia Jax and Tamina shared the same birthday, and WWE only remembered to offer well wishes to one of them on Twitter, you wouldn't put them in a programme.

You'd ideally want somebody halfway competent to make the other one look not terrible.

*Not quite the sh*ttiest, actually, that award goes to...


4. That Whole "God" Thing

God Backlash
WWE

The God patter was top drawer to be fair.

It was only ever a psychological ruse designed to infuriate Shawn Michaels and entertain us all, and it did, because the notion of God actually performing in a WWE ring (and being cleared to do so by a referee!) was delightfully absurd. He'd have waited 14 years and gone to AEW if he was so omniscient, eh? Eh?

You 'avin that?

It didn't prove as controversial as time weirdly remembers it to be. This didn't cause a furore. There were no calls to ban the sick filth. Vince McMahon strutted in search of the shock value that had rescued his company - and strutted alongside God before defeating God - but nobody was really concerned.

But that in itself is a source of regret; WWE didn't generate much buzz, but rather solidified its reputation as the passé clown show that appealed to who, exactly? The casuals had left forever, and the lapsed wrestling fans resisted immediately after WrestleMania had faded to black most years.

To like WWE during this period, you had to really like WWE; this was schlock precision engineered to create the appetite for an alternative over time.


3. The Beginnings Of A Deeply Damaging Feud

kevin owens braun strowman
WWE.com

Kevin Owens almost had to turn babyface in 2019. The story didn't demand it; he was simply beaten like a drum in an abysmal, one-sided and cruel storyline with Braun Strowman, who also suffered through its appalling, incredibly WWE scripting.

What happened, reductively, is that what WWE values as decent character attributes are so deranged that they effectively penned an inadvertent double-turn angle.

It started at Backlash - well, it didn't, it started on RAW in a superior prequel, which is another problem entirely - when the hapless pair of Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn were annihilated by Braun Strowman and Bobby Lashley. Owens was barely given a damn thing; the vicious, indiscriminate prizefighter, who's hardly f*cking Sunil Singh in the size department, further devolved into a chickensh*t heel.

And thus the theme of their subsequent, internecine conflict was formed: Owens was the lamentable villain unable to draw heat, because he was just scared sh*tless all the time, while Strowman was the gigantic a*shole who with no real rationale covered Owens in sh*t and half-killed him via table bump from the top of a steel cage.

It was a tale of bully versus wimp, promoted by the B a STAR guys, in which the bully was the hero.


2. Laying Out THAT Match Between Samoa Joe And Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns Samoa Joe
WWE.com

Remember how in March, tonnes of toilet paper went missing, and everybody thought it was weird because diarrhoea isn't a symptom? That was WWE.

They sh*t the bed so hard at Backlash 2018 that they're still cleaning it up.

After so many unsuccessful attempts to get Roman Reigns over, Vince McMahon and his team of wacky road agents hatched a cunning plan for his main event versus Samoa Joe. It was genius. How had they never thought of this in the four definitive years of sustained audience rejection?

The rub from the Undertaker, the rub from John Cena, incessant use of the word "bitch": nothing had worked. Roman Reigns was simply positioned in such a way that didn't align with the fan reaction, and the longer WWE didn't budge, the more it felt like a personal affront to those not among the millions that had stopped watching. So they find Roman boring, huh?

Well, what if we make Samoa Joe so boring that we'll get Roman over on the tried-and-true "Lesser of two evils" push? The very same principle had literally failed at WrestleMania 34 - "Unlike that Brock Lesnar, at least he's there every week, much like a production assistant!" - and it failed at Backlash.

"That's Roman Reigns...and he's winning us back!" the fans didn't say, because he spent 10 minutes in a neck crank.


1. Strapping Jinder Mahal In 2017

Jinder Mahal Backlash 2017
WWE.com

Has a WWE pay-per-view ever been more appropriately named?

This marked a tipping point for many long-suffering WWE fans. Jinder Mahal wasn't merely a thoroughly mundane worker by modern standards. He wasn't just playing a covert foreign menace role lost to time. He wasn't just Jinder Mahal.

He was an enhancement talent a few weeks before he inexplicably found himself in WWE Title contention. This was WWE at its most craven and artless, and they didn't credit you with the intelligence to obscure it. They didn't wait. They didn't build. They didn't immerse. They rushed from the finance meeting that informed this decision directly into the creative meeting, and if anybody questioned the decision - they didn't - they'd have been met with a "F*ck you, what else are they going to watch?"

Jinder Mahal didn't know his own finish, and neither did WWE; they mustn't have costed this woefully transparent quest, because as it turned out, Mahal wasn't a draw in India, and in 2017 broadband speeds were too erratic to effectively stream his pay-per-view matches that were available as part of the existing TV deal, anyway.

All WWE had to show for this disastrous decision was a 1995-style attendance in the one show that went ahead - and a jaded, insulted domestic audience tired of the bullsh*t.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!